Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

HOW TO TEACH AN OLD DOG NEW TRICKS: QUANTUM INFORMATION, QUANTUM COMPUTATION, AND THE PHILOSOPHY OF PHYSICS

Armond Duwell

Published Jan 1, 2004• 8 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

My dissertation consists of two independent parts. Part one of my dissertation examines concepts of quantum information. I clarify three very different concepts of information and assess their implications for understanding quantum mechanics. First I clarify the concept of information due to Shannon, and its relation to physical theories. Using the Shannon concept, I examine two purportedly new concepts of quantum information. I argue that a fundamental philosophical mistake is made regarding these concepts. Advocates of these new concepts do not properly distinguish between the properties of information due to the physical medium it is stored in from the properties of information per se. This distinction is crucial for developing a new concept to help us understand quantum mechanics and evaluating its merits. Part two of my dissertation examines explanations of the efficiency that quantum computers enjoy over classical computers for some computational tasks, and the relationship between explanations of efficiency and interpretations of quantum mechanics. I examine the so-called quantum parallelism thesis, that quantum computers can perform many computations in a single step, a feat thought not to be possible on classical computers. The truth of this thesis is not obvious, and contested by some. I develop a set of general criteria for computation that any computing device must satisfy. I use these criteria to demonstrate that the quantum parallelism thesis is true. As an application of these general criteria for computation I articulate three distinct concepts of parallelism and demonstrate that classical computers can compute in parallel as well. This demonstrates that the truth of the quantum parallelism thesis alone does not provide a complete explanation of the efficiency of quantum computers. I supplement the quantum parallelism thesis to provide a complete explanation. Finally, I address the claim that only the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics can underwrite the truth of the quantum parallelism thesis. The general criteria for computation provide support for the quantum parallelism thesis independent of any interpretation of quantum mechanics.

Related papers

Quantum mechanics and quantum information theory

Van Camp, Wesley William

The principle aim of this dissertation is to investigate the philosophical application of quantum information theory to interpretational issues regarding the theory of quantum mechanics. Recently, quantum information theory has emerged as a potential source for such an interpretation. The main question with which this dissertation will be concerned is whether or not an information-theoretic interpretation can serve as a conceptually acceptable interpretation of quantum mechanics. It will be argued that some of the more obvious approaches - that quantum information theory shows us that ultimately the world is made of information, and quantum Bayesianism - fail as philosophical interpretations of quantum mechanics. However, the information-theoretic approach of Clifton, Bub, and Halvorson introduces Einstein's distinction between principle theories and constructive theories, arguing that quantum mechanics is best understood as an information-theoretic principle theory. While I argue that this particular approach fails, it does offer a viable new philosophical role for information theory. Specifically, an investigation of interpretationally successful principle theories such as Newtonian mechanics, special relativity, and general relativity, shows that the particular principles employed are necessary as constitutive elements of a framework which partially defines the basic explanatory concepts of space, time, and motion. Without such constitutive principles as preconditions for empirical meaning, scientific progress is hampered. It is argued that the philosophical issues in quantum mechanics stem from an analogous conceptual crisis. On the basis of this comparison, the best strategy for resolving these problems is to apply a similar sort of conceptual analysis to quantum mechanics so as to provide an appropriate set of constitutive principles clarifying the conceptual issues at stake. It is further argued that quantum information theory is ideally placed as a novel conceptual framework from which to conduct this analysis.

•Jan 1, 2009•1 citation

OVERVIEW OF QUANTUM COMPUTATION

H.E. Caicedo-Ortiz, Elizabeth Santiago-Cortes

Computation and quantum information [1] are an extension of the information process concept, and they are used for the effects of quantum mechanic [2]. This new scheme provides a work scene that is not restricted to only two operations; on the contrary, this can gain multiple intermediate states as a result of these two ways of superposition. By performing this operation, the system can evaluate all possibilities in only one step by making a parallel computation; meanwhile, in the classic way, this evaluation is carried out independently of each other, and in different steps. The quantum parallelism can be defined as a reduction in time and an increase in the fast of information process. In this chapter, the fundamental elements that make possible to use the mechanical-quantum phenomena as a tool in the process information are presented.

Apple Academic Press eBooks•Oct 22, 2014•1 citation

On the Physical Explanation for Quantum Computational Speedup

Michael E. Cuffaro

The aim of this dissertation is to clarify the debate over the explanation of quantum speedup and to submit a tentative resolution to it. In particular, I argue that the physical explanation for quantum speedup is precisely the fact that the phenomenon of quantum entanglement enables a quantum computer to fully exploit the representational capacity of Hilbert space. This is impossible for classical systems, joint states of which must always be representable as product states. Chapter 2 begins with a discussion of the most popular of the candidate physical explanations for quantum speedup: the many worlds explanation. I argue that unlike the neo-Everettian interpretation of quantum mechanics it does not have the conceptual resources required to overcome the `preferred basis objection'. I further argue that the many worlds explanation, at best, can serve as a good description of the physical process which takes place in so-called network-based computation, but that it is incompatible with other models of computation such as cluster state quantum computing. I next consider, in Chapter 3, a common component of most other candidate explanations of quantum speedup: quantum entanglement. I investigate whether entanglement can be said to be a necessary component of any explanation for quantum speedup, and I consider two major purported counter-examples to this claim. I argue that neither of these, in fact, show that entanglement is unnecessary for speedup, and that, on the contrary, we should conclude that it is. In Chapters 4 and 5 I then ask whether entanglement can be said to be sufficient as well. In Chapter 4 I argue that despite a result that seems to indicate the contrary, entanglement, considered as a resource, can be seen as sufficient to enable quantum speedup. Finally, in Chapter 5 I argue that entanglement is sufficient to explain quantum speedup as well.

arXiv:1304.0208•Mar 31, 2013•2 citations

Entanglement Theory and the Quantum Simulation of Many-Body Physics

Fernando G. S. L. Brandão

Quantum mechanics led us to reconsider the scope of physics and its building principles, such as the notions of realism and locality. More recently, quantum theory has changed in an equally dramatic manner our understanding of information processing and computation. On one hand, the fundamental properties of quantum systems can be harnessed to transmit, store, and manipulate information in a more efficient and secure way than possible in the realm of classical physics. On the other hand, the development of systematic procedures to manipulate systems of a large number of particles in the quantum regime, crucial to the implementation of quantum-based information processing, has triggered new possibilities in the exploration of quantum many-body physics and related areas. In this thesis, we present new results relevant to two important problems in quantum information science: the development of a theory of entanglement, intrinsically quantum correlations, and the exploration of the use of controlled quantum systems to the computation and simulation of quantum many-body phenomena. In the first part we introduce a new approach to the study of entanglement

•Oct 1, 2008•28 citations

ACCESSIBLE INFORMATION IN SYMMETRIC QUANTUM CHANNELS

Ajay Gopinathan

This thesis is a study of how information theory can be used to analyse and interpret quantum mechanical systems, specifically, systems that are being used for information processing and communication tasks. Quantum information science is a relatively new field, and it has only been recently that we have started to look at using quantum mechanical systems to accomplish information processing tasks that are not possible using classical systems. As this method of information processing is a relatively new paradigm, there are many possibilities for new algorithms and discoveries in this area of computing. The application of information theory towards the analysis and description of quantum mechanical systems yields new interesting results - it can even be argued that information theory provides a natural and intuitive way to intepret quantum mechanics, as correlations and measurement outcomes in quantum processes can be described using information theory. Chapter 1 is an introduction to the strange new world of quantum mechanics and takes a brief look at one of the applications of quantum information science in quantum cryptography. A mathematical overview of the postulates and framework that quantum mechanics is built on is presented in Chapter 2. Chapter 3 is a brief study of classical information theory and some of the fundamental concepts and ideas that form the crux of the subject. In Chapter 4, we present the main results of the thesis by taking a look at an optimal measurement scheme that improves on previous schemes by allowing us to extract the maximal amount of information from states in a quantum channel of specific geometry. The findings have an impact on various other areas of the field, including security analysis of quantum cryptographic protocols and building better quantum cloning machines.

•Jan 1, 2005•0 citations

Quantum Information Theory and the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics

Christopher G. Timpson

This thesis is a contribution to the debate on the implications of quantum information theory for the foundations of quantum mechanics. In Part 1, the logical and conceptual status of various notions of information is assessed. It is emphasized that the everyday notion of information is to be firmly distinguished from the technical notions arising in information theory; however it is maintained that in both settings `information' functions as an abstract noun, hence does not refer to a particular or substance (the worth of this point is illustrated in application to quantum teleportation). The claim that `Information is Physical' is assessed and argued to face a destructive dilemma. Accordingly, the slogan may not be understood as an ontological claim, but at best, as a methodological one. The reflections of Bruckner and Zeilinger (2001) and Deutsch and Hayden (2000) on the nature of information in quantum mechanics are critically assessed and some results presented on the characterization of entanglement in the Deutsch-Hayden formalism. Some philosophical aspects of quantum computation are discussed and general morals drawn concerning the nature of quantum information theory. In Part II, following some preliminary remarks, two particular information-theoretic approaches to the foundations of quantum mechanics are assessed in detail. It is argued that Zeilinger's (1999) Foundational Principle is unsuccessful as a foundational principle for quantum mechanics. The information-theoretic characterization theorem of Clifton, Bub and Halvorson (2003) is assessed more favourably, but the generality of the approach is questioned and it is argued that the implications of the theorem for the traditional foundational problems in quantum mechanics remains obscure.

arXiv:quant-ph/0412063•Dec 8, 2004•39 citations
My dissertation consists of two independent parts. Part one of my dissertation examines concepts of quantum information. I clarify three very different concepts of information and assess their implications for understanding quantum mechanics. First I clarify the concept of information due to Shannon, and its relation to physical theories. Using the Shannon concept, I examine two purportedly new concepts of quantum information. I argue that a fundamental philosophical mistake is made regarding these concepts. Advocates of these new concepts do not properly distinguish between the properties of information due to the physical medium it is stored in from the properties of information per se. This distinction is crucial for developing a new concept to help us understand quantum mechanics and evaluating its merits. Part two of my dissertation examines explanations of the efficiency that quantum computers enjoy over classical computers for some computational tasks, and the relationship between explanations of efficiency and interpretations of quantum mechanics. I examine the so-called quantum parallelism thesis, that quantum computers can perform many computations in a single step, a feat thought not to be possible on classical computers. The truth of this thesis is not obvious, and contested by some. I develop a set of general criteria for computation that any computing device must satisfy. I use these criteria to demonstrate that the quantum parallelism thesis is true. As an application of these general criteria for computation I articulate three distinct concepts of parallelism and demonstrate that classical computers can compute in parallel as well. This demonstrates that the truth of the quantum parallelism thesis alone does not provide a complete explanation of the efficiency of quantum computers. I supplement the quantum parallelism thesis to provide a complete explanation. Finally, I address the claim that only the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics can underwrite the truth of the quantum parallelism thesis. The general criteria for computation provide support for the quantum parallelism thesis independent of any interpretation of quantum mechanics.
The principle aim of this dissertation is to investigate the philosophical application of quantum information theory to interpretational issues regarding the theory of quantum mechanics. Recently, quantum information theory has emerged as a potential source for such an interpretation. The main question with which this dissertation will be concerned is whether or not an information-theoretic interpretation can serve as a conceptually acceptable interpretation of quantum mechanics. It will be argued that some of the more obvious approaches - that quantum information theory shows us that ultimately the world is made of information, and quantum Bayesianism - fail as philosophical interpretations of quantum mechanics. However, the information-theoretic approach of Clifton, Bub, and Halvorson introduces Einstein's distinction between principle theories and constructive theories, arguing that quantum mechanics is best understood as an information-theoretic principle theory. While I argue that this particular approach fails, it does offer a viable new philosophical role for information theory. Specifically, an investigation of interpretationally successful principle theories such as Newtonian mechanics, special relativity, and general relativity, shows that the particular principles employed are necessary as constitutive elements of a framework which partially defines the basic explanatory concepts of space, time, and motion. Without such constitutive principles as preconditions for empirical meaning, scientific progress is hampered. It is argued that the philosophical issues in quantum mechanics stem from an analogous conceptual crisis. On the basis of this comparison, the best strategy for resolving these problems is to apply a similar sort of conceptual analysis to quantum mechanics so as to provide an appropriate set of constitutive principles clarifying the conceptual issues at stake. It is further argued that quantum information theory is ideally placed as a novel conceptual framework from which to conduct this analysis.
Computation and quantum information [1] are an extension of the information process concept, and they are used for the effects of quantum mechanic [2]. This new scheme provides a work scene that is not restricted to only two operations; on the contrary, this can gain multiple intermediate states as a result of these two ways of superposition. By performing this operation, the system can evaluate all possibilities in only one step by making a parallel computation; meanwhile, in the classic way, this evaluation is carried out independently of each other, and in different steps. The quantum parallelism can be defined as a reduction in time and an increase in the fast of information process. In this chapter, the fundamental elements that make possible to use the mechanical-quantum phenomena as a tool in the process information are presented.
The aim of this dissertation is to clarify the debate over the explanation of quantum speedup and to submit a tentative resolution to it. In particular, I argue that the physical explanation for quantum speedup is precisely the fact that the phenomenon of quantum entanglement enables a quantum computer to fully exploit the representational capacity of Hilbert space. This is impossible for classical systems, joint states of which must always be representable as product states. Chapter 2 begins with a discussion of the most popular of the candidate physical explanations for quantum speedup: the many worlds explanation. I argue that unlike the neo-Everettian interpretation of quantum mechanics it does not have the conceptual resources required to overcome the `preferred basis objection'. I further argue that the many worlds explanation, at best, can serve as a good description of the physical process which takes place in so-called network-based computation, but that it is incompatible with other models of computation such as cluster state quantum computing. I next consider, in Chapter 3, a common component of most other candidate explanations of quantum speedup: quantum entanglement. I investigate whether entanglement can be said to be a necessary component of any explanation for quantum speedup, and I consider two major purported counter-examples to this claim. I argue that neither of these, in fact, show that entanglement is unnecessary for speedup, and that, on the contrary, we should conclude that it is. In Chapters 4 and 5 I then ask whether entanglement can be said to be sufficient as well. In Chapter 4 I argue that despite a result that seems to indicate the contrary, entanglement, considered as a resource, can be seen as sufficient to enable quantum speedup. Finally, in Chapter 5 I argue that entanglement is sufficient to explain quantum speedup as well.
Quantum mechanics led us to reconsider the scope of physics and its building principles, such as the notions of realism and locality. More recently, quantum theory has changed in an equally dramatic manner our understanding of information processing and computation. On one hand, the fundamental properties of quantum systems can be harnessed to transmit, store, and manipulate information in a more efficient and secure way than possible in the realm of classical physics. On the other hand, the development of systematic procedures to manipulate systems of a large number of particles in the quantum regime, crucial to the implementation of quantum-based information processing, has triggered new possibilities in the exploration of quantum many-body physics and related areas. In this thesis, we present new results relevant to two important problems in quantum information science: the development of a theory of entanglement, intrinsically quantum correlations, and the exploration of the use of controlled quantum systems to the computation and simulation of quantum many-body phenomena. In the first part we introduce a new approach to the study of entanglement
This thesis is a study of how information theory can be used to analyse and interpret quantum mechanical systems, specifically, systems that are being used for information processing and communication tasks. Quantum information science is a relatively new field, and it has only been recently that we have started to look at using quantum mechanical systems to accomplish information processing tasks that are not possible using classical systems. As this method of information processing is a relatively new paradigm, there are many possibilities for new algorithms and discoveries in this area of computing. The application of information theory towards the analysis and description of quantum mechanical systems yields new interesting results - it can even be argued that information theory provides a natural and intuitive way to intepret quantum mechanics, as correlations and measurement outcomes in quantum processes can be described using information theory. Chapter 1 is an introduction to the strange new world of quantum mechanics and takes a brief look at one of the applications of quantum information science in quantum cryptography. A mathematical overview of the postulates and framework that quantum mechanics is built on is presented in Chapter 2. Chapter 3 is a brief study of classical information theory and some of the fundamental concepts and ideas that form the crux of the subject. In Chapter 4, we present the main results of the thesis by taking a look at an optimal measurement scheme that improves on previous schemes by allowing us to extract the maximal amount of information from states in a quantum channel of specific geometry. The findings have an impact on various other areas of the field, including security analysis of quantum cryptographic protocols and building better quantum cloning machines.
This thesis is a contribution to the debate on the implications of quantum information theory for the foundations of quantum mechanics. In Part 1, the logical and conceptual status of various notions of information is assessed. It is emphasized that the everyday notion of information is to be firmly distinguished from the technical notions arising in information theory; however it is maintained that in both settings `information' functions as an abstract noun, hence does not refer to a particular or substance (the worth of this point is illustrated in application to quantum teleportation). The claim that `Information is Physical' is assessed and argued to face a destructive dilemma. Accordingly, the slogan may not be understood as an ontological claim, but at best, as a methodological one. The reflections of Bruckner and Zeilinger (2001) and Deutsch and Hayden (2000) on the nature of information in quantum mechanics are critically assessed and some results presented on the characterization of entanglement in the Deutsch-Hayden formalism. Some philosophical aspects of quantum computation are discussed and general morals drawn concerning the nature of quantum information theory. In Part II, following some preliminary remarks, two particular information-theoretic approaches to the foundations of quantum mechanics are assessed in detail. It is argued that Zeilinger's (1999) Foundational Principle is unsuccessful as a foundational principle for quantum mechanics. The information-theoretic characterization theorem of Clifton, Bub and Halvorson (2003) is assessed more favourably, but the generality of the approach is questioned and it is argued that the implications of the theorem for the traditional foundational problems in quantum mechanics remains obscure.