Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Nature

Can quantum theory be understood?

John Maddox

Published Feb 11, 1993• 21 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1038/361493a0

Related papers

Can We Ever Hope to Understand Quantum Mechanics?

Selçuk Ş. Bayın

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

An introduction to the quantum theory

Greg Parker

Quantum theory, however taught, is always a shock to the system for a new student . This is unfortunate because a lot of 'forefront-of-technology' calculations are possible with only a rudimentary knowledge of quantum mechanics . If you can, I strongly advise you to do the following. Do not try to understand the mechanics of the theory at this stage. Use the mathematics that are presented in this chapter in order to understand the new 'low-dimensional devices' (LDDs) only. Virtually all the new quantum devices and quantum effects in semiconductor physics can be understood if you are well versed in just one quantum mechanical solution. The particular solution we are going to study is called 'the particle-in-a­ box'. This may not sound very glamorous but the theory is easily understood and the applications are far reaching. For this reason, the way I am going to introduce the quantum theory is biased with just one aim in mind, to understand the physics and applications of the particle-in-a-box.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 30, 2004•335 citations

Pragmatist Quantum Realism

Richard Healey

Realism comes in many varieties, in science and elsewhere. Van Fraassen’s influential formulation took scientific realism to include the view that science aims to give us, in its theories, a literally true story of what the world is like. So understood, a quantum realist takes quantum theory to aim at correctly representing the world: many would add that its success justifies believing this representation is more or less correct. But quantum realism has been understood both more narrowly and more broadly. A pragmatist considers use prior to representation and this has prompted some to dub pragmatist views anti-realist, including the view of quantum theory that the author has been developing recently. But whether a pragmatist view of quantum theory should be labeled anti-realist depends not only on its ingredients but also on how that label should be applied. Pragmatism offers a healthy diet of quantum realism.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 27, 2020•20 citations

Interpretations of the quantum theory

Ralph Schiller

Synthese•Mar 1, 1962•0 citations

Quantum theory only makes sense in Lazare Carnot's participatory engineering thermodynamics, a development of Leibniz's dynamics

Terry Bristol

Feynman insisted 'no one understands quantum theory'. Yet, experimentalists tell us quantum theory is the most successful theory in history. Quantum theory cannot be understood as a classical mechanical theory since it arose through the 'interpolation' of two highly successful but complementary classical mechanics: Newtonian particle mechanics and Maxwellian wave mechanics. The two-slit experiment illustrates that what is experienced depends on choice of experimental set-up. Quantum theory is properly understood within the more general framework of engineering thermodynamics. In Part One, I point to four essential characteristics of quantum theory that cannot be understood in any framework defined by the classical mechanical presuppositions of symmetry and conservation. These four characteristics are the participatory, the complementary, the indeterminate and the new non-commutative geometry. In Part Two, articulating engineering thermodynamics, I note there are two histories and two formulations of thermodynamics: Carnot's engineering thermodynamics and the 'rational mechanical' tradition of Clausius-Boltzmann. These four essential characteristics of quantum theory are also characteristics of engineering thermodynamics. In Part Three, I trace the precursors of Lazare Carnot's engineering thermodynamics to earlier insights of Huygens, d'Alembert, Leibniz and the Bernoullis. Leibniz brought these forth in his meta-paradigm shift from Statics to Dynamics. This article is part of the theme issue 'Thermodynamics 2.0: Bridging the natural and social sciences (Part 2)'.

Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Aug 13, 2023•4 citations

Interpretation of quantum theory

Benjamin Liebowitz

Il Nuovo cimento della Società italiana di fisica. B/Il Nuovo cimento B•Jun 1, 1975•5 citations
Quantum theory, however taught, is always a shock to the system for a new student . This is unfortunate because a lot of 'forefront-of-technology' calculations are possible with only a rudimentary knowledge of quantum mechanics . If you can, I strongly advise you to do the following. Do not try to understand the mechanics of the theory at this stage. Use the mathematics that are presented in this chapter in order to understand the new 'low-dimensional devices' (LDDs) only. Virtually all the new quantum devices and quantum effects in semiconductor physics can be understood if you are well versed in just one quantum mechanical solution. The particular solution we are going to study is called 'the particle-in-a­ box'. This may not sound very glamorous but the theory is easily understood and the applications are far reaching. For this reason, the way I am going to introduce the quantum theory is biased with just one aim in mind, to understand the physics and applications of the particle-in-a-box.
Realism comes in many varieties, in science and elsewhere. Van Fraassen’s influential formulation took scientific realism to include the view that science aims to give us, in its theories, a literally true story of what the world is like. So understood, a quantum realist takes quantum theory to aim at correctly representing the world: many would add that its success justifies believing this representation is more or less correct. But quantum realism has been understood both more narrowly and more broadly. A pragmatist considers use prior to representation and this has prompted some to dub pragmatist views anti-realist, including the view of quantum theory that the author has been developing recently. But whether a pragmatist view of quantum theory should be labeled anti-realist depends not only on its ingredients but also on how that label should be applied. Pragmatism offers a healthy diet of quantum realism.
Feynman insisted 'no one understands quantum theory'. Yet, experimentalists tell us quantum theory is the most successful theory in history. Quantum theory cannot be understood as a classical mechanical theory since it arose through the 'interpolation' of two highly successful but complementary classical mechanics: Newtonian particle mechanics and Maxwellian wave mechanics. The two-slit experiment illustrates that what is experienced depends on choice of experimental set-up. Quantum theory is properly understood within the more general framework of engineering thermodynamics. In Part One, I point to four essential characteristics of quantum theory that cannot be understood in any framework defined by the classical mechanical presuppositions of symmetry and conservation. These four characteristics are the participatory, the complementary, the indeterminate and the new non-commutative geometry. In Part Two, articulating engineering thermodynamics, I note there are two histories and two formulations of thermodynamics: Carnot's engineering thermodynamics and the 'rational mechanical' tradition of Clausius-Boltzmann. These four essential characteristics of quantum theory are also characteristics of engineering thermodynamics. In Part Three, I trace the precursors of Lazare Carnot's engineering thermodynamics to earlier insights of Huygens, d'Alembert, Leibniz and the Bernoullis. Leibniz brought these forth in his meta-paradigm shift from Statics to Dynamics. This article is part of the theme issue 'Thermodynamics 2.0: Bridging the natural and social sciences (Part 2)'.