Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

An experimental test of semiclassical radiation theories

John M. Wessner

Published Jan 1, 1972• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

An experiment is described which tests the semi-classical radiation theory proposed by E. T. Jaynes and his collaborators.Their work predicted that the n = 2 level of hydrogen will have a lifetime which varies linearly with the 2s state population for small excited state components.By applying a short electrical pulse to a 60 keV atomic hydrogen beam with a 2s population of approximately 9%, the variation of the lifetime could be measured as a function of the 2s occupation after the pulse.A total change of approximately + 4% is predicted while the observed change was -.2%.

Related papers

Radiative Decay of the 2P State of Atomic Hydrogen: A Test of the Exponential Decay Law

John M. Wessner, David K. Anderson, R. T. Robiscoe

In Jaynes's semiclassical radiation theory, the decay of an excited atomic state depends on its initial population. For the radiative decay of the $2P$ level in atomic hydrogen, produced by pulsed excitation from the $2S$ level, the theory predicts a decay rate $\ensuremath{\Gamma}=(1\ensuremath{-}f){\ensuremath{\Gamma}}_{0}+\ensuremath{\beta}P$, where $\ensuremath{\beta}=f{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}_{0}$. Here $f$ is the initial $2S$ population, ${\ensuremath{\Gamma}}_{0}$ is the natural $2P$ decay rate, and $P$ is the $2P$ population relative to $f$. For $f=0.086\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.016$, and $P$ values in the range 0.15 to 0.64, we have measured $\ensuremath{\beta}=\ensuremath{-}(2.8\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}2.8)\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{6}$ ${\mathrm{sec}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. The corresponding value from the semiclassical theory is $\ensuremath{\beta}=+(53.8\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}10.0)\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{6}$ ${\mathrm{sec}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$.

Physical Review Letters•Oct 23, 1972•30 citations

Contradictions with the Neoclassical Theory of Radiation in Weakly Excited Multilevel Systems

H. M. Gibbs, G. G. Churchill, G. J. Salamo

The neoclassical or semiclassical theory (NCT) of the radiative decay of an isolated atom predicts that the decay rate of an excited state is proportional to the atoms's population in the state to which the atom is decaying. For weak excitation of a two-level system, this prediction is consistent with observations and with the Weisskopf-Wigner theory of decay, which assumes a quantized electromagnetic field as in quantum electrodynamics (QED). But for weak excitation of a system with three or more levels, there can be gross disagreements between NCT and QED. NCT predicts that the lifetime of an excited state depends on the nuclear spin which determines the number of ground states between which the atom's unity population density is divided. Also NCT predicts no fluorescence to a third level not initially populated, even though the transition is highly allowed. Observations in Pb vapor are inconsistent with NCT and consistent with QED. The oscillator strengths of the 2833-, 3640-, and 4058-A transitions were determined to be 0.167(20), 0.061(04), and 0.146(10), respectively, by measuring the ratios of oscillator strengths and using the lifetime measurements of Happer and Saloman.

Physical Review A•May 1, 1973•15 citations

Lifetime of the 2S State of Atomic Hydrogen

Wade L. Fite, R. T. Brackmann, David G. Hummer +1 more

A sensitive test for any mixing of the $2{S}_{\frac{1}{2}}$ and $2{P}_{\frac{1}{2}}$ state of atomic hydrogen is the measurement of the rate for single-quantum decay of the $2S$ atom to the ground state. A new upper limit of this decay rate has been determined. A section along a beam of $2S$ atoms, produced by electron excitation of a ground-state atom beam, was viewed by an iodine-vapor-filled ultraviolet photon counter, which responds to the Lymanalpha radiation of the single-quantum decay process. From the counts observed when an electrostatic quenching field was superposed on the counter's field of view, the necessary experimental parameter (product of $2S$ atom current and counter efficiency) was determined. With the field removed, a portion of the remaining counts could be ascribed to quenching on collision of the $2S$ atoms with residual gases in the vacuum chamber, the quenching cross sections for which were measured. The decay rate not ascribable to known quenching effects was 420 ${\mathrm{sec}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. Since unknown quenching effects may have been operative, this figure must be considered only as an upper limit for the natural single-quantum decay rate.

Physical Review•Dec 15, 1961•11 citations

Lifetime of the 2S State of Atomic Hydrogen

Wade L. Fite, R. T. Brackmann, David G. Hummer +1 more

A sensitive test for any mixing of the $2{S}_{\frac{1}{2}}$ and $2{P}_{\frac{1}{2}}$ state of atomic hydrogen is the measurement of the rate for single-quantum decay of the $2S$ atom to the ground state. A new upper limit of this decay rate has been determined. A section along a beam of $2S$ atoms, produced by electron excitation of a ground-state atom beam, was viewed by an iodine-vapor-filled ultraviolet photon counter, which responds to the Lymanalpha radiation of the single-quantum decay process. From the counts observed when an electrostatic quenching field was superposed on the counter's field of view, the necessary experimental parameter (product of $2S$ atom current and counter efficiency) was determined. With the field removed, a portion of the remaining counts could be ascribed to quenching on collision of the $2S$ atoms with residual gases in the vacuum chamber, the quenching cross sections for which were measured. The decay rate not ascribable to known quenching effects was 420 ${\mathrm{sec}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. Since unknown quenching effects may have been operative, this figure must be considered only as an upper limit for the natural single-quantum decay rate.

Physical Review•Oct 15, 1959•61 citations

Radiative lifetime measurements of rubidium Rydberg states

Drew Branden, T Juhasz, Tatenda Mahlokozera +5 more

We have measured the radiative lifetimes of ns, np and nd Rydberg states of rubidium in the range 28 < n < 45. To enable long-lived states to be measured, our experiment uses slow-moving Rb atoms in a magneto-optical trap (MOT). Two experimental techniques have been adopted to reduce random and systematic errors. First, a narrow-bandwidth pulsed laser is used to excite the target Rydberg state, resulting in minimal shot-to-shot variation in the initial state population. Second, we monitor the target state population as a function of time delay from the laser pulse using a short-duration, millimetre-wave pulse that is resonant with a one- or two-photon transition. We then selectively field ionize the monitor state, and detect the resulting electrons with a micro-channel plate. This signal is an accurate mirror of the target state population, and is uncontaminated by contributions from other states which are populated by black body radiation. Our results are generally consistent with other recent experimental results obtained using a less sensitive method, and are also in excellent agreement with theory.

arXiv:0910.1073•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Dec 8, 2009•70 citations

QUANTUM THEORY OF RADIATION

Murray, Iii Sargent

In our preceding treatments of the interaction of radiation with matter, we assumed that the electric field is classical. In most cases, this assumption is validated by experiment. There are several instances, however, for which a classical field fails to give experimentally observed results, whereas a quantized field succeeds. This is true, for example, of spontaneous emission, a phenom­ enon which was described phenomenologically in our earlier work (see Chaps. 2 and 7). Another case involves the 2 and 2p \ states in the hydrogen atom, which are predicted to have the same energy not only by the simple theory of Chap. 1, but also by the more sophisticated Dirac theory. In both cases, a classical electric field was assumed. Experimentally, the two levels differ by approximately the Lamb shift, 1057 MHz. A fully quantized treatment of the field and atom system gives impressive agreement with the experimentally observed shift. Derivation of the fluctuations in intensity of a laser near threshold requires the quantum theory o f radiation. In addition there are other problems for which the concept of a “particle,” the photon, is either necessary or convenient. Despite a popular impression to the contrary, however the explanation of the photoelectric effect is not one of these (see Prob. 2-10).

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2018•880 citations
An experiment is described which tests the semi-classical radiation theory proposed by E. T. Jaynes and his collaborators.Their work predicted that the n = 2 level of hydrogen will have a lifetime which varies linearly with the 2s state population for small excited state components.By applying a short electrical pulse to a 60 keV atomic hydrogen beam with a 2s population of approximately 9%, the variation of the lifetime could be measured as a function of the 2s occupation after the pulse.A total change of approximately + 4% is predicted while the observed change was -.2%.
In Jaynes's semiclassical radiation theory, the decay of an excited atomic state depends on its initial population. For the radiative decay of the 2P2P2P level in atomic hydrogen, produced by pulsed excitation from the 2S2S2S level, the theory predicts a decay rate $\ensuremath{\Gamma}=(1\ensuremath{-}f){\ensuremath{\Gamma}}_{0}+\ensuremath{\beta}P$, where $\ensuremath{\beta}=f{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}_{0}$. Here fff is the initial 2S2S2S population, ${\ensuremath{\Gamma}}_{0}$ is the natural 2P2P2P decay rate, and PPP is the 2P2P2P population relative to fff. For $f=0.086\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.016$, and PPP values in the range 0.15 to 0.64, we have measured $\ensuremath{\beta}=\ensuremath{-}(2.8\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}2.8)\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{6}$ ${\mathrm{sec}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. The corresponding value from the semiclassical theory is $\ensuremath{\beta}=+(53.8\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}10.0)\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{6}$ ${\mathrm{sec}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$.
The neoclassical or semiclassical theory (NCT) of the radiative decay of an isolated atom predicts that the decay rate of an excited state is proportional to the atoms's population in the state to which the atom is decaying. For weak excitation of a two-level system, this prediction is consistent with observations and with the Weisskopf-Wigner theory of decay, which assumes a quantized electromagnetic field as in quantum electrodynamics (QED). But for weak excitation of a system with three or more levels, there can be gross disagreements between NCT and QED. NCT predicts that the lifetime of an excited state depends on the nuclear spin which determines the number of ground states between which the atom's unity population density is divided. Also NCT predicts no fluorescence to a third level not initially populated, even though the transition is highly allowed. Observations in Pb vapor are inconsistent with NCT and consistent with QED. The oscillator strengths of the 2833-, 3640-, and 4058-A transitions were determined to be 0.167(20), 0.061(04), and 0.146(10), respectively, by measuring the ratios of oscillator strengths and using the lifetime measurements of Happer and Saloman.
A sensitive test for any mixing of the 2S122{S}_{\frac{1}{2}}2S21​​ and 2P122{P}_{\frac{1}{2}}2P21​​ state of atomic hydrogen is the measurement of the rate for single-quantum decay of the 2S2S2S atom to the ground state. A new upper limit of this decay rate has been determined. A section along a beam of 2S2S2S atoms, produced by electron excitation of a ground-state atom beam, was viewed by an iodine-vapor-filled ultraviolet photon counter, which responds to the Lymanalpha radiation of the single-quantum decay process. From the counts observed when an electrostatic quenching field was superposed on the counter's field of view, the necessary experimental parameter (product of 2S2S2S atom current and counter efficiency) was determined. With the field removed, a portion of the remaining counts could be ascribed to quenching on collision of the 2S2S2S atoms with residual gases in the vacuum chamber, the quenching cross sections for which were measured. The decay rate not ascribable to known quenching effects was 420 ${\mathrm{sec}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. Since unknown quenching effects may have been operative, this figure must be considered only as an upper limit for the natural single-quantum decay rate.
A sensitive test for any mixing of the 2S122{S}_{\frac{1}{2}}2S21​​ and 2P122{P}_{\frac{1}{2}}2P21​​ state of atomic hydrogen is the measurement of the rate for single-quantum decay of the 2S2S2S atom to the ground state. A new upper limit of this decay rate has been determined. A section along a beam of 2S2S2S atoms, produced by electron excitation of a ground-state atom beam, was viewed by an iodine-vapor-filled ultraviolet photon counter, which responds to the Lymanalpha radiation of the single-quantum decay process. From the counts observed when an electrostatic quenching field was superposed on the counter's field of view, the necessary experimental parameter (product of 2S2S2S atom current and counter efficiency) was determined. With the field removed, a portion of the remaining counts could be ascribed to quenching on collision of the 2S2S2S atoms with residual gases in the vacuum chamber, the quenching cross sections for which were measured. The decay rate not ascribable to known quenching effects was 420 ${\mathrm{sec}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. Since unknown quenching effects may have been operative, this figure must be considered only as an upper limit for the natural single-quantum decay rate.
We have measured the radiative lifetimes of ns, np and nd Rydberg states of rubidium in the range 28 < n < 45. To enable long-lived states to be measured, our experiment uses slow-moving Rb atoms in a magneto-optical trap (MOT). Two experimental techniques have been adopted to reduce random and systematic errors. First, a narrow-bandwidth pulsed laser is used to excite the target Rydberg state, resulting in minimal shot-to-shot variation in the initial state population. Second, we monitor the target state population as a function of time delay from the laser pulse using a short-duration, millimetre-wave pulse that is resonant with a one- or two-photon transition. We then selectively field ionize the monitor state, and detect the resulting electrons with a micro-channel plate. This signal is an accurate mirror of the target state population, and is uncontaminated by contributions from other states which are populated by black body radiation. Our results are generally consistent with other recent experimental results obtained using a less sensitive method, and are also in excellent agreement with theory.
In our preceding treatments of the interaction of radiation with matter, we assumed that the electric field is classical. In most cases, this assumption is validated by experiment. There are several instances, however, for which a classical field fails to give experimentally observed results, whereas a quantized field succeeds. This is true, for example, of spontaneous emission, a phenom­ enon which was described phenomenologically in our earlier work (see Chaps. 2 and 7). Another case involves the 2 and 2p \ states in the hydrogen atom, which are predicted to have the same energy not only by the simple theory of Chap. 1, but also by the more sophisticated Dirac theory. In both cases, a classical electric field was assumed. Experimentally, the two levels differ by approximately the Lamb shift, 1057 MHz. A fully quantized treatment of the field and atom system gives impressive agreement with the experimentally observed shift. Derivation of the fluctuations in intensity of a laser near threshold requires the quantum theory o f radiation. In addition there are other problems for which the concept of a “particle,” the photon, is either necessary or convenient. Despite a popular impression to the contrary, however the explanation of the photoelectric effect is not one of these (see Prob. 2-10).