This chapter examines the applicability of several known multiplexing disciplines to purify-and-swap quantum repeater networks: straightforward circuit switching, time division multiplexing (TDM), statistical multiplexing, and a buffer memory allocation and sharing mechanism. The different multiplexing schemes are studied in order to recommend a mechanism for sharing resources in multi-user network, and ultimately to be able to predict the performance of given network under certain traffic patterns. When the use of the network is not uniform, using the same working fidelity throughout the entire network results in portions sitting idle while a flow waits for its turn to use a shared resource. The simulations presented here set the purification threshold for the 10 uncontested links to 0.99, whereas the contested links EF and FJ are set to 0.98. Statistical multiplexing is simpler to implement than any scheme requiring explicit resource management, whether it is circuit switching, TDM or buffer space multiplexing.
This chapter examines the applicability of several known multiplexing disciplines to purify-and-swap quantum repeater networks: straightforward circuit switching, time division multiplexing (TDM), statistical multiplexing, and a buffer memory allocation and sharing mechanism. The different multiplexing schemes are studied in order to recommend a mechanism for sharing resources in multi-user network, and ultimately to be able to predict the performance of given network under certain traffic patterns. When the use of the network is not uniform, using the same working fidelity throughout the entire network results in portions sitting idle while a flow waits for its turn to use a shared resource. The simulations presented here set the purification threshold for the 10 uncontested links to 0.99, whereas the contested links EF and FJ are set to 0.98. Statistical multiplexing is simpler to implement than any scheme requiring explicit resource management, whether it is circuit switching, TDM or buffer space multiplexing.
When built, quantum repeater networks will require classical network protocols to control the quantum operations. However, existing work on repeaters has focused on the quantum operations themselves, with less attention paid to the contents, semantics, ordering and reliability of the classical control messages. In this work we define and describe our implementation of the classical control protocols. The state machines and packet sequences for the three protocol layers are presented, and operation confirmed by running the protocols over simulations of the physical network. We also show that proper management of the resources in a bottleneck link allows the aggregate throughput of two end-to-end flows to substantially exceed that of a single flow. Our layered architectural framework will support independent evolution of the separate protocol layers. Networks of quantum repeaters utilize three concepts to execute a distributed algorithm that creates entangled quantum states between nodes that are far apart: a basic entanglement mechanism which depends on the physical implementation, error management (in this work, we study a method known as purification), and finally a quantum state propagation layer (here we implement entanglement swapping, which builds multi-hop connections from single-hop connections). Some researchers are investigating approaches that are substantially different from entanglement swapping [30, 24, 19]. Here we focus on swapping, but the layered architecture approach is broadly applicable, allowing other implementations to replace only a single layer in the protocol stack. Previous work primarily focused on the physical and mathematical tools for building repeaters. Classical information is also needed to enable teleportation and swapping, as many quantum operations are not deterministic, and results of quantum measurements need to be reported to distant partners before further operations can proceed. Also, operations in the middle of the network must be coordinated to route and swap properly. This requires classical messages to make operations robust, but message propagation times penalize performance. Even though this delay is usually included in repeater simulations, prior work has not defined the protocols in detail, especially with respect to how all of the nodes make consistent decisions in a timely fashion. In this work, we introduce a protocol stack for networks of quantum repeaters that considers all the necessary classical messages and which can be easily adapted for different approaches at all three protocol layers. We run simulations of competing flows on a dumbbell topology in order to increase our confidence in the behavior of our network protocols. By adjusting the fidelity thresholds required for entanglement swapping, we show that some configurations boost the aggregate throughput for multiple flows significantly above the maximum for a single flow, taking advantage of resources that would otherwise sit idle. The operation of such complex networks and such delicate tuning of the system without formal protocol definitions would not be possible. Previous work has also concentrated almost exclusively on the dedicated use of a single line or chain of repeaters, delivering Bell pairs only to the two nodes at the ends of the chain. Networks, however, typically have more than two end points, and allow any pair of these end nodes to communicate. More topologically complex networks, with numerous end nodes, are obviously much more scalable than connecting every possible pair of nodes using a dedicated line of repeaters. we investigate how classical multiplexing schemes translate to the domain of quantum repeaters, in order to manage shared resources and active communication flows of data from different stations. We simulate four sharing protocols in a complex network with competing traffic. Circuit switching gives any individual flow the best performance, but makes poor use of the overall network and is inflexible. We use circuit switching as our baseline case to compare time division multiplexing, buffer space multiplexing, and statistical multiplexing, and show that all multiplexing schemes are better than circuit switching. For the particular network simulated, we find that statistical multiplexing outperforms time division multiplexing by 28% and buffer space multiplexing by 13%. We find that all three multiplexing schemes are fair; each flow is penalized a similar percentage of its throughput as the the total number of users in the network increases. Finally, statistical multiplexing requires no network-wide coordination of the use of quantum memory or channels, and is easier to implement than a robust, scalable scheme for the other protocols. Our current results suggest that the best strategy for quantum repeater networks is statistical multiplexing. (This is in fact the quantum analogue of the basis on which the Internet works.) However, our current simulations are done with no degradation of memory over time, using the assumption of quantum error-corrected memory at each repeater; inclusion of decoherence and a finite qubit lifetime remains as future work.
When built, quantum repeaters will allow the distribution of entangled quantum states across large distances, playing a vital part in many proposed quantum technologies. Enabling multiple users to connect through the same network will be key to their real-world deployment. Previous work on repeater technologies has focussed only on simple entanglment production, without considering the issues of resource scarcity and competition that necessarily arise in a network setting. In this paper we simulated a thirteen-node network with up to five flows sharing different parts of the network, measuring the total throughput and fairness for each case. Our results suggest that the Internet-like approach of statistical multiplexing use of a congested link gives the highest aggregate throughput. Time division multiplexing and buffer space multiplexing were slightly less effective, but all three schemes allow the sum of multiple flows to substantially exceed that of any one flow, improving over circuit switching by taking advantage of resources that are forced to remain idle in circuit switching. All three schemes proved to have excellent fairness. The high performance, fairness and simplicity of implementation support a recommendation of statistical multiplexing for shared quantum repeater networks.
In this work we consider a quantum network consisting of multiple interconnected quantum repeaters. In this network, data plane of communication is achieved by photon transmission over fibre cables, while the control plane which transmits results of measurements and control information is implemented over classical Internet. Important part of the control plane is the server which distributes connection requests and entanglement resources to nodes involved in the path. Together, data and control plane establish reliable multi hop links over the network deploying purification and swapping operations. We analyze the performance of such a network using probabilistic model of communication time between repeaters, rather than slotted time. We consider random arrivals of connection requests to each repeater and variable path lengths. We model a single repeater using theory ofM[x]/G/m+rqueues where each batch request encompasses heralding, purification, and swapping times pertaining to a single repeater node. To model the network, we have used the concept of Jackson's network over repeater nodes in the path. This model allows derivation of end-to-end entanglement delivery time as random distribution and calculation of probability of decoherence of qubits stored in quantum memories over the path. We considered different numbers of entanglements per request and different types of quantum memories. Results of this analysis are useful for dimensioning capacities of quantum repeaters, memories and links in order to avoid decoherence of quantum memories.
The primary task of a quantum repeater network is to deliver entanglement among end nodes. Most of existing entanglement distribution protocols do not consider purification, which is thus delegated to an upper layer. This is a major drawback since, once an end-to-end entangled connection (or a portion thereof) is established it cannot be purified if its fidelity (F) does not fall within an interval bounded by Fmin (greater than 0.5) and Fmax (less than 1). In this paper, we propose the Ranked Entanglement Distribution Protocol (REDiP), a connection-oriented protocol that overcomes the above drawback. This result was achieved by including in our protocol two mechanisms for carrying out jointly purification and entanglement swapping. We use simulations to investigate the impact of these mechanisms on the performance of a repeater network, in terms of throughput and fidelity. Moreover, we show how REDiP can easily be configured to implement custom entanglement swapping and purification strategies, including (but not restricted to) those adopted in two recent works.
Quantum repeater networks that allow long-distance entanglement distribution will be the backbone of distributed quantum information processing. In this paper we explore entanglement distribution using quantum repeaters with optimized buffer time, equipped with noisy quantum memories and performing imperfect entanglement purification and swapping. We observe that increasing the number of memories on end nodes leads to a higher entanglement distribution rate per memory and higher probability of high-fidelity entanglement distribution, at least for the case with perfect operations. When imperfect operations are considered, however, we make the surprising observation that the permemory entanglement rate decreases with increasing number of memories. Our results suggest that building quantum repeaters that perform well under realistic conditions requires careful modeling and design that takes into consideration the operations and resources that are finite and imperfect.
In communication networks many different channels must share a limited amount of resources. In order to allow for multiple simultaneous communications, multiple access techniques are routinely employed. With quantum communication, it is possible to share a new kind of resource. All of the system channels can be accommodated into a single channel in a larger Hilbert space. In the scheme, a single line combines the information of all the users, and, at the receiver, the original quantum channels are recovered. The given multiplexer/demultiplexer circuit can perform this n qubits to qudit transformation. Connections with superdense coding and classical multiple access schemes are discussed.