Two sets of studies are described in this thesis. The first describes studies conducted with sodium Bose-Einstein condensates (BEC) while the second focuses on the pairing of fermionic lithium-6 pairs in an optical lattice within the strongly interacting BEC-BCS regime. Common to both sets of studies is the use of a magnetically tunable Feshbach resonance to manipulate interactions between the atoms. In the first experiment, we destabilize a sodium BEC by switching its interactions from repulsive to attractive and studied the resulting dynamics. A local amplification of low momentum energetic instabilities was observed and the measured rate of amplification agreed well with theoretical predictions. For large condensates, this process depleted the condensate faster than the global inward collapse. Subsequently, I describe the major construction effort that was undertaken to convert our BEC machine to a two-species machine capable of cooling fermionic lithium-6. Upon its completion, we obtained a resonance superfluid of loosely bound 6Li pairs in the BECBCS crossover. When placed in a shallow optical lattice, long range phase coherence of this resonance superfluid was inferred from the presence of sharp interference peaks after ballistic expansion. With this observation we have obtained the first evidence of superfluidity of fermions in an optical lattice. A loss in phase coherence occurred when the lattice depth was increased past a critical value, possibly signaling a transition to an insulating state. Further preliminary explorations of this novel system is described followed by an outline of its potential for studying condensed matter phenomena like high temperature superconductivity.
Two sets of studies are described in this thesis. The first describes studies conducted with sodium Bose-Einstein condensates (BEC) while the second focuses on the pairing of fermionic lithium-6 pairs in an optical lattice within the strongly interacting BEC-BCS regime. Common to both sets of studies is the use of a magnetically tunable Feshbach resonance to manipulate interactions between the atoms. In the first experiment, we destabilize a sodium BEC by switching its interactions from repulsive to attractive and studied the resulting dynamics. A local amplification of low momentum energetic instabilities was observed and the measured rate of amplification agreed well with theoretical predictions. For large condensates, this process depleted the condensate faster than the global inward collapse. Subsequently, I describe the major construction effort that was undertaken to convert our BEC machine to a two-species machine capable of cooling fermionic lithium-6. Upon its completion, we obtained a resonance superfluid of loosely bound 6Li pairs in the BECBCS crossover. When placed in a shallow optical lattice, long range phase coherence of this resonance superfluid was inferred from the presence of sharp interference peaks after ballistic expansion. With this observation we have obtained the first evidence of superfluidity of fermions in an optical lattice. A loss in phase coherence occurred when the lattice depth was increased past a critical value, possibly signaling a transition to an insulating state. Further preliminary explorations of this novel system is described followed by an outline of its potential for studying condensed matter phenomena like high temperature superconductivity.
The pairing of fermionic particles is an essential ingredient of superconductivity and of the superfluidity of 3He. While such phenomena are accurately described by BCS theory in the limit of weak pairing strength, a complete understanding remains elusive when pairing strength is increased, such as in high temperature superconductors. We create ultracold gases of trapped fermionic 6Li atoms, through which we directly observe fermionic pairing. In our system, there are no impurities whatsoever, and parameters such as the number and temperature of the trapped atoms are precisely and independently controlled. In addition, a Feshbach resonance enables the continuous tuning of interaction strength and sign between the paired atoms. This control allows us to observe the smooth crossover of a molecular Bose Einstein condensate (MBEC) to a superfluid of weakly interacting Cooper pairs. With these tools, we have performed several fundamental measurements of pairing in fermionic systems.\nWe use optical molecular spectroscopy to precisely measure the closed-channel contribution to the many body state of paired 6Li atoms within a broad Feshbach resonance. The magnitude of this contribution is small, and supports the concept of universality for the description of broad Feshbach resonances. Moreover, the dynamics of the excitation provide clear evidence for pairing across the BEC-BCS crossover, and for the first time, into the weakly interacting BCS regime.\nWe also prepare a polarized Fermi gas with unequal numbers of two spin states of 6Li atoms. The real-space densities of the polarized, strongly-interacting, two-component Fermi gas reveal two low temperature regimes. At the lowest temperatures, the gas separates into a phase with a uniformly paired superfluid core surrounded by a shell of normal, unpaired atoms. This phase separation is accompanied by a spatial deformation of the core. At higher temperatures, the uniformly paired core persists, though it does not deform. This temperature dependence is consistent with a tri-critical point in the phase diagram. These measurements of pairing in a polarized Fermi gas are relevant to predictions of exotic phases of quark matter and magnetized superconductors.
The work described in this thesis can be divided into two parts. The first part is concerned with the production of degenerate Fermi gases and Bose-Fermi mixtures. The second part of the thesis describes studies of strongly interacting spin-mixtures of ultracold fermions. We have cooled a magnetically trapped spin-polarized 6Li Fermi gas into quantum degeneracy by sympathetic cooling with bosonic 23Na. In order to do this, we have converted our previously developed apparatus for Bose-Einstein condensation of 23Na into a two-species cooling facility. We have produced 6Li samples with up to 7 × 107 atoms at temperatures below 0.5TF , and up to 3× 107 atoms at temperatures as low as 0.05TF . Further, we have also produced stable quantum degenerate mixtures of 23Na and 6Li, with several million atoms of each species. In a second set of experiments, we have studied strongly interacting spin-mixtures of 6Li. The strength of interactions was resonantly controlled by applying a magnetic field and tuning to “Feshbach resonances”, which occur when the total energy of the colliding particles coincides with the energy of a bound molecular state. These studies are relevant for the continuing quest for a superfluid transition in a Fermi gas. By studying the inelastic decay of the cloud, we have experimentally identified two Feshbach resonances for the inter-state interactions of the two lowest ground states of 6Li. Most importantly, we found that the lifetime of the strongly interacting system is long enough to observe a superfluid transition in the future. The effects of the coherent collisions in 6Li spin-mixtures were studied using radiofrequency (RF) spectroscopy. We demonstrated the absence of mean field “clock shifts” in a two-state mixture of fermions, and have introduced a three-level method to observe the interaction energy shifts. In the strongly interacting regime, near a Feshbach resonance, we have observed universal behavior of the interaction energy, independent of the value of the scattering length. Finally, we have theoretically studied the effects of Pauli blocking during a free expansion of a degenerate Fermi gas. We have concluded that a strongly interacting normal gas will undergo a hydrodynamic expansion even at zero temperature, due to inefficiency of the Pauli suppression of collisions. Therefore, the already observed hydrodynamic expansion cannot be conclusively interpreted as a signature of superfluidity. Thesis Supervisor: Wolfgang Ketterle Title: John D. MacArthur Professor of Physics
This thesis presents experiments probing physics in the crossover between Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) and BCS superconductivity using an ultracold gas of atomic fermions. Scattering resonances in these ultracold gases (known as Feshbach resonances) provide the unique ability to tune the fermion-fermion interactions. The work presented here pioneered the use of fermionic Feshbach resonances as a highly controllable and tunable system ideal for studying the cusp of the BCS-BEC crossover problem. Here pairs of fermionic atoms have some properties of diatomic molecules and some properties of Cooper pairs. I present studies of a normal Fermi gas at a Feshbach resonance and the work required to cool the gas to temperatures where superfluidity in the crossover is predicted. These studies culminated in our observation of a phase transition at the cusp of the BCS-BEC crossover through condensation of fermionic atom pairs. I also discuss subsequent work that confirmed the crossover nature of the pairs in these condensates.
This thesis presents experiments in which a strongly interacting gas of fermions was brought into the superfluid regime. The strong interactions are induced by a Feshbach scattering resonance that allows to tune the interfermion scattering length via an external magnetic field. When a Fermi mixture was cooled on the molecular side of such a Feshbach resonance, Bose-Einstein condensation of up to 107 molecules was observed. Subsequently, the crossover region interpolating between such a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) of molecules and a Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer superfluid of long-range Cooper pairs was studied. Condensates of fermion pairs were detected in a regime where pairing is purely a many-body effect, the pairs being stabilized by the presence of the surrounding particles. Superfluidity and phase coherence in these systems was directly demonstrated throughout the crossover via the observation of long-lived, ordered vortex lattices in a rotating Fermi mixture. Finally, superfluidity in imbalanced Fermi mixtures was established, and its Clogston limit was observed for high imbalance. The gas was found to separate into a region of equal densities, surrounded by a shell at unequal densities.
Cold atoms trapped in optical lattices (crystals of light) provide a pristine platform for exploring quantum many body physics. Motivated by several recent experiments, this thesis examines the equilibrium and non-equilibrium dynamics of a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) loaded in a low dimensional optical lattice in order to realize novel quantum phases. There are two main research directions in this thesis. The first one involves the possibility that exotic order spontaneously forms when two-component bosons are trapped in a honeycomb lattice. My studies on this theme is motivated by the observation of a “twisted superfluid” state in Prof. Klaus Sengstock’s group at Hamburg (Soltan-Panahi et al., Nat. Phys. 8, 71 (2012)). A twisted superfluid involves Bose-Einstein condensation into a state whose order parameter has a spatially varying phase. In chapter 3, I study the stability of a Bose-Einstein condensate towards forming a twisted superfluid within the framework of mean field theory. Despite a exhaustive numerical search I do not find a parameter regime with a twisted superfluid. This search involved all experimentally relevant parameter regimes and therefore mean field theory predicted that the experimentalists should not observe a twisted superfluid. I conclude that the experimental observations were either a manifestation of counter superfluidity or due to interactions during time-of-flight. Subsequent experiments showed that the observations were an artifact of the measurement process. The second research direction in this thesis is an exploration of the stability of periodically driven quantum systems (also known as Floquet systems). Floquet systems can be used to realize exotic non-equilibrium quantum phases which do not have a counterpart in static systems. However, the driving can cause these systems to heat up which presents a major obstacle to creating exotic states. To explore this issue in a concrete example, I model an experiment (Parker, Ha, and Chin, Nat. Phys. 9, 769 (2013)) where a Bose-Einstein condensate loaded in an optical lattice is subjected to periodic shaking. I investigate the stability of this Floquet BEC to interactions. This research direction consists of 3 studies. In chapter 4, I first do this analysis for a purely one-dimensional system and identify a large parameter regime where the BEC is stable. In the next two chapters, I go beyond 1D and consider the role of transverse degrees of freedom. This is because the shaken lattice experiments that I model involves a 1D array of pancakes. I find that this geometry leads to much more dissipation than a purely 1D system. This extra dissipation arises because interactions can transfer energy between different directions. In chapter 5, I consider the extreme case where there is no transverse confinement. I find that in the absence of transverse confinement, a one-dimensional Floquet BEC is generically unstable. Finally, in chapter 6, I consider harmonic transverse confinement modeling the crossover between chapters 4 and 5. I find that as the transverse confinement is made stronger, the atom loss rate initially increases, but beyond a critical transverse confinement, the atom loss disappears due to unavailability of phase space for scattering. I also predict that if the transverse confinement is tuned to the vicinity of certain magic values, the heating rate exhibits a sharp drop. I perform similar analyses for a shaken square lattice and find that generically a low-dimensional Floquet BEC can be stabilized by suitably designing the transverse confinement.
In this thesis, we discuss ultracold quantum gases both in continuum and optical lattices. For the continuum Fermi gases in BCS-BEC crossover, we present an effective field theory study on the recently discovered puzzling damping phenomena on the BCS side of the crossover. We find that in contrast to the previous proposed pair-breaking mechanism of damping, the damping process is due to the interaction between superfluid phonons and thermally excited fermionic quasi particles. Results from our effective field theory are compared quantitatively with experiments, showing a good agreement. For the ultracold fermionic atoms in optical lattices, we propose two novel quantum phases. Firstly, we show that a novel superconducting pairing occurs for spin-imbalanced Fermi gases with the spin up and down Fermi levels lying within the px- and s- orbital bands of a quasi-one-dimensional optical lattice. The pairs condense at a finite momentum equal to the sum of the two Fermi momenta of spin up and down fermions, and form a p-orbital condensate. The phase diagram shows that the p-orbital pair condensate occurs in a wide range of fillings. Secondly, we study instabilities of single-species fermionic atoms in the p-orbital bands in two-dimensional square optical lattices. From the nearly-perfect nesting Fermi surfaces, charge density wave and orbital density wave orderings with stripe or checkerboard patterns are found for attractive and repulsive interactions, respectively. The superconducting phase, usually expected of attractively interacting fermions, is strongly suppressed. We also use field theory to analyze the possible liquid crystal phases in our system. For bosons, we study ultracold bosonic atoms loaded in a one-dimensional optical lattice of two-fold p-orbital degeneracy at each site, and find an anti-ferro-orbital, a homogeneous px Mott insulator phase and two kinds of superfluid phases distinguished by the orbital ordering.