We study the plaquette valence bond solid phase in an XXZ-type spin-1/2 model in the kagome lattice. The low-energy theory for this phase is a U(1) lattice gauge theory on the honeycomb lattice. We find that there is an emergent 1-form U(1) symmetry at low energy and there is a mixed anomaly. We also show that this 1-form symmetry restricts the longitudinal dynamical structure factor and leads to the selection rule relating to the vanishing intensity along some high-symmetry momentum paths (e.g., the $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}\text{\ensuremath{-}}M$ path). Since this emergent 1-form symmetry is robust in the presence of local UV perturbation, the selection rule will also apply to the model which is obtained by perturbing the classical limit of our model.
We study general conditions in which disordered, spin liquid, and valence-bond ordered phases occur in the Kagome lattice quantum Ising antiferromagnets. Different quantum dynamical processes in the Ising model, with and without total Ising spin conserved, are analytically shown to yield all three characteristic quantum paramagnetic phases in the Kagome system. Special emphasis is given to the
XXZ model that can be sensibly compared to the Kagome lattice Heisenberg antiferromagnet. It is explicitly demonstrated that the total-spin-conserving dynamics can yield a resonant valence bond liquid phase with very short-ranged correlations, but also a valence-bond ordered phase compatible with the one proposed to explain the seemingly gapless singlet states of the Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the Kagome lattice. Likely consequences for generic spin models are discussed. The analysis combines compact U(1) gauge theory, duality transformations, lattice-field-theoretical methods, and variational approach.