Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

How Pauli's rule became the exclusion principle: from Fermi–Dirac statistics to the spin–statistics theorem

Michela Massimi

Published Aug 4, 2005• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Shortly after their introduction, the electron's Zweideutigkeit and Pauli's Ausschliessungsregel were embedded into a growing theoretical framework: from Fermi–Dirac statistics in 1926 (Section 4.2), to the non-relativistic quantum mechanics of the magnetic electron with Pauli's spin matrices in 1927 (Section 4.3); from Wigner and von Neumann's group theoretical derivation of the spin matrices in 1927 (Section 4.4), to Jordan's reinterpretation of Pauli's exclusion principle in terms of anticommutation relations for particle creation and annihilation operators in 1928 (Section 4.5), which paved the way for quantum field theory. The most important step in building up this theoretical framework was the transition from non-relativistic to relativistic quantum mechanics, with Dirac's equation for the electron in 1928 (Section 4.6), which finally allowed the derivation of the electron's spin with its anomalous magnetic moment and hence clarified in a conclusive way the origin of spectroscopic anomalies. The negative energy solutions of the Dirac equation, and Dirac's attempt to accommodate them via the hole theory in 1930, anticipated the experimental discovery of the antiparticle of the electron, the positron. Sections 4.7-4.9 reconstruct Pauli's sustained criticism of Dirac's hole theory. The history of this debate is intertwined with Pauli's search for a spin–statistics connection, which finally culminated in the spin–statistics theorem in 1940. With this theorem, the nomological shift from the status of a phenomenological rule to that of a fundamental scientific principle is finally completed.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511535352.008

Related papers

History of Spin and Statistics

André Martin

These lectures were given in the framework of the ``Dixième séminaire rhodanien de physique'' entitled ``Le spin en physique'', given at Villa Gualino, Turin, March 2002. We have shown how the difficulties of interpretation of atomic spectra led to the Pauli exclusion principle and to the notion of spin, and then described the following steps: the Pauli spin with 2$\times$2 matrices after the birth of "new" quantum mechanics, the Dirac equation and the magnetic moment of the electron, the spins and magnetic moments of other particles, proton, neutron and hyperons. Finally, we show the crucial role of statistics in the stability of the world.

arXiv:hep-ph/0209068•Sep 6, 2002•8 citations

Introduction

Michela Massimi

The history of the exclusion principle is already an old one, but its conclusion has not yet been written. It is now eighty years since Wolfgang Pauli introduced an ‘extremely natural’ prescriptive rule, while dealing with some spectroscopic anomalies that beset physicists in the heyday of the old quantum theory. The rule excluded the possibility that any two bound electrons in an atom were in the same dynamic state, identified by a set of four quantum numbers. Hence the name of Ausschlieβungsregel (exclusion rule), or Pauli's Verbot (Pauli's veto) as Werner Heisenberg nicknamed it. The far-reaching physical significance of this rule became clear only later. From spectroscopy to atomic physics, from quantum field theory to high-energy physics, there is hardly another scientific principle that has more far-reaching implications than Pauli's exclusion principle. It is thanks to Pauli's principle that one obtains the electronic configurations underlying the classification of chemical elements in Mendeleev's periodic table as well as atomic spectra. To this same principle we credit the statistical behaviour of any half-integral spin particles (protons, neutrons, among many others) and the stability of matter. Shifting to high-energy physics, it is the exclusion principle that fixes the crucial constraint for binding quarks in hadrons, which together with leptons compose our physical world. This book advances a philosophical analysis of the enduring and far-reaching validity of Pauli's principle. It does not aim to address what a scientific principle is.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 4, 2005•2 citations

Toward an understanding of the spin-statistics theorem

Ian Duck, E. C. G. Sudarshan

We respond to a recent request from Neuenschwander for an elementary proof of the Spin-Statistics Theorem. First, we present a pedagogical discussion of the results for the spin-0 Klein–Gordon field quantized according to Bose–Einstein statistics; and for the spin-12 Dirac field quantized according to Fermi–Dirac statistics and the Pauli Exclusion Principle. This discussion is intended to make our paper accessible to students familiar with the matrix solution of the quantum harmonic oscillator. Next, we discuss a number of candidate intuitive proofs and conclude that none of them pass muster. The reasons for their shortcomings are fully discussed. Then we discuss an argument, originally suggested by Sudarshan, which proves the theorem with a minimal set of requirements. Although we use Lorentz invariance in a specific and limited part of the argument, we do not need the full complexity of relativistic quantum field theory. Motivated by our particular use of Lorentz invariance, if we are permitted to elevate the conclusion of flavor symmetry (which we explain in the text) to the status of a postulate, one could recast our proof without any explicit relativistic assumptions, and thus make it applicable even in the nonrelativistic context. Such an argument, presented in the text, sheds some light on why it is that the ordinary Schrödinger field, considered strictly in the nonrelativistic context, seems to be quantizable with either statistics. Finally, an argument starting with ordinary-number valued (commuting), and with Grassmann-valued (anticommuting), oscillators shows in a natural way that these must relativistically embed into Klein–Gordon spin-0 and Dirac spin-12 fields, respectively. In this way, the Spin-Statistics Theorem is understood at the expense of admitting the existence of the simplest Grassmann-valued field.

American Journal of Physics•Apr 1, 1998•109 citations

Electron exchange-correlation in quantum mechanics

Burke Ritchie

It is shown that Fermi-Dirac statistics is guaranteed by the Dirac current, from which spin-dependent quantum velocity fields and spin-dependent quantum trajectories can be inferred. Pauli's exclusion principle is demonstrated using the spin-dependent quantum trajectories. The Dirac current, unlike the Schroedinger current, is nonzero for stationary bound states due to the permanent magnetic moment of the electron. It is of order c{sup 0} in agreement with observation that Fermi-Dirac statistics is independent of electronic velocity. In summary the physical basis for exchange-correlation is found in Dirac's equation, although Schroedinger's equation may be used to evaluate the Dirac current in the nonrelativistic regime of electronic velocity.

•Jan 30, 2009•0 citations

On the relativistic concept of the Dirac's electron spin

Nizar Hamdan, A. Chamaa, José Luis López-Bonilla

Despite the success of the Dirac equation, the incorporation of the special theory of relativity into quantum mechanics predicts some paradoxes, like that the spin prediction from Dirac equation can be only identified with non- relativistic approximations (Pauli and Foldy-Wouthysen), as well as the spin predication is a relativistic quantum phenomena because the spin prediction is a necessary requirement of the relativistic quantum mechanics only. In this paper we show that the derivation of the spin and its magnetic moment can be done with a pure classical treatment. Since we start from the classical physical laws and the classical relativity principle to get the linear Schrödinger equation as a result the derivation of the spin and its magnetic moment can be done with a pure classical treatment. This approach result a Schrödinger equation, in which we show that the spin of the electron is a non relativistic quantum phenomenon too.

Latin American journal of physics education•Jan 1, 2008•1 citation

Pauli's First Proof of the Spin-Statistics Theorem

Pauli made the first attempt to prove that the spin-statistics relation is a necessary result of the postulates of relativistic quantum field theory. Almost simultaneously, Iwanenko and Socolow showed that quantization of the Dirac equation using anticommutation relations led naturally to results analogous to those of Pauli and Weisskopf for the spin-0 equation. In their paper, Iwanenko and Socolow also point out that problems arise from the wrong commutation relations.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 1, 1998•0 citations
Shortly after their introduction, the electron's Zweideutigkeit and Pauli's Ausschliessungsregel were embedded into a growing theoretical framework: from Fermi–Dirac statistics in 1926 (Section 4.2), to the non-relativistic quantum mechanics of the magnetic electron with Pauli's spin matrices in 1927 (Section 4.3); from Wigner and von Neumann's group theoretical derivation of the spin matrices in 1927 (Section 4.4), to Jordan's reinterpretation of Pauli's exclusion principle in terms of anticommutation relations for particle creation and annihilation operators in 1928 (Section 4.5), which paved the way for quantum field theory. The most important step in building up this theoretical framework was the transition from non-relativistic to relativistic quantum mechanics, with Dirac's equation for the electron in 1928 (Section 4.6), which finally allowed the derivation of the electron's spin with its anomalous magnetic moment and hence clarified in a conclusive way the origin of spectroscopic anomalies. The negative energy solutions of the Dirac equation, and Dirac's attempt to accommodate them via the hole theory in 1930, anticipated the experimental discovery of the antiparticle of the electron, the positron. Sections 4.7-4.9 reconstruct Pauli's sustained criticism of Dirac's hole theory. The history of this debate is intertwined with Pauli's search for a spin–statistics connection, which finally culminated in the spin–statistics theorem in 1940. With this theorem, the nomological shift from the status of a phenomenological rule to that of a fundamental scientific principle is finally completed.
These lectures were given in the framework of the ``Dixième séminaire rhodanien de physique'' entitled ``Le spin en physique'', given at Villa Gualino, Turin, March 2002. We have shown how the difficulties of interpretation of atomic spectra led to the Pauli exclusion principle and to the notion of spin, and then described the following steps: the Pauli spin with 2$\times$2 matrices after the birth of "new" quantum mechanics, the Dirac equation and the magnetic moment of the electron, the spins and magnetic moments of other particles, proton, neutron and hyperons. Finally, we show the crucial role of statistics in the stability of the world.
The history of the exclusion principle is already an old one, but its conclusion has not yet been written. It is now eighty years since Wolfgang Pauli introduced an ‘extremely natural’ prescriptive rule, while dealing with some spectroscopic anomalies that beset physicists in the heyday of the old quantum theory. The rule excluded the possibility that any two bound electrons in an atom were in the same dynamic state, identified by a set of four quantum numbers. Hence the name of Ausschlieβungsregel (exclusion rule), or Pauli's Verbot (Pauli's veto) as Werner Heisenberg nicknamed it. The far-reaching physical significance of this rule became clear only later. From spectroscopy to atomic physics, from quantum field theory to high-energy physics, there is hardly another scientific principle that has more far-reaching implications than Pauli's exclusion principle. It is thanks to Pauli's principle that one obtains the electronic configurations underlying the classification of chemical elements in Mendeleev's periodic table as well as atomic spectra. To this same principle we credit the statistical behaviour of any half-integral spin particles (protons, neutrons, among many others) and the stability of matter. Shifting to high-energy physics, it is the exclusion principle that fixes the crucial constraint for binding quarks in hadrons, which together with leptons compose our physical world. This book advances a philosophical analysis of the enduring and far-reaching validity of Pauli's principle. It does not aim to address what a scientific principle is.
We respond to a recent request from Neuenschwander for an elementary proof of the Spin-Statistics Theorem. First, we present a pedagogical discussion of the results for the spin-0 Klein–Gordon field quantized according to Bose–Einstein statistics; and for the spin-12 Dirac field quantized according to Fermi–Dirac statistics and the Pauli Exclusion Principle. This discussion is intended to make our paper accessible to students familiar with the matrix solution of the quantum harmonic oscillator. Next, we discuss a number of candidate intuitive proofs and conclude that none of them pass muster. The reasons for their shortcomings are fully discussed. Then we discuss an argument, originally suggested by Sudarshan, which proves the theorem with a minimal set of requirements. Although we use Lorentz invariance in a specific and limited part of the argument, we do not need the full complexity of relativistic quantum field theory. Motivated by our particular use of Lorentz invariance, if we are permitted to elevate the conclusion of flavor symmetry (which we explain in the text) to the status of a postulate, one could recast our proof without any explicit relativistic assumptions, and thus make it applicable even in the nonrelativistic context. Such an argument, presented in the text, sheds some light on why it is that the ordinary Schrödinger field, considered strictly in the nonrelativistic context, seems to be quantizable with either statistics. Finally, an argument starting with ordinary-number valued (commuting), and with Grassmann-valued (anticommuting), oscillators shows in a natural way that these must relativistically embed into Klein–Gordon spin-0 and Dirac spin-12 fields, respectively. In this way, the Spin-Statistics Theorem is understood at the expense of admitting the existence of the simplest Grassmann-valued field.
It is shown that Fermi-Dirac statistics is guaranteed by the Dirac current, from which spin-dependent quantum velocity fields and spin-dependent quantum trajectories can be inferred. Pauli's exclusion principle is demonstrated using the spin-dependent quantum trajectories. The Dirac current, unlike the Schroedinger current, is nonzero for stationary bound states due to the permanent magnetic moment of the electron. It is of order c{sup 0} in agreement with observation that Fermi-Dirac statistics is independent of electronic velocity. In summary the physical basis for exchange-correlation is found in Dirac's equation, although Schroedinger's equation may be used to evaluate the Dirac current in the nonrelativistic regime of electronic velocity.
Despite the success of the Dirac equation, the incorporation of the special theory of relativity into quantum mechanics predicts some paradoxes, like that the spin prediction from Dirac equation can be only identified with non- relativistic approximations (Pauli and Foldy-Wouthysen), as well as the spin predication is a relativistic quantum phenomena because the spin prediction is a necessary requirement of the relativistic quantum mechanics only. In this paper we show that the derivation of the spin and its magnetic moment can be done with a pure classical treatment. Since we start from the classical physical laws and the classical relativity principle to get the linear Schrödinger equation as a result the derivation of the spin and its magnetic moment can be done with a pure classical treatment. This approach result a Schrödinger equation, in which we show that the spin of the electron is a non relativistic quantum phenomenon too.