A CONTROVERSIAL ROLE FOR "CORRESPONDENCE" IN THEORETICAL PHYSICS AND QUANTUM MECHANICS
Salvo D’Agostino
A correspondence principle has been used in physics as a tool for developing new theories. Many physicists also believe that this principle implies the fact that new theories cannot contradict the well-confirmed former theories. In this essay, I examine critically and historically the epistemological consistency of this position. I explore Einstein's technical usage of a correspondence principle as a guide towards generalising special relativity. I also refer to his thoughts and perplexities in face of the doubts posed by the epistemological significance of the correspondence above. The correspondence problem also intrigued Bohr at a certain period in his research, because classical theories represented a glorious patrimony of science that had to be recovered and salvaged in some way. In my analysis of Bohr's correspondence principle I look at the historical development of the principle in Bohr's various contributions to the Copenhagen philosophy. Another response to the correspondence riddle was given by Schrödinger. In the fifties, he proposed a new conception of ondulatory mechanics, a continuous theory in opposition to Bohr's and Heisenberg's fundamental discreteness. The lack of individuality of the atomic particles presented in the new statistics, and in Heisenberg's indeterminacy relations, were by Schrödinger considered to be aspects of a more general crisis in the ontology of classical atomism.
Conference on the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: Historical Analysis and Open Questions•May 1, 2000•0 citations