Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Sacrificing Free Will is beneficial than allowing Signaling in `semi quantum' game

Manik Banik

Published Apr 23, 2013• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In a world described by quantum mechanics, one cannot have determinism, no-signaling and free will all together. Under validation of all these three assumptions, together, the set of statistical correlations are bounded to the set of Bell local correlations. In standard Bell scenario any non-local correlation has a deterministic explanation if one either sacrifices free will or allows signaling. Recently in [Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 200401 (2012)] F. Buscemi generalizes the standard Bell scenario into `semi-quantum' Bell scenario. Interestingly, in this article, we show that in `semi-quantum' Bell game one can get correlations that cannot be obtained by giving up no signaling, alone; whereas such correlations can be obtained by sacrificing free will.

Related papers

Lack of measurement independence can simulate quantum correlations even when signaling can not

Manik Banik

In the Bell scenario, any nonlocal correlation shared between two spatially separated parties can be modeled deterministically either by allowing communications between the two parties or by restricting their free will in choosing the measurement settings. Recently, the Bell scenario has been generalized into a ``semiquantum'' scenario where external quantum inputs are provided to the parties. We show that in the semiquantum scenario, entangled states produce correlations whose deterministic explanation is possible only if measurement independence is reduced. Thus in simulating quantum correlation the semiquantum scenario reveals a qualitative distinction between signaling and measurement dependence which is absent in the Bell scenario. We further show that such distinction is not observed in the ``steering-game'' scenario, a special case of the semiquantum scenario.

arXiv:1304.6425•Physical Review A•Sep 27, 2013•13 citations

Exact Identification of Quantum Correlations in the Minimal Bell Scenario

Liang-Liang Sun, Jie Wang, Sixia Yu

Bell nonlocality places the long-standing philosophical disputes over the nature of quantum theory on a mathematically rigorous, experimentally testable footing, positioning quantum mechanics between local realism and the most general no-signaling theories. Yet the precise quantum boundary has remained elusive even in the minimal Bell scenario, where the extreme points generating the set are known. Here we characterize this boundary through a computable necessary and sufficient criterion: a correlation is quantum if and only if it can be decomposed into an extreme quantum correlation and a classical correlation. The criterion follows from our proof that every Bell functional exhibiting quantum advantage admits a unique quantum maximizer. We further classify the finitely many maximal-face structures containing each nonlocal exposed point according to their local deterministic vertices. By sharply distinguishing physically realizable correlations from nonphysical ones, these results resolve a long-standing open problem and provide a new foundation for identifying the principles underlying quantum theory and determining the ultimate information-theoretic limits of quantum correlations.

quant-pharXiv:2610.34364•Oct 27, 2026•1 citation

Nonclassicality in correlations without causal order

Ravi Kunjwal, Ognyan Oreshkov

Bell scenarios are multipartite scenarios that exclude any signalling between parties. This leads to a strict hierarchy of classical, quantum, and non-signalling correlations in such scenarios. Here we consider a minimal relaxation of non-signalling: each party is allowed to receive a system once, implement any local intervention on it, and send out the resulting system once. Crucially, unlike Bell, we make no global assumption about causal relations between parties, e.g., they could be embedded in some exotic spacetime with indefinite causal order. We do make a causal assumption local to each party, i.e., the input received by it causally precedes the output it sends out. We then ask: Can we device-independently certify the nonclassicality of multipartite correlations in such scenarios, just as Bell inequality violations do so in Bell scenarios? A priori, this is not clear: without some assumptions on the underlying physics (e.g., non-signalling), parties can realize arbitrary correlations. We therefore make a minimal assumption of logical consistency on the underlying physics, i.e., it must be free of time-travel antinomies without imposing any restrictions on local interventions of the parties. We then define antinomicity as a device-independent notion of nonclassicality and prove a strict hierarchy between correlation sets based on their antinomicity. An antinomic correlation cannot be explained by a classical physical theory compatible with free local interventions on pain of logical contradictions in the theory. On the other hand, parties exchanging quantum systems can witness antinomicity while respecting logical consistency. Antinomicity reduces to Bell nonlocality for non-signalling parties. It also resolves a conceptual puzzle, namely, the failure of causal inequalities as witnesses of nonclassicality: antinomicity implies causal inequality violations, but not conversely.

arXiv:2307.02565•Jul 5, 2023•14 citations

The axiom of choice and the no-signalling principle

Ämin Baumeler, Borivoje Dakić, Flavio Del Santo

We show that the axiom of choice , a basic yet controversial postulate of set theory, together with one of the pillars of our best physical theories, namely the no-signalling principle , may point to a limitation in modelling physical problems using standard mathematics. While it is well known that probabilistic no-signalling resources (such as quantum non-locality) are stronger than deterministic ones, we show—by invoking the axiom of choice—the opposite: functional (deterministic) no-signalling resources can be stronger than probabilistic ones (e.g. stronger than quantum entanglement or non-locality in general). To prove this, we devise a Bell-like game that shows a systematic advantage of functional no-signalling with respect to any probabilistic no-signalling resource.

arXiv:2206.08467•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Jul 1, 2025•2 citations

The Last Loophole in Bell's Theorem? A prima facie problem with superdeterminism

Kent A. Peacock

Hance and Hossenfelder recently claim that the extensive experimental confirmations of Bell's Theorem do not in fact demonstrate that nature is nonlocal, but merely that nature can be local only if the distant detector settings in a Bell-EPR setup are not statistically independent. They suggest that such interdependence could take a local-deterministic form. There is no question that in general quantum mechanics not only allows but demands that the distant detectors be entangled and thus correlated, even though it is possible to do experiments in which such correlations can be ignored. The real question is whether entanglement itself could have a deterministic explanation. We review why any such attempted deterministic underpinning for quantum statistics would run into immediate conflict with quantum indeterminacy and the noncommutativity upon which the latter is based. Some cosmological implications are briefly explored.

arXiv:2410.05296•Oct 3, 2024•0 citations

Multistage games and Bell scenarios with communication

George Moreno, Ranieri Nery, Alberto B. de Palhares +1 more

Bell nonlocality is a cornerstone of quantum theory with applications in information processing ranging from cryptography to distributed computing and game theory. Indeed, it is known that Bell's theorem can be formally linked to Bayesian games, allowing the use of nonlocal correlations to advise players and thereby achieve new points of equilibrium that are unavailable classically. Here we generalize this link, proving the connection between multistage games of incomplete information with Bell scenarios involving the communication of measurement outcomes between the parties. We apply the general framework for a few cases of interest and analyze the equilibrium reached by quantum nonlocal correlations.

arXiv:2012.00733•Physical Review A•Oct 26, 2020•3 citations
In a world described by quantum mechanics, one cannot have determinism, no-signaling and free will all together. Under validation of all these three assumptions, together, the set of statistical correlations are bounded to the set of Bell local correlations. In standard Bell scenario any non-local correlation has a deterministic explanation if one either sacrifices free will or allows signaling. Recently in [Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 200401 (2012)] F. Buscemi generalizes the standard Bell scenario into semi-quantum' Bell scenario. Interestingly, in this article, we show that in semi-quantum' Bell game one can get correlations that cannot be obtained by giving up no signaling, alone; whereas such correlations can be obtained by sacrificing free will.
In the Bell scenario, any nonlocal correlation shared between two spatially separated parties can be modeled deterministically either by allowing communications between the two parties or by restricting their free will in choosing the measurement settings. Recently, the Bell scenario has been generalized into a ``semiquantum'' scenario where external quantum inputs are provided to the parties. We show that in the semiquantum scenario, entangled states produce correlations whose deterministic explanation is possible only if measurement independence is reduced. Thus in simulating quantum correlation the semiquantum scenario reveals a qualitative distinction between signaling and measurement dependence which is absent in the Bell scenario. We further show that such distinction is not observed in the ``steering-game'' scenario, a special case of the semiquantum scenario.
Bell nonlocality places the long-standing philosophical disputes over the nature of quantum theory on a mathematically rigorous, experimentally testable footing, positioning quantum mechanics between local realism and the most general no-signaling theories. Yet the precise quantum boundary has remained elusive even in the minimal Bell scenario, where the extreme points generating the set are known. Here we characterize this boundary through a computable necessary and sufficient criterion: a correlation is quantum if and only if it can be decomposed into an extreme quantum correlation and a classical correlation. The criterion follows from our proof that every Bell functional exhibiting quantum advantage admits a unique quantum maximizer. We further classify the finitely many maximal-face structures containing each nonlocal exposed point according to their local deterministic vertices. By sharply distinguishing physically realizable correlations from nonphysical ones, these results resolve a long-standing open problem and provide a new foundation for identifying the principles underlying quantum theory and determining the ultimate information-theoretic limits of quantum correlations.
Bell scenarios are multipartite scenarios that exclude any signalling between parties. This leads to a strict hierarchy of classical, quantum, and non-signalling correlations in such scenarios. Here we consider a minimal relaxation of non-signalling: each party is allowed to receive a system once, implement any local intervention on it, and send out the resulting system once. Crucially, unlike Bell, we make no global assumption about causal relations between parties, e.g., they could be embedded in some exotic spacetime with indefinite causal order. We do make a causal assumption local to each party, i.e., the input received by it causally precedes the output it sends out. We then ask: Can we device-independently certify the nonclassicality of multipartite correlations in such scenarios, just as Bell inequality violations do so in Bell scenarios? A priori, this is not clear: without some assumptions on the underlying physics (e.g., non-signalling), parties can realize arbitrary correlations. We therefore make a minimal assumption of logical consistency on the underlying physics, i.e., it must be free of time-travel antinomies without imposing any restrictions on local interventions of the parties. We then define antinomicity as a device-independent notion of nonclassicality and prove a strict hierarchy between correlation sets based on their antinomicity. An antinomic correlation cannot be explained by a classical physical theory compatible with free local interventions on pain of logical contradictions in the theory. On the other hand, parties exchanging quantum systems can witness antinomicity while respecting logical consistency. Antinomicity reduces to Bell nonlocality for non-signalling parties. It also resolves a conceptual puzzle, namely, the failure of causal inequalities as witnesses of nonclassicality: antinomicity implies causal inequality violations, but not conversely.
We show that the axiom of choice , a basic yet controversial postulate of set theory, together with one of the pillars of our best physical theories, namely the no-signalling principle , may point to a limitation in modelling physical problems using standard mathematics. While it is well known that probabilistic no-signalling resources (such as quantum non-locality) are stronger than deterministic ones, we show—by invoking the axiom of choice—the opposite: functional (deterministic) no-signalling resources can be stronger than probabilistic ones (e.g. stronger than quantum entanglement or non-locality in general). To prove this, we devise a Bell-like game that shows a systematic advantage of functional no-signalling with respect to any probabilistic no-signalling resource.
Hance and Hossenfelder recently claim that the extensive experimental confirmations of Bell's Theorem do not in fact demonstrate that nature is nonlocal, but merely that nature can be local only if the distant detector settings in a Bell-EPR setup are not statistically independent. They suggest that such interdependence could take a local-deterministic form. There is no question that in general quantum mechanics not only allows but demands that the distant detectors be entangled and thus correlated, even though it is possible to do experiments in which such correlations can be ignored. The real question is whether entanglement itself could have a deterministic explanation. We review why any such attempted deterministic underpinning for quantum statistics would run into immediate conflict with quantum indeterminacy and the noncommutativity upon which the latter is based. Some cosmological implications are briefly explored.
Bell nonlocality is a cornerstone of quantum theory with applications in information processing ranging from cryptography to distributed computing and game theory. Indeed, it is known that Bell's theorem can be formally linked to Bayesian games, allowing the use of nonlocal correlations to advise players and thereby achieve new points of equilibrium that are unavailable classically. Here we generalize this link, proving the connection between multistage games of incomplete information with Bell scenarios involving the communication of measurement outcomes between the parties. We apply the general framework for a few cases of interest and analyze the equilibrium reached by quantum nonlocal correlations.