Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

On a Minimum Property of the Free Energy

R. Peierls

Published Dec 1, 1938• 248 citations
Publisher

Abstract

a minimum ; the value of the integral is the corresponding eigenvalue El of the Hamiltonian H. It is also well known that this property leads to a powerful method of approximating, at least qualitatively, 4,1 and Er, by minimizing (1) among a restricted class of functions. No similarly simple minimum property exists for the higher eigenvalues . One can obtain the nth eigenvalue by minimizing (1) with the subsidiary condition that >G be orthogonal to ¢l, 42, y n-r• However, this procedure becomes progressively more cumbersome as n increases and besides it is of no use unless 4,1, 02, • • • , 4'n-1 are very exactly known. For problems of thermal equilibrium one is often concerned with the free energy, rather than with the individual eigenvalues . It is the purpose of this note to draw attention to a simple minimum property of the free energy which may be considered as a generalization of the variation principle for the lowest eigenvalue. The free energy has the following property: If v1, W2 , • • • , pn, • • • are an arbitrary set of orthogonal and normalized functions, and

DOI
10.1103/physrev.54.918

Related papers

On a Minimum Property of the Free Energy

R. Peierls

a minimum ; the value of the integral is the corresponding eigenvalue El of the Hamiltonian H. It is also well known that this property leads to a powerful method of approximating, at least qualitatively, 4,1 and Er, by minimizing (1) among a restricted class of functions. No similarly simple minimum property exists for the higher eigenvalues . One can obtain the nth eigenvalue by minimizing (1) with the subsidiary condition that >G be orthogonal to ¢l, 42, y n-r• However, this procedure becomes progressively more cumbersome as n increases and besides it is of no use unless 4,1, 02, • • • , 4'n-1 are very exactly known. For problems of thermal equilibrium one is often concerned with the free energy, rather than with the individual eigenvalues . It is the purpose of this note to draw attention to a simple minimum property of the free energy which may be considered as a generalization of the variation principle for the lowest eigenvalue. The free energy has the following property: If v1, W2 , • • • , pn, • • • are an arbitrary set of orthogonal and normalized functions, and

World Scientific series in 20th century physics•Apr 1, 1997•0 citations

Chapter 9: Optimization with the adiabatic theorem

Giacomo Nannicini

The adiabatic theorem is a powerful result concerning the evolution of quantum mechanical systems. Intuitively, it states the following: suppose we want to study the evolution of a quantum mechanical system governed by a given Hamiltonian \(\mathcal H\) (Def. 6.1), and the initial state of the system is the eigenstate of \(\mathcal H\) corresponding to its lowest eigenvalue. The laws of quantum physics tell us that the evolution of the system over time follows the Schrüdinger equation, Eq. (6.1). Suppose now that the Hamiltonian is not fixed, but rather, it changes very slowly over time, so that the evolution of the system is described by the differential equation \(i\,\frac{\mathrm{d} | \psi(t) \rangle}{\mathrm{d}t} = \mathcal{H}(t) | \psi(t) \rangle\), and \(\mathcal{H}(t)\) is slowly changing. If, for any value of the time parameter \(t\), there is always a gap between the lowest eigenvalue of \(\mathcal{H}(t)\) and all other eigenvalues, then the adiabatic theorem asserts that the state of the system always remains in an eigenstate with the lowest eigenvalue throughout the evolution. One specific case of interest in this chapter occurs when the time-dependent Hamiltonian \(\mathcal{H}(t)\) varies from an initial (time-independent) Hamiltonian \(\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{I}}\) to a final Hamiltonian \(\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{F}}\). If the change happens slowly, and the initial state of the system is an eigenstate of \(\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{I}}\) with minimum eigenvalue, the adiabatic theorem asserts that the evolution eventually leads to the eigenstate with minimum eigenvalue of the final Hamiltonian \(\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{F}}\). This result can be used for optimization: imagine that the initial Hamiltonian encodes an easy problem for which we can construct the eigenstate with minimum eigenvalue, and the final Hamiltonian encodes a difficult optimization problem whose solution is given by the eigenstate with minimum eigenvalue. By the adiabatic theorem, evolving the eigenstate of the initial Hamiltonian while slowly changing the Hamiltonian into the final one leads to the solution of the difficult optimization problem. Of course we need to know how slowly \(\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{I}}\) should be changed into \(\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{F}}\). The adiabatic theorem is at the heart of the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA), a framework that has been widely used to implement optimization algorithms on existing quantum hardware, because it has low requirements of quantum resources–although it does not guarantee improvements over classical algorithms in general. In this chapter we first discuss the adiabatic theorem, and then give an overview of QAOA.

Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics eBooks•Dec 17, 2025•0 citations

Extremum in the Schrodinger variational principle

Chen Gang

Some references indicated that the extremum in the Schrodinger variational principle is a minimum.It was shown that the extremum corresponding to the ground state is indeed a minimum,while the extremum corresponding to the excited states are not a minimum,unless the wave-function used in variation is orthogonal to all the lower energy state wave-functions.

Journal of Shandong University•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Derivation of a Lower Bound on the Free Energy

Robert H. T. Yeh

For a Hamiltonian with a ground-state energy E0 = 0, we show that for any normalized state |ψ〉, 〈ψ| e−βH |ψ〉≤e−β〈ψ|H|ψ〉a, where a=exp [−β 〈ψ| H 2 |ψ〉/〈ψ| H |ψ〉]. From this inequality, a general formula for a lower bound on the free energy is derived.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•May 1, 1970•4 citations

Energy eigenvalues for an arbitrary potential well with N minima

Örjan Dammert

For a general smooth one-dimensional potential well with N minima (containing N−1 barrier humps of arbitrary shape), a phase-integral quantization condition (including σ terms) is obtained, from which the energy eigenvalues can be calculated with an accuracy relative to the chosen order of the Fröman phase-integral approximation. The quantization equation is derived from a condition for total transmission through a general system of potential barriers of arbitrary shape, by means of a limiting procedure, in which the two outermost barriers are made to grow large in a particular way. Finally, the quantization condition is expressed by means of a concise recursion formula. As an illustration, the special case N=2 is treated in some detail. For N=2, the quantization condition turns out to be identical to a previously well-known phase-integral quantization condition for the double-minimum potential, the accuracy of which has been examined in several papers by other authors. Their results concerning a symmetric double-minimum model potential show that when the σ term is included, the third- and fifth-order energy eigenvalues are accurate enough for all practical purposes, even close to the barrier maximum, but if the σ term is neglected, the quantization condition breaks down near the barrier maximum, this breakdown becoming more dramatic with increasing order. A table displaying phase-integral eigenvalues for the model potential as compared with exact (numerical) quantum mechanical results is given here; the figures are quoted from the papers mentioned. Applying the results to the special case N=3, it will be given explicitly the quantization condition for an arbitrary triple-minimum potential.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jul 1, 1991•3 citations

Nodal variational principle for excited states

Federico E. Zahariev, Mark S. Gordon, Mel Levy

It is proven that the exact excited-state wave function and energy may be obtained by minimizing the energy expectation value of trial wave functions that are constrained only to have the correct nodes of the state of interest. This excited-state nodal minimum principle has the advantage that it requires neither minimization with the constraint of wave-function orthogonality to all lower eigenstates nor the antisymmetry of the trial wave functions. It is also found that the minimization over the entire space can be partitioned into several interconnected minimizations within the individual nodal regions, and the exact excited-state energy may be obtained by a minimization in just one or several of these nodal regions. For the proofs of the theorem, it is observed that the many-electron eigenfunction (excited state as well as ground state), restricted to a nodal region, is equivalent to a ground-state wave function of one electron in a higher-dimensional space; and, alternatively, an explicit excited-state energy variational expression is utilized by generalizing the Jacobi method of multiplicative variation. In corollaries, error functions are constructed for cases for which the nodes are not necessarily exact. The exact nodes minimize the energy error functions with respect to nodal variations. Simple numerical illustrations of the error functions are presented.

arXiv:1609.02241•Physical Review A•Jul 31, 2018•11 citations
a minimum ; the value of the integral is the corresponding eigenvalue El of the Hamiltonian H. It is also well known that this property leads to a powerful method of approximating, at least qualitatively, 4,1 and Er, by minimizing (1) among a restricted class of functions. No similarly simple minimum property exists for the higher eigenvalues . One can obtain the nth eigenvalue by minimizing (1) with the subsidiary condition that >G be orthogonal to ¢l, 42, y n-r• However, this procedure becomes progressively more cumbersome as n increases and besides it is of no use unless 4,1, 02, • • • , 4'n-1 are very exactly known. For problems of thermal equilibrium one is often concerned with the free energy, rather than with the individual eigenvalues . It is the purpose of this note to draw attention to a simple minimum property of the free energy which may be considered as a generalization of the variation principle for the lowest eigenvalue. The free energy has the following property: If v1, W2 , • • • , pn, • • • are an arbitrary set of orthogonal and normalized functions, and
a minimum ; the value of the integral is the corresponding eigenvalue El of the Hamiltonian H. It is also well known that this property leads to a powerful method of approximating, at least qualitatively, 4,1 and Er, by minimizing (1) among a restricted class of functions. No similarly simple minimum property exists for the higher eigenvalues . One can obtain the nth eigenvalue by minimizing (1) with the subsidiary condition that >G be orthogonal to ¢l, 42, y n-r• However, this procedure becomes progressively more cumbersome as n increases and besides it is of no use unless 4,1, 02, • • • , 4'n-1 are very exactly known. For problems of thermal equilibrium one is often concerned with the free energy, rather than with the individual eigenvalues . It is the purpose of this note to draw attention to a simple minimum property of the free energy which may be considered as a generalization of the variation principle for the lowest eigenvalue. The free energy has the following property: If v1, W2 , • • • , pn, • • • are an arbitrary set of orthogonal and normalized functions, and
The adiabatic theorem is a powerful result concerning the evolution of quantum mechanical systems. Intuitively, it states the following: suppose we want to study the evolution of a quantum mechanical system governed by a given Hamiltonian H\mathcal HH (Def. 6.1), and the initial state of the system is the eigenstate of H\mathcal HH corresponding to its lowest eigenvalue. The laws of quantum physics tell us that the evolution of the system over time follows the Schrüdinger equation, Eq. (6.1). Suppose now that the Hamiltonian is not fixed, but rather, it changes very slowly over time, so that the evolution of the system is described by the differential equation i d∣ψ(t)⟩dt=H(t)∣ψ(t)⟩i\,\frac{\mathrm{d} | \psi(t) \rangle}{\mathrm{d}t} = \mathcal{H}(t) | \psi(t) \rangleidtd∣ψ(t)⟩​=H(t)∣ψ(t)⟩, and H(t)\mathcal{H}(t)H(t) is slowly changing. If, for any value of the time parameter ttt, there is always a gap between the lowest eigenvalue of H(t)\mathcal{H}(t)H(t) and all other eigenvalues, then the adiabatic theorem asserts that the state of the system always remains in an eigenstate with the lowest eigenvalue throughout the evolution. One specific case of interest in this chapter occurs when the time-dependent Hamiltonian H(t)\mathcal{H}(t)H(t) varies from an initial (time-independent) Hamiltonian HI\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{I}}HI​ to a final Hamiltonian HF\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{F}}HF​. If the change happens slowly, and the initial state of the system is an eigenstate of HI\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{I}}HI​ with minimum eigenvalue, the adiabatic theorem asserts that the evolution eventually leads to the eigenstate with minimum eigenvalue of the final Hamiltonian HF\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{F}}HF​. This result can be used for optimization: imagine that the initial Hamiltonian encodes an easy problem for which we can construct the eigenstate with minimum eigenvalue, and the final Hamiltonian encodes a difficult optimization problem whose solution is given by the eigenstate with minimum eigenvalue. By the adiabatic theorem, evolving the eigenstate of the initial Hamiltonian while slowly changing the Hamiltonian into the final one leads to the solution of the difficult optimization problem. Of course we need to know how slowly HI\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{I}}HI​ should be changed into HF\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{F}}HF​. The adiabatic theorem is at the heart of the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA), a framework that has been widely used to implement optimization algorithms on existing quantum hardware, because it has low requirements of quantum resources–although it does not guarantee improvements over classical algorithms in general. In this chapter we first discuss the adiabatic theorem, and then give an overview of QAOA.
For a general smooth one-dimensional potential well with N minima (containing N−1 barrier humps of arbitrary shape), a phase-integral quantization condition (including σ terms) is obtained, from which the energy eigenvalues can be calculated with an accuracy relative to the chosen order of the Fröman phase-integral approximation. The quantization equation is derived from a condition for total transmission through a general system of potential barriers of arbitrary shape, by means of a limiting procedure, in which the two outermost barriers are made to grow large in a particular way. Finally, the quantization condition is expressed by means of a concise recursion formula. As an illustration, the special case N=2 is treated in some detail. For N=2, the quantization condition turns out to be identical to a previously well-known phase-integral quantization condition for the double-minimum potential, the accuracy of which has been examined in several papers by other authors. Their results concerning a symmetric double-minimum model potential show that when the σ term is included, the third- and fifth-order energy eigenvalues are accurate enough for all practical purposes, even close to the barrier maximum, but if the σ term is neglected, the quantization condition breaks down near the barrier maximum, this breakdown becoming more dramatic with increasing order. A table displaying phase-integral eigenvalues for the model potential as compared with exact (numerical) quantum mechanical results is given here; the figures are quoted from the papers mentioned. Applying the results to the special case N=3, it will be given explicitly the quantization condition for an arbitrary triple-minimum potential.
It is proven that the exact excited-state wave function and energy may be obtained by minimizing the energy expectation value of trial wave functions that are constrained only to have the correct nodes of the state of interest. This excited-state nodal minimum principle has the advantage that it requires neither minimization with the constraint of wave-function orthogonality to all lower eigenstates nor the antisymmetry of the trial wave functions. It is also found that the minimization over the entire space can be partitioned into several interconnected minimizations within the individual nodal regions, and the exact excited-state energy may be obtained by a minimization in just one or several of these nodal regions. For the proofs of the theorem, it is observed that the many-electron eigenfunction (excited state as well as ground state), restricted to a nodal region, is equivalent to a ground-state wave function of one electron in a higher-dimensional space; and, alternatively, an explicit excited-state energy variational expression is utilized by generalizing the Jacobi method of multiplicative variation. In corollaries, error functions are constructed for cases for which the nodes are not necessarily exact. The exact nodes minimize the energy error functions with respect to nodal variations. Simple numerical illustrations of the error functions are presented.