Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Second-Order Effects of Nuclear Magnetic Fields

Morton M. Sternheim

Published Oct 15, 1962• 68 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Using the Dirac equation, we consider the contributions to atomic levels of terms quadratic in A. A may be, for example, the nuclear magnetic dipole field. We show that a consistent quantum mechanical treatment cancels all terms arising from $[{A}_{i}, {A}_{j}]\ensuremath{\ne}0$. This resolves a disagreement between hyperfine structure corrections calculated nonrelativistically and relativistically.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.128.676

Related papers

On the reduction of the Dirac equation to non-relativistic form: the Fermi contact interaction in the hydrogen atom

Elaine Ann Moore, R.E. Moss

The second-order hyperfine energy in the 1s and 2s states of the hydrogen atom is calculated analytically using the Dirac equation for an electron in a Coulomb potential perturbed by a point nuclear magnetic moment. The (divergent) result is compared with the calculation using the non-relativistic form of the hamiltonian. It is emphasized that in this comparison all the contributions to the non-relativistic second-order energy must be included. It is shown that, at least for the Fermi contact interaction, the results are the same to order mc 2α6, so that for this case the reduction of the Dirac equation to non-relativistic form is not suspect, contrary to previous assertions.

Molecular Physics•Nov 1, 1975•24 citations

Finite Nuclear Size Effect on the Relativistic Hyperfine Splittings of 2s and 2p Excited States of Hydrogen-like Atoms

K.L. Franzke, U. Gerstmann

Hyperfine splittings play an important role in quantum information and spintronics applications. They allow for the readout of the spin qubits, while at the same time providing the dominant mechanism for the detrimental spin decoherence. Their exact knowledge is thus of prior relevance. In this work, we analytically investigate the relativistic effects on the hyperfine splittings of hydrogen-like atoms, including finite-size effects of the nucleis’ structure. We start from exact solutions of Dirac’s equation using different nuclear models, where the nucleus is approximated by (i) a point charge (Coulomb potential), (ii) a homogeneously charged full sphere, and (iii) a homogeneously charged spherical shell. Equivalent modelling has been done for the distribution of the nuclear magnetic moment. For the 1s ground state and 2s excited state of the one-electron systems H1, H2, H3, and He+3, the calculated finite-size related hyperfine shifts are quite similar for the different structure models and in excellent agreement with those estimated by comparing QED and experiment. This holds also in a simplified approach where relativistic wave functions from a Coulomb potential combined with spherical-shell distributed nuclear magnetic moments promises an improved treatment without the need for an explicit solution of Dirac’s equation within the nuclear core. Larger differences between different nuclear structure models are found in the case of the anisotropic 2p3/2 orbitals of hydrogen, rendering these excited states as promising reference systems for exploring the proton structure.

Foundations•Oct 1, 2024•2 citations

Relativistic Paschen-Back Effect for the Two-Dimensional H-Like Atoms

A. Poszwa, Andrzej Rutkowski

The classification of states based on good quantum numbers for the two-dimensional Coulomb problem is proposed.The first order magnetic energy corrections are calculated using exact field-free analytic solutions of the Dirac equation as a zero-order approximation.

Acta Physica Polonica A•Mar 1, 2010•7 citations

The quantum mechanical current of the Pauli equation

Marek Nowakowski

We argue that the process of constructing the quantum mechanical current of the Pauli equation by copying the line of argument used in the spin-0 case, i.e., the Schrödinger equation, is ambiguous. We show that a nonrelativistic reduction of the relativistic Dirac four-vector current is, however, capable of fully resolving the problem. This analysis reveals that the nonrelativistic current of the Pauli equation should include an extra term of the form ∇×(ψ†σψ). We present an initial exploration of the potential consequences of this new “spin term” by solving the Pauli equation for crossed magnetic and electric fields and calculating the corresponding current.

arXiv:physics/9807019•American Journal of Physics•Oct 1, 1999•32 citations

Relativistic Quantum Mechanics

Jean-Pierre Antoine

The aim of relativistic quantum mechanics is to describe the finer details of the structure of atoms and molecules, where relativistic effects become nonnegligible. It is a sort of intermediate realm, between the familiar nonrelativistic quantum mechanics and fully relativistic quantum field theory, and thus it lacks the simplicity and elegance of both. Yet it is a necessary tool, mostly for quantum chemists. Pilkuhn's book offers to this audience an up-to-date survey of these methods, which is quite welcome since most previous textbooks are at least ten years old. The point of view of the author is to start immediately in the relativistic domain, following the lead of Maxwell's equations rather than classical mechanics, and thus to treat the nonrelativistic version as an approximation. Thus Chapter 1 takes off from Maxwell's equations (in the noncovariant Coulomb gauge) and gradually derives the basic aspects of Quantum Mechanics in a rather pedestrian way (states and observables, Hilbert space, operators, quantum measurement, scattering,. Chapter 2 starts with the Lorentz transformations, then continues with the Pauli spin equation and the Dirac equation and some of their applications (notably the hydrogen atom). Chapter 3 is entitled `Quantum fields and particles', but falls short of treating quantum field theory properly: only creation/annihilation operators are considered, for a particle in a box. The emphasis is on two-electron states (the Pauli principle, the Foldy--Wouthuysen elimination of small components of Dirac spinors, Breit projection operators. Chapter 4 is devoted to scattering theory and the description of relativistic bound states. Chapter 5, finally, covers hyperfine interactions and radiative corrections. As we said above, relativistic quantum mechanics is by nature limited in scope and rather inelegant and Pilkuhn's book is no exception. The notation is often heavy (mostly noncovariant) and the mathematical level rather low. The central topic is the description of atoms and molecules, including relativistic effects. The author fulfils this program in a reasonable way and offers a valuable tool to the targeted audience. I am not overly enthusiastic about the end result, but I might be prejudiced. Clearly, going further would require the full power of quantum field theory, but this is clearly beyond the scope of the book.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jan 9, 2004•15 citations

Comparing the Schrödinger and Dirac Descriptions of an Electron in a Uniform Magnetic Field

David Velasco Villamizar, Benjamin Russell

In this article we present a detailed description, using ladder operators, of an electron in a uniform magnetic field evolving under the Schrödinger equation.We go on to describe the same physical system in terms of relativistic quantum mechanics using the Dirac equation and to compare the two models in detail.The main differences between these two quantum mechanical approaches are discussed and we observe specifically how the relativistic phenomena modify the description of this particular quantum system by isolating effects which only exist in the relativistic model.

arXiv:1706.00822•Revista Brasileira de Ensino de Física•Jun 11, 2018•0 citations
Using the Dirac equation, we consider the contributions to atomic levels of terms quadratic in A. A may be, for example, the nuclear magnetic dipole field. We show that a consistent quantum mechanical treatment cancels all terms arising from [Ai,Aj]\ensuremath≠0[{A}_{i}, {A}_{j}]\ensuremath{\ne}0[Ai​,Aj​]\ensuremath=0. This resolves a disagreement between hyperfine structure corrections calculated nonrelativistically and relativistically.
The second-order hyperfine energy in the 1s and 2s states of the hydrogen atom is calculated analytically using the Dirac equation for an electron in a Coulomb potential perturbed by a point nuclear magnetic moment. The (divergent) result is compared with the calculation using the non-relativistic form of the hamiltonian. It is emphasized that in this comparison all the contributions to the non-relativistic second-order energy must be included. It is shown that, at least for the Fermi contact interaction, the results are the same to order mc 2α6, so that for this case the reduction of the Dirac equation to non-relativistic form is not suspect, contrary to previous assertions.
Hyperfine splittings play an important role in quantum information and spintronics applications. They allow for the readout of the spin qubits, while at the same time providing the dominant mechanism for the detrimental spin decoherence. Their exact knowledge is thus of prior relevance. In this work, we analytically investigate the relativistic effects on the hyperfine splittings of hydrogen-like atoms, including finite-size effects of the nucleis’ structure. We start from exact solutions of Dirac’s equation using different nuclear models, where the nucleus is approximated by (i) a point charge (Coulomb potential), (ii) a homogeneously charged full sphere, and (iii) a homogeneously charged spherical shell. Equivalent modelling has been done for the distribution of the nuclear magnetic moment. For the 1s ground state and 2s excited state of the one-electron systems H1, H2, H3, and He+3, the calculated finite-size related hyperfine shifts are quite similar for the different structure models and in excellent agreement with those estimated by comparing QED and experiment. This holds also in a simplified approach where relativistic wave functions from a Coulomb potential combined with spherical-shell distributed nuclear magnetic moments promises an improved treatment without the need for an explicit solution of Dirac’s equation within the nuclear core. Larger differences between different nuclear structure models are found in the case of the anisotropic 2p3/2 orbitals of hydrogen, rendering these excited states as promising reference systems for exploring the proton structure.
We argue that the process of constructing the quantum mechanical current of the Pauli equation by copying the line of argument used in the spin-0 case, i.e., the Schrödinger equation, is ambiguous. We show that a nonrelativistic reduction of the relativistic Dirac four-vector current is, however, capable of fully resolving the problem. This analysis reveals that the nonrelativistic current of the Pauli equation should include an extra term of the form ∇×(ψ†σψ). We present an initial exploration of the potential consequences of this new “spin term” by solving the Pauli equation for crossed magnetic and electric fields and calculating the corresponding current.
The aim of relativistic quantum mechanics is to describe the finer details of the structure of atoms and molecules, where relativistic effects become nonnegligible. It is a sort of intermediate realm, between the familiar nonrelativistic quantum mechanics and fully relativistic quantum field theory, and thus it lacks the simplicity and elegance of both. Yet it is a necessary tool, mostly for quantum chemists. Pilkuhn's book offers to this audience an up-to-date survey of these methods, which is quite welcome since most previous textbooks are at least ten years old. The point of view of the author is to start immediately in the relativistic domain, following the lead of Maxwell's equations rather than classical mechanics, and thus to treat the nonrelativistic version as an approximation. Thus Chapter 1 takes off from Maxwell's equations (in the noncovariant Coulomb gauge) and gradually derives the basic aspects of Quantum Mechanics in a rather pedestrian way (states and observables, Hilbert space, operators, quantum measurement, scattering,. Chapter 2 starts with the Lorentz transformations, then continues with the Pauli spin equation and the Dirac equation and some of their applications (notably the hydrogen atom). Chapter 3 is entitled `Quantum fields and particles', but falls short of treating quantum field theory properly: only creation/annihilation operators are considered, for a particle in a box. The emphasis is on two-electron states (the Pauli principle, the Foldy--Wouthuysen elimination of small components of Dirac spinors, Breit projection operators. Chapter 4 is devoted to scattering theory and the description of relativistic bound states. Chapter 5, finally, covers hyperfine interactions and radiative corrections. As we said above, relativistic quantum mechanics is by nature limited in scope and rather inelegant and Pilkuhn's book is no exception. The notation is often heavy (mostly noncovariant) and the mathematical level rather low. The central topic is the description of atoms and molecules, including relativistic effects. The author fulfils this program in a reasonable way and offers a valuable tool to the targeted audience. I am not overly enthusiastic about the end result, but I might be prejudiced. Clearly, going further would require the full power of quantum field theory, but this is clearly beyond the scope of the book.
In this article we present a detailed description, using ladder operators, of an electron in a uniform magnetic field evolving under the Schrödinger equation.We go on to describe the same physical system in terms of relativistic quantum mechanics using the Dirac equation and to compare the two models in detail.The main differences between these two quantum mechanical approaches are discussed and we observe specifically how the relativistic phenomena modify the description of this particular quantum system by isolating effects which only exist in the relativistic model.