Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Complement 2A: Classical model of the atom-field interaction: the Lorentz model

G. Grynberg, Alain Aspect, Claude Fabre, Claude N. Cohen-Tannoudji

Published Sep 2, 2010• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This first complement is devoted to a completely classical approach of lightmatter interaction which was proposed by Lorentz at the end of the nineteenth century, before the advent of quantum mechanics, but after the discovery of the electron. Lorentz' phenomenological model is based on the experimental fact that atoms have well-defined and sharp absorption lines: he assumed that atoms behaved like harmonic oscillators, in which the electrons are bound to the atomic nucleus by a restoring force which varies linearly with its displacement (from its equilibrium point close to a nucleus), and makes them oscillate at a given frequency ω0 equal to the experimentally determined absorption frequency.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511778261.007

Related papers

The classical physics pathway

P. van der Straten, Harold J. Metcalf

Introduction While it might appear that the nineteenth-century physics presented in this chapter has no place in a topic as quantum mechanically oriented as atomic physics, this is simply not the case. The purpose of this first chapter is to try to convince the readers that the material learned in their early years of studying physics is not disjoint from modern topics, but in fact can provide a foundation for their further understanding. Other examples will occur later. The reader may be a bit surprised to see that the results of the classical description turn out to be so close to the quantum mechanical results. Where there are significant disagreements between classical and quantum descriptions, it is necessary to explain why these occur. The correspondence principle requires that in the limit of large quantum numbers the complete quantum mechanical description must agree with the classical one. It is always better to need fewer of these explanations and to be able to treat physics as a coherent whole instead of a collection of topics. The consequences of classical physics are intuitively familiar, and this is often most helpful in gaining deeper understanding. In fact, the approach taken in very many of the chapters in this book is to start with a purely classical description of a topic, and then transport it directly into the Schrödinger equation. Radiation from an accelerated charge, as treated here in the harmonic case, provides an ideal setting for such pedagogy. Even though classical mechanics is used in place of quantum mechanics, for the case of harmonic motion, the results are quite compatible. The early history of atomic physics contains many topics that are well worth reading about, especially the experimental facilities. For example, there were no electric motors, wire was not readily available, and making even a crude vacuum was an experimental tour de force. Very many textbooks have discussions of these topics, and so they will not be presented here. But the reader is warned that certain oft-repeated modern descriptions are simply wrong. Perhaps the most important notion to be gained from this chapter is that the classical description of a harmonically bound electron provides quite accurate results about the interaction between atoms and light. Of course, the utility of this description is limited because the classical harmonic oscillator has no internal structure, is infinitely deep, and has a continuous energy spectrum.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 31, 2015•0 citations

Classical Interpretation of Quantum Mechanical Concepts

Clymer, NY, USA, Richard Joseph Oldani

All of the mathematical formulations of quantum mechanics describe the interaction between radiation and atoms, but we show here that only Einstein has been able to establish a solid logical connection with classical theory. His methods are used to interpret the other mathematical models by requiring that observables be described in a physically-defined coordinate system and that there be strict adherence to the conservation of momentum. The properties of momentum exchange are included in a quantum oscillator, or clock, by replacing the non-relativistic Hamiltonian model with a relativistically correct Lagrangian model. Equal contributions are assigned to photon, electron, and nucleus; and field boundaries are defined that coincide with the electron shells. The fields of the particles superpose linearly, but otherwise their physical integrity is maintained throughout. The Lagrangian model accounts for the 720 degree rotation of a wave function as an initial 360 degree electromagnetic wave cycle (photon absorption) followed by a second wave cycle (photon emission), yielding two wave cycles to correspond with one complete electron cycle. The abstract space of quantum mechanics is replaced by a real classical space.

Japan Journal of Research•Feb 28, 2023•0 citations

Introduction: Classical Theory of Electric Dipole Radiative Interactions

Robert P. Lucht

The classical theory of the interaction of light with the electron clouds of atoms and molecules will be discussed in this chapter. The discussion will begin with the interaction of a steady electric field with a collection of point charges, leading to the development of terms describing the electric dipole and quadrupole moments. The classical Lorentz model is then introduced to describe interaction of an oscillating electric field with the electron cloud of an atom, and the concepts of absorption and emission are introduced. The propagation of a light wave through a medium with electric dipoles is then discussed. Finally, the classical theory of radiation from an oscillating dipole is discussed.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 12, 2024•0 citations

Electrodynamics II: Microscopic Interaction of Light and Matter

Michael E. Thomas

Although the primarily phenomenological theory of absorption and refraction of light by matter, based on classical models as presented in Chapter 4, is very useful, it is incomplete and often inadequate. A more complete and accurate picture of electrodynamics is given by the theory of quantum optics, and that is the topic of this chapter. The models developed in this chapter are more detailed and therefore more complicated than the phenomenological models of Chapter 4. The most robust models, which are applied in Part II, are presented in this chapter. The quantum models accurately represent experimental data and allow extrapolation and interpolation of such data. Many practical computer based models concerning optical propagation are based on this theory. The theory of elastic scatter as presented in Chapter 4 is consistent with quantum optics and is not presented again. (However, inelastic scatter must address the quantum nature of the scattering medium.) Quantum optics is not completely covered in this chapter. Entire textbooks are devoted to this diverse and comprehensive topic covering optics (see Refs. 5.1–5.3). The emphasis of this book is on absorption and reflection spectroscopy. Now details of internal structure of the medium impacting light–matter interaction are examined. The classical oscillator model is upgraded by semiclassical radiation theory and a quantum oscillator model is developed. Semiclassical radiation theory is based on a quantized medium coupled to a classical field. It is often applied to laser theory, where near-line-center stimulated emission dominates. The quantum oscillator model again utilizes the quantized medium and classical field, but with more attention to detailed balance between absorption and emission. It satisfies causality and the fundamental symmetry relationships established in Chapter 2. These quantum optics models are more complete formalisms and provide solutions to the shortcomings of classical electrodynamics. Of particular interest to propagation in gaseous media is the line shape in the far wing. To achieve long path lengths, propagation near line center of a resonance must be avoided. Line shape models in quantum optics accurately represent much of the frequency and temperature dependence observed in experimental data.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 28, 2006•0 citations

Antennas, quantum optics and near-field microscopy

Vahid Sandoghdar, Mario Agio, Xuewen Chen +2 more

The atom is the most elementary constituent of any model that describes the quantum nature of light–matter interaction. Because atoms emit and absorb light at well-defined frequencies, nineteenth century scientists thought of them as collections of harmonically oscillating electric dipole moments or EHDs. In the language of modern physics, the latter represent dipolar transitions among the various quantum mechanical states of an atom. In a strict definition, the field of quantum optics deals with problems that not only require the quantization of matter but also of the electromagnetic field, with examples such as (i) generation of squeezed light or Fock states, (ii) strong coupling of an atom and a photon, (iii) entanglement of a photon with an atom and (iv) Casimir and van der Waals forces. There are also many other important topics that have been discussed within the quantum optics community but do not necessarily require a full quantum electrodynamic (QED) treatment. Examples are (i) cooling and trapping of atoms, (ii) precision spectroscopy and (iii) modification of spontaneous emission. The simple picture of a TLS as an EHD remains very insightful and valuable to this day. Indeed, much of what we discuss in this chapter has to do with the interplay between the quantum and classical mechanical characters of dipolar oscillators. For instance, the extinction cross-section of a TLS, given by 3λ2/2π, can be derived just as well using quantum mechanics [70] or classical optics [234]. Another example, albeit more subtle, concerns the spontaneous emission rate.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 3, 2013•9 citations

The classical theory of dispersion

Stephen G. Lipson, H. Lipson, David Stefan Tannhauser

Classical dispersion theory Many aspects of the interaction between radiation and matter can be described quite accurately by a classical theory in which the medium is represented by model atoms consisting of positive and negative parts bound by an attraction which depends linearly on their separation. Although quantum theory is necessary to calculate from first principles the magnitude of the parameters involved, in this chapter we shall show that many optical effects can be interpreted physically in terms of this model by the use of classical mechanics. In §13.5 we shall relax the restriction of linearity. Some of the quantum mechanical foundations will be discussed briefly in Chapter 14, but most are outside the scope of this book (see Yariv, 1989; Loudon, 1983). The term dispersion means the dependence of dielectric response (dielectric constant and refractive index) on frequency of the wave field. This will be the topic of the present section. Afterwards we shall see some of the applications of dielectric response to spatial effects. The classical atom Our classical picture of an atom consists of a massive positive nucleus surrounded by a light spherically-symmetrical cloud of electrons with an equal negative charge. We imagine the two as bound together by springs as in Fig. 13.1, so that in equilibrium the centres of mass and charge of the core and electron charge coincide. As a result the static atom has zero dipole moment.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 27, 1995•0 citations
This first complement is devoted to a completely classical approach of lightmatter interaction which was proposed by Lorentz at the end of the nineteenth century, before the advent of quantum mechanics, but after the discovery of the electron. Lorentz' phenomenological model is based on the experimental fact that atoms have well-defined and sharp absorption lines: he assumed that atoms behaved like harmonic oscillators, in which the electrons are bound to the atomic nucleus by a restoring force which varies linearly with its displacement (from its equilibrium point close to a nucleus), and makes them oscillate at a given frequency ω0 equal to the experimentally determined absorption frequency.
Introduction While it might appear that the nineteenth-century physics presented in this chapter has no place in a topic as quantum mechanically oriented as atomic physics, this is simply not the case. The purpose of this first chapter is to try to convince the readers that the material learned in their early years of studying physics is not disjoint from modern topics, but in fact can provide a foundation for their further understanding. Other examples will occur later. The reader may be a bit surprised to see that the results of the classical description turn out to be so close to the quantum mechanical results. Where there are significant disagreements between classical and quantum descriptions, it is necessary to explain why these occur. The correspondence principle requires that in the limit of large quantum numbers the complete quantum mechanical description must agree with the classical one. It is always better to need fewer of these explanations and to be able to treat physics as a coherent whole instead of a collection of topics. The consequences of classical physics are intuitively familiar, and this is often most helpful in gaining deeper understanding. In fact, the approach taken in very many of the chapters in this book is to start with a purely classical description of a topic, and then transport it directly into the Schrödinger equation. Radiation from an accelerated charge, as treated here in the harmonic case, provides an ideal setting for such pedagogy. Even though classical mechanics is used in place of quantum mechanics, for the case of harmonic motion, the results are quite compatible. The early history of atomic physics contains many topics that are well worth reading about, especially the experimental facilities. For example, there were no electric motors, wire was not readily available, and making even a crude vacuum was an experimental tour de force. Very many textbooks have discussions of these topics, and so they will not be presented here. But the reader is warned that certain oft-repeated modern descriptions are simply wrong. Perhaps the most important notion to be gained from this chapter is that the classical description of a harmonically bound electron provides quite accurate results about the interaction between atoms and light. Of course, the utility of this description is limited because the classical harmonic oscillator has no internal structure, is infinitely deep, and has a continuous energy spectrum.
All of the mathematical formulations of quantum mechanics describe the interaction between radiation and atoms, but we show here that only Einstein has been able to establish a solid logical connection with classical theory. His methods are used to interpret the other mathematical models by requiring that observables be described in a physically-defined coordinate system and that there be strict adherence to the conservation of momentum. The properties of momentum exchange are included in a quantum oscillator, or clock, by replacing the non-relativistic Hamiltonian model with a relativistically correct Lagrangian model. Equal contributions are assigned to photon, electron, and nucleus; and field boundaries are defined that coincide with the electron shells. The fields of the particles superpose linearly, but otherwise their physical integrity is maintained throughout. The Lagrangian model accounts for the 720 degree rotation of a wave function as an initial 360 degree electromagnetic wave cycle (photon absorption) followed by a second wave cycle (photon emission), yielding two wave cycles to correspond with one complete electron cycle. The abstract space of quantum mechanics is replaced by a real classical space.
The classical theory of the interaction of light with the electron clouds of atoms and molecules will be discussed in this chapter. The discussion will begin with the interaction of a steady electric field with a collection of point charges, leading to the development of terms describing the electric dipole and quadrupole moments. The classical Lorentz model is then introduced to describe interaction of an oscillating electric field with the electron cloud of an atom, and the concepts of absorption and emission are introduced. The propagation of a light wave through a medium with electric dipoles is then discussed. Finally, the classical theory of radiation from an oscillating dipole is discussed.
Although the primarily phenomenological theory of absorption and refraction of light by matter, based on classical models as presented in Chapter 4, is very useful, it is incomplete and often inadequate. A more complete and accurate picture of electrodynamics is given by the theory of quantum optics, and that is the topic of this chapter. The models developed in this chapter are more detailed and therefore more complicated than the phenomenological models of Chapter 4. The most robust models, which are applied in Part II, are presented in this chapter. The quantum models accurately represent experimental data and allow extrapolation and interpolation of such data. Many practical computer based models concerning optical propagation are based on this theory. The theory of elastic scatter as presented in Chapter 4 is consistent with quantum optics and is not presented again. (However, inelastic scatter must address the quantum nature of the scattering medium.) Quantum optics is not completely covered in this chapter. Entire textbooks are devoted to this diverse and comprehensive topic covering optics (see Refs. 5.1–5.3). The emphasis of this book is on absorption and reflection spectroscopy. Now details of internal structure of the medium impacting light–matter interaction are examined. The classical oscillator model is upgraded by semiclassical radiation theory and a quantum oscillator model is developed. Semiclassical radiation theory is based on a quantized medium coupled to a classical field. It is often applied to laser theory, where near-line-center stimulated emission dominates. The quantum oscillator model again utilizes the quantized medium and classical field, but with more attention to detailed balance between absorption and emission. It satisfies causality and the fundamental symmetry relationships established in Chapter 2. These quantum optics models are more complete formalisms and provide solutions to the shortcomings of classical electrodynamics. Of particular interest to propagation in gaseous media is the line shape in the far wing. To achieve long path lengths, propagation near line center of a resonance must be avoided. Line shape models in quantum optics accurately represent much of the frequency and temperature dependence observed in experimental data.
The atom is the most elementary constituent of any model that describes the quantum nature of light–matter interaction. Because atoms emit and absorb light at well-defined frequencies, nineteenth century scientists thought of them as collections of harmonically oscillating electric dipole moments or EHDs. In the language of modern physics, the latter represent dipolar transitions among the various quantum mechanical states of an atom. In a strict definition, the field of quantum optics deals with problems that not only require the quantization of matter but also of the electromagnetic field, with examples such as (i) generation of squeezed light or Fock states, (ii) strong coupling of an atom and a photon, (iii) entanglement of a photon with an atom and (iv) Casimir and van der Waals forces. There are also many other important topics that have been discussed within the quantum optics community but do not necessarily require a full quantum electrodynamic (QED) treatment. Examples are (i) cooling and trapping of atoms, (ii) precision spectroscopy and (iii) modification of spontaneous emission. The simple picture of a TLS as an EHD remains very insightful and valuable to this day. Indeed, much of what we discuss in this chapter has to do with the interplay between the quantum and classical mechanical characters of dipolar oscillators. For instance, the extinction cross-section of a TLS, given by 3λ2/2π, can be derived just as well using quantum mechanics [70] or classical optics [234]. Another example, albeit more subtle, concerns the spontaneous emission rate.
Classical dispersion theory Many aspects of the interaction between radiation and matter can be described quite accurately by a classical theory in which the medium is represented by model atoms consisting of positive and negative parts bound by an attraction which depends linearly on their separation. Although quantum theory is necessary to calculate from first principles the magnitude of the parameters involved, in this chapter we shall show that many optical effects can be interpreted physically in terms of this model by the use of classical mechanics. In §13.5 we shall relax the restriction of linearity. Some of the quantum mechanical foundations will be discussed briefly in Chapter 14, but most are outside the scope of this book (see Yariv, 1989; Loudon, 1983). The term dispersion means the dependence of dielectric response (dielectric constant and refractive index) on frequency of the wave field. This will be the topic of the present section. Afterwards we shall see some of the applications of dielectric response to spatial effects. The classical atom Our classical picture of an atom consists of a massive positive nucleus surrounded by a light spherically-symmetrical cloud of electrons with an equal negative charge. We imagine the two as bound together by springs as in Fig. 13.1, so that in equilibrium the centres of mass and charge of the core and electron charge coincide. As a result the static atom has zero dipole moment.