Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Lagrangian Formulation for Particle Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics

Roderick I. Sutherland

Published Nov 13, 2014• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

A Lagrangian description is presented here that can be used in conjunction with a particle interpretation of quantum mechanics. The advantages of this description are that the field equations and the particle equations of motion can both be deduced from a single Lagrangian density expression and that conservation of energy and momentum are assured. This Lagrangian formulation is then applied to the special case of the well-known Bohm model as an example. It is thereby demonstrated that such a formulation is compatible with the predictions of quantum mechanics.

Related papers

Hamiltonian theory of wave and particle in quantum mechanics I. Liouville's theorem and the interpretation of the de Broglie-Bohm theory

Peter Holland

This paper and a following one develop a Hamiltonian formulation of the de Broglie-Bohm (deBB) interpretation of quantum mechanics. Drawing upon a unified Hamiltonian treatment of a classical particle and its associated ensemble, it is shown how the interaction of a particle and a spin-0 quantum wave can be consistently expressed in a canonical framework. A formulation is found in which the particle is acted upon by a force determined by the quantum potential but the particle does not react on the Schrodinger field. This requires the introduction of an additional field which the particle does act upon, and allows the deBB theory to be expressed in Hamiltonian terms. An ensemble theory for the wave-particle system based on Liouville's equation is developed, and it is shown that for a pure quantum state the particle obeys its own Liouville equation. The general particle phase space distribution that is compatible with ‖ψ‖ 2 is derived. A special case of this corresponds to the relation p = ∂S/∂q (and thus the guidance law of the deBB theory) but more general distributions, and hence non-deBB motions, are possible. This relation is interpreted as a constraint on the phase space of the composite system. Using the theory of Hamiltonian constraints it is shown that the first-order guidance law and Hamilton's second-order particle equations are dynamically equivalent.

Il Nuovo Cimento B•Sep 1, 2001•12 citations

Incorporating action and reaction into a particle interpretation for quantum mechanics -- Schrodinger case

Roderick I. Sutherland

This paper follows on from a previous one in which it was shown that it is possible, within a de Broglie-Bohm style ontology for quantum mechanics, to incorporate action and reaction between the particle and its guiding field while remaining consistent with the usual experimental predictions. Whereas the previous paper focussed on the Dirac equation, the present work addresses the Schrodinger case and demonstrates that the same two-way interaction can be achieved. The aim in each case is to increase the physical plausibility of such models. The transition to include the reaction of the particle back on the field, and hence energy and momentum conservation, is attained by employing standard Lagrangian techniques. In formulating this description an interesting bonus emerges in that the hitherto unrelated concept of a gauge transformation is found to arise naturally as an essential part of the formalism. In particular, the phase S of the gauge transformation is seen to be the action function describing the hidden motion of the particle.

arXiv:1911.07663•Nov 12, 2019•1 citation

Quantum Mechanics as a Classical Field Theory

de la Torre, A. C., Alejandro Daleo

The formalism of quantum mechanics is presented in a way that its interpretation as a classical field theory is emphasized. Two coupled real fields are defined with given equations of motion. Densities and currents associated to the fields are found with their corresponding conserved quantities. The behavior of these quantities under a galilean transformation suggest the association of the fields with a quantum mechanical free particle. An external potential is introduced in the Lagrange formalism. The description is equivalent to the conventional Schrödinger equation treatment of a particle. We discuss the attempts to build an interpretation of quantum mechanics based on this scheme. The fields become the primary onthology of the theory and the particles appear as emergent properties of the fields. These interpretations face serious problems for systems with many degrees of freedom.

arXiv:quant-ph/9905032•May 10, 1999•2 citations

Incorporating action and reaction into a particle interpretation for quantum mechanics -- Dirac case

Roderick I. Sutherland

A weakness which has previously seemed unavoidable in particle interpretations of quantum mechanics (such as in the de Broglie-Bohm model) is addressed here and a resolution proposed. The weakness in question is the lack of action and reaction occurring between the model's field (or "pilot wave") and the particle. Although the field acts on the particle, the particle does not act back on the field. It is shown here that this rather artificial feature is, in fact, not necessary and can be fully eliminated while remaining consistent with the usual quantum predictions. Mathematically this amounts to demonstrating that there exists a suitable Lagrangian density function which generates equations coinciding with quantum mechanics yet incorporates the desired action and reaction. As a by-product, an appealing explanation emerges to another long-standing question, namely why the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics seems only to be describing fields when measurements generally detect localised particles. A further bonus is that the hitherto unrelated concept of a gauge transformation is found to arise naturally as an essential part of the formalism. In particular, the phase S of the gauge transformation is seen to be the action function describing the hidden motion of the particle.

arXiv:1908.04897•Aug 14, 2019•1 citation

Lagrangian Formulation and Mechanical Interpretation

Mario Bunge

The question is asked whether, as is often claimed, the Lagrangian formulation of a physical theory provides its mechanical interpretation. For purposes of this enquiry, an analysis of physical theories is performed, with special emphasis on classical mechanics, electromagnetism, and quantum mechanics. Three aspects are distinguished and defined: the formulation (statement), the representation (transformation properties), and the interpretation (meaning). Confusion of formalism with meaning is criticized, and is suggested as a source of some misunderstandings of recent reinterpretations of quantum mechanics. Properties and advantages of Lagrangian formulations are listed, and it is recalled that their chief usefulness lies in that they are the most helpful precisely when mechanisms are either ignored or absent. It is concluded that Lagrangian formulations contribute to the demechanization of physics and that the program of reduction to mechanics has not succeeded in physics.

American Journal of Physics•Apr 1, 1957•15 citations

Quantum mechanics from Newton's second law and the canonical commutation relation [ X , P ] = i

Mark C. Palenik

Despite the fact that it has been known since the time of Heisenberg that quantum operators obey a quantum version of Newton's laws, students are often told that derivations of quantum mechanics must necessarily follow from the Hamiltonian or Lagrangian formulations of mechanics. Here, we first derive the existing Heisenberg equations of motion from Newton's laws and the uncertainty principle using only the equations $F=\frac{dP}{dt}$, $P=m\frac{dV}{dt}$, and $\left[X,P\right]=i$. Then, a new expression for the propagator is derived that makes a connection between time evolution in quantum mechanics and the motion of a classical particle under Newton's laws. The propagator is solved for three cases where an exact solution is possible 1) the free particle 2) the harmonic oscillator 3) a constant force, or linear potential in the standard interpretation. Such a picture may be useful for students as they make the transition from classical to quantum mechanics and help solidify the equivalence of the Hamiltonian, Lagrangian, and Newtonian formulations of physics in their minds.

arXiv:1402.0396•European Journal of Physics•May 9, 2014•5 citations
A Lagrangian description is presented here that can be used in conjunction with a particle interpretation of quantum mechanics. The advantages of this description are that the field equations and the particle equations of motion can both be deduced from a single Lagrangian density expression and that conservation of energy and momentum are assured. This Lagrangian formulation is then applied to the special case of the well-known Bohm model as an example. It is thereby demonstrated that such a formulation is compatible with the predictions of quantum mechanics.
This paper and a following one develop a Hamiltonian formulation of the de Broglie-Bohm (deBB) interpretation of quantum mechanics. Drawing upon a unified Hamiltonian treatment of a classical particle and its associated ensemble, it is shown how the interaction of a particle and a spin-0 quantum wave can be consistently expressed in a canonical framework. A formulation is found in which the particle is acted upon by a force determined by the quantum potential but the particle does not react on the Schrodinger field. This requires the introduction of an additional field which the particle does act upon, and allows the deBB theory to be expressed in Hamiltonian terms. An ensemble theory for the wave-particle system based on Liouville's equation is developed, and it is shown that for a pure quantum state the particle obeys its own Liouville equation. The general particle phase space distribution that is compatible with ‖ψ‖ 2 is derived. A special case of this corresponds to the relation p = ∂S/∂q (and thus the guidance law of the deBB theory) but more general distributions, and hence non-deBB motions, are possible. This relation is interpreted as a constraint on the phase space of the composite system. Using the theory of Hamiltonian constraints it is shown that the first-order guidance law and Hamilton's second-order particle equations are dynamically equivalent.
This paper follows on from a previous one in which it was shown that it is possible, within a de Broglie-Bohm style ontology for quantum mechanics, to incorporate action and reaction between the particle and its guiding field while remaining consistent with the usual experimental predictions. Whereas the previous paper focussed on the Dirac equation, the present work addresses the Schrodinger case and demonstrates that the same two-way interaction can be achieved. The aim in each case is to increase the physical plausibility of such models. The transition to include the reaction of the particle back on the field, and hence energy and momentum conservation, is attained by employing standard Lagrangian techniques. In formulating this description an interesting bonus emerges in that the hitherto unrelated concept of a gauge transformation is found to arise naturally as an essential part of the formalism. In particular, the phase S of the gauge transformation is seen to be the action function describing the hidden motion of the particle.
The formalism of quantum mechanics is presented in a way that its interpretation as a classical field theory is emphasized. Two coupled real fields are defined with given equations of motion. Densities and currents associated to the fields are found with their corresponding conserved quantities. The behavior of these quantities under a galilean transformation suggest the association of the fields with a quantum mechanical free particle. An external potential is introduced in the Lagrange formalism. The description is equivalent to the conventional Schrödinger equation treatment of a particle. We discuss the attempts to build an interpretation of quantum mechanics based on this scheme. The fields become the primary onthology of the theory and the particles appear as emergent properties of the fields. These interpretations face serious problems for systems with many degrees of freedom.
A weakness which has previously seemed unavoidable in particle interpretations of quantum mechanics (such as in the de Broglie-Bohm model) is addressed here and a resolution proposed. The weakness in question is the lack of action and reaction occurring between the model's field (or "pilot wave") and the particle. Although the field acts on the particle, the particle does not act back on the field. It is shown here that this rather artificial feature is, in fact, not necessary and can be fully eliminated while remaining consistent with the usual quantum predictions. Mathematically this amounts to demonstrating that there exists a suitable Lagrangian density function which generates equations coinciding with quantum mechanics yet incorporates the desired action and reaction. As a by-product, an appealing explanation emerges to another long-standing question, namely why the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics seems only to be describing fields when measurements generally detect localised particles. A further bonus is that the hitherto unrelated concept of a gauge transformation is found to arise naturally as an essential part of the formalism. In particular, the phase S of the gauge transformation is seen to be the action function describing the hidden motion of the particle.
The question is asked whether, as is often claimed, the Lagrangian formulation of a physical theory provides its mechanical interpretation. For purposes of this enquiry, an analysis of physical theories is performed, with special emphasis on classical mechanics, electromagnetism, and quantum mechanics. Three aspects are distinguished and defined: the formulation (statement), the representation (transformation properties), and the interpretation (meaning). Confusion of formalism with meaning is criticized, and is suggested as a source of some misunderstandings of recent reinterpretations of quantum mechanics. Properties and advantages of Lagrangian formulations are listed, and it is recalled that their chief usefulness lies in that they are the most helpful precisely when mechanisms are either ignored or absent. It is concluded that Lagrangian formulations contribute to the demechanization of physics and that the program of reduction to mechanics has not succeeded in physics.
Despite the fact that it has been known since the time of Heisenberg that quantum operators obey a quantum version of Newton's laws, students are often told that derivations of quantum mechanics must necessarily follow from the Hamiltonian or Lagrangian formulations of mechanics. Here, we first derive the existing Heisenberg equations of motion from Newton's laws and the uncertainty principle using only the equations F=dPdtF=\frac{dP}{dt}F=dtdP​, P=mdVdtP=m\frac{dV}{dt}P=mdtdV​, and [X,P]=i\left[X,P\right]=i[X,P]=i. Then, a new expression for the propagator is derived that makes a connection between time evolution in quantum mechanics and the motion of a classical particle under Newton's laws. The propagator is solved for three cases where an exact solution is possible 1) the free particle 2) the harmonic oscillator 3) a constant force, or linear potential in the standard interpretation. Such a picture may be useful for students as they make the transition from classical to quantum mechanics and help solidify the equivalence of the Hamiltonian, Lagrangian, and Newtonian formulations of physics in their minds.