Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Observations on variational and projector Monte Carlo methods

Cyrus J. Umrigar

Published Oct 26, 2015• 31 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Variational Monte Carlo and various projector Monte Carlo (PMC) methods are presented in a unified manner. Similarities and differences between the methods and choices made in designing the methods are discussed. Both methods where the Monte Carlo walk is performed in a discrete space and methods where it is performed in a continuous space are considered. It is pointed out that the usual prescription for importance sampling may not be advantageous depending on the particular quantum Monte Carlo method used and the observables of interest, so alternate prescriptions are presented. The nature of the sign problem is discussed for various versions of PMC methods. A prescription for an exact PMC method in real space, i.e., a method that does not make a fixed-node or similar approximation and does not have a finite basis error, is presented. This method is likely to be practical for systems with a small number of electrons. Approximate PMC methods that are applicable to larger systems and go beyond the fixed-node approximation are also discussed.

DOI
10.1063/1.4933112

Related papers

Quantum Monte Carlo simulations of interacting electrons

Ryszard Olchawa

A brief introduction to the Monte Carlo methods and the most common types of Quantum Monte Carlo, Variational Monte Carlo and Diffusion Monte Carlo are presented. The fermion sign problem in Diffusion Monte Carlo is outlined and a way of bypassing the fixed-node approximation is discussed.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Feb 28, 2006•1 citation

A brief introduction to the diffusion Monte Carlo method and the fixed-node approximation

Alfonso Annarelli, Dario Alfè, Andrea Zen

Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) methods represent a powerful family of computational techniques for tackling complex quantum many-body problems and performing calculations of stationary state properties. QMC is among the most accurate and powerful approaches to the study of electronic structure, but its application is often hindered by a steep learning curve; hence it is rarely addressed in undergraduate and postgraduate classes. This tutorial is a step toward filling this gap. We offer an introduction to the diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) method, which aims to solve the imaginary time Schrödinger equation through stochastic sampling of the configuration space. Starting from the theoretical foundations, the discussion leads naturally to the formulation of a step-by-step algorithm. To illustrate how the method works in simplified scenarios, examples such as the harmonic oscillator and the hydrogen atom are provided. The discussion extends to the fixed-node approximation, a crucial approach for addressing the fermionic sign problem in multi-electron systems. In particular, we examine the influence of trial wave function nodal surfaces on the accuracy of DMC energy by evaluating results from a non-interacting two-fermion system. Extending the method to excited states is feasible in principle, but some additional considerations are needed, supported by practical insights. By addressing the fundamental concepts from a hands-on perspective, we hope this tutorial will serve as a valuable guide for researchers and students approaching DMC for the first time.

arXiv:2412.06006•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Dec 28, 2024•9 citations

6. An Overview of Quantum Monte Carlo Methods

David M. Ceperley

In this brief article, I introduce the various types of quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) methods, in particular, those that are applicable to systems in extreme regimes of temperature and pressure.We give references to longer articles where detailed discussion of applications and algorithms appear. MOTIVATIONOne does QMC for the same reason as one does classical simulations; there is no other method able to treat exactly the quantum many-body problem aside from the direct simulation method where electrons and ions are directly represented as particles, instead of as a "fluid" as is done in mean-field based methods.However, quantum systems are more difficult than classical systems because one does not know the distribution to be sampled, it must be solved for.In fact, it is not known today which quantum problems can be "solved" with simulation on a classical computer in a reasonable amount of computer time.One knows that certain systems, such as most quantum many-body systems in 1D and most bosonic systems are amenable to solution with Monte Carlo methods, however, the "sign problem" prevents making the same statement for systems with electrons in 3D.Some limitations or approximations are needed in practice.On the other hand, in contrast to simulation of classical systems, one does know the Hamiltonian exactly: namely charged particles interacting with a Coulomb potential.Given sufficient computer resources, the results can be of quite high quality and for systems where there is little reliable experimental data.For this reason, QMC methods, though more expensive, are useful to benchmark and validate results from other methods.The two main applications that we will discuss in this review are the "electronic structure problem"; computing the energy of the an interacting systems of electrons and fixed ions, and the problem of quantum effects of the nuclei. RANDOM WALK AND MARKOV CHAINSMost QMC algorithms are based on random walks, known mathematically as Markov chains.This is a general class of algorithms, introduced in the famous work by Metropolis, the Rosenbluths and the Tellers (1953) for sampling any probability distribution.Let us denote the desired distribution as Π(S), where the variable "S" represents the state of the walk, for example the coordinates of all of the particles.In a random walk, one invents some moving rules (transition probabilities) for changing the state of the system so that the probability of being in state S n+1 in the (n+1) step, given that the random walk was S n is given by T(S n ; S n+1 ).By

De Gruyter eBooks•Dec 31, 2010•2 citations

A unified theory of variational and quantum Monte Carlo methods and beyond

Mohammad-Sadegh Vaezi, Abolhassan Vaezi

We present a unified theory of the variational Monte Carlo (VMC) and determinant quantum Monte Carlo (DQMC) methods using a novel density matrix formulation of VMC. We introduce an efficient algorithm for VMC to compute correlation functions and expectation values based on the auxiliary field Hirsch-Hubbard-Stratonovic transformation. We show that this new approach to VMC converges significantly faster than its traditional implementations. Furthermore, we generalize the Trotter-Suzuki decomposition to finite imaginary time steps $τ\sim O(1)$ and develop a variational quantum Monte Carlo (VQMC) method accordingly, which is more accurate than VMC and can incorporate quantum fluctuations more efficiently. The two extreme limits of the VQMC method, namely infinitesimal and infinite imaginary time steps, correspond to the DQMC and VMC techniques, respectively. We demonstrate that our VQMC allows us to access lower temperatures in comparison with the conventional DQMC before the sign problem comes into play. We finally show that our VQMC can also enhance the accuracy of the projector Monte Carlo methods by providing better and less biased candidates for the trial wave functions, requiring shorter projection times for a given accuracy and alleviating the sign problem further.

arXiv:1810.00864•Oct 1, 2018•6 citations

Explicitly correlated projector Monte Carlo method based on Slater determinants (PMC-SD-F12 method)

Yuhki Ohtsuka, Seiichiro Ten‐no

We propose the explicitly correlated projector Monte Carlo method based on Slater determinants (PMC-SDF12 method) for accurate calculations of correlated wave functions. The F12 similarity transformed Hamiltonian is used to calculate the transition probabilities, weights, and electronic energies in the PMC-SD-F12 method. Test applications show that the energy convergence against the quality of basis set is accelerated compared to the PMC-SD method. The correlation energy using aug-cc-pCVQZ basis gave good agreement with the best values available in the literature.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2012•8 citations

Projector quantum Monte Carlo with matrix product states

Sebastian Wouters, Brecht Verstichel, Dimitri Van Neck +1 more

We marry tensor network states (TNS) and projector quantum Monte Carlo (PMC) to overcome the high computational scaling of TNS and the sign problem of PMC. Using TNS as trial wave functions provides a route to systematically improve the sign structure and to eliminate the bias in fixed-node and constrained-path PMC. As a specific example, we describe phaseless auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo with matrix product states (MPS-AFQMC). MPS-AFQMC improves significantly on the density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) ground-state energy. For the ${J}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{2}$ model on two-dimensional square lattices, we observe with MPS-AFQMC an order of magnitude reduction in the error for all couplings, compared to DMRG. The improvement is independent of walker bond dimension, and we therefore use bond dimension 1 for the walkers. The computational cost of MPS-AFQMC is then quadratic in the bond dimension of the trial wave function, which is lower than the cubic scaling of DMRG. The error due to the constrained-path bias is proportional to the variational error of the trial wave function. We show that for the ${J}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{2}$ model on two-dimensional square lattices, a linear extrapolation of the MPS-AFQMC energy with the discarded weight from the DMRG calculation allows us to remove the constrained-path bias. Extensions to other tensor networks are briefly discussed.

arXiv:1403.3125•Physical Review B•Jul 3, 2014•30 citations
Variational Monte Carlo and various projector Monte Carlo (PMC) methods are presented in a unified manner. Similarities and differences between the methods and choices made in designing the methods are discussed. Both methods where the Monte Carlo walk is performed in a discrete space and methods where it is performed in a continuous space are considered. It is pointed out that the usual prescription for importance sampling may not be advantageous depending on the particular quantum Monte Carlo method used and the observables of interest, so alternate prescriptions are presented. The nature of the sign problem is discussed for various versions of PMC methods. A prescription for an exact PMC method in real space, i.e., a method that does not make a fixed-node or similar approximation and does not have a finite basis error, is presented. This method is likely to be practical for systems with a small number of electrons. Approximate PMC methods that are applicable to larger systems and go beyond the fixed-node approximation are also discussed.
Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) methods represent a powerful family of computational techniques for tackling complex quantum many-body problems and performing calculations of stationary state properties. QMC is among the most accurate and powerful approaches to the study of electronic structure, but its application is often hindered by a steep learning curve; hence it is rarely addressed in undergraduate and postgraduate classes. This tutorial is a step toward filling this gap. We offer an introduction to the diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) method, which aims to solve the imaginary time Schrödinger equation through stochastic sampling of the configuration space. Starting from the theoretical foundations, the discussion leads naturally to the formulation of a step-by-step algorithm. To illustrate how the method works in simplified scenarios, examples such as the harmonic oscillator and the hydrogen atom are provided. The discussion extends to the fixed-node approximation, a crucial approach for addressing the fermionic sign problem in multi-electron systems. In particular, we examine the influence of trial wave function nodal surfaces on the accuracy of DMC energy by evaluating results from a non-interacting two-fermion system. Extending the method to excited states is feasible in principle, but some additional considerations are needed, supported by practical insights. By addressing the fundamental concepts from a hands-on perspective, we hope this tutorial will serve as a valuable guide for researchers and students approaching DMC for the first time.
In this brief article, I introduce the various types of quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) methods, in particular, those that are applicable to systems in extreme regimes of temperature and pressure.We give references to longer articles where detailed discussion of applications and algorithms appear. MOTIVATIONOne does QMC for the same reason as one does classical simulations; there is no other method able to treat exactly the quantum many-body problem aside from the direct simulation method where electrons and ions are directly represented as particles, instead of as a "fluid" as is done in mean-field based methods.However, quantum systems are more difficult than classical systems because one does not know the distribution to be sampled, it must be solved for.In fact, it is not known today which quantum problems can be "solved" with simulation on a classical computer in a reasonable amount of computer time.One knows that certain systems, such as most quantum many-body systems in 1D and most bosonic systems are amenable to solution with Monte Carlo methods, however, the "sign problem" prevents making the same statement for systems with electrons in 3D.Some limitations or approximations are needed in practice.On the other hand, in contrast to simulation of classical systems, one does know the Hamiltonian exactly: namely charged particles interacting with a Coulomb potential.Given sufficient computer resources, the results can be of quite high quality and for systems where there is little reliable experimental data.For this reason, QMC methods, though more expensive, are useful to benchmark and validate results from other methods.The two main applications that we will discuss in this review are the "electronic structure problem"; computing the energy of the an interacting systems of electrons and fixed ions, and the problem of quantum effects of the nuclei. RANDOM WALK AND MARKOV CHAINSMost QMC algorithms are based on random walks, known mathematically as Markov chains.This is a general class of algorithms, introduced in the famous work by Metropolis, the Rosenbluths and the Tellers (1953) for sampling any probability distribution.Let us denote the desired distribution as Π(S), where the variable "S" represents the state of the walk, for example the coordinates of all of the particles.In a random walk, one invents some moving rules (transition probabilities) for changing the state of the system so that the probability of being in state S n+1 in the (n+1) step, given that the random walk was S n is given by T(S n ; S n+1 ).By
We present a unified theory of the variational Monte Carlo (VMC) and determinant quantum Monte Carlo (DQMC) methods using a novel density matrix formulation of VMC. We introduce an efficient algorithm for VMC to compute correlation functions and expectation values based on the auxiliary field Hirsch-Hubbard-Stratonovic transformation. We show that this new approach to VMC converges significantly faster than its traditional implementations. Furthermore, we generalize the Trotter-Suzuki decomposition to finite imaginary time steps τ∼O(1)τ\sim O(1)τ∼O(1) and develop a variational quantum Monte Carlo (VQMC) method accordingly, which is more accurate than VMC and can incorporate quantum fluctuations more efficiently. The two extreme limits of the VQMC method, namely infinitesimal and infinite imaginary time steps, correspond to the DQMC and VMC techniques, respectively. We demonstrate that our VQMC allows us to access lower temperatures in comparison with the conventional DQMC before the sign problem comes into play. We finally show that our VQMC can also enhance the accuracy of the projector Monte Carlo methods by providing better and less biased candidates for the trial wave functions, requiring shorter projection times for a given accuracy and alleviating the sign problem further.
We propose the explicitly correlated projector Monte Carlo method based on Slater determinants (PMC-SDF12 method) for accurate calculations of correlated wave functions. The F12 similarity transformed Hamiltonian is used to calculate the transition probabilities, weights, and electronic energies in the PMC-SD-F12 method. Test applications show that the energy convergence against the quality of basis set is accelerated compared to the PMC-SD method. The correlation energy using aug-cc-pCVQZ basis gave good agreement with the best values available in the literature.
We marry tensor network states (TNS) and projector quantum Monte Carlo (PMC) to overcome the high computational scaling of TNS and the sign problem of PMC. Using TNS as trial wave functions provides a route to systematically improve the sign structure and to eliminate the bias in fixed-node and constrained-path PMC. As a specific example, we describe phaseless auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo with matrix product states (MPS-AFQMC). MPS-AFQMC improves significantly on the density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) ground-state energy. For the ${J}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{2}$ model on two-dimensional square lattices, we observe with MPS-AFQMC an order of magnitude reduction in the error for all couplings, compared to DMRG. The improvement is independent of walker bond dimension, and we therefore use bond dimension 1 for the walkers. The computational cost of MPS-AFQMC is then quadratic in the bond dimension of the trial wave function, which is lower than the cubic scaling of DMRG. The error due to the constrained-path bias is proportional to the variational error of the trial wave function. We show that for the ${J}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{2}$ model on two-dimensional square lattices, a linear extrapolation of the MPS-AFQMC energy with the discarded weight from the DMRG calculation allows us to remove the constrained-path bias. Extensions to other tensor networks are briefly discussed.