Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Observation of Superradiant and Subradiant Spontaneous Emission of Two Trapped Ions

Ralph G. DeVoe, Richard G. Brewer

Published Mar 18, 1996• 485 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We report the first observation of a microscopically resolved interaction between two trapped atoms. This is also the first observation of two-ion superradiance and subradiance, the most elementary example of Dicke's theory. Its signature is the variation of the spontaneous emission decay rate of a laser-cooled two-ion crystal, $+1.5%$ and $\ensuremath{-}1.2%$, as the ion-ion distance is changed from 1380 to 1540 nm, in agreement with a no-free-parameter theory. The experiment uses an ion microtrap (80 \ensuremath{\mu}m radius) with planar electrodes and a new few-atom technique for measuring lifetimes.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.76.2049

Related papers

Search for superradiance of two trapped ions

Ralph G. DeVoe, Richard G. Brewer

Laser-cooled trapped ion crystals offer a unique opportunity to study the interactions between atoms. We have previously developed a microscopic planar Paul trap1 which is small and strong enough to bring the ion separation into the sub-micron region where quantum collective effects become important. A search is underway for the superradiant coupling of two atoms which manifests itself as a variation of the spontaneous emission rate with the ion-ion distance. We have produced an ion crystal with a separation of 1.1 microns in an 80 micron radius planar Paul trap. At this distance, equal to 2.2 wavelengths of the 493 nm Ba + transition, superradiant effects should alter the decay rate by about 10%. The two-ion crystal is imaged with sub-micron resolution by a new diffraction-limited vacuum-compatible microscope. The spontaneous emission rate is measured by a high repetition-rate transient spectrometer with an error of less than 1% for a single ion in a few minutes. Efficient extinction of the exciting laser light is provided by a new nonlinear electrooptic sideband switch.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1993•0 citations

Coherent interactions of two trapped ions

Ralph G. DeVoe

Advances in laser cooling and trapping have made possible a new kind of microscopic atomic physics experiment in which each atom is detected individually and in which the interatomic distances are known and controlled on a sub-micron scale. This chapter shows that the triplet and singlet states represent states in which the dipole moments of the two atoms are either correlated or anticorrelated. Since the two atoms’ wave-functions are identical, so are all their physical observables, including the dipole moments. The chapter describes the theory of superradiant and subradiant spontaneous emission in sufficient detail to understand current experiments. An experiment will in general prepare a partially coherent state described by a density matrix. The chapter discusses a simple physical picture of singlet and triplet states in both wave function and density matrix approaches. It also describes a classical model of the decay rate oscillations, and also shows how the experimental signal depends on the excitation conditions.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 12, 2020•0 citations

Two-ion superradiance theory

Richard G. Brewer

A superradiance theory is developed for two identical hydrogenic ions (four states each) in a microtrap, as in recent experiments. The ions oscillate (micromotion) due to the trap's radio frequency (rf) electric quadrupole field. One signature of superradiance is a deviation of the two-ion average upper state decay rate \ensuremath{\gamma}\ifmmode\bar\else\textasciimacron\fi{} from the one-ion value \ensuremath{\gamma}. A master equation is derived, giving a fractional change in the upper state lifetime \ensuremath{\gamma}/\ensuremath{\gamma}\ifmmode\bar\else\textasciimacron\fi{}-1=sinkR/2kR [${\mathit{J}}_{0}^{2}$(z)-2${\mathit{J}}_{1}^{2}$(z)+...]cos\ensuremath{\Phi}, where k=2\ensuremath{\pi}/\ensuremath{\lambda}, \ensuremath{\lambda} is the emission wavelength, R is the ion-ion distance, ${\mathit{J}}_{\mathit{n}}$(z) is a Bessel function of integer order n, and z=ka, a is the ion amplitude of motion, and \ensuremath{\Phi} is the two-ion relative phase due to the preparation. In the Lamb-Dicke regime, a, ${\mathit{J}}_{0}^{2}$(z)\ensuremath{\approxeq}1 and thus superradiance is not influenced significantly by ion motion. This damped sinusoid is diluted by the factor of 1/2 due to destructive interference. Superradiance vanishes in the absence of coherent preparation, e.g., with inversion, as indicated by the time evolution of the two-ion dipole correlation function. Fringes and a beat at the rf are predicted in forward scattering, the most elementary form of optical free induction decay.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1995•24 citations

Two-Ion Interference: Bragg Scattering and Superradiance

Richard G. Brewer

Bragg scattering and superradiance, always considered independently, are examined jointly for the case of two trapped ions. The two phenomena are seen to be different representations of the same basic two-ion interference resulting from a common coherent optical preparation. Solutions of a master equation for two four-level atoms show that fringes (spatial interference) and a variation of the spontaneous emission lifetime with ion-ion distance (temporal interference) can occur either simultaneously or separately. Unlike a classical calculation, not all scatterings result in interference, a quantum effect not considered in interpreting recent experiments.

Physical Review Letters•Dec 23, 1996•14 citations

Superradiance and subradiance. III. Small samples

A. Crubellier

For pt.II see ibid., vol.19, p.2109 (1986). This paper is the third in a theoretical study of subradiance, i.e. the cooperative inhibition of spontaneous emission by a destructive interatomic interference, a phenomenon which has recently been observed. The paper is devoted to the problem of the cooperative spontaneous emission of atomic samples with linear dimensions much smaller than the wavelength of the emitted light. The treatment, which is based on a fully quantum mechanical description of the problem, corroborates the results obtained in a semiclassical treatment by Friedberg and Hartmann (1974). Starting from a master equation describing both the cooperative spontaneous emission and the dipole-dipole interaction, a statistical treatment of the latter is introduced and the corresponding symmetry relaxation is studied. The evolution of the atoms is described in three typical cases that correspond to different sample geometries and/or atomic distributions. In one of these cases, in particular, the symmetry is first conserved and the atoms follow Dicke's predictions for a time. A 'retarded' symmetry breaking then occurs suddenly, near the zero value of the collective energy, as in Friedberg and Hartmann's calculations for a small sphere. With regard to the further evolution of the atoms in this case, which cannot be studied in a semiclassical model, it is shown that the decay rate quickly becomes much smaller than the incoherent decay rate. An unquestionable subradiance phenomenon is thus predicted in this case.

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics•Mar 14, 1987•18 citations

Time-resolved interplay between superradiant and subradiant states in superradiance lattices of Bose-Einstein condensates

Chengdong Mi, Khan Sadiq Nawaz, Liangchao Chen +5 more

The collective spontaneous emission of many atoms is significantly different from that of a single atom, depending on the geometry and the phase correlation of atomic ensembles. However, experimental observation of arbitrary superradiant and subradiant states of atoms remains challenging due to the difficulties in both preparation and detection of those states. Here we report the time-resolved observation of superradiance from a timed Dicke state in a momentum-space superradiance lattice of Bose-Einstein condensates, which enables an in situ measurement of the coherent lattice dynamics involving both superradiant and subradiant states. The long-lasting oscillation in the superradiant emission is contributed by population transport from the subradiant states in the superradiance lattice. This work paves the way to prepare and observe subradiant states, which has promising applications in quantum information processing.

Physical Review A•Oct 28, 2021•14 citations
We report the first observation of a microscopically resolved interaction between two trapped atoms. This is also the first observation of two-ion superradiance and subradiance, the most elementary example of Dicke's theory. Its signature is the variation of the spontaneous emission decay rate of a laser-cooled two-ion crystal, +1.5+1.5%+1.5 and \ensuremath−1.2\ensuremath{-}1.2%\ensuremath−1.2, as the ion-ion distance is changed from 1380 to 1540 nm, in agreement with a no-free-parameter theory. The experiment uses an ion microtrap (80 \ensuremath{\mu}m radius) with planar electrodes and a new few-atom technique for measuring lifetimes.
Laser-cooled trapped ion crystals offer a unique opportunity to study the interactions between atoms. We have previously developed a microscopic planar Paul trap1 which is small and strong enough to bring the ion separation into the sub-micron region where quantum collective effects become important. A search is underway for the superradiant coupling of two atoms which manifests itself as a variation of the spontaneous emission rate with the ion-ion distance. We have produced an ion crystal with a separation of 1.1 microns in an 80 micron radius planar Paul trap. At this distance, equal to 2.2 wavelengths of the 493 nm Ba + transition, superradiant effects should alter the decay rate by about 10%. The two-ion crystal is imaged with sub-micron resolution by a new diffraction-limited vacuum-compatible microscope. The spontaneous emission rate is measured by a high repetition-rate transient spectrometer with an error of less than 1% for a single ion in a few minutes. Efficient extinction of the exciting laser light is provided by a new nonlinear electrooptic sideband switch.
Advances in laser cooling and trapping have made possible a new kind of microscopic atomic physics experiment in which each atom is detected individually and in which the interatomic distances are known and controlled on a sub-micron scale. This chapter shows that the triplet and singlet states represent states in which the dipole moments of the two atoms are either correlated or anticorrelated. Since the two atoms’ wave-functions are identical, so are all their physical observables, including the dipole moments. The chapter describes the theory of superradiant and subradiant spontaneous emission in sufficient detail to understand current experiments. An experiment will in general prepare a partially coherent state described by a density matrix. The chapter discusses a simple physical picture of singlet and triplet states in both wave function and density matrix approaches. It also describes a classical model of the decay rate oscillations, and also shows how the experimental signal depends on the excitation conditions.
A superradiance theory is developed for two identical hydrogenic ions (four states each) in a microtrap, as in recent experiments. The ions oscillate (micromotion) due to the trap's radio frequency (rf) electric quadrupole field. One signature of superradiance is a deviation of the two-ion average upper state decay rate \ensuremath{\gamma}\ifmmode\bar\else\textasciimacron\fi{} from the one-ion value \ensuremath{\gamma}. A master equation is derived, giving a fractional change in the upper state lifetime \ensuremath{\gamma}/\ensuremath{\gamma}\ifmmode\bar\else\textasciimacron\fi{}-1=sinkR/2kR [J02{\mathit{J}}_{0}^{2}J02​(z)-2J12{\mathit{J}}_{1}^{2}J12​(z)+...]cos\ensuremath{\Phi}, where k=2\ensuremath{\pi}/\ensuremath{\lambda}, \ensuremath{\lambda} is the emission wavelength, R is the ion-ion distance, Jn{\mathit{J}}_{\mathit{n}}Jn​(z) is a Bessel function of integer order n, and z=ka, a is the ion amplitude of motion, and \ensuremath{\Phi} is the two-ion relative phase due to the preparation. In the Lamb-Dicke regime, a, J02{\mathit{J}}_{0}^{2}J02​(z)\ensuremath{\approxeq}1 and thus superradiance is not influenced significantly by ion motion. This damped sinusoid is diluted by the factor of 1/2 due to destructive interference. Superradiance vanishes in the absence of coherent preparation, e.g., with inversion, as indicated by the time evolution of the two-ion dipole correlation function. Fringes and a beat at the rf are predicted in forward scattering, the most elementary form of optical free induction decay.
Bragg scattering and superradiance, always considered independently, are examined jointly for the case of two trapped ions. The two phenomena are seen to be different representations of the same basic two-ion interference resulting from a common coherent optical preparation. Solutions of a master equation for two four-level atoms show that fringes (spatial interference) and a variation of the spontaneous emission lifetime with ion-ion distance (temporal interference) can occur either simultaneously or separately. Unlike a classical calculation, not all scatterings result in interference, a quantum effect not considered in interpreting recent experiments.
For pt.II see ibid., vol.19, p.2109 (1986). This paper is the third in a theoretical study of subradiance, i.e. the cooperative inhibition of spontaneous emission by a destructive interatomic interference, a phenomenon which has recently been observed. The paper is devoted to the problem of the cooperative spontaneous emission of atomic samples with linear dimensions much smaller than the wavelength of the emitted light. The treatment, which is based on a fully quantum mechanical description of the problem, corroborates the results obtained in a semiclassical treatment by Friedberg and Hartmann (1974). Starting from a master equation describing both the cooperative spontaneous emission and the dipole-dipole interaction, a statistical treatment of the latter is introduced and the corresponding symmetry relaxation is studied. The evolution of the atoms is described in three typical cases that correspond to different sample geometries and/or atomic distributions. In one of these cases, in particular, the symmetry is first conserved and the atoms follow Dicke's predictions for a time. A 'retarded' symmetry breaking then occurs suddenly, near the zero value of the collective energy, as in Friedberg and Hartmann's calculations for a small sphere. With regard to the further evolution of the atoms in this case, which cannot be studied in a semiclassical model, it is shown that the decay rate quickly becomes much smaller than the incoherent decay rate. An unquestionable subradiance phenomenon is thus predicted in this case.
The collective spontaneous emission of many atoms is significantly different from that of a single atom, depending on the geometry and the phase correlation of atomic ensembles. However, experimental observation of arbitrary superradiant and subradiant states of atoms remains challenging due to the difficulties in both preparation and detection of those states. Here we report the time-resolved observation of superradiance from a timed Dicke state in a momentum-space superradiance lattice of Bose-Einstein condensates, which enables an in situ measurement of the coherent lattice dynamics involving both superradiant and subradiant states. The long-lasting oscillation in the superradiant emission is contributed by population transport from the subradiant states in the superradiance lattice. This work paves the way to prepare and observe subradiant states, which has promising applications in quantum information processing.