Traditionally, antenna systems have been designed to achieve reliable wireless communication, while the problem of securing that communication from eavesdropping was left to mathematical cryptography. Recent research into physical layer encryption shows that jointly designing for reliability and secrecy at the physical layer may be a better solution. Physical layer encryption involves techniques that ensure a signal is information-theoretically secure, meaning that an eavesdropper with infinite time and computational resources will not be able to decode a message. Such techniques include purposely broadcasting artificial noise, transmitting direction-dependent signals, and opportunistic communications. This work addresses different methods for broadcasting artificial noise using fixed arrays, including tradeoffs with power usage and computational complexity. In addition, a method of producing direction-dependent distortion using reconfigurable arrays is also shown. These two methods are combined and shown to be more secure and power-efficient than either in isolation. An analysis of secrecy rates through mutual information makes it possible to compare the performance of all the various secure communication techniques. Simulations with various wireless channels as well as an experimental test using a fixed and reconfigurable array are presented.
Traditionally, antenna systems have been designed to achieve reliable wireless communication, while the problem of securing that communication from eavesdropping was left to mathematical cryptography. Recent research into physical layer encryption shows that jointly designing for reliability and secrecy at the physical layer may be a better solution. Physical layer encryption involves techniques that ensure a signal is information-theoretically secure, meaning that an eavesdropper with infinite time and computational resources will not be able to decode a message. Such techniques include purposely broadcasting artificial noise, transmitting direction-dependent signals, and opportunistic communications. This work addresses different methods for broadcasting artificial noise using fixed arrays, including tradeoffs with power usage and computational complexity. In addition, a method of producing direction-dependent distortion using reconfigurable arrays is also shown. These two methods are combined and shown to be more secure and power-efficient than either in isolation. An analysis of secrecy rates through mutual information makes it possible to compare the performance of all the various secure communication techniques. Simulations with various wireless channels as well as an experimental test using a fixed and reconfigurable array are presented.
Wireless communications are naturally exposed to important security risks due to their broadcast nature. In contrast with wired communications, no physical medium is isolating the transmission surroundings to a specific path. Traditional methods to reach the goals of communications security rely on algorithms at protocol stack level, which are based on mathematically derived cryptographic protocols. With the tremendous proliferation of wireless devices, and the increase in computational power available for decryption, traditional cryptographic measures may be compromised. To protect communications at the lowest level, physical layer (PHY) security methods have been proposed recently. These techniques aim to ensure secure communications by exploiting the unique characteristics of the physical medium between communicating nodes, effectively reducing the decryption capabilities of an eavesdropper to intercept transmissions. This thesis explains within a general framework the most important PHY layer security schemes. First we explore approaches which utilize the knowledge of the unique channel between communicating nodes to distort a transmitted signal with various kinds of randomizations, in such a way that the intended receivers are unaffected by the distortion, but any other observer will be exposed to it. These techniques, however, introduce several trade-offs between transmission resources and the effectiveness in achieving secrecy. Of particular interest for this investigation is a class of methods which can be referred to as "security enhancing techniques", in which minimal priors about the potential eavesdroppers locations and capabilities are assumed. In this thesis, a wave-based approach to the communication secrecy problem is introduced. An interesting perspective is provided by studying the relation between electromagnetic theory and information theory, the so-called electromagnetic information theory. This allows to properly identify the unavoidable limitations imposed by the laws of electromagnetics to our ability to communicate securely. The proposed model can be extended to the analysis of different signal distortion methodologies and different channel conditions. The resulting approach is highly relevant to the study of PHY layer security methods since it is physically fundamental as well as architecture independent, which leads to a consolidating point of view of the secrecy problem. In addition, the thesis presents computer simulation results which shed insight on the security possibilities and limitations of three different security scenarios, which are termed MISO (multiple-input, single-output) (with single eavesdropper), MISOME (multiple-input, single-output, multiple eavesdropper), and MIMOME (multiple-input, multiple-output, multiple-eavesdropper).
Exploiting the randomness embedded in wireless channels, the physical-layer security techniques can provide additional security robustness against malicious eavesdropping at the physical layer of communication systems. To further this line of study, this thesis focuses on developing advanced multi-antenna transmission strategies for enhancing the secrecy performance of wireless communication systems. Assuming perfect channel feedback from the desired receiver and none from the eavesdropper, we consider beamforming with smartly injected artificial noise, aiming to confuse the eavesdropper whilst leaving the desired receiver unaffected. The system parameters are either chosen to be fixed for all transmissions, or adaptively adjusted based on the channel feedback from the desired receiver. For both cases, we provide novel and explicit design solutions for achieving the maximum throughput subject to a secrecy outage constraint. We then derive accurate approximations for the maximum throughput, and give new insights into the additional power cost for achieving a higher security level and the throughput gain of adaptive transmission over non-adaptive transmission. Having investigated the perfect feedback scenario, we then relax the feedback assumption and consider practical effects imposed by limited feedback constraints on the channel from the desired receiver to the transmitter. To deal with quantization error due to limited feedback whilst also accounting for unknown channel of the eavesdropper, we specify a connection outage constraint to guarantee the reliability of desired communication and a secrecy outage constraint to guard against malicious eavesdropping. Under dual outage constraints, we derive a novel optimized rate-adaptive transmission design to maximize the average secrecy throughput. New insights regarding the optimal power/feedback allocation and the number of feedback bits required for efficient quantization are obtained through our analysis. Our preceding study focused on isolated point-to-point transmission without any interference. However, the performance of contemporary wireless networks is often limited by interference from concurrent transmissions. To characterize the impact of interference on secure communication, we consider an interference-limited large-scale network. To confuse the malicious eavesdroppers, in addition to information-bearing signals, the transmitters are designed to generate artificial noise through either beamforming or antenna sectoring in a distributed manner. For both cases, using tools from stochastic geometry, we provide a statistical characterization of the reliability performance of desired communication and the secrecy performance against eavesdropping. We then investigate the networkwide secrecy throughput performance and optimize the transmit power allocation. Our analysis reveals interesting differences between the beamforming and sectoring approaches in terms of the optimal power allocation and the maximum networkwide secrecy throughput.
With the ever-growing demand for services that rely on transmission over wireless networks, a challenging issue is the security of the transmitted information. Due to its open nature, wireless communications is prone to eavesdropping attacks. Typically, secrecy of the transmitted information is ensured with the aid of cryptographic techniques, which are deployed on upper layers of the network protocol stack. However, due to the need for key distribution and management, cryptographic solutions are difficult to implement in decentralized networks. Moreover, the security provided by key based solutions is not provable from a mathematical point of view. Physical layer security is an alternative or complement to the cryptographic techniques, which can resolve the complexities associated with key distribution and management. The basic principle of physical layer security is to exploit the randomness of the communication channels to allow a transmitter deliver its message to an intended receiver reliably while guaranteeing that a third party cannot infer any information about it. Much of the existing research in physical layer security focuses on investigating the information theoretic limits of secure communications. Among different techniques proposed, multiple-antenna based solutions have been shown to exhibit a high potential for enhancing security. Furthermore, Gaussian inputs are proved to be the optimal input distributions in a variety of scenarios. However, due to the high detection complexity, Gaussian signaling is not used in practice, and the transmission is carried out with the aid of symbols drawn from standard signal constellations. In this thesis, we develop several secure multi-antenna transmission techniques under the practical finite-alphabet input assumption. We first consider multipleinput multiple-output (MIMO) wiretap channels under finite-alphabet input constraints. We assume that the statistical channel state information (CSI) of the eavesdropper is available at the transmitter, and study two different scenarios regarding the transmitter's knowledge on the main channel CSI (MCSI) including availability of perfect and statistical MCSI at the transmitter. In each scenario, we introduce iterative algorithms for joint optimization of data precoder and arti ficial noise. We also propose different strategies to reduce the computational complexity associated with the transmit signal design. Moreover, we consider the setups with simultaneous wireless information and power transfer (SWIPT), and propose transmission schemes for achieving the trade-off between the secrecy rate and the harvested power. We demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed transmit signal design algorithms via extensive numerical examples. We also introduce several secure transmission schemes with spatial modulation and space shift keying (SSK). We derive an expression for the achievable secrecy rate, and develop precoder optimization algorithms for its maximization using transmitter side CSI. Furthermore, we introduce a group of secure SSK transmission schemes, which rely on dynamic antenna index assignment over reciprocal channels. Our results reveal that the fundamentally different working principle of SSK opens up new avenues for secure multi-antenna transmission.
The thesis focuses on the privacy of communication that can be ensured by means of the physical layer, i.e., by appropriately chosen coding and resource allocation schemes. The fundamentals of physical-layer security have been already formulated in the 1970s by Wyner (1975), Csiszár and Körner (1978). But only nowadays we have the technical progress such that these ideas can find their way in current and future communication systems, which has driven the growing interest in this area of research in the last years. We analyze two physical-layer approaches that can ensure the secret transmission of private information in wireless systems in presence of an eavesdropper. One is the direct transmission of the information to the intended receiver, where the transmitter has to simultaneously ensure the reliability and the secrecy of the information. The other is a two-phase approach, where two legitimated users first agree on a common and secret key, which they use afterwards to encrypt the information before it is transmitted. In this case, the secrecy and the reliability of the transmission are managed separately in the two phases. The secrecy of the transmitted messages mainly depends on reliable information or reasonable and justifiable assumptions about the channel to the potential eavesdropper. Perfect state information about the channel to a passive eavesdropper is not a rational assumption. Thus, we introduce a deterministic model for the uncertainty about this channel, which yields a set of possible eavesdropper channels. We consider the optimization of worst-case rates in systems with multi-antenna Gaussian channels for both approaches. We study which transmit strategy can yield a maximum rate if we assume that the eavesdropper can always observe the corresponding worst-case channel that reduces the achievable rate for the secret transmission to a minimum. For both approaches, we show that the resulting max-min problem over the matrices that describe the multi-antenna system can be reduced to an equivalent problem over the eigenvalues of these matrices. We characterize the optimal resource allocation under a sum power constraint over all antennas and derive waterfilling solutions for the corresponding worst-case channel to the eavesdropper for a constraint on the sum of all channel gains. We show that all rates converge to finite limits for high signal-to-noise ratios (SNR), if we do not restrict the number of antennas for the eavesdropper. These limits are characterized by the quotients of the eigenvalues resulting from the Gramian matrices of both channels. For the low-SNR regime, we observe a rate increase that depends only on the differences of these eigenvalues for the direct-transmission approach. For the key generation approach, there exists no dependence from the eavesdropper channel in this regime. The comparison of both approaches shows that the superiority of an approach over the other mainly depends on the SNR and the quality of the eavesdropper channel. The direct-transmission approach is advantageous for low SNR and comparably bad eavesdropper channels, whereas the key generation approach benefits more from high SNR and comparably good eavesdropper channels. All results are discussed in combination with numerous illustrations.
Wireless broadcast allows widespread and easy information transfer. However, it may expose the information to unintended receivers, which could include eavesdroppers. As a solution, cryptography at the higher network levels has been used to encrypt and protect data. Cryptography relies on the fact that the computational power of the adversary is not enough to break the encryption. However, due to increasing computing power, the adversary power also increases. To further strengthen the security and complement the encryption, the concept of physical layer security has been introduced and surged an enormous amount of research. Widely speaking, the research in physical layer security can be divided into two directions: the information-theoretic and signal processing paradigms. This thesis starts with an overview of the physical layer security literature and continues with the contributions which are divided into the two following parts. In the first part, we investigate the information-theoretic secrecy rate. In the first scenario, we study the confidentiality of a bidirectional satellite network consisting of two mobile users who exchange two messages via a multibeam satellite using the XOR network coding protocol. We maximize the sum secrecy rate by designing the optimal beamforming vector along with optimizing the return and forward link time allocation. In the second scenario, we study the effect of interference on the secrecy rate. We investigate the secrecy rate in a two-user interference network where one of the users, namely user 1, requires to establish a confidential connection. User 1 wants to prevent an unintended user of the network to decode its transmission. User 1 has to adjust its transmission power such that its secrecy rate is maximized while the quality of service at the destination of the other user, user 2, is satisfied. We obtain closed-form solutions for optimal joint power control. In the third scenario, we study secrecy rate over power ratio, namely ``secrecy energy efficiency''. We design the optimal beamformer for a multiple-input single-output system with and without considering the minimum required secrecy rate at the destination. In the second part, we follow the signal processing paradigm to improve the security. We employ the directional modulation concept to enhance the security of a multi-user multiple-input multiple-output communication system in the presence of a multi-antenna eavesdropper. Enhancing the security is accomplished by increasing the symbol error rate at the eavesdropper without the eavesdropper's CSI. We show that when the eavesdropper has less antennas than the users, regardless of the received signal SNR, it cannot recover any useful information; in addition, it has to go through extra noise enhancing processes to estimate the symbols when it has more antennas than the users. Finally, we summarize the conclusions and discuss the promising research directions in the physical layer security.
As a complement to high-layer encryption techniques, physical layer security has been widely recognized as a promising way to enhance wireless security by exploiting the characteristics of wireless channels, including fading, noise, and interference. In order to enhance the received signal power at legitimate receivers and impair the received signal quality at eavesdroppers simultaneously, multiple-antenna techniques have been proposed for physical layer security to improve secrecy performance via exploiting spatial degrees of freedom. This paper provides a comprehensive survey on various multiple-antenna techniques in physical layer security, with an emphasis on transmit beamforming designs for multiple-antenna nodes. Specifically, we provide a detailed investigation on multiple-antenna techniques for guaranteeing secure communications in point-to-point systems, dual-hop relaying systems, multiuser systems, and heterogeneous networks. Finally, future research directions and challenges are identified.