Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Revista Mexicana de Física

On the necessity of the postulate of the collapse of the wave function: an explicit calculation of the "double-slit" problem

Ricardo Martínez-Galicia, Víctor Romero-Rochín

Published Jan 1, 2005• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Based on numerical calculations of the two-slit problem, we object van Kampen´s proposal that the collapse of the wave function is an unnecessary postulate of Quantum Mechanics if the measuring apparatus is included in a unitary evolution of the system-apparatus. We argue that van Kampen´s interpretation does not substitute the collapse postulate, it is not precise and it appears impracticable.

Related papers

The Quantum Mechanics Needs the Principle of Wave-Function Collapse—But This Principle Shouldn’t Be Misunderstood

Sofia Wechsler

The postulate of the collapse of the wave-function stands between the microscopic, quantum world, and the macroscopic world. Because of this intermediate position, the collapse process cannot be examined with the formalism of the quantum mechanics (QM), neither with that of classical mechanics. This fact makes some physicists propose interpretations of QM, which avoid this postulate. However, the common procedure used in that is making assumptions incompatible with the QM formalism. The present work discusses the most popular interpretations. It is shown that because of such assumptions those interpretations fail, i.e. predict for some experiments results which differ from the QM predictions. Despite that, special attention is called to a proposal of S. Gao, the only one which addresses and tries to solve an obvious and major contradiction. A couple of theorems are proved for showing that the collapse postulate is necessary in the QM. Although non-explainable with the quantum formalism, this postulate cannot be denied, otherwise one comes to conclusions which disagree with the QM. It is also proved here that the idea of “collapse at a distance” is problematic especially in relativistic cases, and is a misunderstanding. Namely, in an entanglement of two quantum systems, assuming that the measurement of one of the systems (accompanied by collapse of that system on one of its states) collapses the other systems, too without the second system being measured, which leads to a contradiction.

arXiv:2102.10000•Journal of Quantum Information Science•Jan 1, 2021•10 citations

Minimal Set of Quantum Postulates and Realistic Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Sumio Wada

We argue that quantum mechanics makes sense without such controversial postulates as the wave function collapse, the quantum probability rule and the observable postulate. We only need the existence of a wave function as a representation of a state, its dynamical evolution rule and another rather trivial postulate proposed here (Read-Off Postulate). The wave function collapse and the probability rule are replaced with intrinsic properties of the theory, i.e. decoherence and relative frequency, respectively. Interpretation of the wave function as a faithful representation of the reality naturally emerges, although quantum reality has a peculiar feature which distinguishes it from classical reality.

arXiv:0909.3188•Sep 17, 2009•1 citation

N-slit interference and ‘the collapse of the wave function’

Francisco Duarte

It is explained that, in an N-slit experimental configuration the so called ‘collapse of the wave function’ is an unnecessary concept. The explanation begins going back to the original words of Heisenberg on the reduction of the wave packet and continues while considering the measurement process in an N-slit interferometer. In this regard, it is articulated that a clean and direct transition from the superposition probability amplitude to the probability distribution is all that is needed. The discussion includes measurable decoherence in the interferometric domain and the Diósi-Penrose hypothesis.

•Jul 10, 2026•0 citations

N-slit interference and ‘the collapse of the wave function’

Francisco Duarte

It is explained that, in an N-slit experimental configuration the so called ‘collapse of the wave function’ is an unnecessary concept. The explanation begins going back to the original words of Heisenberg on the reduction of the wave packet and continues while considering the measurement process in an N-slit interferometer. In this regard, it is articulated that a clean and direct transition from the superposition probability amplitude to the probability distribution is all that is needed. The discussion includes measurable decoherence in the interferometric domain and the Diósi-Penrose hypothesis.

•Jul 10, 2026•0 citations

N-slit interference and ‘the collapse of the wave function’

Francisco Duarte

It is explained that, in an N-slit experimental configuration the so called ‘collapse of the wave function’ is an unnecessary concept. The explanation begins going back to the original words of Heisenberg on the reduction of the wave packet and continues while considering the measurement process in an N-slit interferometer. In this regard, it is articulated that a clean and direct transition from the superposition probability amplitude to the probability distribution is all that is needed. The discussion includes measurable decoherence in the interferometric domain and the Diósi-Penrose hypothesis.

•Aug 4, 2026•0 citations

Deterministic Decoherence: Modeling the Measuring Apparatus as an Active Noise Source in the Double-Slit Interferometer

Joshua Knoechelman

The “measurement problem” and the subsequent postulate of instantaneous wave-function collapse remain persistent pedagogical challenges in quantum mechanics. This paper proposes that the apparent paradox of measurement arises from an incomplete idealization of the measuring apparatus as a passive observer, rather than a physical, interacting system. By discarding the unitary state vector formalism during the act of measurement and modeling the detector explicitly as an active noise manifold using the Lindblad master equation, we demonstrate that the suppression of quantum interference is a deterministic, calculable mechanical degradation of phase coherence. Through a numerical simulation of the double-slit experiment, we show that scaling the detector’s stochastic noise rate γD smoothly reproduces the pure unitary interference regime, the weak-measurement partial decoherence regime, and the emergence of classical probability distributions, offering a concrete pedagogical alternative to non-unitary projection postulates.

•Mar 13, 2026•0 citations
Based on numerical calculations of the two-slit problem, we object van Kampen´s proposal that the collapse of the wave function is an unnecessary postulate of Quantum Mechanics if the measuring apparatus is included in a unitary evolution of the system-apparatus. We argue that van Kampen´s interpretation does not substitute the collapse postulate, it is not precise and it appears impracticable.
The postulate of the collapse of the wave-function stands between the microscopic, quantum world, and the macroscopic world. Because of this intermediate position, the collapse process cannot be examined with the formalism of the quantum mechanics (QM), neither with that of classical mechanics. This fact makes some physicists propose interpretations of QM, which avoid this postulate. However, the common procedure used in that is making assumptions incompatible with the QM formalism. The present work discusses the most popular interpretations. It is shown that because of such assumptions those interpretations fail, i.e. predict for some experiments results which differ from the QM predictions. Despite that, special attention is called to a proposal of S. Gao, the only one which addresses and tries to solve an obvious and major contradiction. A couple of theorems are proved for showing that the collapse postulate is necessary in the QM. Although non-explainable with the quantum formalism, this postulate cannot be denied, otherwise one comes to conclusions which disagree with the QM. It is also proved here that the idea of “collapse at a distance” is problematic especially in relativistic cases, and is a misunderstanding. Namely, in an entanglement of two quantum systems, assuming that the measurement of one of the systems (accompanied by collapse of that system on one of its states) collapses the other systems, too without the second system being measured, which leads to a contradiction.
We argue that quantum mechanics makes sense without such controversial postulates as the wave function collapse, the quantum probability rule and the observable postulate. We only need the existence of a wave function as a representation of a state, its dynamical evolution rule and another rather trivial postulate proposed here (Read-Off Postulate). The wave function collapse and the probability rule are replaced with intrinsic properties of the theory, i.e. decoherence and relative frequency, respectively. Interpretation of the wave function as a faithful representation of the reality naturally emerges, although quantum reality has a peculiar feature which distinguishes it from classical reality.
It is explained that, in an N-slit experimental configuration the so called ‘collapse of the wave function’ is an unnecessary concept. The explanation begins going back to the original words of Heisenberg on the reduction of the wave packet and continues while considering the measurement process in an N-slit interferometer. In this regard, it is articulated that a clean and direct transition from the superposition probability amplitude to the probability distribution is all that is needed. The discussion includes measurable decoherence in the interferometric domain and the Diósi-Penrose hypothesis.
It is explained that, in an N-slit experimental configuration the so called ‘collapse of the wave function’ is an unnecessary concept. The explanation begins going back to the original words of Heisenberg on the reduction of the wave packet and continues while considering the measurement process in an N-slit interferometer. In this regard, it is articulated that a clean and direct transition from the superposition probability amplitude to the probability distribution is all that is needed. The discussion includes measurable decoherence in the interferometric domain and the Diósi-Penrose hypothesis.
It is explained that, in an N-slit experimental configuration the so called ‘collapse of the wave function’ is an unnecessary concept. The explanation begins going back to the original words of Heisenberg on the reduction of the wave packet and continues while considering the measurement process in an N-slit interferometer. In this regard, it is articulated that a clean and direct transition from the superposition probability amplitude to the probability distribution is all that is needed. The discussion includes measurable decoherence in the interferometric domain and the Diósi-Penrose hypothesis.
The “measurement problem” and the subsequent postulate of instantaneous wave-function collapse remain persistent pedagogical challenges in quantum mechanics. This paper proposes that the apparent paradox of measurement arises from an incomplete idealization of the measuring apparatus as a passive observer, rather than a physical, interacting system. By discarding the unitary state vector formalism during the act of measurement and modeling the detector explicitly as an active noise manifold using the Lindblad master equation, we demonstrate that the suppression of quantum interference is a deterministic, calculable mechanical degradation of phase coherence. Through a numerical simulation of the double-slit experiment, we show that scaling the detector’s stochastic noise rate γD smoothly reproduces the pure unitary interference regime, the weak-measurement partial decoherence regime, and the emergence of classical probability distributions, offering a concrete pedagogical alternative to non-unitary projection postulates.