Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Dirac Equation's Mystery

Daehyeon Kang

Published Dec 1, 2013• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Agualar momentum j in the Dirac equation and j in the schronger equation are eqaul or different ? they are equal. but, j=0 in the dirac equation is forbidden, j=0 in the schronger equation is allowed. from this fact, it seems Dirac equation is not appropriate to study atomic phenomenon. maybe, only in a central field of force.

Related papers

The Dirac equation as a path to the concept of quanta, and its role in quantum electrodynamics

Mário Bacelar Valente

In this article the Dirac equation is used as a guideline to see the historical emergence of the concept of quanta, associated with the quantum field. In P. Jordan’s approach, electrons as quanta result from the quantization of a classical field described by the Dirac equation. With this quantization procedure – also used for the electromagnetic field – the concept of quanta becomes a central piece in the applications of quantum electrodynamics. This does not seem to avoid the apparent impossibility of using the concept of quanta – and with it the common interpretation of quantum fields – when interacting fields are considered together as one complete system. In this article it is defended that the type of analysis that leads to so drastic conclusions is avoidable if a clear distinction is made between the mathematical framework of the theory and the particular physical models (used in the empirical corroboration of the theory) that are constructed using the theory. When dealing with models there really is no system of complete interacting fields, and what we have is a description of the interactions between distinct fields. In this situation the concept of quanta is central in the description of interacting fields, the Fock space being the natural mathematical structure that permits maintaining the quanta concept when considering the interaction between fields.

•Apr 1, 2008•1 citation

The Dirac equation, the concept of quanta, and the description of interactions in quantum electrodynamics

Mário Bacelar Valente

In this article the Dirac equation is used as a guideline to the historical emergence of the concept of quanta, associated with the quantum field. In Pascual Jordan’s approach, electrons as quanta result from the quantization of a classical field described by the Dirac equation. With this quantization procedure – also used for the electromagnetic field – the concept of quanta becomes a central piece in quantum electrodynamics. This does not seem to avoid the apparent impossibility of using the concept of quanta when interacting fields are considered together as a closed system. In this article it is defended that the type of analysis that leads to so drastic conclusions is avoidable if we look beyond the mathematical structure of the theory and take into account the physical ideas inscribed in this mathematical structure. In this case we see that in quantum electrodynamics we are not considering a closed system of interacting fields, what we have is a description of the interactions between distinct fields. In this situation the concept of quanta is central, the Fock space being the natural mathematical structure that permits maintaining the concept of quanta when considering the interaction between the fields.

•Aug 2, 2010•1 citation

The stationary state of hydrogen atom described by dirac equation is notthe instrinsic state of the operation S

HU Kun-ming

The stationary state of hydrogen atom described by Dirac theory has a simple characteristic.That is the values of quantum number n and j of the energy level are decided,but that of l can be different.So this stationary state corresponding to the fine structure of the energy level is not the intrinsic state of the operator S·.and that the electron spin is not the theory of relativity effect of orbit angular momentum of the polition-figure space is dissertated.

•Jan 1, 2005•0 citations

The Dirac oscillator

M. Moshińsky, Adam P. Szczepaniak

Dirac's free particle equation originated in an attempt to express linearly the relativistic quadratic relation between energy and momentum. The authors introduce a Dirac equation which, besides the momentum, is also linear in the coordinates. They call it the Dirac oscillator because in the nonrelativistic limit it becomes a harmonic oscillator with a very strong spin-orbit coupling term. The eigenstates and eigenvalues of the Dirac oscillator can be obtained in an elementary fashion, with the degeneracy of the latter being quite different from that of the ordinary oscillator. They briefly mention the symmetry Lie algebra responsible for this degeneracy and the generalisation of the problem to many-particle systems.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Sep 7, 1989•736 citations

Derivation of a Relativistic Wave Equation more Profound than Dirac’s Relativistic Wave Equation

Koshun Suto

The author has previously derived an energy-momentum relationship applicable in a hydrogen atom. Since this relationship is taken as a departure point, there is a similarity with the Dirac’s relativistic wave equation, but an equation more profound than the Dirac equation is derived. When determining the coefficients and β of the Dirac equation, Dirac assumed that the equation satisfies the Klein-Gordon equation. The Klein-Gordon equation is an equation which quantizes Einstein's energy-momentum relationship. This paper derives an equation similar to the Klein-Gordon equation by quantizing the relationship between energy and momentum of the electron in a hydrogen atom. By looking to the Dirac equation, it is predicted that there is a relativistic wave equation which satisfies that equation, and its coefficients are determined. With the Dirac equation it is necessary to insert a term for potential energy into the equation when describing the state of the electron in a hydrogen atom. However, in this paper, a potential energy term is not introduced into the relativistic wave equation. Instead, potential energy is incorporated into the equation by changing the coefficient of the Dirac equation.

Applied Physics Research•Nov 30, 2018•15 citations

On Dirac theory in the space with deformed Heisenberg algebra. Exact solutions

I. O. Vakarchuk

The Dirac equation has been studied in which the Dirac matrices $\\hat{\\boldmath$\\alpha$}, \\hat\\beta$ have space factors, respectively $f$ and $f_1$, dependent on the particle's space coordinates. The $f$ function deforms Heisenberg algebra for the coordinates and momenta operators, the function $f_1$ being treated as a dependence of the particle mass on its position. The properties of these functions in the transition to the Schr\\"odinger equation are discussed. The exact solution of the Dirac equation for the particle motion in the Coulomnb field with a linear dependence of the $f$ function on the distance $r$ to the force centre and the inverse dependence on $r$ for the $f_1$ function has been found.

•Mar 19, 2005•4 citations
In this article the Dirac equation is used as a guideline to see the historical emergence of the concept of quanta, associated with the quantum field. In P. Jordan’s approach, electrons as quanta result from the quantization of a classical field described by the Dirac equation. With this quantization procedure – also used for the electromagnetic field – the concept of quanta becomes a central piece in the applications of quantum electrodynamics. This does not seem to avoid the apparent impossibility of using the concept of quanta – and with it the common interpretation of quantum fields – when interacting fields are considered together as one complete system. In this article it is defended that the type of analysis that leads to so drastic conclusions is avoidable if a clear distinction is made between the mathematical framework of the theory and the particular physical models (used in the empirical corroboration of the theory) that are constructed using the theory. When dealing with models there really is no system of complete interacting fields, and what we have is a description of the interactions between distinct fields. In this situation the concept of quanta is central in the description of interacting fields, the Fock space being the natural mathematical structure that permits maintaining the quanta concept when considering the interaction between fields.
In this article the Dirac equation is used as a guideline to the historical emergence of the concept of quanta, associated with the quantum field. In Pascual Jordan’s approach, electrons as quanta result from the quantization of a classical field described by the Dirac equation. With this quantization procedure – also used for the electromagnetic field – the concept of quanta becomes a central piece in quantum electrodynamics. This does not seem to avoid the apparent impossibility of using the concept of quanta when interacting fields are considered together as a closed system. In this article it is defended that the type of analysis that leads to so drastic conclusions is avoidable if we look beyond the mathematical structure of the theory and take into account the physical ideas inscribed in this mathematical structure. In this case we see that in quantum electrodynamics we are not considering a closed system of interacting fields, what we have is a description of the interactions between distinct fields. In this situation the concept of quanta is central, the Fock space being the natural mathematical structure that permits maintaining the concept of quanta when considering the interaction between the fields.
Dirac's free particle equation originated in an attempt to express linearly the relativistic quadratic relation between energy and momentum. The authors introduce a Dirac equation which, besides the momentum, is also linear in the coordinates. They call it the Dirac oscillator because in the nonrelativistic limit it becomes a harmonic oscillator with a very strong spin-orbit coupling term. The eigenstates and eigenvalues of the Dirac oscillator can be obtained in an elementary fashion, with the degeneracy of the latter being quite different from that of the ordinary oscillator. They briefly mention the symmetry Lie algebra responsible for this degeneracy and the generalisation of the problem to many-particle systems.
The author has previously derived an energy-momentum relationship applicable in a hydrogen atom. Since this relationship is taken as a departure point, there is a similarity with the Dirac’s relativistic wave equation, but an equation more profound than the Dirac equation is derived. When determining the coefficients and β of the Dirac equation, Dirac assumed that the equation satisfies the Klein-Gordon equation. The Klein-Gordon equation is an equation which quantizes Einstein's energy-momentum relationship. This paper derives an equation similar to the Klein-Gordon equation by quantizing the relationship between energy and momentum of the electron in a hydrogen atom. By looking to the Dirac equation, it is predicted that there is a relativistic wave equation which satisfies that equation, and its coefficients are determined. With the Dirac equation it is necessary to insert a term for potential energy into the equation when describing the state of the electron in a hydrogen atom. However, in this paper, a potential energy term is not introduced into the relativistic wave equation. Instead, potential energy is incorporated into the equation by changing the coefficient of the Dirac equation.
The Dirac equation has been studied in which the Dirac matrices $\\hat{\\boldmath$\\alpha$}, \\hat\\beta$ have space factors, respectively fff and f1f_1f1​, dependent on the particle's space coordinates. The fff function deforms Heisenberg algebra for the coordinates and momenta operators, the function f1f_1f1​ being treated as a dependence of the particle mass on its position. The properties of these functions in the transition to the Schr\\"odinger equation are discussed. The exact solution of the Dirac equation for the particle motion in the Coulomnb field with a linear dependence of the fff function on the distance rrr to the force centre and the inverse dependence on rrr for the f1f_1f1​ function has been found.