Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Comment on: {open_quotes}Interference effects between independent gamma rays{close_quotes}

IL (United States) Argonne National Lab., Ian McNulty, USDOE, Washington, DC (United States), Efim S. Gluskin, Malcolm R. Howells

Published Jul 17, 1992• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In a recent letter, E. Ikonen proposed a Hanbury Brown and Twiss (HBT) intensity interferometry experiment to demonstrate interference effects between independent gamma rays. Ikonen suggests that in order to obtain a measurable correlation signal with gamma or x-radiation, it would be necessary to use a highly monochromatic beam such as that produced by a monochromator based on the Mossbauer effect, operating on a high brilliance beamline at a synchrotron storage ring. In this comment, the authors point out that, although this is a possible approach, it is unnecessary to utilize the extremely narrow bandwidth afforded by nuclear resonant monochromatization to demonstrate the HBT effect with x-rays. Furthermore, they do not agree that the proposed experiment would provide evidence of interference between independent quanta in the x-ray region, or that the results of such an experiment depend on quantum phenomena which are fundamentally different than those which apply to conventional (amplitude) interferometry.

DOI
10.2172/10134490

Related papers

Hanbury Brown–Twiss Effect with Wave Packets

Tabish Qureshi, Ushba Rizwan

The Hanbury Brown–Twiss (HBT) effect, at the quantum level, is essentially an interference of one particle with another, as opposed to interference of a particle with itself. Conventional treatments of identical particles encounter difficulties while dealing with entanglement. A recently introduced label-free approach to indistinguishable particles is described, and is used to analyze the HBT effect. Quantum wave-packets have been used to provide a better understanding of the quantum interpretation of the HBT effect. The effect is demonstrated for two independent particles governed by Bose–Einstein or Fermi–Dirac statistics. The HBT effect is also analyzed for pairs of entangled particles. Surprisingly, entanglement has almost no effect on the interference seen in the HBT effect. In the light of the results, an old quantum optics experiment is reanalyzed, and it is argued that the interference seen in that experiment is not a consequence of non-local correlations between the photons, as is commonly believed. Quanta 2017; 6: 61–69.

arXiv:1509.02221•Quanta•Nov 29, 2017•8 citations

Interference of independently generated beams of γ-quanta

It should be pointed out that a sharp decrease in the angular divergence of radiation produced by a spatially–modulated beam appreciably facilitates the conditions for performing experiments for observation of the interference of the pairs of X-ray quanta that this beam emits. Such interference arises due to photon identity when the pairs of X-ray quanta are registered by two independent counters (see Fig. 18.1) in the so-called regime of counting the coincidence of particle registrations by both detectors at time moment t within a certain small time interval Δ t (instantaneous coincidence counting) or in the counting regime when the coincidence is the event in which after the registration in one of the detectors, the other detector registers the particle after time Δ T in the time interval Δ t (delayed coincidence counting). This interference of the pairs of quanta in the optical range enabled designing the Brown–Twiss interferometer [Hanbury Brown and Twiss (1954); Bromberg et al . (2010)]. The requirement that should be met for performing these interesting experiments in the X-ray range are stated in [Baryshevskii and Podgoretskii (1968); Baryshevsky and Feranchuk (1980)]. Note that this phenomenon has a general character and, e.g., for pions and other particles it is not only observed, but used to study space–time characteristics of the production processes [Grishin et al . (1971); Kopylov and Podgoretskii (1972); Kopylov (1974); Kopylov and Podgoretskii (1975); Podgoretskii (1989); Wiedemann et al . (1997); Lisa et al . (2000); Lednicky (2007)].

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Interference effects between independent gamma rays

Erkki Ikonen

An intensity correlation experiment is proposed that would test the presence of true interference between independent gamma rays. Clear intensity correlations are predicted within a reasonable counting time, as the experiment is greatly benefitted by the pulsed time structure and high brilliance of the future dedicated synchrotron radiation sources. Applications of the novel method are suggested.

Physical Review Letters•May 4, 1992•44 citations

Phase-dependent Hanbury-Brown and Twiss effect for the complete measurement of the complex coherence function

Xuan Tang, Yunxiao Zhang, Xueshi Guo +3 more

Hanbury-Brown and Twiss (HBT) effect is the foundation for stellar intensity interferometry. However, it is a phase insensitive two-photon interference effect. Here we extend the HBT interferometer by mixing intensity-matched reference fields with the input fields before intensity correlation measurement. With the freely available coherent state serving as the reference field, we experimentally demonstrate the phase sensitive two-photon interference effect when the input fields are thermal fields in either continuous wave or non-stationary pulsed wave and measure the complete complex second-order coherence function of the input fields without bringing them together from separate locations. Moreover, we discuss how to improve the signal level by using the more realistic continuous wave broadband anti-bunched light fields as the reference field. Our investigations pave the way for developing new technology of remote sensing and interferometric imaging with applications in long baseline high-resolution astronomy.

arXiv:2308.11459•Light Science & Applications•Jan 13, 2025•8 citations

Generalized Hanbury Brown–Twiss interferometer

Yiqi Song, Meixue Chen, Yuhan Ma +7 more

The Hanbury Brown–Twiss (HBT) interferometer, which is used to measure the correlation of two photons or two light beams, has played a crucial role in quantum optics and quantum information. We propose a generalized HBT interferometer, which is able to measure the correlation of photons or light beams up to eight in a single experimental run. With an improved time correlated single-photon counting (TCSPC) algorithm, two-, three-, and four-photon coincidence counts, and the degree of fifth-order coherence of pseudothermal light are measured with a data collection time of 60 s. The generalized HBT interferometer can be used to measure the correlation of two multi-photon detection events by simulating photon number resolving detectors with multiple single-photon detectors. The generalized HBT interferometer and improved TCSPC algorithm provide a versatile framework for studying multi-photon correlations and interference, which is helpful to understand the physics of multi-photon interference and may find applications in fluorescence lifetime imaging and other techniques using TCSPC.

Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Mar 3, 2026•0 citations

Multifrequency-resolved Hanbury Brown–Twiss effect

Joseph Ferrantini, Jesse Crawford, Sergei Kulkov +14 more

The Hanbury Brown–Twiss (HBT) effect holds a pivotal place in intensity interferometry and gave a seminal contribution to the development of quantum optics. To observe such an effect, both good spectral and timing resolutions are necessary. Most often, the HBT effect is observed for a single frequency at a time due to its limitations in dealing with multifrequencies simultaneously, halting and limiting some applications. Here, we report a fast and data-driven spectrometer built with a one-dimensional array of single-photon-sensitive avalanche diodes. We report observing the HBT effect for multiple frequencies at the same time. In particular, we observe the HBT effect for up to five lines of the Ne spectrum, but this can be improved upon to include more lines. Our work represents a major step in making spectral binning and multifrequency HBT more widely available. The technology we present can benefit both classical and quantum applications.

arXiv:2406.13959•APL Photonics•Feb 1, 2025•9 citations
In a recent letter, E. Ikonen proposed a Hanbury Brown and Twiss (HBT) intensity interferometry experiment to demonstrate interference effects between independent gamma rays. Ikonen suggests that in order to obtain a measurable correlation signal with gamma or x-radiation, it would be necessary to use a highly monochromatic beam such as that produced by a monochromator based on the Mossbauer effect, operating on a high brilliance beamline at a synchrotron storage ring. In this comment, the authors point out that, although this is a possible approach, it is unnecessary to utilize the extremely narrow bandwidth afforded by nuclear resonant monochromatization to demonstrate the HBT effect with x-rays. Furthermore, they do not agree that the proposed experiment would provide evidence of interference between independent quanta in the x-ray region, or that the results of such an experiment depend on quantum phenomena which are fundamentally different than those which apply to conventional (amplitude) interferometry.
The Hanbury Brown–Twiss (HBT) effect, at the quantum level, is essentially an interference of one particle with another, as opposed to interference of a particle with itself. Conventional treatments of identical particles encounter difficulties while dealing with entanglement. A recently introduced label-free approach to indistinguishable particles is described, and is used to analyze the HBT effect. Quantum wave-packets have been used to provide a better understanding of the quantum interpretation of the HBT effect. The effect is demonstrated for two independent particles governed by Bose–Einstein or Fermi–Dirac statistics. The HBT effect is also analyzed for pairs of entangled particles. Surprisingly, entanglement has almost no effect on the interference seen in the HBT effect. In the light of the results, an old quantum optics experiment is reanalyzed, and it is argued that the interference seen in that experiment is not a consequence of non-local correlations between the photons, as is commonly believed. Quanta 2017; 6: 61–69.
It should be pointed out that a sharp decrease in the angular divergence of radiation produced by a spatially–modulated beam appreciably facilitates the conditions for performing experiments for observation of the interference of the pairs of X-ray quanta that this beam emits. Such interference arises due to photon identity when the pairs of X-ray quanta are registered by two independent counters (see Fig. 18.1) in the so-called regime of counting the coincidence of particle registrations by both detectors at time moment t within a certain small time interval Δ t (instantaneous coincidence counting) or in the counting regime when the coincidence is the event in which after the registration in one of the detectors, the other detector registers the particle after time Δ T in the time interval Δ t (delayed coincidence counting). This interference of the pairs of quanta in the optical range enabled designing the Brown–Twiss interferometer [Hanbury Brown and Twiss (1954); Bromberg et al . (2010)]. The requirement that should be met for performing these interesting experiments in the X-ray range are stated in [Baryshevskii and Podgoretskii (1968); Baryshevsky and Feranchuk (1980)]. Note that this phenomenon has a general character and, e.g., for pions and other particles it is not only observed, but used to study space–time characteristics of the production processes [Grishin et al . (1971); Kopylov and Podgoretskii (1972); Kopylov (1974); Kopylov and Podgoretskii (1975); Podgoretskii (1989); Wiedemann et al . (1997); Lisa et al . (2000); Lednicky (2007)].
Hanbury-Brown and Twiss (HBT) effect is the foundation for stellar intensity interferometry. However, it is a phase insensitive two-photon interference effect. Here we extend the HBT interferometer by mixing intensity-matched reference fields with the input fields before intensity correlation measurement. With the freely available coherent state serving as the reference field, we experimentally demonstrate the phase sensitive two-photon interference effect when the input fields are thermal fields in either continuous wave or non-stationary pulsed wave and measure the complete complex second-order coherence function of the input fields without bringing them together from separate locations. Moreover, we discuss how to improve the signal level by using the more realistic continuous wave broadband anti-bunched light fields as the reference field. Our investigations pave the way for developing new technology of remote sensing and interferometric imaging with applications in long baseline high-resolution astronomy.
The Hanbury Brown–Twiss (HBT) interferometer, which is used to measure the correlation of two photons or two light beams, has played a crucial role in quantum optics and quantum information. We propose a generalized HBT interferometer, which is able to measure the correlation of photons or light beams up to eight in a single experimental run. With an improved time correlated single-photon counting (TCSPC) algorithm, two-, three-, and four-photon coincidence counts, and the degree of fifth-order coherence of pseudothermal light are measured with a data collection time of 60 s. The generalized HBT interferometer can be used to measure the correlation of two multi-photon detection events by simulating photon number resolving detectors with multiple single-photon detectors. The generalized HBT interferometer and improved TCSPC algorithm provide a versatile framework for studying multi-photon correlations and interference, which is helpful to understand the physics of multi-photon interference and may find applications in fluorescence lifetime imaging and other techniques using TCSPC.
The Hanbury Brown–Twiss (HBT) effect holds a pivotal place in intensity interferometry and gave a seminal contribution to the development of quantum optics. To observe such an effect, both good spectral and timing resolutions are necessary. Most often, the HBT effect is observed for a single frequency at a time due to its limitations in dealing with multifrequencies simultaneously, halting and limiting some applications. Here, we report a fast and data-driven spectrometer built with a one-dimensional array of single-photon-sensitive avalanche diodes. We report observing the HBT effect for multiple frequencies at the same time. In particular, we observe the HBT effect for up to five lines of the Ne spectrum, but this can be improved upon to include more lines. Our work represents a major step in making spectral binning and multifrequency HBT more widely available. The technology we present can benefit both classical and quantum applications.