Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Routledge eBooks

Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics

Karl Popper

Published Apr 15, 2013• 51 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics is one of the three volumes of Karl Popper’s Postscript to the Logic of scientific Discovery. The Postscript is the culmination of Popper’s work in the philosophy of physics and a new famous attack on subjectivist approaches to philosophy of science. Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics is the third volume of the Postscript. It may be read independently, but it also forms part of Popper’s interconnected argument in the Postscript. It presents Popper’s classic statement on quantum physics and offers important insights into his thinking on problems of method within science and physics as a whole.

DOI
10.4324/9780203713990

Related papers

Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics

Geoffrey L. Price

Karl R Popper 1982 London: Hutchinson xviii + 228 pp price £15 This final volume of Sir Karl Popper's long-awaited Postscript to The Logic of Scientific Discovery appears through the editorial efforts of W W Bartley III, and constitutes a major addition to Popper's published corpus, of particular interest to theoretical physicists, historians of the quantum revolution, and philosophers of science. In it, a basic theme of Popper's philosophy, that something can come from nothing, is related to the present situation in physical theory.

Physics Bulletin•Jan 1, 1983•260 citations

The great quantum muddle

N. David Mermin

These are volumes II and III of Sir Karl Popper's hitherto unpublished Postscript to the Logic of Scientific Discovery. In addition to the Postscript itself, which was largely completed twenty years after L.S.D. in 1954, about a third of each volume is devoted to more recent writings. Volume II, The Open Universe, subtitled “An argument for Indeterminism”, has three “addenda”: a reprint of Popper's 1973 essay, “Indeterminism is not enough”, a revised version of his 1974 “Scientific Reduction and the essential incompleteness of all science”, and a brief essay, “Further remarks on reduction”, written in 1981. Volume III, Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics, has a lengthy 1982 preface, and contains a revised and expanded version of Popper's 1967 “Quantum mechanics without the observer”.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 15, 1990•0 citations

Popper and the Quantum Theory

Michael L. G. Redhead

Popper wrote extensively on the quantum theory. In Logic der Forschung (LSD) he devoted a whole chapter to the topic, while the whole of Volume 3 of the Postscript to the Logic of Scientific Discovery is devoted to the quantum theory. This volume entitled Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics (QTSP) incorporated a famous earlier essay, ‘Quantum Mechanics without “the Observer”’ (QM). In addition Popper's development of the propensity interpretation of probability was much influenced by his views on the role of probability in quantum theory, and he also wrote an insightful critique of the 1936 paper of Birkhoff and von Neumann on nondistributive quantum logic (BNIQM).

Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement•Sep 1, 1995•12 citations

Popper and the Quantum Theory

Michael L. G. Redhead

Popper wrote extensively on the quantum theory. In Logic der Forschung (LSD) he devoted a whole chapter to the topic, while the whole of Volume 3 of the Postscript to the Logic of Scientific Discovery is devoted to the quantum theory. This volume entitled Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics ( QTSP ) incorporated a famous earlier essay, ‘Quantum Mechanics without “the Observer”’ (QM). In addition Popper’s development of the propensity interpretation of probability was much influenced by his views on the role of probability in quantum theory, and he also wrote an insightful critique of the 1936 paper of Birkhoff and von Neumann on nondistributive quantum logic 1 (BNIQM).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 25, 2024•0 citations

Popper and the Quantum Theory

Michael L. G. Redhead

Popper wrote extensively on the quantum theory. In Logic der Forschung (LSD) he devoted a whole chapter to the topic, while the whole of Volume 3 of the Postscript to the Logic of Scientific Discovery is devoted to the quantum theory. This volume entitled Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics (QTSP) incorporated a famous earlier essay, ‘Quantum Mechanics without “the Observer”’ (QM). In addition Popper's development of the propensity interpretation of probability was much influenced by his views on the rôle of probability in quantum theory, and he also wrote an insightful critique of the 1936 paper of Birkhoff and von Neumann on nondistributive quantum logic (BNIQM).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 28, 1996•2 citations

Philosophy and the New Physics

Jonathan Powers

First Published in 1982 Philosophy and the New Physics is a compact and yet remarkably rich excursion through the history of physics from Newtonian mechanics to quantum physics. The theory of relativity, quantum mechanics and ideas about the ‘fundamental constituents’ of matter have attracted a great deal of philosophical comment. Indeed, the originators of some of these theories thought they were solving philosophical problems as well as scientific ones. Classical physics is often portrayed as epitomizing ‘mechanistic materialism’, and the revolution in modern physics is variously claimed to vindicate ‘logical positivism’, ‘operationalism’, ‘organicism’, ‘dialectical materialism’ and ‘Buddhist metaphysics’. In this book Jonathan Powers criticizes all of these claims and argues that such varied and conflicting interpretations are possible because of ineradicable elements of conventionality in scientific theories. This is a must read for scholars and researchers of philosophy of science and philosophy in general.

Routledge eBooks•Jul 10, 2023•3 citations
Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics is one of the three volumes of Karl Popper’s Postscript to the Logic of scientific Discovery. The Postscript is the culmination of Popper’s work in the philosophy of physics and a new famous attack on subjectivist approaches to philosophy of science. Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics is the third volume of the Postscript. It may be read independently, but it also forms part of Popper’s interconnected argument in the Postscript. It presents Popper’s classic statement on quantum physics and offers important insights into his thinking on problems of method within science and physics as a whole.
Karl R Popper 1982 London: Hutchinson xviii + 228 pp price £15 This final volume of Sir Karl Popper's long-awaited Postscript to The Logic of Scientific Discovery appears through the editorial efforts of W W Bartley III, and constitutes a major addition to Popper's published corpus, of particular interest to theoretical physicists, historians of the quantum revolution, and philosophers of science. In it, a basic theme of Popper's philosophy, that something can come from nothing, is related to the present situation in physical theory.
These are volumes II and III of Sir Karl Popper's hitherto unpublished Postscript to the Logic of Scientific Discovery. In addition to the Postscript itself, which was largely completed twenty years after L.S.D. in 1954, about a third of each volume is devoted to more recent writings. Volume II, The Open Universe, subtitled “An argument for Indeterminism”, has three “addenda”: a reprint of Popper's 1973 essay, “Indeterminism is not enough”, a revised version of his 1974 “Scientific Reduction and the essential incompleteness of all science”, and a brief essay, “Further remarks on reduction”, written in 1981. Volume III, Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics, has a lengthy 1982 preface, and contains a revised and expanded version of Popper's 1967 “Quantum mechanics without the observer”.
Popper wrote extensively on the quantum theory. In Logic der Forschung (LSD) he devoted a whole chapter to the topic, while the whole of Volume 3 of the Postscript to the Logic of Scientific Discovery is devoted to the quantum theory. This volume entitled Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics (QTSP) incorporated a famous earlier essay, ‘Quantum Mechanics without “the Observer”’ (QM). In addition Popper's development of the propensity interpretation of probability was much influenced by his views on the role of probability in quantum theory, and he also wrote an insightful critique of the 1936 paper of Birkhoff and von Neumann on nondistributive quantum logic (BNIQM).
Popper wrote extensively on the quantum theory. In Logic der Forschung (LSD) he devoted a whole chapter to the topic, while the whole of Volume 3 of the Postscript to the Logic of Scientific Discovery is devoted to the quantum theory. This volume entitled Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics ( QTSP ) incorporated a famous earlier essay, ‘Quantum Mechanics without “the Observer”’ (QM). In addition Popper’s development of the propensity interpretation of probability was much influenced by his views on the role of probability in quantum theory, and he also wrote an insightful critique of the 1936 paper of Birkhoff and von Neumann on nondistributive quantum logic 1 (BNIQM).
Popper wrote extensively on the quantum theory. In Logic der Forschung (LSD) he devoted a whole chapter to the topic, while the whole of Volume 3 of the Postscript to the Logic of Scientific Discovery is devoted to the quantum theory. This volume entitled Quantum Theory and the Schism in Physics (QTSP) incorporated a famous earlier essay, ‘Quantum Mechanics without “the Observer”’ (QM). In addition Popper's development of the propensity interpretation of probability was much influenced by his views on the rôle of probability in quantum theory, and he also wrote an insightful critique of the 1936 paper of Birkhoff and von Neumann on nondistributive quantum logic (BNIQM).
First Published in 1982 Philosophy and the New Physics is a compact and yet remarkably rich excursion through the history of physics from Newtonian mechanics to quantum physics. The theory of relativity, quantum mechanics and ideas about the ‘fundamental constituents’ of matter have attracted a great deal of philosophical comment. Indeed, the originators of some of these theories thought they were solving philosophical problems as well as scientific ones. Classical physics is often portrayed as epitomizing ‘mechanistic materialism’, and the revolution in modern physics is variously claimed to vindicate ‘logical positivism’, ‘operationalism’, ‘organicism’, ‘dialectical materialism’ and ‘Buddhist metaphysics’. In this book Jonathan Powers criticizes all of these claims and argues that such varied and conflicting interpretations are possible because of ineradicable elements of conventionality in scientific theories. This is a must read for scholars and researchers of philosophy of science and philosophy in general.