Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

A Classical Spin on Quantized Angular Momentum

Dallin Durfee, James L. Archibald

Published Dec 31, 2011• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We present an intuition-building activity for the quantum description of angular momentum. Using concepts of orthogonality in space and linear independence, we can logically deduce the relationships between the three spatially orthogonal basis sets of the spin-1/2 system. Rather than a mathematically rigorous derivation, the relationships are found by enforcing properties we expect the basis states to have. The process highlights the correspondence of quantized spin state properties with classical notions of orthogonality, illustrating differences and connections between geometrical space and Hilbert space and dispelling misconceptions often held by students.

Related papers

Applying classical geometry intuition to quantum spin

Dallin Durfee, James L. Archibald

Using concepts of geometric orthogonality and linear independence, we logically deduce the form of the Pauli spin matrices and the relationships between the three spatially orthogonal basis sets of the spin-1/2 system. Rather than a mathematically rigorous derivation, the relationships are found by forcing expectation values of the different basis states to have the properties we expect of a classical, geometric coordinate system. The process highlights the correspondence of quantum angular momentum with classical notions of geometric orthogonality, even for the inherently non-classical spin-1/2 system. In the process, differences in and connections between geometrical space and Hilbert space are illustrated.

arXiv:1201.0302•European Journal of Physics•Jul 20, 2016•3 citations

Angular Momentum and Spin

Gennaro Auletta, Shang-Yung Wang

In this chapter we shall treat two of the most important observables of quantum mechanical systems: angular momentum and spin. We shall argue that angular momentum is the generator of rotations. In quantummechanics, angular momentum is quantized in units of the reduced Planck constant. The quantization of angular momentum is dealt with by finding the angular momentum eigenvalues and eigenstates. We shall then apply the theory of angular momentum to study the hydrogen atom. Spin is an intrinsic angular momentum of subatomic particles and therefore corresponds to an important intrinsic degree of freedom. We shall discuss briefly how spin was discovered and many of its important properties. Finally, we shall also explore here some further subtleties of quantum theory.a When we consider quantum systems in two or three spatial dimensions, we need to take into account also the effect of rotations. In this case, we need to introduce a physical quantity called the angular momentum, that is, themomentum induced by or connected with rotations. In classical physics the angular momentum of a particle about a given origin is defined by [see Fig. 8.1]

•Jun 20, 2014•1 citation

A classical, elementary approach to the foundations of Quantum Mechanics

David Rodríguez

Elementary particles are found in two different situations: (i) bound to metastable states of matter, for which angular momentum is quantized, and (ii) free, for which, due to their high energy-momentum and leaving aside inner a.m. or spin, the $h$-quantization step is completely harmless. Perhaps Quantum Mechanics can be seen just as the simplest mathematical formalism where angular momentum (the magnitude of each of its three orthogonal projections) is by construction quantized: all possible values are taken from a discrete set. Indeed: (i) This idea finds support in very reasonable, completely classical physical arguments, if we place ourselves in the framework of Stochastic Electrodynamics (SED): there, all sustained periodic movement of a charge must satisfy a power balance that restricts the value of the average angular momentum, on each of its projections. (ii) It gives a natural explanation of the concept of "photon", as a constraint on the observable spectrum of energy-momentum exchanges between metastable physical states, in particular also for its discreteness. QM would be, in this picture, a semi-static theory, transparent to all the (micro)-dynamics taking place between apparently "discrete" events (transitions in the state of the system). For instance, (the magnitude of the projections of) quantum angular momentum would only reflect average values over a (classical) cyclic trajectory, a fact that we regard as almost obvious given the particularity of the corresponding addition rules in QM.

arXiv:1112.3369•Dec 13, 2011•1 citation

Elementary introduction to the properties of angular momentum operators through three-dimensional rotations

C. Leubner

For pedagogical purposes it is demonstrated that with little effort the customary discussion of rotations in introductory courses can be extended to naturally produce a number of angular momentum operator properties, if coordinate-free rotation operators are used in their exponential form. This form gives rise to a particularly useful coordinate-free representation of the generators of rotations in three-space, from which the student can derive the usual angular momentum formalism for the case j=1 by elementary vector algebra alone. Since in this approach the j=1 formalism appears as a set of relations among simple geometric objects in ordinary space, it admits of a geometric interpretation and will leave the student better prepared for a more profound appreciation of the abstract concepts of the full theory.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1980•0 citations

Angular momentum

P. C. W. Davies, David S. Betts

One of the most important applications of the quantum mechanical formalism developed in the previous chapter is to angular momentum. This is because many microsystems are spherically symmetric, or approximately so, and angular momentum is therefore conserved. This chapter discusses that a careful study of quantized angular momentum leads to a completely new physical phenomenon – intrinsic spin. The fact that the angular momentum vector of a quantum particle must point in certain restricted directions is a bizarre quantum property. In some respects the abstract idea of an internal angular momentum is reminiscent of the classical concept of a spinning body. In classical mechanics angular momentum is added vectorially but in the quantum case the issue is more subtle. The procedure will be illustrated by the example of the addition of two spins. As in classical mechanics a charged quantum system with angular momentum possesses a magnetic moment μ.

Routledge eBooks•Apr 27, 2018•0 citations

Angular Momentum

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

In Chapter 1 we discussed the role of linear momentum as the generator of translational displacement in homogeneous space. Likewise, it is instructive to explore the role of angular momentum as the generator of rotational displacements in isotropic space. Not surprisingly, analogies drawn from classical physics are not adequate to describe physical particles and fields. One must therefore redefine angular momentum to describe appropriately the physical properties in nature by quantum mechanics. 4.1 Definition and Properties of Angular Momentu m Kepler orbits of planets around the sun signify our intuitive understanding of angular momentum of an object about a point (Fig. 4.1). It interprets angular momentum as moment of the momentum , expressed as the cross product of the position vector of an object with its instantaneous linear momentum. We recognize it to represent a physical quantity that is conserved in isotropic space. The classical definition of angular momentum is however not sustainable, and not just because simultaneous measurements of position and momentum are incompatible. Physical properties of particles and fields have properties that have no classical analogues. Quantum mechanics acknowledges the intrinsic incompatibility in observations of some physical properties and provides a defensible alternative theory to describe nature. We shall therefore be able to persist with the classical interpretation of angular momentum as the generator of rotation in isotropic space only up to a certain point of our analysis; beyond it, we shall require a worthier mathematical model that is robust enough to describe nature acceptably. We consider an object having an arbitrary shape and subject it to a rotation about an axis through it, such as the one schematically shown in Fig. 4.2a. On turning it through an infinitesimal angle, the shape transforms to. We denote the rotation by an operator and express this operation as With reference to a Cartesian coordinate system, a rotation relocates a point whose position vector is to (Fig. 4.2b): Equation 4.1 tells us that the function has the same value at the new orientation as the function, i.e., as, R being the operator corresponding to the said rotation. We shall refer to such a description of transformation of the function as active . In passive description, an equivalent inverse operation on the coordinate system is employed (Fig. 4.2c), leaving the function itself unchanged. The active and the passive descriptions are equivalent.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations
We present an intuition-building activity for the quantum description of angular momentum. Using concepts of orthogonality in space and linear independence, we can logically deduce the relationships between the three spatially orthogonal basis sets of the spin-1/2 system. Rather than a mathematically rigorous derivation, the relationships are found by enforcing properties we expect the basis states to have. The process highlights the correspondence of quantized spin state properties with classical notions of orthogonality, illustrating differences and connections between geometrical space and Hilbert space and dispelling misconceptions often held by students.
Using concepts of geometric orthogonality and linear independence, we logically deduce the form of the Pauli spin matrices and the relationships between the three spatially orthogonal basis sets of the spin-1/2 system. Rather than a mathematically rigorous derivation, the relationships are found by forcing expectation values of the different basis states to have the properties we expect of a classical, geometric coordinate system. The process highlights the correspondence of quantum angular momentum with classical notions of geometric orthogonality, even for the inherently non-classical spin-1/2 system. In the process, differences in and connections between geometrical space and Hilbert space are illustrated.
In this chapter we shall treat two of the most important observables of quantum mechanical systems: angular momentum and spin. We shall argue that angular momentum is the generator of rotations. In quantummechanics, angular momentum is quantized in units of the reduced Planck constant. The quantization of angular momentum is dealt with by finding the angular momentum eigenvalues and eigenstates. We shall then apply the theory of angular momentum to study the hydrogen atom. Spin is an intrinsic angular momentum of subatomic particles and therefore corresponds to an important intrinsic degree of freedom. We shall discuss briefly how spin was discovered and many of its important properties. Finally, we shall also explore here some further subtleties of quantum theory.a When we consider quantum systems in two or three spatial dimensions, we need to take into account also the effect of rotations. In this case, we need to introduce a physical quantity called the angular momentum, that is, themomentum induced by or connected with rotations. In classical physics the angular momentum of a particle about a given origin is defined by [see Fig. 8.1]
Elementary particles are found in two different situations: (i) bound to metastable states of matter, for which angular momentum is quantized, and (ii) free, for which, due to their high energy-momentum and leaving aside inner a.m. or spin, the hhh-quantization step is completely harmless. Perhaps Quantum Mechanics can be seen just as the simplest mathematical formalism where angular momentum (the magnitude of each of its three orthogonal projections) is by construction quantized: all possible values are taken from a discrete set. Indeed: (i) This idea finds support in very reasonable, completely classical physical arguments, if we place ourselves in the framework of Stochastic Electrodynamics (SED): there, all sustained periodic movement of a charge must satisfy a power balance that restricts the value of the average angular momentum, on each of its projections. (ii) It gives a natural explanation of the concept of "photon", as a constraint on the observable spectrum of energy-momentum exchanges between metastable physical states, in particular also for its discreteness. QM would be, in this picture, a semi-static theory, transparent to all the (micro)-dynamics taking place between apparently "discrete" events (transitions in the state of the system). For instance, (the magnitude of the projections of) quantum angular momentum would only reflect average values over a (classical) cyclic trajectory, a fact that we regard as almost obvious given the particularity of the corresponding addition rules in QM.
For pedagogical purposes it is demonstrated that with little effort the customary discussion of rotations in introductory courses can be extended to naturally produce a number of angular momentum operator properties, if coordinate-free rotation operators are used in their exponential form. This form gives rise to a particularly useful coordinate-free representation of the generators of rotations in three-space, from which the student can derive the usual angular momentum formalism for the case j=1 by elementary vector algebra alone. Since in this approach the j=1 formalism appears as a set of relations among simple geometric objects in ordinary space, it admits of a geometric interpretation and will leave the student better prepared for a more profound appreciation of the abstract concepts of the full theory.
One of the most important applications of the quantum mechanical formalism developed in the previous chapter is to angular momentum. This is because many microsystems are spherically symmetric, or approximately so, and angular momentum is therefore conserved. This chapter discusses that a careful study of quantized angular momentum leads to a completely new physical phenomenon – intrinsic spin. The fact that the angular momentum vector of a quantum particle must point in certain restricted directions is a bizarre quantum property. In some respects the abstract idea of an internal angular momentum is reminiscent of the classical concept of a spinning body. In classical mechanics angular momentum is added vectorially but in the quantum case the issue is more subtle. The procedure will be illustrated by the example of the addition of two spins. As in classical mechanics a charged quantum system with angular momentum possesses a magnetic moment μ.
In Chapter 1 we discussed the role of linear momentum as the generator of translational displacement in homogeneous space. Likewise, it is instructive to explore the role of angular momentum as the generator of rotational displacements in isotropic space. Not surprisingly, analogies drawn from classical physics are not adequate to describe physical particles and fields. One must therefore redefine angular momentum to describe appropriately the physical properties in nature by quantum mechanics. 4.1 Definition and Properties of Angular Momentu m Kepler orbits of planets around the sun signify our intuitive understanding of angular momentum of an object about a point (Fig. 4.1). It interprets angular momentum as moment of the momentum , expressed as the cross product of the position vector of an object with its instantaneous linear momentum. We recognize it to represent a physical quantity that is conserved in isotropic space. The classical definition of angular momentum is however not sustainable, and not just because simultaneous measurements of position and momentum are incompatible. Physical properties of particles and fields have properties that have no classical analogues. Quantum mechanics acknowledges the intrinsic incompatibility in observations of some physical properties and provides a defensible alternative theory to describe nature. We shall therefore be able to persist with the classical interpretation of angular momentum as the generator of rotation in isotropic space only up to a certain point of our analysis; beyond it, we shall require a worthier mathematical model that is robust enough to describe nature acceptably. We consider an object having an arbitrary shape and subject it to a rotation about an axis through it, such as the one schematically shown in Fig. 4.2a. On turning it through an infinitesimal angle, the shape transforms to. We denote the rotation by an operator and express this operation as With reference to a Cartesian coordinate system, a rotation relocates a point whose position vector is to (Fig. 4.2b): Equation 4.1 tells us that the function has the same value at the new orientation as the function, i.e., as, R being the operator corresponding to the said rotation. We shall refer to such a description of transformation of the function as active . In passive description, an equivalent inverse operation on the coordinate system is employed (Fig. 4.2c), leaving the function itself unchanged. The active and the passive descriptions are equivalent.