Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

AIP conference proceedings

Arrival time and backflow effect

Gebhard Grübl

Published Jan 1, 2006• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We contrast the average arrival time at x according to the Bohmian mechanics of one dimensional free Schrödinger evolution with the standard quantum mechanical one. For positive momentum wave functions the first cannot be larger than the second one. Equality holds if and only if the wave function does not lead to position probability backflow through x. This position probability backflow has the least upper bound of approximately 0.04. We describe a numerical method to determine this backflow constant, introduced by Bracken and Melloy, more precisely and we illustrate the approximate wave function of maximal backflow.

DOI
10.1063/1.2219361

Related papers

Times of arrival: Bohm beats Kijowski

M Ruggenthaler, G Grübl, S Kreidl

We prove that the Bohmian arrival time of the one-dimensional Schrödinger evolution violates the quadratic form structure on which Kijowski's axiomatic treatment of arrival times is based. Within Kijowski's framework, for a free right moving wave packet Ψ, the various notions of arrival time (at a fixed point x on the real line) all yield the same average arrival time . We derive the inequality relating the average Bohmian arrival time to that of Kijowksi. We prove that if and only if Ψ leads to position probability backflow through x .

arXiv:quant-ph/0504185•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Sep 14, 2005•15 citations

A new approach to quantum backflow

Markus Penz, Gebhard Grübl, Sabine Kreidl +1 more

We derive some rigorous results concerning the backflow operator introduced by Bracken and Melloy. We show that it is linear bounded, self adjoint, and not compact. Thus the question is underlined whether the backflow constant is an eigenvalue of the backflow operator. From the position representation of the backflow operator we obtain a more efficient method to determine the backflow constant. Finally, detailed position probability flow properties of a numerical approximation to the (perhaps improper) wave function of maximal backflow are displayed.

arXiv:quant-ph/0511109•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Dec 14, 2005•54 citations

Time of arrival in quantum and Bohmian mechanics

C. Richard Leavens

In a recent paper Grot, Rovelli, and Tate (GRT) [Phys. Rev. A 54, 4676 (1996)] derived an expression for the probability distribution $\ensuremath{\pi}(T;X)$ of intrinsic arrival times $T(X)$ at position $x=X$ for a quantum particle with initial wave function $\ensuremath{\psi}(x,t=0)$ freely evolving in one dimension. This was done by quantizing the classical expression for the time of arrival of a free particle at $X,$ assuming a particular choice of operator ordering, and then regulating the resulting time of arrival operator. For the special case of a minimum-uncertainty-product wave packet at $t=0$ with average wave number $〈k〉$ and variance $\ensuremath{\Delta}k$ they showed that their analytical expression for $\ensuremath{\pi}(T;X)$ agreed with the probability current density $J(x=X,t=T)$ only to terms of order $\ensuremath{\Delta}k/〈k〉.$ They dismissed the probability current density as a viable candidate for the exact arrival time distribution on the grounds that it can sometimes be negative. This fact is not a problem within Bohmian mechanics where the arrival time distribution for a particle, either free or in the presence of a potential, is rigorously given by $|J(X,T)|$ (suitably normalized) [W. R. McKinnon and C. R. Leavens, Phys. Rev. A 51, 2748 (1995); C. R. Leavens, Phys. Lett. A 178, 27 (1993); M. Daumer et al., in On Three Levels: The Mathematical Physics of Micro-, Meso-, and Macro-Approaches to Physics, edited by M. Fannes et al. (Plenum, New York, 1994); M. Daumer, in Bohmian Mechanics and Quantum Theory: An Appraisal, edited by J. T. Cushing et al. (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 1996)]. The two theories are compared in this paper and a case presented for which the results could not differ more: According to GRT's theory, every particle in the ensemble reaches a point $x=X,$ where $\ensuremath{\psi}(x,t)$ and $J(x,t)$ are both zero for all $t,$ while no particle ever reaches $X$ according to the theory based on Bohmian mechanics. Some possible implications are discussed.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1998•91 citations

An introduction to the quantum backflow effect

James M. Yearsley, J. J. Halliwell

We present an introduction to the backflow effect in quantum mechanics – the phenomenon in which a state consisting entirely of positive momenta may have negative current and the probability flows in the opposite direction to the momentum. We show that the effect is present even for simple states consisting of superpositions of gaussian wave packets, although the size of the effect is small. Inspired by the numerical results of Penz et al, we present a wave function whose current at any time may be computed analytically and which has periods of significant backflow, with a backwards flux equal to about 70 percent of the maximum possible backflow, a dimensionless number c bm ≈ 0.04, discovered by Bracken and Melloy. This number has the unusual property of being independent of ℏ (and also of all other parameters of the model), despite corresponding to a quantum-mechanical effect, and we shed some light on this surprising property by considering the classical limit of backflow. We conclude by discussing a specific measurement model in which backflow may be identified in certain measurable probabilities.

arXiv:1301.4893•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 10, 2013•33 citations

The Quantum Backflow Phenomenon

Harkan J. Kirk-Karakaya

It has been known since at least 1969, that there exist quantum states of a free particle on the line with purely positive momentum that exhibit probability transfer towards the negative half-line. This phenomenon, the quantum backflow effect, is the subject of this thesis. The largest amount of backflow any state can exhibit over a single time interval, the Bracken–Melloy constant, was initially calculated to be cBM ≈ 0.04. In the first half of this thesis, we consider the question of how much quantum backflow states can exhibit over disjoint time intervals. This is done by formulating the question in terms of the spectra of bounded operators. When considering more than one disjoint time interval, we discuss a new phenomenon where a state exhibits more probability transfer in the same direction as its momentum than any classical state. We call this effect quantum overflow. Given a number M of disjoint time intervals, we give bounds on the maximum amount of backflow and overflow a state can exhibit over any M many intervals. The limiting cases in which two disjoint intervals merge into one is particularly studied. Finally, we show plots of the time t = 0 momentum space wavefunction of states exhibiting multiple quantum backflow and quantum overflow. The second half of the thesis contains a detailed numerical investigation into the single backflow problem. Based on previous conjectures, we construct the maximum backflow state from a given set of normalised states closely resembling the sinc function. The Bracken—Melloy constant is then bounded from below by the largest solution to a generalised eigenvalue problem. Using a multi-step numerical procedure, we solve a high precision large dense generalised eigenvalue problem. From this we obtain new numerical approximation to the backflow state and the best known rigorous lower bound of the Bracken—Melloy constant.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Analytical examples, measurement models, and classical limit of quantum backflow

James M. Yearsley, J. J. Halliwell, R. Hartshorn +1 more

We investigate the backflow effect in elementary quantum mechanics---the phenomenon in which a state consisting entirely of positive momenta may have negative current and the probability flows in the opposite direction to the momentum. We compute the current and flux for states consisting of superpositions of Gaussian wave packets. These are experimentally realizable but the amount of backflow is small. Inspired by the numerical results of Penz et al. [Penz, Gr\"ubl, Kreidl, and Wagner, J. Phys. A 39, 423 (2006)], we find two nontrivial wave functions whose current at any time may be computed analytically and which have periods of significant backflow, in one case with a backward flux equal to about 70$%$ of the maximum possible backflow, a dimensionless number ${c}_{bm}\ensuremath{\approx}0.04$, discovered by Bracken and Melloy [Bracken and Melloy, J. Phys. A 27, 2197 (1994)]. This number has the unusual property of being independent of $\ensuremath{\hbar}$ (and also of all other parameters of the model), despite corresponding to an obviously quantum-mechanical effect, and we shed some light on this surprising property by considering the classical limit of backflow. We discuss some specific measurement models in which backflow may be identified in certain measurable probabilities.

arXiv:1202.1783•Physical Review A•Oct 15, 2012•44 citations
We contrast the average arrival time at x according to the Bohmian mechanics of one dimensional free Schrödinger evolution with the standard quantum mechanical one. For positive momentum wave functions the first cannot be larger than the second one. Equality holds if and only if the wave function does not lead to position probability backflow through x. This position probability backflow has the least upper bound of approximately 0.04. We describe a numerical method to determine this backflow constant, introduced by Bracken and Melloy, more precisely and we illustrate the approximate wave function of maximal backflow.
We prove that the Bohmian arrival time of the one-dimensional Schrödinger evolution violates the quadratic form structure on which Kijowski's axiomatic treatment of arrival times is based. Within Kijowski's framework, for a free right moving wave packet Ψ, the various notions of arrival time (at a fixed point x on the real line) all yield the same average arrival time . We derive the inequality relating the average Bohmian arrival time to that of Kijowksi. We prove that if and only if Ψ leads to position probability backflow through x .
We derive some rigorous results concerning the backflow operator introduced by Bracken and Melloy. We show that it is linear bounded, self adjoint, and not compact. Thus the question is underlined whether the backflow constant is an eigenvalue of the backflow operator. From the position representation of the backflow operator we obtain a more efficient method to determine the backflow constant. Finally, detailed position probability flow properties of a numerical approximation to the (perhaps improper) wave function of maximal backflow are displayed.
In a recent paper Grot, Rovelli, and Tate (GRT) [Phys. Rev. A 54, 4676 (1996)] derived an expression for the probability distribution $\ensuremath{\pi}(T;X)$ of intrinsic arrival times T(X)T(X)T(X) at position x=Xx=Xx=X for a quantum particle with initial wave function $\ensuremath{\psi}(x,t=0)$ freely evolving in one dimension. This was done by quantizing the classical expression for the time of arrival of a free particle at X,X,X, assuming a particular choice of operator ordering, and then regulating the resulting time of arrival operator. For the special case of a minimum-uncertainty-product wave packet at t=0t=0t=0 with average wave number 〈k〉〈k〉〈k〉 and variance $\ensuremath{\Delta}k$ they showed that their analytical expression for $\ensuremath{\pi}(T;X)$ agreed with the probability current density J(x=X,t=T)J(x=X,t=T)J(x=X,t=T) only to terms of order $\ensuremath{\Delta}k/〈k〉.$ They dismissed the probability current density as a viable candidate for the exact arrival time distribution on the grounds that it can sometimes be negative. This fact is not a problem within Bohmian mechanics where the arrival time distribution for a particle, either free or in the presence of a potential, is rigorously given by ∣J(X,T)∣|J(X,T)|∣J(X,T)∣ (suitably normalized) [W. R. McKinnon and C. R. Leavens, Phys. Rev. A 51, 2748 (1995); C. R. Leavens, Phys. Lett. A 178, 27 (1993); M. Daumer et al., in On Three Levels: The Mathematical Physics of Micro-, Meso-, and Macro-Approaches to Physics, edited by M. Fannes et al. (Plenum, New York, 1994); M. Daumer, in Bohmian Mechanics and Quantum Theory: An Appraisal, edited by J. T. Cushing et al. (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 1996)]. The two theories are compared in this paper and a case presented for which the results could not differ more: According to GRT's theory, every particle in the ensemble reaches a point x=X,x=X,x=X, where $\ensuremath{\psi}(x,t)$ and J(x,t)J(x,t)J(x,t) are both zero for all t,t,t, while no particle ever reaches XXX according to the theory based on Bohmian mechanics. Some possible implications are discussed.
We present an introduction to the backflow effect in quantum mechanics – the phenomenon in which a state consisting entirely of positive momenta may have negative current and the probability flows in the opposite direction to the momentum. We show that the effect is present even for simple states consisting of superpositions of gaussian wave packets, although the size of the effect is small. Inspired by the numerical results of Penz et al, we present a wave function whose current at any time may be computed analytically and which has periods of significant backflow, with a backwards flux equal to about 70 percent of the maximum possible backflow, a dimensionless number c bm ≈ 0.04, discovered by Bracken and Melloy. This number has the unusual property of being independent of ℏ (and also of all other parameters of the model), despite corresponding to a quantum-mechanical effect, and we shed some light on this surprising property by considering the classical limit of backflow. We conclude by discussing a specific measurement model in which backflow may be identified in certain measurable probabilities.
It has been known since at least 1969, that there exist quantum states of a free particle on the line with purely positive momentum that exhibit probability transfer towards the negative half-line. This phenomenon, the quantum backflow effect, is the subject of this thesis. The largest amount of backflow any state can exhibit over a single time interval, the Bracken–Melloy constant, was initially calculated to be cBM ≈ 0.04. In the first half of this thesis, we consider the question of how much quantum backflow states can exhibit over disjoint time intervals. This is done by formulating the question in terms of the spectra of bounded operators. When considering more than one disjoint time interval, we discuss a new phenomenon where a state exhibits more probability transfer in the same direction as its momentum than any classical state. We call this effect quantum overflow. Given a number M of disjoint time intervals, we give bounds on the maximum amount of backflow and overflow a state can exhibit over any M many intervals. The limiting cases in which two disjoint intervals merge into one is particularly studied. Finally, we show plots of the time t = 0 momentum space wavefunction of states exhibiting multiple quantum backflow and quantum overflow. The second half of the thesis contains a detailed numerical investigation into the single backflow problem. Based on previous conjectures, we construct the maximum backflow state from a given set of normalised states closely resembling the sinc function. The Bracken—Melloy constant is then bounded from below by the largest solution to a generalised eigenvalue problem. Using a multi-step numerical procedure, we solve a high precision large dense generalised eigenvalue problem. From this we obtain new numerical approximation to the backflow state and the best known rigorous lower bound of the Bracken—Melloy constant.
We investigate the backflow effect in elementary quantum mechanics---the phenomenon in which a state consisting entirely of positive momenta may have negative current and the probability flows in the opposite direction to the momentum. We compute the current and flux for states consisting of superpositions of Gaussian wave packets. These are experimentally realizable but the amount of backflow is small. Inspired by the numerical results of Penz et al. [Penz, Gr\"ubl, Kreidl, and Wagner, J. Phys. A 39, 423 (2006)], we find two nontrivial wave functions whose current at any time may be computed analytically and which have periods of significant backflow, in one case with a backward flux equal to about 70% of the maximum possible backflow, a dimensionless number ${c}_{bm}\ensuremath{\approx}0.04$, discovered by Bracken and Melloy [Bracken and Melloy, J. Phys. A 27, 2197 (1994)]. This number has the unusual property of being independent of $\ensuremath{\hbar}$ (and also of all other parameters of the model), despite corresponding to an obviously quantum-mechanical effect, and we shed some light on this surprising property by considering the classical limit of backflow. We discuss some specific measurement models in which backflow may be identified in certain measurable probabilities.