Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Perpendicular Susceptibility of the Ising Model

Michael Ellis Fisher

Published Jan 1, 1963• 308 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A high-temperature expansion of the partition function for a lattice of N spins with Hamiltonian H=−J ∑ (ij)σizσjz−mHz ∑ iσiz−mHx ∑ iσixis derived and thence an expansion for the zero-field perpendicular susceptibility is found. By perturbation theory, χ⊥(T) is also expanded at low temperatures and seen, in general, to increase with T from the value χ⊥(O) = Nm2/q | J |, where q is the coordination number of the lattice. The perpendicular susceptibility is re-expressed in terms of near neighbor pair and higher-order spin correlation functions in zero field. This yields exact closed formulas for the linear chain, the Bethe pseudolattices, and for the plane square and honeycomb lattices. The behavior of χ⊥(T) in the critical region is investigated for these lattices and for the plane superexchange lattice.

DOI
10.1063/1.1703878

Related papers

On the Exact Frequency-Dependent Susceptibility of the Two-Dimensional Ising Model

G. A. T. Allan, Donald D. Betts

Fisher has found exactly for the square and honeycomb lattice the static initial perpendicular susceptibility of the quantum-mechanical version of the Ising model defined by the Hamiltonian H=−J ∑ nnσizσjz−mHx(t) ∑ iσix,where all symbols have their usual meanings. As the magnetization, Mx = mΣiσix, does not commute with the Hamiltonian, the system can relax and Kubo's linear response theory can be applied. We have been able to evaluate the response function exactly and hence obtain simply the exact frequency-dependent initial perpendicular susceptibility for the honeycomb lattice Jχ⊥(ω,T)/Nm2=¾[〈σ0zσ1z〉−〈σ0zσ1zσ2zσ3z〉]ω02/(ω02−ω2)+3[¾〈σ0zσ1z〉+¼〈σ0zσ1zσ2zσ3z〉]ω02/(9ω02−ω2),where ω0 = 2J/ℏ and 〈σ0zσ1z〉 is the nearest-neighbor correlation evaluated by Onsager. A similar expression is obtained for the square lattice. For the four-particle correlation 〈σ0zσ1zσ2zσ3z〉 the other three spins are nearest neighbors to spin zero, and we have obtained its value from Fisher's transformation theory. The behavior of χ⊥ as a function of T and ω is described and its physical significance is discussed.

Journal of Applied Physics•Feb 1, 1968•1 citation

The frequency-dependent initial perpendicular susceptibility of the Ising model

G. A. T. Allan, Donald D. Betts

The Kubo linear response theory is applied to the quantum mechanical Ising model to obtain a general expression which is valid for all regular lattices for the perpendicular response function in terms of spin correlations. For the honeycomb and the square lattices, exact expressions are found for the frequency-dependent initial perpendicular susceptibility, [Formula: see text] valid for all temperatures. For the honeycomb lattice, the present result for zero frequency agrees with Fisher's static calculation, whereas there is disagreement in the case of the square lattice. The discrepancy is resolved by using an extended calculation which explicitly illustrates the difference between isothermal and adiabatic susceptibilities.

Canadian Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 1968•20 citations

Ising-Model Spin Correlations on the Triangular Lattice

John Stephenson

A Pfaffian representation, of the partition function of the triangular lattice is used to derive expressions for various two, four, and six spin correlations in terms of Pfaffians. The pair correlations along a diagonal are expressed as a Toeplitz determinant whose limiting form yields the spontaneous magnetization. At the ferromagnetic critical point the correlations decay as 1/r12 with approximately radial symmetry. At the antiferromagnetic zero point the ground state is highly degenerate—it has finite entropy—and on a given sublattice the pair correlations along a row decay as ε/r12, where ε=+ε0 on the sublattice containing the origin spin and ε≃−12ε0 on the other two sublattices. Finally, the perpendicular susceptibility, χ⊥, which depends on a finite number of correlations, is calculated; its ferromagnetic behavior is similar to that of the perpendicular susceptibilities of the quadratic and honeycomb lattices, but for an antiferromagnet χ⊥ diverges as 1/T at low temperatures.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 1964•289 citations

Critical Point Behavior of the Ising Model with Higher-Neighbor Interactions Present

N W Dalton, David W. Wood

The method of developing exact power-series expansions for the partition function ZN and related thermodynamic functions for the Ising model valid below the critical point is generalized to include exchange interactions between first-, second-, and third-neighbor pairs. Expansions of the spontaneous magnetization M0(T) and zero field susceptibility χ0(T) are derived through to sixth order of perturbation for the s.q. lattice, and through to fifth order of perturbation for the Δ′r, b.c.c., s.c., and f.c.c. lattices, when interactions J1SizSjz and J2SkzSlz are present between first- and second-neighbor spins, respectively (second-neighbor model). These expansions have also been obtained for the case where interactions of equal magnitude (J1 = J2 = J3) are present between first-, second-, and third-neighbor pairs (third-equivalent-neighbor model); here expansions through to fifth order of perturbation are obtained for the s.q., Δ′r, b.c.c., and s.c. lattices and through to fourth order for the f.c.c. lattice. The Padé approximant·procedure is employed to discuss the effects of an extended but finite range of interaction on the behavior of M0(T) and χ0(T) for T→Tc− as characterized by the critical exponents β and γ′, respectively. For the second-equivalent-neighbor model lattices, it is found that 0.122 ≤ β ≤ 0.134 in two dimensions, and that 0.308 ≤ β ≤ 0.328 in three dimensions; from which it is concluded that β remains unchanged from its value in the nearest-neighbor model. The corresponding limits for γ′ in three dimensions are 1.18 ≤ γ′ ≤ 1.28; from this and the results for the b.c.c. lattice in particular, it is concluded that γ′ is probably 54 and hence the transition in χ0 is symmetrical about Tc (γ′ = γ). A repetition of this analysis for the third-equivalent-neighbor model three-dimensional lattices shows a marked shift in the estimated range of β and γ′; the results are 0.345 ≤ β ≤ 0.365, and 1.01 ≤ γ′ ≤ 1.14. In each of the above cases, the corresponding high-temperature (T > Tc) expansions of χ0(T) obtained previously have been analyzed to yield estimates of the critical exponent γ. The over-all results and in particular the estimates of γ for the s.q. and b.c.c. lattices suggest that this index is unaffected by extending the range of interaction, and that if γ is a rational fraction then it is the same fraction for the n.n. model and second- and third-equivalent neighbor models. Finally the high-temperature expansions of ZN in zero field, and of χ0(T) for the second-neighbor model are used to examine the dependence of the critical temperature Tc, the critical energy (E∞ − Ec)/kTc, and the critical entropy (S∞ − Sc)/k on the relative strengths of J1 and J2 for values of J2/J1 in the range 0 to 1. It is found that the variation of the critical point is well represented by Tc(α)=Tc(0)[1+m1α],where α = J2/J1 and lies in the range 0 ≤ α ≤ 1; and Tc(0) is the critical temperature of the nearest-neighbor model. The values of m1 are 0.61, 2.47, 0.84, 1.45, and 1.35 for the f.c.c., s.c., b.c.c., s.q., and Δ′r lattices, respectively. All these calculations are compared with the corresponding results for the Heisenberg model.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jul 1, 1969•127 citations

Derivation of series expansions for the spin-spin correlation function of the Ising model

Douglas S. Ritchie, J W Essam

A method is described for obtaining perturbation expansions of the pair correlation function about the ferromagnetically ordered state of the S=1/2 Ising model. The expansions take the form of a double power series in temperature and field variables and may be used in any region of the T-H plane of the ferromagnetic and in the disordered region of the antiferromagnet. Coefficients are calculated for the face-centred cubic lattice which allow the low-temperature expansions in zero field to be obtained through u31 and the high-field expansions along the critical isotherm to be obtained through mu 6. Agreement is obtained with existing high-temperature expansions.

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics•Oct 14, 1977•0 citations

Modified Admittance, Perpendicular Susceptibilities, and Transformation of Correlations of the Ising Model

Shoon Kyung Kim

A modified admittance is introduced to give Kubo's admittance at nonzero frequencies and to give the isothermal static admittance at zero frequency within the scope of the Kubo linear-response theory. The method is demonstrated by exact calculations of the frequency-dependent perpendicular susceptibility at zero field and its modified susceptibility of the regular Ising model. The results appear as linear combinations of the equilibrium spin-spin correlation functions of the lattice. The results are valid for all dimensions and all frequencies and temperatures. A (q + 1) × (q + 1) matrix a(q) describes the linear combinations explicitly, where q is the coordination number of the lattice. The properties of this matrix are extensively discussed as a special case of a matrix A(q)(ξ), which satisfies a simple quadratic equation of the form [A(q)(ξ)]2 = (1 + ξ)q for arbitrary values of ξ. Fisher's algebraic transformation of the spin-spin correlation functions for the regular Ising lattice is derived from the linear relation which holds between the perpendicular susceptibility and the corresponding modified susceptibility. By means of the product rules of the matrix A(q)(ξ), the higher-order spin-spin correlation functions are expressed in terms of the lower-order ones in complete generality.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Oct 1, 1968•5 citations
A high-temperature expansion of the partition function for a lattice of N spins with Hamiltonian H=−J ∑ (ij)σizσjz−mHz ∑ iσiz−mHx ∑ iσixis derived and thence an expansion for the zero-field perpendicular susceptibility is found. By perturbation theory, χ⊥(T) is also expanded at low temperatures and seen, in general, to increase with T from the value χ⊥(O) = Nm2/q | J |, where q is the coordination number of the lattice. The perpendicular susceptibility is re-expressed in terms of near neighbor pair and higher-order spin correlation functions in zero field. This yields exact closed formulas for the linear chain, the Bethe pseudolattices, and for the plane square and honeycomb lattices. The behavior of χ⊥(T) in the critical region is investigated for these lattices and for the plane superexchange lattice.
Fisher has found exactly for the square and honeycomb lattice the static initial perpendicular susceptibility of the quantum-mechanical version of the Ising model defined by the Hamiltonian H=−J ∑ nnσizσjz−mHx(t) ∑ iσix,where all symbols have their usual meanings. As the magnetization, Mx = mΣiσix, does not commute with the Hamiltonian, the system can relax and Kubo's linear response theory can be applied. We have been able to evaluate the response function exactly and hence obtain simply the exact frequency-dependent initial perpendicular susceptibility for the honeycomb lattice Jχ⊥(ω,T)/Nm2=¾[〈σ0zσ1z〉−〈σ0zσ1zσ2zσ3z〉]ω02/(ω02−ω2)+3[¾〈σ0zσ1z〉+¼〈σ0zσ1zσ2zσ3z〉]ω02/(9ω02−ω2),where ω0 = 2J/ℏ and 〈σ0zσ1z〉 is the nearest-neighbor correlation evaluated by Onsager. A similar expression is obtained for the square lattice. For the four-particle correlation 〈σ0zσ1zσ2zσ3z〉 the other three spins are nearest neighbors to spin zero, and we have obtained its value from Fisher's transformation theory. The behavior of χ⊥ as a function of T and ω is described and its physical significance is discussed.
The Kubo linear response theory is applied to the quantum mechanical Ising model to obtain a general expression which is valid for all regular lattices for the perpendicular response function in terms of spin correlations. For the honeycomb and the square lattices, exact expressions are found for the frequency-dependent initial perpendicular susceptibility, [Formula: see text] valid for all temperatures. For the honeycomb lattice, the present result for zero frequency agrees with Fisher's static calculation, whereas there is disagreement in the case of the square lattice. The discrepancy is resolved by using an extended calculation which explicitly illustrates the difference between isothermal and adiabatic susceptibilities.
A Pfaffian representation, of the partition function of the triangular lattice is used to derive expressions for various two, four, and six spin correlations in terms of Pfaffians. The pair correlations along a diagonal are expressed as a Toeplitz determinant whose limiting form yields the spontaneous magnetization. At the ferromagnetic critical point the correlations decay as 1/r12 with approximately radial symmetry. At the antiferromagnetic zero point the ground state is highly degenerate—it has finite entropy—and on a given sublattice the pair correlations along a row decay as ε/r12, where ε=+ε0 on the sublattice containing the origin spin and ε≃−12ε0 on the other two sublattices. Finally, the perpendicular susceptibility, χ⊥, which depends on a finite number of correlations, is calculated; its ferromagnetic behavior is similar to that of the perpendicular susceptibilities of the quadratic and honeycomb lattices, but for an antiferromagnet χ⊥ diverges as 1/T at low temperatures.
The method of developing exact power-series expansions for the partition function ZN and related thermodynamic functions for the Ising model valid below the critical point is generalized to include exchange interactions between first-, second-, and third-neighbor pairs. Expansions of the spontaneous magnetization M0(T) and zero field susceptibility χ0(T) are derived through to sixth order of perturbation for the s.q. lattice, and through to fifth order of perturbation for the Δ′r, b.c.c., s.c., and f.c.c. lattices, when interactions J1SizSjz and J2SkzSlz are present between first- and second-neighbor spins, respectively (second-neighbor model). These expansions have also been obtained for the case where interactions of equal magnitude (J1 = J2 = J3) are present between first-, second-, and third-neighbor pairs (third-equivalent-neighbor model); here expansions through to fifth order of perturbation are obtained for the s.q., Δ′r, b.c.c., and s.c. lattices and through to fourth order for the f.c.c. lattice. The Padé approximant·procedure is employed to discuss the effects of an extended but finite range of interaction on the behavior of M0(T) and χ0(T) for T→Tc− as characterized by the critical exponents β and γ′, respectively. For the second-equivalent-neighbor model lattices, it is found that 0.122 ≤ β ≤ 0.134 in two dimensions, and that 0.308 ≤ β ≤ 0.328 in three dimensions; from which it is concluded that β remains unchanged from its value in the nearest-neighbor model. The corresponding limits for γ′ in three dimensions are 1.18 ≤ γ′ ≤ 1.28; from this and the results for the b.c.c. lattice in particular, it is concluded that γ′ is probably 54 and hence the transition in χ0 is symmetrical about Tc (γ′ = γ). A repetition of this analysis for the third-equivalent-neighbor model three-dimensional lattices shows a marked shift in the estimated range of β and γ′; the results are 0.345 ≤ β ≤ 0.365, and 1.01 ≤ γ′ ≤ 1.14. In each of the above cases, the corresponding high-temperature (T > Tc) expansions of χ0(T) obtained previously have been analyzed to yield estimates of the critical exponent γ. The over-all results and in particular the estimates of γ for the s.q. and b.c.c. lattices suggest that this index is unaffected by extending the range of interaction, and that if γ is a rational fraction then it is the same fraction for the n.n. model and second- and third-equivalent neighbor models. Finally the high-temperature expansions of ZN in zero field, and of χ0(T) for the second-neighbor model are used to examine the dependence of the critical temperature Tc, the critical energy (E∞ − Ec)/kTc, and the critical entropy (S∞ − Sc)/k on the relative strengths of J1 and J2 for values of J2/J1 in the range 0 to 1. It is found that the variation of the critical point is well represented by Tc(α)=Tc(0)[1+m1α],where α = J2/J1 and lies in the range 0 ≤ α ≤ 1; and Tc(0) is the critical temperature of the nearest-neighbor model. The values of m1 are 0.61, 2.47, 0.84, 1.45, and 1.35 for the f.c.c., s.c., b.c.c., s.q., and Δ′r lattices, respectively. All these calculations are compared with the corresponding results for the Heisenberg model.
A method is described for obtaining perturbation expansions of the pair correlation function about the ferromagnetically ordered state of the S=1/2 Ising model. The expansions take the form of a double power series in temperature and field variables and may be used in any region of the T-H plane of the ferromagnetic and in the disordered region of the antiferromagnet. Coefficients are calculated for the face-centred cubic lattice which allow the low-temperature expansions in zero field to be obtained through u31 and the high-field expansions along the critical isotherm to be obtained through mu 6. Agreement is obtained with existing high-temperature expansions.
A modified admittance is introduced to give Kubo's admittance at nonzero frequencies and to give the isothermal static admittance at zero frequency within the scope of the Kubo linear-response theory. The method is demonstrated by exact calculations of the frequency-dependent perpendicular susceptibility at zero field and its modified susceptibility of the regular Ising model. The results appear as linear combinations of the equilibrium spin-spin correlation functions of the lattice. The results are valid for all dimensions and all frequencies and temperatures. A (q + 1) × (q + 1) matrix a(q) describes the linear combinations explicitly, where q is the coordination number of the lattice. The properties of this matrix are extensively discussed as a special case of a matrix A(q)(ξ), which satisfies a simple quadratic equation of the form [A(q)(ξ)]2 = (1 + ξ)q for arbitrary values of ξ. Fisher's algebraic transformation of the spin-spin correlation functions for the regular Ising lattice is derived from the linear relation which holds between the perpendicular susceptibility and the corresponding modified susceptibility. By means of the product rules of the matrix A(q)(ξ), the higher-order spin-spin correlation functions are expressed in terms of the lower-order ones in complete generality.