Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Demonstrations of adaptive quantum measurements in optics

Brendon L. Higgins, Dominic William Berry, Byron Booth, Morgan W. Mitchell, Andrew C. Doherty, Stephen D. Bartlett, Howard M. Wiseman, Geoff J. Pryde

Published Jan 1, 2009• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Quantum measurement protocols make use of the quantum nature of the universe to gain more information about a system using fewer resources than would otherwise be possible. Achieving precision at the fundamental limits imposed by quantum mechanics nevertheless remains a challenge. Adaptive quantum measurement protocols may allow us to step closer to these ultimate limits. We present an overview of some interesting recent results of quantum measurement schemes as demonstrated in single-photon optical implementations, in the contexts of unambiguous phase estimation and multiple-copy non-orthogonal state discrimination.

Related papers

Adaptive Measurements in the Optical Quantum Information Laboratory

Howard M. Wiseman, Dominic William Berry, Stephen D. Bartlett +2 more

Adaptive techniques make practical many quantum measurements that would otherwise be beyond current laboratory capabilities. For example, they allow discrimination of nonorthogonal states with a probability of error equal to the Helstrom bound, measurement of the phase of a quantum oscillator with accuracy approaching (or in some cases attaining) the Heisenberg limit (HL), and estimation of phase in interferometry with a variance scaling at the HL, using only single qubit measurement and control. Each of these examples has close links with quantum information, in particular, experimental optical quantum information: the first is a basic quantum communication protocol; the second has potential application in linear optical quantum computing; the third uses an adaptive protocol inspired by the quantum phase estimation algorithm. We discuss each of these examples and their implementation in the laboratory, but concentrate upon the last, which was published most recently [Higginset al.,Nature, vol. 450, p. 393, 2007].

arXiv:0904.2045•IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics•Jan 1, 2009•38 citations

Demonstrating Heisenberg-limited unambiguous phase estimation without adaptive measurements

B L Higgins, Dominic William Berry, Stephen D. Bartlett +3 more

We derive, and experimentally demonstrate, an interferometric scheme for unambiguous phase estimation with precision scaling at the Heisenberg limit that does not require adaptive measurements. That is, with no prior knowledge of the phase, we can obtain an estimate of the phase with a standard deviation that is only a small constant factor larger than the minimum physically allowed value. Our scheme resolves the phase ambiguity that exists when multiple passes through a phase shift, or NOON states, are used to obtain improved phase resolution. Like a recently introduced adaptive technique (Higgins et al 2007 Nature 450 393), our experiment uses multiple applications of the phase shift on single photons. By not requiring adaptive measurements, but rather using a predetermined measurement sequence, the present scheme is both conceptually simpler and significantly easier to implement. Additionally, we demonstrate a simplified adaptive scheme that also surpasses the standard quantum limit for single passes.

arXiv:0809.3308•New Journal of Physics•Jul 9, 2009•135 citations

Heisenberg Limit beyond Quantum Fisher Information

Wojciech Górecki

The Heisenberg limit provides a fundamental bound on the achievable estimation precision with a limited number of $N$ resources used (e.g., atoms, photons, etc.). Using entangled quantum states makes it possible to scale the precision with $N$ better than when resources would be used independently. Consequently, the optimal use of all resources involves accumulating them in a single execution of the experiment. Unfortunately, that implies that the most common theoretical tool used to analyze metrological protocols - quantum Fisher information (QFI) - does not allow for a reliable description of this problem, as it becomes operationally meaningful only with multiple repetitions of the experiment. In this thesis, using the formalism of Bayesian estimation and the minimax estimator, I derive asymptotically saturable bounds on the precision of the estimation for the case of noiseless unitary evolution. For the case where the number of resources $N$ is strictly constrained, I show that the final measurement uncertainty is $π$ times larger than would be implied by a naive use of QFI. I also analyze the case where a constraint is imposed only on the average amount of resources, the exact value of which may fluctuate (in which case QFI does not provide any universal bound for precision). In both cases, I study the asymptotic saturability and the rate of convergence of these bounds. In the following part, I analyze the problem of the Heisenberg limit when multiple parameters are measured simultaneously on the same physical system. In particular, I investigate the existence of a gain from measuring all parameters simultaneously compared to distributing the same amount of resources to measure them independently. I focus on two examples - the measurement of multiple phase shifts in a multi-arm interferometer and the measurement of three magnetic field components.

arXiv:2304.14370•Apr 27, 2023•7 citations

Towards Experimental Implementation of Adaptive Measurements for Efficient Qubit Phase Estimation

Soumya Pani, Marco A. Rodríguez-García, Isaac Pérez Castillo +2 more

We work towards the experimental implementation of an adaptive quantum measurement for single-qubit phase estimation that can theoretically achieve the quantum bound over the entire range of phases [0,2π].

Quantum 2.0 Conference and Exhibition•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

Quantum Measurements: a modern view for quantum optics experimentalists

Aephraim M. Steinberg

In these notes, based on lectures given as part of the Les Houches summer school on Quantum Optics and Nanophotonics in August, 2013, I have tried to give a brief survey of some important approaches and modern tendencies in quantum measurement. I wish it to be clear from the outset that I shy explicitly away from the "quantum measurement problem," and that the present treatment aims to elucidate the theory and practice of various ways in which measurements can, in light of quantum mechanics, be carried out; and various formalisms for describing them. While the treatment is by necessity largely theoretical, the emphasis is meant to be on an experimental "perspective" on measurement -- that is, to place the priority on the possibility of gaining information through some process, and then attempting to model that process mathematically and consider its ramifications, rather than stressing a particular mathematical definition as the {\it sine qua non} of measurement. The textbook definition of measurement as being a particular set of mathematical operations carried out on particular sorts of operators has been so well drilled into us that many have the unfortunate tendency of saying "that experiment can't be described by projections onto the eigenstates of a Hermitian operator, so it is not really a measurement," when of course any practitioner of an experimental science such as physics should instead say "that experiment allowed us to measure something, and if the standard theory of measurement does not describe it, the standard theory of measurement is incomplete." Idealisations are important, but when the real world breaks the approximations made in the theory, it is the theory which must be fixed, and not the real world.

arXiv:1406.5535•Jun 20, 2014•3 citations

Discriminating nonorthogonal quantum states with minimum average number of copies (Conference Presentation)

Sergei Slussarenko, Morgan M. Weston, Jungang Li +3 more

Quantum measurement and control science provides a toolkit for implementing quantum information protocols, overcoming noisy operation and minimizing the use of costly quantum resources. The importance of finding optimal measurement and control strategies is revealed in the task of quantum state discrimination, a characteristic feature of quantum mechanics and a primitive for quantum information science and technology. When a quantum system is prepared in one of two known nonorthogonal quantum states, no measurement can deterministically tell which state the system is in. Two strategies can be applied to discriminate non-orthogonal states efficiently. Unambiguous state discrimination (USD) is strategy that provides a guess which is either correct, or inconclusive [1]. Alternatively, minimum error discrimination (MED) strategy will always provide a conclusive answer, which can sometimes be incorrect [2]. Perfect nonorthogonal state discrimination is still impossible even when multiple copies of the system are available, although different strategies increase the chance of having conclusive (for USD), or correct (for MED) result. Multiple-copy measurement strategies can be either collective, when a single measurement involves all the copies of the system, or local, when each copy of the system is measured separately. The latter can be further divided into fixed, where the measurement applied to each copy is the same, or adaptive, where the measurement on each subsequent copy depends on the outcomes of the previous measurements [3,4]. A multiple-copy MED strategy is defined by its goal of minimizing the average error for fixed resources, i.e. the number of copies of the system. An alternative approach we consider, is to minimize the average resources required, while keeping errors below a given bound [5]. This approach is central for fault-tolerant quantum computing and has been applied to a number of quantum control strategies [6,7]. We call the corresponding state discrimination task the guaranteed bounded error discrimination (GBED) task. Intuitively, one may assume that the multiple-copy strategies optimal for MED would be also optimal for GBED. We experimentally apply two known local non-adaptive strategies, previously considered for the MED task, to the two-state GBED problem [5]. We then derive and experimentally demonstrate a new local strategy, designed specifically for the GBED task that outperforms other strategies. Moreover, it performs usually better than, and in the regime of small error, scales better than, the theoretical performance of the optimal adaptive strategy for the MED task. The discovered reversal in the performance of schemes when swapping the task definition from performance-maximization to resource-minimization, is similar to that previously observed in state purification [6], suggesting that this phenomenon is a generic one. [1] I. D. Ivanovic, Phys. Lett. A 123, 257 (1987). [2] C. W. Helstrom, Quantum detection and estimation theory (1976). [3] A. Acín, et al., Phys. Rev. A 71, 032338 (2005). [4] B. L. Higgins, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 220503 (2009). [5] S. Slussarenko, et al., PRL 118, 030502 (2017). [6] H. M. Wiseman and J. F. Ralph. New J. Phys. 8, 90 (2006). [7] J. Combes, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 160503 (2008).

SPIE Quantum Information Science and Technology•Oct 11, 2018•0 citations
Quantum measurement protocols make use of the quantum nature of the universe to gain more information about a system using fewer resources than would otherwise be possible. Achieving precision at the fundamental limits imposed by quantum mechanics nevertheless remains a challenge. Adaptive quantum measurement protocols may allow us to step closer to these ultimate limits. We present an overview of some interesting recent results of quantum measurement schemes as demonstrated in single-photon optical implementations, in the contexts of unambiguous phase estimation and multiple-copy non-orthogonal state discrimination.
Adaptive techniques make practical many quantum measurements that would otherwise be beyond current laboratory capabilities. For example, they allow discrimination of nonorthogonal states with a probability of error equal to the Helstrom bound, measurement of the phase of a quantum oscillator with accuracy approaching (or in some cases attaining) the Heisenberg limit (HL), and estimation of phase in interferometry with a variance scaling at the HL, using only single qubit measurement and control. Each of these examples has close links with quantum information, in particular, experimental optical quantum information: the first is a basic quantum communication protocol; the second has potential application in linear optical quantum computing; the third uses an adaptive protocol inspired by the quantum phase estimation algorithm. We discuss each of these examples and their implementation in the laboratory, but concentrate upon the last, which was published most recently [Higginset al.,Nature, vol. 450, p. 393, 2007].
We derive, and experimentally demonstrate, an interferometric scheme for unambiguous phase estimation with precision scaling at the Heisenberg limit that does not require adaptive measurements. That is, with no prior knowledge of the phase, we can obtain an estimate of the phase with a standard deviation that is only a small constant factor larger than the minimum physically allowed value. Our scheme resolves the phase ambiguity that exists when multiple passes through a phase shift, or NOON states, are used to obtain improved phase resolution. Like a recently introduced adaptive technique (Higgins et al 2007 Nature 450 393), our experiment uses multiple applications of the phase shift on single photons. By not requiring adaptive measurements, but rather using a predetermined measurement sequence, the present scheme is both conceptually simpler and significantly easier to implement. Additionally, we demonstrate a simplified adaptive scheme that also surpasses the standard quantum limit for single passes.
The Heisenberg limit provides a fundamental bound on the achievable estimation precision with a limited number of NNN resources used (e.g., atoms, photons, etc.). Using entangled quantum states makes it possible to scale the precision with NNN better than when resources would be used independently. Consequently, the optimal use of all resources involves accumulating them in a single execution of the experiment. Unfortunately, that implies that the most common theoretical tool used to analyze metrological protocols - quantum Fisher information (QFI) - does not allow for a reliable description of this problem, as it becomes operationally meaningful only with multiple repetitions of the experiment. In this thesis, using the formalism of Bayesian estimation and the minimax estimator, I derive asymptotically saturable bounds on the precision of the estimation for the case of noiseless unitary evolution. For the case where the number of resources NNN is strictly constrained, I show that the final measurement uncertainty is πππ times larger than would be implied by a naive use of QFI. I also analyze the case where a constraint is imposed only on the average amount of resources, the exact value of which may fluctuate (in which case QFI does not provide any universal bound for precision). In both cases, I study the asymptotic saturability and the rate of convergence of these bounds. In the following part, I analyze the problem of the Heisenberg limit when multiple parameters are measured simultaneously on the same physical system. In particular, I investigate the existence of a gain from measuring all parameters simultaneously compared to distributing the same amount of resources to measure them independently. I focus on two examples - the measurement of multiple phase shifts in a multi-arm interferometer and the measurement of three magnetic field components.
In these notes, based on lectures given as part of the Les Houches summer school on Quantum Optics and Nanophotonics in August, 2013, I have tried to give a brief survey of some important approaches and modern tendencies in quantum measurement. I wish it to be clear from the outset that I shy explicitly away from the "quantum measurement problem," and that the present treatment aims to elucidate the theory and practice of various ways in which measurements can, in light of quantum mechanics, be carried out; and various formalisms for describing them. While the treatment is by necessity largely theoretical, the emphasis is meant to be on an experimental "perspective" on measurement -- that is, to place the priority on the possibility of gaining information through some process, and then attempting to model that process mathematically and consider its ramifications, rather than stressing a particular mathematical definition as the {\it sine qua non} of measurement. The textbook definition of measurement as being a particular set of mathematical operations carried out on particular sorts of operators has been so well drilled into us that many have the unfortunate tendency of saying "that experiment can't be described by projections onto the eigenstates of a Hermitian operator, so it is not really a measurement," when of course any practitioner of an experimental science such as physics should instead say "that experiment allowed us to measure something, and if the standard theory of measurement does not describe it, the standard theory of measurement is incomplete." Idealisations are important, but when the real world breaks the approximations made in the theory, it is the theory which must be fixed, and not the real world.
Quantum measurement and control science provides a toolkit for implementing quantum information protocols, overcoming noisy operation and minimizing the use of costly quantum resources. The importance of finding optimal measurement and control strategies is revealed in the task of quantum state discrimination, a characteristic feature of quantum mechanics and a primitive for quantum information science and technology. When a quantum system is prepared in one of two known nonorthogonal quantum states, no measurement can deterministically tell which state the system is in. Two strategies can be applied to discriminate non-orthogonal states efficiently. Unambiguous state discrimination (USD) is strategy that provides a guess which is either correct, or inconclusive [1]. Alternatively, minimum error discrimination (MED) strategy will always provide a conclusive answer, which can sometimes be incorrect [2]. Perfect nonorthogonal state discrimination is still impossible even when multiple copies of the system are available, although different strategies increase the chance of having conclusive (for USD), or correct (for MED) result. Multiple-copy measurement strategies can be either collective, when a single measurement involves all the copies of the system, or local, when each copy of the system is measured separately. The latter can be further divided into fixed, where the measurement applied to each copy is the same, or adaptive, where the measurement on each subsequent copy depends on the outcomes of the previous measurements [3,4]. A multiple-copy MED strategy is defined by its goal of minimizing the average error for fixed resources, i.e. the number of copies of the system. An alternative approach we consider, is to minimize the average resources required, while keeping errors below a given bound [5]. This approach is central for fault-tolerant quantum computing and has been applied to a number of quantum control strategies [6,7]. We call the corresponding state discrimination task the guaranteed bounded error discrimination (GBED) task. Intuitively, one may assume that the multiple-copy strategies optimal for MED would be also optimal for GBED. We experimentally apply two known local non-adaptive strategies, previously considered for the MED task, to the two-state GBED problem [5]. We then derive and experimentally demonstrate a new local strategy, designed specifically for the GBED task that outperforms other strategies. Moreover, it performs usually better than, and in the regime of small error, scales better than, the theoretical performance of the optimal adaptive strategy for the MED task. The discovered reversal in the performance of schemes when swapping the task definition from performance-maximization to resource-minimization, is similar to that previously observed in state purification [6], suggesting that this phenomenon is a generic one. [1] I. D. Ivanovic, Phys. Lett. A 123, 257 (1987). [2] C. W. Helstrom, Quantum detection and estimation theory (1976). [3] A. Acín, et al., Phys. Rev. A 71, 032338 (2005). [4] B. L. Higgins, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 220503 (2009). [5] S. Slussarenko, et al., PRL 118, 030502 (2017). [6] H. M. Wiseman and J. F. Ralph. New J. Phys. 8, 90 (2006). [7] J. Combes, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 160503 (2008).