Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

Wavefunction, energy spectrum and uncertainty relation for a particle contained between moving potential walls

Horst E. Wilhelm

Published Jul 11, 1983• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The temporal energy spectrum Es,a(t) and the uncertainty product Delta psa(t) Delta x,s,a(t) are derived from an analytical solution psi (x,t) of the initial-boundary-value problem for the Schrodinger equation of a particle contained between moving potential walls at x=+or-s(t), which are set in motion according to an arbitrary (non-relativistic) translation s=s(t) at time t=0. Both symmetrical (s) and antisymmetrical (a) particle states are considered as initial conditions in the region -s(0)<or=x<or=+s(0). The physical implications of the compression and expansion of the probability density by the moving walls on the wave mechanics of the particle are discussed. The results are understandable within the statistical interpretation of quantum theory.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/16/10/011

Related papers

Schrodinger Equation from Fokker-Planck Equation and Contradiction Due To Interference? Part II

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Classical mechanics traces a particle’s movement through space and time through x(t). For example, one may consider the case of a particle moving at constant speed (momentum p) in one direction or a particle bouncing back and forth at constant speed in a box. These problems are described in time and have direction and position associated with time etc. It is possible to define a probability P(x,t) in the classical picture based on delta time, the amount of time a particle spends in a little region of space dx. P(x,t), by itself, loses much relevant information present in the x(t) scenario because a particle moving to the right, or to the left, or bouncing back and forth all have the same probability, 1/L, where L is length. Furthermore, this probability is the same for all p (momentum) values. Thus a probability description, without extra information, is a subset of the relevant information in the problem. As a result, to describe the classical picture fully, one might say that a particle has a probability of 1/L, but also a mass mo and velocity +v (i.e. momentum mov nonrelativistically). For the particle bouncing back and forth in a box with constant p, one needs to give the initial position at time=0 and then a subsequent time (as well as the initial velocity and mo) in order to fully describe the problem, even though probability = 1/L. In the literature (see (1)), there have been many attempts to derive the quantum Schrodinger equation from a classical Fockker-Planck equation or a continuity equation (which follows from the Fokker-Planck equation as shown in (1)). The continuity equation contains a probability P(x,t) and a velocity(x,t) and is generally argued to represent classical physics. It does, if one retains appropriate classical conditions such as the discontinuity of density for a particle in a box (i.e. density=0 outside the box, but 1/L inside) and the notion of differing directions within the box. In fact, one may write density=W*(x,t)W(x,t) where W(x,t) is an ad hoc complex function and still retain compatibility with classical physics. If one does not, however, retain the classical conditions completely, nonclassical physics is introduced, even if density(x,t)=1/L. For example, in quantum mechanics density(x) is considered to be continuous in all x. Thus for a particle moving in a box, density outside the box is 0 so at the box wall it must also be 0. In the classical case, the density is 1 inside the box and 0 outside. There is a discontinuity classically and this cannot be changed and this contradicts the quantum mechanical picture. Thus quantum mechanics does not follow form classical Fokker-Planck or continuity equations which retain classical conditions.. Furthermore, because time is completely removed in the FP-continuity approach as applied to quantum mechanics, one cannot distinguish between forwards and backwards motion. As seen by the velocity field given in (1), v is zero for a bound particle which completely removes the sense of time and violates the classical physics conditions. It is, however, not zero for a particle moving in one direction. Thus there seems to be no issue in describing a Fokker-Planck-continuity equation as describing classical physics. One may even introduce density(x,t)= W*(x,t)W(x,t) provided one retains classical conditions allowing for discontinuity in density and different W(x,t) values at different times i.e. a discontinuity in W(x,t) at a box wall. If these conditions, however, are not met, then one no longer describes classical physics, but a new kind of physics (quantum physics). Thus one cannot argue that quantum mechanics follows from classical statistical Fokker-Planck-continuity equations. It may follow from these if one adds a set of extra conditions. Given these extra conditions, however, one could derive quantum mechanics without starting with classical density.

•Apr 24, 2023•0 citations

Energy-Time Uncertainty Relation for Absorbing Boundaries

Roderich Tumulka

We prove the uncertainty relation $σ_T \, σ_E \geq \hbar/2$ between the time $T$ of detection of a quantum particle on the surface $\partial Ω$ of a region $Ω\subset \mathbb{R}^3$ containing the particle's initial wave function, using the "absorbing boundary rule" for detection time, and the energy $E$ of the initial wave function. Here, $σ$ denotes the standard deviation of the probability distribution associated with a quantum observable and a wave function. Since $T$ is associated with a POVM rather than a self-adjoint operator, the relation is not an instance of the standard version of the uncertainty relation due to Robertson and Schrödinger. We also prove that if there is nonzero probability that the particle never reaches $\partial Ω$ (in which case we write $T=\infty$), and if $σ_T$ denotes the standard deviation conditional on the event $T<\infty$, then $σ_T \, σ_E \geq (\hbar/2) \sqrt{\mathrm{Prob}(T<\infty)}$.

arXiv:2005.14514•May 29, 2020•1 citation

Sources of quantum waves

Andrés D. Baute, I. L. Egusquiza, Juan Gonzalo Muga

Due to the space and time dependence of the wavefunction in the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, different boundary conditions are possible. The equation is usually solved as an `initial-value problem', by fixing the value of the wavefunction in all space at a given instant. We compare this standard approach to `source boundary conditions' that fix the wave at all times in a given region, in particular at a point in one dimension. In contrast to the well known physical interpretation of the initial-value-problem approach, the interpretation of the source approach has remained unclear, since it introduces negative energy components, even for `free motion', and a time-dependent norm. This work provides physical meaning to the source method by finding the link with equivalent initial-value problems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0007066•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•May 9, 2001•32 citations

On quantum mechanics on a half-line

V. Pažma, Peter Prešnajder

The origin and the physical interpretation of boundary conditions for a free particle confined to a half-line are analysed. The authors consider potentials V(x,a, . . .) (depending upon parameters a, . . . and x in (- infinity , + infinity )) for which solutions psi (x,a, . . ., t) of the corresponding Schrodinger equation reduce, in a suitable limit a from a 0 , . . ., to solutions psi (x,t) of the Schrodinger equation for a free particle confined to a half-line satisfying the boundary condition ( delta psi / delta x)(x=0, t)=a psi (x=0, t) with real alpha = alpha (a 0 , . . .).

European Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 1989•8 citations

Joint Phase Space (x-p) Probability and Free Particle Quantum Mechanics Part 2

Ruggeri, Francesco R.

In Part 1, we argued that P(x)dx=dx/L (where L is an arbitrary length) applies to a particle at rest. If one views such a particle from a frame moving at constant -v, it is moving. We argued that in such a case, the relevant probability is not simply linked to the position x, but also to the momentum p at x because this delivers an impulse hit. In particular, probability is presumably to be used in a physical problem with interactions and probability and a dynamical particle requires a dynamical probability describing both x,t and E,p. This led to exp(-iEt+px) which actually predicts intervals in space hbar/p and time hbar/E. In other words, a probabilistic view point leads to these results. Here, we ask the question: What if one simply wishes to use deterministic physics to describe a moving particle? After all, Newtonian mechanics is deterministic and one does not really need to focus on P(x)=1/L or its modification for a moving particle. In such a case, a particle moving with constant v (starting at x=0, t=0) is described by x/t=v both in Newtonian mechanics and special relativity. There is no uncertainty in x and t here which begs the question: Why does it appear in the probabilistic formalism of Part 1? In particular, exp(-iEt+ipx) derived in Part 1 implies physical regions: dx = hbar/p and dt=hbar/E and these seem to be absent in x/t=v and this is a problem. We suggest that a probabilistic approach is buried in the Lagrangian formalism which leads to the result d/dt v = 0, i.e describes the particle’s motion in space. This motion is actually x/t=v, but this equation only presents a subset of the description of a particle that is moving with constant speed, even in a deterministic Lagrangian/Action approach. We have already pointed this out in (1). We briefly explain it again here, but the real question is why does one need to consider the Lagrangian in order to describe x/t=v? In other words, the probabilistic approach associated with v=x/t only emerges in the Lagrangian formalism using a relativistic action Lt = -Et+px, with x/t=v. Ignoring the action and Lagrangian leads to an absence of hbar/p and hbar/E and one is only concerned with x/t=v. We note that the Lagrangian is primarily linked to the result: p = dL/dv partial and so argue that one is not simply interested in motion (x/t=v), but also in interaction because p is associated with an impulse hit. Thus, the Lagrangian approach is more than simply a mechanism which describes x,t motion, it is associated with p and E (through Hamiltonian = E = pv-L.) Using the Lagrangian approach suggests that it does not suffice to consider x and t by themselves when p and E are present. One must consider all four variables x,t,E,p which is the same point made in Part 1. The physics of the problem dictates that it is not enough to simply think in terms of x,t,v. The Lagrangian approach, which is constructed to ultimately yield x/t=v, when written in terms of E, p, i.e. Lt = -Et+px demonstrates uncertainty in x, hbar/p and t, hbar/E as shown in (1). This uncertainty must then be written in terms of a probability which is Lorentz invariant and leads to exp(-iEt+ipx). The point is that one would not even consider a probability if one did not consider E,p and x,t together as a complete treatment of a moving particle. In other words, x/t=v is an incomplete description of the state of a particle moving with constant speed, even in a deterministic framework.. At first this might seem surprising, but it is well known that energy and p are linked to interactions. In special relativity, one does not consider x,t,v alone and then compute p and E from these, but considers four vectors and Lorentz invariant equations. It is possible to create a Lorentz invariant equation involving all four state variables x,t,E,p and it turns out that this is the relativistic Lagrangian which describes motion, so this approach is more general than simply stating x/t=v. Thus, delta x = hbar/p and delta t= hbar/E appear in both the probabilistic approach of Part 1 and the deterministic one of the Lagrangian used here.

•Nov 22, 2025•0 citations

Comparison between time-independent and time-dependent quantum systems in the context of energy, Heisenberg uncertainty, average energy, force, average force and thermodynamic quantities

Debraj Nath

Exact solutions of time-dependent Schrödinger equation in presence of time-dependent potential is defined by point transformation and separation of variables. Energy and Heisenberg uncertainty relation are pursued for time-independent potential whereas average energy and Heisenberg uncertainty relation are defined for time-dependent potential. Forces acting on a fixed boundary wall as well as average force acting on moving boundary wall are presented along various trajectories. For high temperature, analytical forms of partition function and the corresponding thermodynamic quantities are derived following the Euler-Maclaurin summation formula over a finite as well as an infinite domain for accurate presentation. Three quantum systems are generated with the help of point transformation, separation of variables and super-symmetric quantum mechanics from one quantum system and the corresponding results are compared among all systems, where two of them are time-independent and another two are time-dependent.

arXiv:2110.05609•Oct 12, 2021•5 citations
The temporal energy spectrum Es,a(t) and the uncertainty product Delta psa(t) Delta x,s,a(t) are derived from an analytical solution psi (x,t) of the initial-boundary-value problem for the Schrodinger equation of a particle contained between moving potential walls at x=+or-s(t), which are set in motion according to an arbitrary (non-relativistic) translation s=s(t) at time t=0. Both symmetrical (s) and antisymmetrical (a) particle states are considered as initial conditions in the region -s(0)<or=x<or=+s(0). The physical implications of the compression and expansion of the probability density by the moving walls on the wave mechanics of the particle are discussed. The results are understandable within the statistical interpretation of quantum theory.
Classical mechanics traces a particle’s movement through space and time through x(t). For example, one may consider the case of a particle moving at constant speed (momentum p) in one direction or a particle bouncing back and forth at constant speed in a box. These problems are described in time and have direction and position associated with time etc. It is possible to define a probability P(x,t) in the classical picture based on delta time, the amount of time a particle spends in a little region of space dx. P(x,t), by itself, loses much relevant information present in the x(t) scenario because a particle moving to the right, or to the left, or bouncing back and forth all have the same probability, 1/L, where L is length. Furthermore, this probability is the same for all p (momentum) values. Thus a probability description, without extra information, is a subset of the relevant information in the problem. As a result, to describe the classical picture fully, one might say that a particle has a probability of 1/L, but also a mass mo and velocity +v (i.e. momentum mov nonrelativistically). For the particle bouncing back and forth in a box with constant p, one needs to give the initial position at time=0 and then a subsequent time (as well as the initial velocity and mo) in order to fully describe the problem, even though probability = 1/L. In the literature (see (1)), there have been many attempts to derive the quantum Schrodinger equation from a classical Fockker-Planck equation or a continuity equation (which follows from the Fokker-Planck equation as shown in (1)). The continuity equation contains a probability P(x,t) and a velocity(x,t) and is generally argued to represent classical physics. It does, if one retains appropriate classical conditions such as the discontinuity of density for a particle in a box (i.e. density=0 outside the box, but 1/L inside) and the notion of differing directions within the box. In fact, one may write density=W*(x,t)W(x,t) where W(x,t) is an ad hoc complex function and still retain compatibility with classical physics. If one does not, however, retain the classical conditions completely, nonclassical physics is introduced, even if density(x,t)=1/L. For example, in quantum mechanics density(x) is considered to be continuous in all x. Thus for a particle moving in a box, density outside the box is 0 so at the box wall it must also be 0. In the classical case, the density is 1 inside the box and 0 outside. There is a discontinuity classically and this cannot be changed and this contradicts the quantum mechanical picture. Thus quantum mechanics does not follow form classical Fokker-Planck or continuity equations which retain classical conditions.. Furthermore, because time is completely removed in the FP-continuity approach as applied to quantum mechanics, one cannot distinguish between forwards and backwards motion. As seen by the velocity field given in (1), v is zero for a bound particle which completely removes the sense of time and violates the classical physics conditions. It is, however, not zero for a particle moving in one direction. Thus there seems to be no issue in describing a Fokker-Planck-continuity equation as describing classical physics. One may even introduce density(x,t)= W*(x,t)W(x,t) provided one retains classical conditions allowing for discontinuity in density and different W(x,t) values at different times i.e. a discontinuity in W(x,t) at a box wall. If these conditions, however, are not met, then one no longer describes classical physics, but a new kind of physics (quantum physics). Thus one cannot argue that quantum mechanics follows from classical statistical Fokker-Planck-continuity equations. It may follow from these if one adds a set of extra conditions. Given these extra conditions, however, one could derive quantum mechanics without starting with classical density.
We prove the uncertainty relation σT σE≥ℏ/2σ_T \, σ_E \geq \hbar/2σT​σE​≥ℏ/2 between the time TTT of detection of a quantum particle on the surface ∂Ω\partial Ω∂Ω of a region Ω⊂R3Ω\subset \mathbb{R}^3Ω⊂R3 containing the particle's initial wave function, using the "absorbing boundary rule" for detection time, and the energy EEE of the initial wave function. Here, σσσ denotes the standard deviation of the probability distribution associated with a quantum observable and a wave function. Since TTT is associated with a POVM rather than a self-adjoint operator, the relation is not an instance of the standard version of the uncertainty relation due to Robertson and Schrödinger. We also prove that if there is nonzero probability that the particle never reaches ∂Ω\partial Ω∂Ω (in which case we write T=∞T=\inftyT=∞), and if σTσ_TσT​ denotes the standard deviation conditional on the event T<∞T<\inftyT<∞, then σT σE≥(ℏ/2)Prob(T<∞)σ_T \, σ_E \geq (\hbar/2) \sqrt{\mathrm{Prob}(T<\infty)}σT​σE​≥(ℏ/2)Prob(T<∞)​.
Due to the space and time dependence of the wavefunction in the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, different boundary conditions are possible. The equation is usually solved as an `initial-value problem', by fixing the value of the wavefunction in all space at a given instant. We compare this standard approach to `source boundary conditions' that fix the wave at all times in a given region, in particular at a point in one dimension. In contrast to the well known physical interpretation of the initial-value-problem approach, the interpretation of the source approach has remained unclear, since it introduces negative energy components, even for `free motion', and a time-dependent norm. This work provides physical meaning to the source method by finding the link with equivalent initial-value problems.
The origin and the physical interpretation of boundary conditions for a free particle confined to a half-line are analysed. The authors consider potentials V(x,a, . . .) (depending upon parameters a, . . . and x in (- infinity , + infinity )) for which solutions psi (x,a, . . ., t) of the corresponding Schrodinger equation reduce, in a suitable limit a from a 0 , . . ., to solutions psi (x,t) of the Schrodinger equation for a free particle confined to a half-line satisfying the boundary condition ( delta psi / delta x)(x=0, t)=a psi (x=0, t) with real alpha = alpha (a 0 , . . .).
In Part 1, we argued that P(x)dx=dx/L (where L is an arbitrary length) applies to a particle at rest. If one views such a particle from a frame moving at constant -v, it is moving. We argued that in such a case, the relevant probability is not simply linked to the position x, but also to the momentum p at x because this delivers an impulse hit. In particular, probability is presumably to be used in a physical problem with interactions and probability and a dynamical particle requires a dynamical probability describing both x,t and E,p. This led to exp(-iEt+px) which actually predicts intervals in space hbar/p and time hbar/E. In other words, a probabilistic view point leads to these results. Here, we ask the question: What if one simply wishes to use deterministic physics to describe a moving particle? After all, Newtonian mechanics is deterministic and one does not really need to focus on P(x)=1/L or its modification for a moving particle. In such a case, a particle moving with constant v (starting at x=0, t=0) is described by x/t=v both in Newtonian mechanics and special relativity. There is no uncertainty in x and t here which begs the question: Why does it appear in the probabilistic formalism of Part 1? In particular, exp(-iEt+ipx) derived in Part 1 implies physical regions: dx = hbar/p and dt=hbar/E and these seem to be absent in x/t=v and this is a problem. We suggest that a probabilistic approach is buried in the Lagrangian formalism which leads to the result d/dt v = 0, i.e describes the particle’s motion in space. This motion is actually x/t=v, but this equation only presents a subset of the description of a particle that is moving with constant speed, even in a deterministic Lagrangian/Action approach. We have already pointed this out in (1). We briefly explain it again here, but the real question is why does one need to consider the Lagrangian in order to describe x/t=v? In other words, the probabilistic approach associated with v=x/t only emerges in the Lagrangian formalism using a relativistic action Lt = -Et+px, with x/t=v. Ignoring the action and Lagrangian leads to an absence of hbar/p and hbar/E and one is only concerned with x/t=v. We note that the Lagrangian is primarily linked to the result: p = dL/dv partial and so argue that one is not simply interested in motion (x/t=v), but also in interaction because p is associated with an impulse hit. Thus, the Lagrangian approach is more than simply a mechanism which describes x,t motion, it is associated with p and E (through Hamiltonian = E = pv-L.) Using the Lagrangian approach suggests that it does not suffice to consider x and t by themselves when p and E are present. One must consider all four variables x,t,E,p which is the same point made in Part 1. The physics of the problem dictates that it is not enough to simply think in terms of x,t,v. The Lagrangian approach, which is constructed to ultimately yield x/t=v, when written in terms of E, p, i.e. Lt = -Et+px demonstrates uncertainty in x, hbar/p and t, hbar/E as shown in (1). This uncertainty must then be written in terms of a probability which is Lorentz invariant and leads to exp(-iEt+ipx). The point is that one would not even consider a probability if one did not consider E,p and x,t together as a complete treatment of a moving particle. In other words, x/t=v is an incomplete description of the state of a particle moving with constant speed, even in a deterministic framework.. At first this might seem surprising, but it is well known that energy and p are linked to interactions. In special relativity, one does not consider x,t,v alone and then compute p and E from these, but considers four vectors and Lorentz invariant equations. It is possible to create a Lorentz invariant equation involving all four state variables x,t,E,p and it turns out that this is the relativistic Lagrangian which describes motion, so this approach is more general than simply stating x/t=v. Thus, delta x = hbar/p and delta t= hbar/E appear in both the probabilistic approach of Part 1 and the deterministic one of the Lagrangian used here.
Exact solutions of time-dependent Schrödinger equation in presence of time-dependent potential is defined by point transformation and separation of variables. Energy and Heisenberg uncertainty relation are pursued for time-independent potential whereas average energy and Heisenberg uncertainty relation are defined for time-dependent potential. Forces acting on a fixed boundary wall as well as average force acting on moving boundary wall are presented along various trajectories. For high temperature, analytical forms of partition function and the corresponding thermodynamic quantities are derived following the Euler-Maclaurin summation formula over a finite as well as an infinite domain for accurate presentation. Three quantum systems are generated with the help of point transformation, separation of variables and super-symmetric quantum mechanics from one quantum system and the corresponding results are compared among all systems, where two of them are time-independent and another two are time-dependent.