Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Detection of Bohmian trajectories for mixed states

Alfredo Luis, Ángel S. Sanz

Published Nov 11, 2013• 2 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

it is shown that this assertion is in general incorrect, unless the context of the system is properly specified. To prove it, without loss of generality, a simple numerical implementation of Young’s paradigmatic two-slit experiment is considered, introducing some degree of incoherence between the two diffracted beams (the lack of interference here usually involves a classical interpretation in terms of path or which-way knowledge). The analysis is carried out with the aid of Bohmian mechanics, more suitable for this task than other conventional pictures of quantum mechanics due to the nonlinearity of its guidance equation. It is found that strong nonlocal quantum signatures still persist even under conditions of maximal mixedness, this being related to the fact that mixed states contain relevant contextual information from a dynamical viewpoint. A simple, realistic experiment based on the use of the weak-measurement technique is proposed to test this puzzling behavior, which would bring in important consequences concerning our understanding of mixed states and the concept of classicality.

Related papers

Experimental nonlocal steering of Bohmian trajectories

Ya Xiao, Yaron Kedem, Jin‐Shi Xu +2 more

Interpretations of quantum mechanics (QM), or proposals for underlying theories, that attempt to present a definite realist picture, such as Bohmian mechanics, require strong non-local effects. Naively, these effects would violate causality and contradict special relativity. However if the theory agrees with QM the violation cannot be observed directly. Here, we demonstrate experimentally such an effect: we steer the velocity and trajectory of a Bohmian particle using a remote measurement. We use a pair of photons and entangle the spatial transverse position of one with the polarization of the other. The first photon is sent to a double-slit-like apparatus, where its trajectory is measured using the technique of Weak Measurements. The other photon is projected to a linear polarization state. The choice of polarization state, and the result, steer the first photon in the most intuitive sense of the word. The effect is indeed shown to be dramatic, while being easy to visualize. We discuss its strength and what are the conditions for it to occur.

arXiv:1706.05757•Optics Express•Jun 16, 2017•29 citations

Exploring the nonclassical dynamics of the “classical” Schrödinger equation

David Navia, Ángel S. Sanz

The introduction of nonlinearities in the Schrödinger equation has been considered in the literature as an effective manner to describe the action of external environments or mean fields. Here, in particular, we explore the nonlinear effects induced by subtracting a term proportional to Bohm’s quantum potential to the usual (linear) Schrödinger equation, which generates the so-called “classical” Schrödinger equation. Although a simple nonlinear transformation allows us to recover the well-known classical Hamilton–Jacobi equation, by combining a series of analytical results (in the limiting cases) and simulations (whenever the analytical treatment is unaffordable), we find an analytical explanation to why the dynamics in the nonlinear “classical” regime is still strongly nonclassical. This is even more evident by establishing a one-to-one comparison between the Bohmian trajectories associated with the corresponding wave function and the classical trajectories that one should obtain. Based on these observations, it is clear that the transition to a fully classical regime requires extra conditions in order to remove any trace of coherence, which is the truly distinctive trait of quantum mechanics. This behavior is investigated in three paradigmatic cases, namely, the dispersion of a free propagating localized particle, the harmonic oscillator, and a simplified version of Young’s two-slit experiment.

arXiv:2312.02977•Annals of Physics•Mar 4, 2024•7 citations

Bohmian analysis of momentum transfer inwelcher Wegmeasurements

Howard M. Wiseman

Whether the loss of visibility due to measurement in two-slit interference patterns can always be attributed to momentum transfer depends upon how one defines the last term. The momentum transfer to a quantum particle can be determined unambiguously if it was initially in a momentum eigenstate, but that is not the state relevant to a two-slit experiment. A sensible answer for the two-slit problem was obtained by Wiseman et al. [Phys. Rev. A 56, 944 (1997)] using the formalism of the Wigner function. Here I show that a more general answer can be obtained using the Bohmian formulation of quantum mechanics, in which particles have a definite position and momentum at all times. By following all possible trajectories of the particle it is possible to calculate the probability distribution ${P}_{\mathrm{total}}^{B}{(p}^{\ensuremath{'}})$ for it to receive a momentum transfer ${p}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ as a result of the measurement. Furthermore, the 1-norm of this distribution obeys the relation $〈|{p}^{\ensuremath{'}}|{〉}_{\mathrm{total}}^{B}d>~2\ensuremath{\Elzxh}(1\ensuremath{-}V)/\ensuremath{\pi},$ where $V$ is the visibility of the interference pattern and $d$ is the slit separation. This confirms that the momentum transfer in a welcher Weg (which path) experiment is in accord with the uncertainty principle. Like the Wignerian analysis, the Bohmian analysis clearly distinguishes between a local momentum transfer (which occurs even if the particle is localized at a single slit) and a nonlocal momentum transfer (which occurs only if the particle is delocalized, at both slits). In the Bohmian analysis the former occurs at the time of the measurement, while the latter occurs after the measurement, and is a consequence of Bohm's ``quantum potential.''

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1998•19 citations

Quantum Interference, Hidden Symmetries: Theory and Experimental Facts

Ángel S. Sanz

The concept of quantum superposition is reconsidered and discussed from the viewpoint of Bohmian mechanics, the hydrodynamic formulation of quantum mechanics, in order to elucidate some physical consequences that go beyond the simple mathematical idea of linearly combining vectors in a Hilbert space. Specifically, the discussion turns around the connection between symmetries characterizing the wave function and the behavior in time displayed by the quantum flux when the latter is analyzed in terms of streamlines (Bohmian trajectories). This is illustrated with a series of analytical results and numerical simulations, which include Young's two-slit experiment, counter-propagating wave packets, grating diffiraction and quantum carpets (e.g., Talbot carpets), and diffiraction under confinement conditions. From the analysis presented it follows that quantum paradoxes appear whenever symmetries related to interference are neglected in the interpretation and understanding of the corresponding phenomena.

arXiv:1712.03702•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Aug 1, 2018•0 citations

Observing the Weak Value through Quantum Interference

森, 琢也

In quantum mechanics, it is well known that counterfactual arguments sometimes lead to paradoxes, which implies that our classical intuition is not always reliable.However, it has been pointed out by several authors that the weak value, which was introduced by Aharonov et al. in 1988, may be useful to comprehend quantum mechanics intuitively.Another extraordinary aspect of the weak value is its amplification, which has been exploited for precision measurement.Nevertheless, the physical meaning of the weak value is still obscure due to its complexity of the value and the very fact of the amplification.In this thesis, by considering various situations of quantum interference, we attempt to provide a possible interpretation of the weak value.We find, on one hand, that the imaginary part of the weak value is relevant to the wave nature.On the other hand, in the double-slit experiment the particle nature can be seen in the real part of the position weak value.This property for the real part does not hold for more general cases such as the multiple (more than two) slit experiment.The position weak value, nevertheless, can be interpreted as the average of the classical trajectories based on a complex probability.We also investigate the possibility of knowing which path the particle takes in the multiple-slit experiment without destroying the interference fringes.We show that, because of the statistical nature of the weak value, obtaining the which-path information and the interference pattern is compatible with complementarity.Our study suggests that the weak value is a reasonable physical quantity.

•Mar 24, 2015•0 citations

Particles, waves and trajectories: 210 years after Young's experiment

Ángel S. Sanz

Mermin's "shut up and calculate!" somehow summarizes the most widely accepted view on quantum mechanics. This conception has led to a rather constraining way to think and understand the quantum world. Nonetheless, a closer look at the principles and formal body of this theory shows that, beyond longstanding prejudices, there is still room enough for alternative tools. This is the case, for example, of Bohmian mechanics. As it is discussed here, there is nothing contradictory or wrong with this hydrodynamical representation, which enhances the dynamical role of the quantum phase to the detriment (to some extent) of the probability density. The possibility to describe the evolution of quantum systems in terms of trajectories or streamlines is just a direct consequence of the fact that Bohmian mechanics (quantum hydrodynamics) is just a way to recast quantum mechanics in the more general language of the theory of characteristics. Misconceptions concerning Bohmian mechanics typically come from the fact that many times it is taken out of context and considered as an alternative theory to quantum mechanics, which is not the case. On the contrary, an appropriate contextualization shows that Bohmian mechanics constitutes a serious and useful representation of quantum mechanics, at the same level as any other quantum picture, such as Schrödinger's, Heisenberg's, Dirac's, or Feynman's, for instance. To illustrate its versatility, two phenomena will be briefly considered, namely dissipation and light interference.

arXiv:1402.3877•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Apr 14, 2014•6 citations
it is shown that this assertion is in general incorrect, unless the context of the system is properly specified. To prove it, without loss of generality, a simple numerical implementation of Young’s paradigmatic two-slit experiment is considered, introducing some degree of incoherence between the two diffracted beams (the lack of interference here usually involves a classical interpretation in terms of path or which-way knowledge). The analysis is carried out with the aid of Bohmian mechanics, more suitable for this task than other conventional pictures of quantum mechanics due to the nonlinearity of its guidance equation. It is found that strong nonlocal quantum signatures still persist even under conditions of maximal mixedness, this being related to the fact that mixed states contain relevant contextual information from a dynamical viewpoint. A simple, realistic experiment based on the use of the weak-measurement technique is proposed to test this puzzling behavior, which would bring in important consequences concerning our understanding of mixed states and the concept of classicality.
Interpretations of quantum mechanics (QM), or proposals for underlying theories, that attempt to present a definite realist picture, such as Bohmian mechanics, require strong non-local effects. Naively, these effects would violate causality and contradict special relativity. However if the theory agrees with QM the violation cannot be observed directly. Here, we demonstrate experimentally such an effect: we steer the velocity and trajectory of a Bohmian particle using a remote measurement. We use a pair of photons and entangle the spatial transverse position of one with the polarization of the other. The first photon is sent to a double-slit-like apparatus, where its trajectory is measured using the technique of Weak Measurements. The other photon is projected to a linear polarization state. The choice of polarization state, and the result, steer the first photon in the most intuitive sense of the word. The effect is indeed shown to be dramatic, while being easy to visualize. We discuss its strength and what are the conditions for it to occur.
The introduction of nonlinearities in the Schrödinger equation has been considered in the literature as an effective manner to describe the action of external environments or mean fields. Here, in particular, we explore the nonlinear effects induced by subtracting a term proportional to Bohm’s quantum potential to the usual (linear) Schrödinger equation, which generates the so-called “classical” Schrödinger equation. Although a simple nonlinear transformation allows us to recover the well-known classical Hamilton–Jacobi equation, by combining a series of analytical results (in the limiting cases) and simulations (whenever the analytical treatment is unaffordable), we find an analytical explanation to why the dynamics in the nonlinear “classical” regime is still strongly nonclassical. This is even more evident by establishing a one-to-one comparison between the Bohmian trajectories associated with the corresponding wave function and the classical trajectories that one should obtain. Based on these observations, it is clear that the transition to a fully classical regime requires extra conditions in order to remove any trace of coherence, which is the truly distinctive trait of quantum mechanics. This behavior is investigated in three paradigmatic cases, namely, the dispersion of a free propagating localized particle, the harmonic oscillator, and a simplified version of Young’s two-slit experiment.
Whether the loss of visibility due to measurement in two-slit interference patterns can always be attributed to momentum transfer depends upon how one defines the last term. The momentum transfer to a quantum particle can be determined unambiguously if it was initially in a momentum eigenstate, but that is not the state relevant to a two-slit experiment. A sensible answer for the two-slit problem was obtained by Wiseman et al. [Phys. Rev. A 56, 944 (1997)] using the formalism of the Wigner function. Here I show that a more general answer can be obtained using the Bohmian formulation of quantum mechanics, in which particles have a definite position and momentum at all times. By following all possible trajectories of the particle it is possible to calculate the probability distribution ${P}_{\mathrm{total}}^{B}{(p}^{\ensuremath{'}})$ for it to receive a momentum transfer ${p}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ as a result of the measurement. Furthermore, the 1-norm of this distribution obeys the relation $〈|{p}^{\ensuremath{'}}|{〉}_{\mathrm{total}}^{B}d>~2\ensuremath{\Elzxh}(1\ensuremath{-}V)/\ensuremath{\pi},$ where VVV is the visibility of the interference pattern and ddd is the slit separation. This confirms that the momentum transfer in a welcher Weg (which path) experiment is in accord with the uncertainty principle. Like the Wignerian analysis, the Bohmian analysis clearly distinguishes between a local momentum transfer (which occurs even if the particle is localized at a single slit) and a nonlocal momentum transfer (which occurs only if the particle is delocalized, at both slits). In the Bohmian analysis the former occurs at the time of the measurement, while the latter occurs after the measurement, and is a consequence of Bohm's ``quantum potential.''
The concept of quantum superposition is reconsidered and discussed from the viewpoint of Bohmian mechanics, the hydrodynamic formulation of quantum mechanics, in order to elucidate some physical consequences that go beyond the simple mathematical idea of linearly combining vectors in a Hilbert space. Specifically, the discussion turns around the connection between symmetries characterizing the wave function and the behavior in time displayed by the quantum flux when the latter is analyzed in terms of streamlines (Bohmian trajectories). This is illustrated with a series of analytical results and numerical simulations, which include Young's two-slit experiment, counter-propagating wave packets, grating diffiraction and quantum carpets (e.g., Talbot carpets), and diffiraction under confinement conditions. From the analysis presented it follows that quantum paradoxes appear whenever symmetries related to interference are neglected in the interpretation and understanding of the corresponding phenomena.
In quantum mechanics, it is well known that counterfactual arguments sometimes lead to paradoxes, which implies that our classical intuition is not always reliable.However, it has been pointed out by several authors that the weak value, which was introduced by Aharonov et al. in 1988, may be useful to comprehend quantum mechanics intuitively.Another extraordinary aspect of the weak value is its amplification, which has been exploited for precision measurement.Nevertheless, the physical meaning of the weak value is still obscure due to its complexity of the value and the very fact of the amplification.In this thesis, by considering various situations of quantum interference, we attempt to provide a possible interpretation of the weak value.We find, on one hand, that the imaginary part of the weak value is relevant to the wave nature.On the other hand, in the double-slit experiment the particle nature can be seen in the real part of the position weak value.This property for the real part does not hold for more general cases such as the multiple (more than two) slit experiment.The position weak value, nevertheless, can be interpreted as the average of the classical trajectories based on a complex probability.We also investigate the possibility of knowing which path the particle takes in the multiple-slit experiment without destroying the interference fringes.We show that, because of the statistical nature of the weak value, obtaining the which-path information and the interference pattern is compatible with complementarity.Our study suggests that the weak value is a reasonable physical quantity.
Mermin's "shut up and calculate!" somehow summarizes the most widely accepted view on quantum mechanics. This conception has led to a rather constraining way to think and understand the quantum world. Nonetheless, a closer look at the principles and formal body of this theory shows that, beyond longstanding prejudices, there is still room enough for alternative tools. This is the case, for example, of Bohmian mechanics. As it is discussed here, there is nothing contradictory or wrong with this hydrodynamical representation, which enhances the dynamical role of the quantum phase to the detriment (to some extent) of the probability density. The possibility to describe the evolution of quantum systems in terms of trajectories or streamlines is just a direct consequence of the fact that Bohmian mechanics (quantum hydrodynamics) is just a way to recast quantum mechanics in the more general language of the theory of characteristics. Misconceptions concerning Bohmian mechanics typically come from the fact that many times it is taken out of context and considered as an alternative theory to quantum mechanics, which is not the case. On the contrary, an appropriate contextualization shows that Bohmian mechanics constitutes a serious and useful representation of quantum mechanics, at the same level as any other quantum picture, such as Schrödinger's, Heisenberg's, Dirac's, or Feynman's, for instance. To illustrate its versatility, two phenomena will be briefly considered, namely dissipation and light interference.