Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Where do the laws of physics come from

V. J. Stenger

Published Nov 1, 2007• 3 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

The laws of physics were not handed down from above. Neither are they rules somehow built into the structure of the universe. They are ingredients of the models that physicists invent to describe observations. Rather than being restrictions on the behavior of matter, the laws of physics are restrictions on the behavior of physicists. If the models of physics are to describe observations based on an objective reality, then those models cannot depend on the point of view of the observer. This suggests a principle of point-of-view invariance that is equivalent to the principle of covariance when applied to space-time. As Noether showed, space-time symmetries lead to the principles of energy, linear momentum, and angular momentum conservation--essentially all of classical mechanics. It also leads to Lorentz invariance and special relativity. When generalized to the abstract space of functions such as the quantum state vector, point-of-view invariance is identified with gauge invariance. Quantum mechanics is then just the mathematics of gauge transformations with no additional assumptions needed to obtain its rules, including the superposition and uncertainty principles. The conservation and quantization of electric charge follow from global gauge invariance. The electromagnetic force is introduced to preserve local gauge invariance. Although not discussed here, the other forces in the standard model of elementary particles are also fields introduced to preserve local gauge invariance. Gravity can also be viewed as such a field. Thus practically all of fundamental physics as we know it follows directly from the single principle of point-of-view invariance.

Related papers

Proposal for a Fundamental Theory of Physics

P. J. van Heerden

The theory is based on a new hypothesis on the nature of matter. This hypothesis is that the elementary particles, atoms, and molecules we have found in nature are not part of the real world, but constitute information about the real world. They are the wave components of a generalized Fourier analysis of our observations (which in the final analysis are always space-time distributions of photon- or particle-counter clicks). This Fourier analysis should be so general that every observation can be expressed in its terms; it thereby becomes axiomatic. Physicists of past generations, with their sound instincts, were intuitively approaching this most general and most powerful possible analysis of our observations. With the discovery of quantum mechanics, this development had advanced so far that the precise formulation of this ultimate analysis could be guessed. The model which can guide us to this mathematical formulation is that of an ideal optical observation on a physical object. This observation is made by illuminating the object with a finite number of laser beams of known amplitude and phase, and observing the amplitude and phase of the finite number of light beams emerging from the object space. The assumption that this is all the information we can ever obtain about the object leads to a wave function of the object which consists of light waves, extrapolated from the photon detectors back to the object space. It is suggested that these light waves should be presented as a product of amplitudes in a $4n$-dimensional space, where $n$ is the number of light quanta in the signal. Most important, force, or interaction, can then be described as a linear transformation in this space. The actual mathematical formalism proposed on the basis of that model is $Xf=\frac{\mathrm{it}df}{\mathrm{dt}}$. $X$ is the Hamiltonian of the whole universe with ${n}_{0}\ensuremath{\cong}{10}^{80}$ particles. It is a $4{n}_{0}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}4{n}_{0}$ linear matrix operator. $f$ is a $4{n}_{0}$-component vector wave function representing waves traveling at the speed of light. The coordinates are the homogeneous coordinates (${x}_{j}, {y}_{j}, {z}_{j}, {u}_{j}$) of the ${n}_{0}$ particles in the closed universe. The eigenvalue $\ensuremath{\omega}$, in $Xf=\ensuremath{\omega}f$, is a $4{n}_{0}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}4{n}_{0}$ Hermitian matrix. It can be divided into ${n}_{0}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{n}_{0}$, 4 \ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{} 4 submatrices, each representing a complete set of dynamic and inertial quantities of elementary particles, or interaction quanta between particles. $\frac{\mathrm{it}df}{\mathrm{dt}}=\ensuremath{\omega}f$ is therefore a complete expression of the dynamic conservation laws. A special orthogonal transformation ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{0}$ transforms the solution into a standard solution with eigenvalue ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$, representing ${n}_{0}$ identical elementary particles. The assumption that the universe is of maximum probability then leads to simple explicit expressions for all matrix elements of ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$. This means that the energy levels of all $n$-particle systems (atoms or molecules) of the theory can be directly calculated. The equations demand relations between cosmological constants and atomic constants. In a universe of the size and mass of our observed universe, the elementary particle would have to be the size of the proton.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Mar 15, 1973•1 citation

Classical Quantum Mechanics

Randell L Mills

Despite its successes, quantum mechanics (QM) has remained mysterious to all who have encountered it. Starting with Bohr and progressing into the present, the departure from intuitive, physical reality has widened. The connection between QM and reality is more than just a “philosophical” issue. It reveals that QM is not a correct or complete theory of the physical world and that inescapable internal inconsistencies and incongruities arise when attempts are made to treat it as physical as opposed to a purely mathematical “tool.” Some of these issues are discussed in a review by F. Laloe [Am. J. Phys. 69, 655 (2001)]. In an attempt to provide some physical insight into atomic problems and starting with the same essential physics as Bohr of e moving in the Coulombic field of the proton and the wave equation as modified by Schrodinger, a classical approach is explored that yields a remarkably accurate model and provides insight into physics on the atomic level. The proverbial view, deeply seated in the wave-particle duality notion, that there is no large-scale physical counterpart to the nature of the electron may not be correct. Physical laws and intuition may be restored when dealing with the wave equation and quantummechanical problems. Specifically, a theory of classical quantum mechanics (CQM) is derived from first principles that successfully applies physical laws on all scales. Rather than using the postulated Schrodinger boundary condition “Ψ → 0 as r → ∞,” which leads to a purely mathematical model of the electron, the constraint is based on experimental observation. Using Maxwell’s equations, the classical wave equation is solved with the constraint that the bound (n = 1)state electron cannot radiate energy. By further application of Maxwell’s equations to electromagnetic and gravitational fields at particle production, the Schwarzschild metric is derived from the classical wave equation, which modifies general relativity to include conservation of spacetime in addition to momentum and matter/energy. The result gives a natural relationship among Maxwell’s equations, special relativity, and general relativity. CQM holds over a scale of spacetime of 85 orders of magnitude — it correctly predicts the nature of the universe from the scale of the quarks to that of the cosmos. A review is given by G. Landvogt [Internat. J. Hydrogen Energy 28, 1155 (2003)].

Physics Essays•Dec 1, 2003•27 citations

On Certain Questions Related to Information and Symmetries - In Physics From Certain View of Philosophy of Science

György Darvas

Introduction My presentation aims at answering a part of the questions posted in the invitation to the session. The questions arose in and originated from the FIS discussion on Physical informatics … in October 2014. No doubt, they were formulated in provocative manner. The goal was to challenge discussion. I plan to illustrate my personal answers with a few examples quoted from the history of 20th c. physics. My answers to the questions are not intended to be enunciations and to provide final solutions, rather they serve as arguments and indicate that nothing is closed, the discussion is open. Methods 1 What do we consider physical information? Can one speak about physical information when there is no live percipient to accept, evaluate and use it? Can one speak about physical information (e.g., signal exchange) between inanimate physical objects (cf., e.g., Feynman diagrams)? And if so, what is it for? Is (physical) information a passive phenomenon, or its existence presumes activity? Interpretation of ‘activity’ plays important role in the possible answers. One of the interpretations says that activity is an antropomorph phenomenon. It is a privilege of the human mind, which is able to perceive and process information, able to teleologically evaluate its possible consequences and (re)act accordingly. Another interpretation says that there is inanimate activity, that means, reception of information between physical agents and their reaction to it. I argue for the latter concept. Let us see the example of the interaction between two (electric) charges. There were two approaches in the classical age of developing these theories (1928-33). When two electric charges interact, there appear two types of interaction. One is a Coulomb-type repulsion/attraction (according to their mutual signs) governed by their scalar potential, and the other is a Lorentz-type one governed by their vector potential depending on their relative velocity to each other. One type of the theories considered first the interaction between the scalar potentials and calculated the effect of the vector potentials as perturbation. It considered two charges approaching to each other from the infinity, when in first approximation they have got information on the amount of the Coulomb charge of the other, but not its velocity and the caused Lorentz force. The latter was considered in the perturbation process. The other type of the theories considered first the effect of the Lorentz force of the approaching charges, and took into consideration the effect of the Coulomb force in course of the perturbation. Representatives of both types of theories agreed that the roles of the interacting electric charges must be symmetrical, but Christian Møller. Møller [7], who belonged to the latter type of theoreticians, applied scattering matrices (1931). He showed that there appeared a component among the matrix elements that was asymmetric in respect to the two interacting charges. H. Bethe (that time a doctoral student of E. Fermi, 1932) could not accept this asymmetry and ‘corrected’ Møller’s theory. He ‘symmetrised’ those matrix elements artificially [1]. That was a rough and unjustified involvement in Møller’s equation, but due to the later attained high authority of both Bethe and Fermi, the physics community accepted the apparently convenient symmetrisation of the theory without discussion and has not treated it until the recent years. Thus any possible distinction between (roles and properties of) interacting charges were unrevealed until the past decade. However, the question can be formulated so: how do the charges, ready to interact, get information from each other? All theories agree that interaction between two charges take place by the exchange of a boson. In case of electromagnetic interaction this boson is a photon. Which of them emits the first photon towards the other? Did this emitter receive any information from the direction of the partner charge prior to the photon emission? What else is this if not an asymmetry between the roles, and possibly between properties of the two interacting charges? The distinction between the interacting charges was introduced by the isotopic field-charge theory, and the notion of ‘isotopic field-charge’ made the distinction between the properties of the two charges [2],[3],[4],[5]. The latter led to the proof of the gauge invariance under rotation of a newly introduced property, the isotopic field-charge spin, in an abstract field, and its conservation. This conservation is a result of a symmetry. Neverthe-less, this mechanism argues for activity between physical objects without an animated (human) agent. 2 What are the limits between (closed and open) systems, from the aspects of information and of symmetries? Further, if so, how wide can we extend the meaning of activity to be still accepted for generating information? What are the roles of different appearances of symmetries in taking a stand in the mentioned questions? What kinds of symmetry (or their absence) may play a role in making decision in the listed problems? The ‘classical’ (20th c.) relativity theories demanded that all physical laws were invariant under the Lorentz transformation. This was established first in the special theory of relativity that was formulated for electromagnetic interactions [6]. Lorentz invariance of physical laws was in fact a symmetry principle (conservation of the form of the laws during reference frame change) [9]. This invariance proved to hold for many other physical laws, so later also the symmetry principle was extended to other physical laws as well. The Lorentz invariant relativity theory included another consequence: there is no distinct (odd) reference frame in nature. In other words, all reference frames are equivalent. Aren’t they? Based on Noether’s theorems [8], one can show that conservation laws hold in all reference frames. However, the quantity of the conserved property (e.g., mass, charge, etc.) may change in the different reference frames. E.g., the amount of mass of matter in a closed system depends on the velocity of the observer relative to that system where the mass is to be measured. One can always find a reference frame from which the amount of the measured mass is minimal. This fact contradicts to the absence of a distinct (odd) reference frame. And there are more. Is there any invariance that compensates this lost equivalence of all reference frames? The observer can be not only a human agent who measures with instruments and reads the records. It can be another inanimate mass that perceives information about the mass from the observed system. Its ‘activity’ is that this information can be obtained by experiencing a force. This force can be gravitational or inertial. According to the general theory of relativity the ‘observer mass’ is unable to make distinction whether the experienced force is of ‘inertial’ or ‘gravitational’ origin. At the same time, the inertial mass changes its value according to its relative velocity to the observer, while the gravitational mass does not. Thus the ‘observer mass’ in different reference frames will experience different inertial forces originating from the ‘observed mass’. Something similar distinction can be made between the Coulomb charges and the Lorentz-type (current) charges. They are sources of the Coulomb force and the Lorentz force, respectively, and similar to the two types of masses, originate from the scalar potential and from the vector potential of the Hamiltonian of the charged object, respectively. The two types of masses and the two types of electric charges are called isotopic field-charge pairs, respectively. They are subject of the same gauge invariance. As such, they can exchange their roles (switch into each other) by the exchange of a gauge boson (in addition to the graviton and the photon, respectively), called delta bosons in the theory. As a consequence of the additional invariance and the corresponding additional mediating gauge boson, the respective systems of the two interacting isotopic field-charges (masses or electric charges) are not subjects of the Lorentz invariance alone. They are subjects of a convolution of the Lorentz- and this additional invariance. One can conclude two things. First, along with the development of physics, there is no more enough to demand invariance under the Lorentz transformation. At extended conditions, one should demand the invariance under a combination of the Lorentz invariance and an additional invariance. In short, we demand invariance under (the applicable) transformations. Secondly, when two charges (let they be either gravitational, electric, or other field-charges) interact, they make a distinction between each other. The system, composed of the interacting two field-charges, follow the Pauli principle. That means, the two interacting field-charges must be in different quantum states. Since this state in which they differ cannot be characterized by any of the earlier known properties, it must be a characteristic of the newly introduced property. It must be one of the two stable positions of the isotopic field-charge that are rotated into each other by the SU(2) symmetry group in the isotopic field-charge field. These two stable positions are called, by an analogically given name, the isotopic field-charge spin (not identical either with the angular momentum spin or the isotopic spin). According to its proven invariance, the isotopic field-charge spin is a conserved property. When two field-charges interact, they must be in the opposite isotopic field-charge spin states. The information that they exchange about each other is about this state: they check whether the partner is in the opposite state. Otherwise they are ‘not allowed’ to interact (Pauli’s exclusion principle). The information exchange takes place by the exchange of a delta boson (called also dion) between them, in addition to the exchange of the traditional mediating bosons (like graviton, photon, weak charged and neutral bosons, or gluons). That delta boson switches the emitting charge from inertial to potential state, and the absorbing charge from potential to inertial state. Conclusions The asymmetry of the interacting charges has been explained. It was subject of information exchange between the interacting particle partners. In order to meet the Pauli principle, physical objects should exchange information about the (opposite) states of each other before getting into active interaction. The explanation led to the loss of an invariance property. However, this loss has been restored by introducing a new physical property (isotopic field-charge spin), by proving its conservation, and completing the Lorentz invariance with the respective invariance attributed to the newly proven conservation. References Bethe, H., Fermi, E., Über die Wechselwirkung von zwei elektronen, Zeitschrift für Physik, 77 (1932), 5-6, 296-306. Darvas, G., The Isotopic Field Charge Spin Assumption, International Journal of Theoretical Physics, 50 (2011), 10, 2961-2991.DOI: 10.1007/s10773-011-0796-9 Darvas, G., The Isotopic Field-Charge Assumption Applied to the Electromagnetic Interaction, Int J Theor Phys, 52 (2013a), 11, 3853-3869, DOI 10.1007/s10773-013-1693-1. Darvas, G., A symmetric adventure beyond the Standard Model – Isotopic field-charge spin conservation in the electromagnetic interaction, Symmetry: Culture and Science, 24 (2013b), 1-4, 17-40. Darvas, G., Electromagnetic Interaction in the Presence of Isotopic Field-Charges and a Kinetic Field, Int J Theor Phys, 53 (2014), 1, 39-51, DOI 10.1007/s10773-013-1781-2. Einstein, A., Zur Elektrodynamik bewegter Körper, Annalen der Physik, 17:891 (1905); English translation: On the electrodynamics of moving bodies, in: The Principle of Relativity, (1923), London: Methuen and Co. Møller, C., Über den Stoß zweier Teilchen unter Berücksichtigung der Retardation der Kräfte, Zeitschrift für Physik, 70 (1931), 11-12, 786-795. Noether, E. A., Invariante Variationsprobleme, Nachrichten von der Königlichen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen: Mathematisch-physikalische Klasse, (1918) 235-257. Wigner, E.P. , Events, laws of nature and invariance principles, pp. 38-50, in: Wigner, Symmetries and Reflections, Bloomington: Indiana University Press (1967).

ISIS Summit: The Information Society at the Crossroads•Jun 30, 2015•0 citations

The road to quantum mechanics

James T. Cushing

The theory of relativity is essentially the culmination of classical physics. Although revisions in our concepts of space and time are necessitated by both the special and general theories of relativity, the notion of causality, in which a cause precedes its effect, remains intact in the relativistic formulations of electrodynamics and mechanics and of gravitation. An upper limit is set on the speed of bodies, and of the propagation of energy, and physical quantities are often defined operationally, but once we adjust ourselves to these new rules, our representations of physical processes proceed pretty much as they did in classical physics. On the other hand, quantum theory seems to require a much more profound philosophical revision of our thought patterns. Even the viability of the usual meaning of a causal connection between one event and another is there called into question.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 29, 1998•0 citations

Quantum Physics

Ernest H. Hutten

Quantum theory has created a fundamental change in our ideas as relativity theory had done before. But while relativity theory is essentially classical in its conceptions—it is in fact the culmination of classical physics—quantum mechanics is founded on some new principles. The quantum laws are very different in character from the laws we find in classical theory. In particular, quantum mechanics is a strictly statistical type of theory : from this arises the different conception of causality that marks the new outlook of modern physics. Classical theory describes the so-called macroscopic phenomena, that is, things and events which are more or less of the same size and kind as we find them in ordinary life; and so a description can be given in terms of concepts close to the ones we use in ordinary language. The language of quantum mechanics is based upon a duality principle ; and most of our ordinary language is equally dualistic.

Routledge eBooks•Dec 7, 2022•0 citations

Causal and Boundary Conditions and CryoBiologiCally sCientifiCs' treating of the living Cells

D. S. Tsvetkov, G. PETROV

The physical fundamental equations describing the absorption and emission of light waves by atoms are symmetric with respect to the sign of the time parameter also the principle of the detail equilibrium is in force – that is, there is no directionality of “time’s arrow” at the microscopic level of this physical phenomena; it is only at the macroscopic level when following Einstein from the macro causality properties of view the irreversible character of time begins to assert itself in the classical sense of the Minkowski space-time, and then for no other reason than probability in the thermodynamically sense by the understanding of his nature. Following this thought it is to remark that the physical phenomena by the light absorption and emission has a relativistic character also the time parameter is not so gut understanding by definition in Minkowski space without Lorenz transformations between the Lorenz manifold’s points of the Lorenz globally geometry whiles the gut understand thermodynamically “time’s arrow” as a physical phenomena is non relativistic and the time is absolutely also the Galileo transformation between the Riemann manifold’s points is in force. All that is connected with the more fine understanding of the symmetry by transformations of the vector valued functional state as the so called super symmetry as by the time inverse connected with the mutuality principles and the principle of detail equilibrium and so as the charge conjugation. For the light propagation in the vacuum at the microscopically level the geometrical understanding of this manifolds is practical from one and the same nature described by local quantum wave fields which was understanding physically very gut as phenomena but not so gut from the so called pure mathematic point of view. Furthermore following the quantum character of the causality properties of the observed physical quantum entities it is clear that the application of the usual mathematic analysis is not more sufficiently to describe this by the help of the fundamental equations. The generalized functions and more special the tempered distributions make possibly the understanding of the nature by those physical phenomena from the mathematical point of view too, e.g. without to consider the set of the zero measures i.e. by Lebesgue’s integrations. The entity of the distributions consist in them that by dropping the knowledge of the function which define the Lebesgue’s zero measure it is possibly to define wide class of generalized functions, included different Dirac δ-functions and his derivations.The real massless photon as a fundamental light quantum particles of the fundamental quantum electromagnetic field is the quantum field vector valued entity of non restrained electric charge of the fundamental relativistic quantum leptons charge field’s systems localized in the so called “strings” in the time like light cone of the Minkowski space coming out from the double cone of definition for the quantum electromagnetic vacuum state. The virtual leptons are the carrier of the electromagnetic field’s energy at the quantum level given by the quantum electromagnetic current and intensity operators. The notion of temporal symmetry in the equations of the quantum interaction between the fundamental particles electrons and photons of the fundamental electron and quantum electromagnetic fields at this level was simply assumed, including the famous Feynman’s diagrams, where the photon is virtual carriers of the interaction’s force between the local quantum currents of those see particles. Then the acausal, atemporal, justification, ignoring: 1) the principle of causality; 2) the time dimension; 3) the gravitational field of matter; 4) the principle of entropy has isregarded the causal, temporal, and local properties of leptons and by implication, all massive particles also all that must be proven anew by the help of the mathematic-physical methods of the theoretical physics. Moreover prove of the causal properties of the Casimir world with given additional boundary conditions are necessary. Than the vacuum is called a physical vacuum and the observed physical entity must fulfilled cinematically conditions (G. Petrov, 1978).For the gravitational field of matter to day is knowing that the aggregate energy represented by the virtual scalar particles, like other forms of energy spectra of the zero fluctuation, could exert a gravitational force, which could be either attractive or repulsive depending on physical principles that are not yet understood, e.g. there are physical phenomena not understanding from the phenomenological point of view. In this case the axiomatic-mathematical physics has his advantages so that we can make predictions for physical phenomena from the point of view of the causality properties of the fine structure of the matter with additional boundary conditions in the global Lorenz geometry induced by the geometry of the Minkowski space-time which describe the special relativistic theory too.By the living cells as an object of the fundamental cryobiological researches i.e. the metabolisms is minimal and also it is possibly by the help of the axiomatically physic-mathematical methods of the relativistic quantum field’s theory to take in the account the problem of a “time’s arrow” at the microscopic level by the contemporary considerations of the quantum vacuum in the Casimir world as a ground state of anyone relativistic quantum system become a fixture by the lyophilized elementary living cells and represented by the symmetrical selfaddjoint Hamiltonian operator taken for simplicity by definition of the quantum scalar fields operator Φ given in the Minkowski space-time. The probability interpretation of his spectral family give as the physical interpretation of the observed entity even for the thermodynamically structure of his ground state, i.e. by the vacuum interactions in the Casimir world, e.g. the Casimir force to day is measured with 5 % exactness. Moreover the Casimir vacuum state may be not belonging in the operator definition domain of the field’s operators, but fulfill the additional causal and boundary conditions for the carrier of the interaction force, the virtual fundamental scalars particles. So also the Casimir vacuum in the asymptotic past at the left of the non moved plate for this case contains from the micro causal point of view the virtual particles for an so one initial observer and in the asymptotic future at the right of this plate and the left of the moved plate the see particles for the late-time observer, e.g. the Maxwell demon, and moreover at the right of the moved plate anew the virtual particles system. Since the 1948 the mathematical description of the so called Casimir world as a part of the physical observed space-time in the relativistic sense is to be considered by the help of the Hamiltonian quantum field’s theory and furthermore it is based on the fine play between the continuity and the discrete too. The axiomatic methods of the local quantum fields theory has given the other possibility then the Lagrange quantum field’s theory and rigorously mathematical way to understand the singularities and the black holes, also the dark energy and the dark matter from one uniformly point of view to describe the fundamental interactions between the anyone concrete fundamental relativistic quantum field system with other someone or with the external and innerness material objects as an external classical fields, material boundaries and everyone internal background. Furthermore it can be set in a Casimir world given by additionally causal and boundary conditions on the Hamiltonian scalar quantum fields system with Banach vector valued one virtual field functional vacuum state and it is element of the so called Hilbert space with infinite metric so also may be not belonging to the definitions domains of the field operators but where they are without perturbation in the set of the symmetrical virtual vacuums and a infinite set of state orbits of Banach vector valued field’s functional states with perturbation by his evolution in the time (oneness and infinity set) e.g. virtual vacuum fluctuations described by the help of the spectral family of the selfaddjoint Hamiltonian operator characterized the mass of the fundamental virtual particles and the vacuum ground state defined on the involutes field’s operators valued algebra on the Hilbert functional spaces with infinite metric in the environment and the innerness between the two parallel plates, non moved and moved with the constant velocity v at the face to the plate at the rest and with the additional causal properties and fulfilled boundary conditions on the plates. The Casimir vacuum is not connected with anyone charge moreover his structure is no more so narrow connected to the structure of the quantum system. The set of the vacuum structure will be obtained by the thermodynamic classical definitions of the Casimir world, i.e. the global structure of the Casimir vacuum state of anyone local quantum field system, e.g. the scalar wave quantum field defined in the Minkowski space-time induced Lorenz global geometry. Also by fulfilling of the following naturally statements defined as early as from the ancient nature-philosophy by Syrian, Egyptian and Grecian in the axiomatically sense of the unity of the opposite entities:1. boundary and infinity2. odd and even 3. oneness and infinity set4. right and left5. manly and womanly6. unmoved and moved7. straight and curve8. light and darkness9. blessing and disguise10. square and parallelogramit is possibly to describe the interacting quantum field’s relativistic systems in the so called Casimir world (boundary and infinity) become a fixture to the environment in living cells and systems from the point of view of the usual axiomatic theory by using the idea of the vacuum as a functional ground state of the axiomatically

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations
The laws of physics were not handed down from above. Neither are they rules somehow built into the structure of the universe. They are ingredients of the models that physicists invent to describe observations. Rather than being restrictions on the behavior of matter, the laws of physics are restrictions on the behavior of physicists. If the models of physics are to describe observations based on an objective reality, then those models cannot depend on the point of view of the observer. This suggests a principle of point-of-view invariance that is equivalent to the principle of covariance when applied to space-time. As Noether showed, space-time symmetries lead to the principles of energy, linear momentum, and angular momentum conservation--essentially all of classical mechanics. It also leads to Lorentz invariance and special relativity. When generalized to the abstract space of functions such as the quantum state vector, point-of-view invariance is identified with gauge invariance. Quantum mechanics is then just the mathematics of gauge transformations with no additional assumptions needed to obtain its rules, including the superposition and uncertainty principles. The conservation and quantization of electric charge follow from global gauge invariance. The electromagnetic force is introduced to preserve local gauge invariance. Although not discussed here, the other forces in the standard model of elementary particles are also fields introduced to preserve local gauge invariance. Gravity can also be viewed as such a field. Thus practically all of fundamental physics as we know it follows directly from the single principle of point-of-view invariance.
The theory is based on a new hypothesis on the nature of matter. This hypothesis is that the elementary particles, atoms, and molecules we have found in nature are not part of the real world, but constitute information about the real world. They are the wave components of a generalized Fourier analysis of our observations (which in the final analysis are always space-time distributions of photon- or particle-counter clicks). This Fourier analysis should be so general that every observation can be expressed in its terms; it thereby becomes axiomatic. Physicists of past generations, with their sound instincts, were intuitively approaching this most general and most powerful possible analysis of our observations. With the discovery of quantum mechanics, this development had advanced so far that the precise formulation of this ultimate analysis could be guessed. The model which can guide us to this mathematical formulation is that of an ideal optical observation on a physical object. This observation is made by illuminating the object with a finite number of laser beams of known amplitude and phase, and observing the amplitude and phase of the finite number of light beams emerging from the object space. The assumption that this is all the information we can ever obtain about the object leads to a wave function of the object which consists of light waves, extrapolated from the photon detectors back to the object space. It is suggested that these light waves should be presented as a product of amplitudes in a 4n4n4n-dimensional space, where nnn is the number of light quanta in the signal. Most important, force, or interaction, can then be described as a linear transformation in this space. The actual mathematical formalism proposed on the basis of that model is Xf=itdfdtXf=\frac{\mathrm{it}df}{\mathrm{dt}}Xf=dtitdf​. XXX is the Hamiltonian of the whole universe with ${n}_{0}\ensuremath{\cong}{10}^{80}$ particles. It is a $4{n}_{0}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}4{n}_{0}$ linear matrix operator. fff is a 4n04{n}_{0}4n0​-component vector wave function representing waves traveling at the speed of light. The coordinates are the homogeneous coordinates (xj,yj,zj,uj{x}_{j}, {y}_{j}, {z}_{j}, {u}_{j}xj​,yj​,zj​,uj​) of the n0{n}_{0}n0​ particles in the closed universe. The eigenvalue $\ensuremath{\omega}$, in $Xf=\ensuremath{\omega}f$, is a $4{n}_{0}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}4{n}_{0}$ Hermitian matrix. It can be divided into ${n}_{0}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{n}_{0}$, 4 \ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{} 4 submatrices, each representing a complete set of dynamic and inertial quantities of elementary particles, or interaction quanta between particles. $\frac{\mathrm{it}df}{\mathrm{dt}}=\ensuremath{\omega}f$ is therefore a complete expression of the dynamic conservation laws. A special orthogonal transformation ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{0}$ transforms the solution into a standard solution with eigenvalue ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$, representing n0{n}_{0}n0​ identical elementary particles. The assumption that the universe is of maximum probability then leads to simple explicit expressions for all matrix elements of ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$. This means that the energy levels of all nnn-particle systems (atoms or molecules) of the theory can be directly calculated. The equations demand relations between cosmological constants and atomic constants. In a universe of the size and mass of our observed universe, the elementary particle would have to be the size of the proton.
Despite its successes, quantum mechanics (QM) has remained mysterious to all who have encountered it. Starting with Bohr and progressing into the present, the departure from intuitive, physical reality has widened. The connection between QM and reality is more than just a “philosophical” issue. It reveals that QM is not a correct or complete theory of the physical world and that inescapable internal inconsistencies and incongruities arise when attempts are made to treat it as physical as opposed to a purely mathematical “tool.” Some of these issues are discussed in a review by F. Laloe [Am. J. Phys. 69, 655 (2001)]. In an attempt to provide some physical insight into atomic problems and starting with the same essential physics as Bohr of e moving in the Coulombic field of the proton and the wave equation as modified by Schrodinger, a classical approach is explored that yields a remarkably accurate model and provides insight into physics on the atomic level. The proverbial view, deeply seated in the wave-particle duality notion, that there is no large-scale physical counterpart to the nature of the electron may not be correct. Physical laws and intuition may be restored when dealing with the wave equation and quantummechanical problems. Specifically, a theory of classical quantum mechanics (CQM) is derived from first principles that successfully applies physical laws on all scales. Rather than using the postulated Schrodinger boundary condition “Ψ → 0 as r → ∞,” which leads to a purely mathematical model of the electron, the constraint is based on experimental observation. Using Maxwell’s equations, the classical wave equation is solved with the constraint that the bound (n = 1)state electron cannot radiate energy. By further application of Maxwell’s equations to electromagnetic and gravitational fields at particle production, the Schwarzschild metric is derived from the classical wave equation, which modifies general relativity to include conservation of spacetime in addition to momentum and matter/energy. The result gives a natural relationship among Maxwell’s equations, special relativity, and general relativity. CQM holds over a scale of spacetime of 85 orders of magnitude — it correctly predicts the nature of the universe from the scale of the quarks to that of the cosmos. A review is given by G. Landvogt [Internat. J. Hydrogen Energy 28, 1155 (2003)].
Introduction My presentation aims at answering a part of the questions posted in the invitation to the session. The questions arose in and originated from the FIS discussion on Physical informatics … in October 2014. No doubt, they were formulated in provocative manner. The goal was to challenge discussion. I plan to illustrate my personal answers with a few examples quoted from the history of 20th c. physics. My answers to the questions are not intended to be enunciations and to provide final solutions, rather they serve as arguments and indicate that nothing is closed, the discussion is open. Methods 1 What do we consider physical information? Can one speak about physical information when there is no live percipient to accept, evaluate and use it? Can one speak about physical information (e.g., signal exchange) between inanimate physical objects (cf., e.g., Feynman diagrams)? And if so, what is it for? Is (physical) information a passive phenomenon, or its existence presumes activity? Interpretation of ‘activity’ plays important role in the possible answers. One of the interpretations says that activity is an antropomorph phenomenon. It is a privilege of the human mind, which is able to perceive and process information, able to teleologically evaluate its possible consequences and (re)act accordingly. Another interpretation says that there is inanimate activity, that means, reception of information between physical agents and their reaction to it. I argue for the latter concept. Let us see the example of the interaction between two (electric) charges. There were two approaches in the classical age of developing these theories (1928-33). When two electric charges interact, there appear two types of interaction. One is a Coulomb-type repulsion/attraction (according to their mutual signs) governed by their scalar potential, and the other is a Lorentz-type one governed by their vector potential depending on their relative velocity to each other. One type of the theories considered first the interaction between the scalar potentials and calculated the effect of the vector potentials as perturbation. It considered two charges approaching to each other from the infinity, when in first approximation they have got information on the amount of the Coulomb charge of the other, but not its velocity and the caused Lorentz force. The latter was considered in the perturbation process. The other type of the theories considered first the effect of the Lorentz force of the approaching charges, and took into consideration the effect of the Coulomb force in course of the perturbation. Representatives of both types of theories agreed that the roles of the interacting electric charges must be symmetrical, but Christian Møller. Møller [7], who belonged to the latter type of theoreticians, applied scattering matrices (1931). He showed that there appeared a component among the matrix elements that was asymmetric in respect to the two interacting charges. H. Bethe (that time a doctoral student of E. Fermi, 1932) could not accept this asymmetry and ‘corrected’ Møller’s theory. He ‘symmetrised’ those matrix elements artificially [1]. That was a rough and unjustified involvement in Møller’s equation, but due to the later attained high authority of both Bethe and Fermi, the physics community accepted the apparently convenient symmetrisation of the theory without discussion and has not treated it until the recent years. Thus any possible distinction between (roles and properties of) interacting charges were unrevealed until the past decade. However, the question can be formulated so: how do the charges, ready to interact, get information from each other? All theories agree that interaction between two charges take place by the exchange of a boson. In case of electromagnetic interaction this boson is a photon. Which of them emits the first photon towards the other? Did this emitter receive any information from the direction of the partner charge prior to the photon emission? What else is this if not an asymmetry between the roles, and possibly between properties of the two interacting charges? The distinction between the interacting charges was introduced by the isotopic field-charge theory, and the notion of ‘isotopic field-charge’ made the distinction between the properties of the two charges [2],[3],[4],[5]. The latter led to the proof of the gauge invariance under rotation of a newly introduced property, the isotopic field-charge spin, in an abstract field, and its conservation. This conservation is a result of a symmetry. Neverthe-less, this mechanism argues for activity between physical objects without an animated (human) agent. 2 What are the limits between (closed and open) systems, from the aspects of information and of symmetries? Further, if so, how wide can we extend the meaning of activity to be still accepted for generating information? What are the roles of different appearances of symmetries in taking a stand in the mentioned questions? What kinds of symmetry (or their absence) may play a role in making decision in the listed problems? The ‘classical’ (20th c.) relativity theories demanded that all physical laws were invariant under the Lorentz transformation. This was established first in the special theory of relativity that was formulated for electromagnetic interactions [6]. Lorentz invariance of physical laws was in fact a symmetry principle (conservation of the form of the laws during reference frame change) [9]. This invariance proved to hold for many other physical laws, so later also the symmetry principle was extended to other physical laws as well. The Lorentz invariant relativity theory included another consequence: there is no distinct (odd) reference frame in nature. In other words, all reference frames are equivalent. Aren’t they? Based on Noether’s theorems [8], one can show that conservation laws hold in all reference frames. However, the quantity of the conserved property (e.g., mass, charge, etc.) may change in the different reference frames. E.g., the amount of mass of matter in a closed system depends on the velocity of the observer relative to that system where the mass is to be measured. One can always find a reference frame from which the amount of the measured mass is minimal. This fact contradicts to the absence of a distinct (odd) reference frame. And there are more. Is there any invariance that compensates this lost equivalence of all reference frames? The observer can be not only a human agent who measures with instruments and reads the records. It can be another inanimate mass that perceives information about the mass from the observed system. Its ‘activity’ is that this information can be obtained by experiencing a force. This force can be gravitational or inertial. According to the general theory of relativity the ‘observer mass’ is unable to make distinction whether the experienced force is of ‘inertial’ or ‘gravitational’ origin. At the same time, the inertial mass changes its value according to its relative velocity to the observer, while the gravitational mass does not. Thus the ‘observer mass’ in different reference frames will experience different inertial forces originating from the ‘observed mass’. Something similar distinction can be made between the Coulomb charges and the Lorentz-type (current) charges. They are sources of the Coulomb force and the Lorentz force, respectively, and similar to the two types of masses, originate from the scalar potential and from the vector potential of the Hamiltonian of the charged object, respectively. The two types of masses and the two types of electric charges are called isotopic field-charge pairs, respectively. They are subject of the same gauge invariance. As such, they can exchange their roles (switch into each other) by the exchange of a gauge boson (in addition to the graviton and the photon, respectively), called delta bosons in the theory. As a consequence of the additional invariance and the corresponding additional mediating gauge boson, the respective systems of the two interacting isotopic field-charges (masses or electric charges) are not subjects of the Lorentz invariance alone. They are subjects of a convolution of the Lorentz- and this additional invariance. One can conclude two things. First, along with the development of physics, there is no more enough to demand invariance under the Lorentz transformation. At extended conditions, one should demand the invariance under a combination of the Lorentz invariance and an additional invariance. In short, we demand invariance under (the applicable) transformations. Secondly, when two charges (let they be either gravitational, electric, or other field-charges) interact, they make a distinction between each other. The system, composed of the interacting two field-charges, follow the Pauli principle. That means, the two interacting field-charges must be in different quantum states. Since this state in which they differ cannot be characterized by any of the earlier known properties, it must be a characteristic of the newly introduced property. It must be one of the two stable positions of the isotopic field-charge that are rotated into each other by the SU(2) symmetry group in the isotopic field-charge field. These two stable positions are called, by an analogically given name, the isotopic field-charge spin (not identical either with the angular momentum spin or the isotopic spin). According to its proven invariance, the isotopic field-charge spin is a conserved property. When two field-charges interact, they must be in the opposite isotopic field-charge spin states. The information that they exchange about each other is about this state: they check whether the partner is in the opposite state. Otherwise they are ‘not allowed’ to interact (Pauli’s exclusion principle). The information exchange takes place by the exchange of a delta boson (called also dion) between them, in addition to the exchange of the traditional mediating bosons (like graviton, photon, weak charged and neutral bosons, or gluons). That delta boson switches the emitting charge from inertial to potential state, and the absorbing charge from potential to inertial state. Conclusions The asymmetry of the interacting charges has been explained. It was subject of information exchange between the interacting particle partners. In order to meet the Pauli principle, physical objects should exchange information about the (opposite) states of each other before getting into active interaction. The explanation led to the loss of an invariance property. However, this loss has been restored by introducing a new physical property (isotopic field-charge spin), by proving its conservation, and completing the Lorentz invariance with the respective invariance attributed to the newly proven conservation. References Bethe, H., Fermi, E., Über die Wechselwirkung von zwei elektronen, Zeitschrift für Physik, 77 (1932), 5-6, 296-306. Darvas, G., The Isotopic Field Charge Spin Assumption, International Journal of Theoretical Physics, 50 (2011), 10, 2961-2991.DOI: 10.1007/s10773-011-0796-9 Darvas, G., The Isotopic Field-Charge Assumption Applied to the Electromagnetic Interaction, Int J Theor Phys, 52 (2013a), 11, 3853-3869, DOI 10.1007/s10773-013-1693-1. Darvas, G., A symmetric adventure beyond the Standard Model – Isotopic field-charge spin conservation in the electromagnetic interaction, Symmetry: Culture and Science, 24 (2013b), 1-4, 17-40. Darvas, G., Electromagnetic Interaction in the Presence of Isotopic Field-Charges and a Kinetic Field, Int J Theor Phys, 53 (2014), 1, 39-51, DOI 10.1007/s10773-013-1781-2. Einstein, A., Zur Elektrodynamik bewegter Körper, Annalen der Physik, 17:891 (1905); English translation: On the electrodynamics of moving bodies, in: The Principle of Relativity, (1923), London: Methuen and Co. Møller, C., Über den Stoß zweier Teilchen unter Berücksichtigung der Retardation der Kräfte, Zeitschrift für Physik, 70 (1931), 11-12, 786-795. Noether, E. A., Invariante Variationsprobleme, Nachrichten von der Königlichen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen: Mathematisch-physikalische Klasse, (1918) 235-257. Wigner, E.P. , Events, laws of nature and invariance principles, pp. 38-50, in: Wigner, Symmetries and Reflections, Bloomington: Indiana University Press (1967).
The theory of relativity is essentially the culmination of classical physics. Although revisions in our concepts of space and time are necessitated by both the special and general theories of relativity, the notion of causality, in which a cause precedes its effect, remains intact in the relativistic formulations of electrodynamics and mechanics and of gravitation. An upper limit is set on the speed of bodies, and of the propagation of energy, and physical quantities are often defined operationally, but once we adjust ourselves to these new rules, our representations of physical processes proceed pretty much as they did in classical physics. On the other hand, quantum theory seems to require a much more profound philosophical revision of our thought patterns. Even the viability of the usual meaning of a causal connection between one event and another is there called into question.
Quantum theory has created a fundamental change in our ideas as relativity theory had done before. But while relativity theory is essentially classical in its conceptions—it is in fact the culmination of classical physics—quantum mechanics is founded on some new principles. The quantum laws are very different in character from the laws we find in classical theory. In particular, quantum mechanics is a strictly statistical type of theory : from this arises the different conception of causality that marks the new outlook of modern physics. Classical theory describes the so-called macroscopic phenomena, that is, things and events which are more or less of the same size and kind as we find them in ordinary life; and so a description can be given in terms of concepts close to the ones we use in ordinary language. The language of quantum mechanics is based upon a duality principle ; and most of our ordinary language is equally dualistic.
The physical fundamental equations describing the absorption and emission of light waves by atoms are symmetric with respect to the sign of the time parameter also the principle of the detail equilibrium is in force – that is, there is no directionality of “time’s arrow” at the microscopic level of this physical phenomena; it is only at the macroscopic level when following Einstein from the macro causality properties of view the irreversible character of time begins to assert itself in the classical sense of the Minkowski space-time, and then for no other reason than probability in the thermodynamically sense by the understanding of his nature. Following this thought it is to remark that the physical phenomena by the light absorption and emission has a relativistic character also the time parameter is not so gut understanding by definition in Minkowski space without Lorenz transformations between the Lorenz manifold’s points of the Lorenz globally geometry whiles the gut understand thermodynamically “time’s arrow” as a physical phenomena is non relativistic and the time is absolutely also the Galileo transformation between the Riemann manifold’s points is in force. All that is connected with the more fine understanding of the symmetry by transformations of the vector valued functional state as the so called super symmetry as by the time inverse connected with the mutuality principles and the principle of detail equilibrium and so as the charge conjugation. For the light propagation in the vacuum at the microscopically level the geometrical understanding of this manifolds is practical from one and the same nature described by local quantum wave fields which was understanding physically very gut as phenomena but not so gut from the so called pure mathematic point of view. Furthermore following the quantum character of the causality properties of the observed physical quantum entities it is clear that the application of the usual mathematic analysis is not more sufficiently to describe this by the help of the fundamental equations. The generalized functions and more special the tempered distributions make possibly the understanding of the nature by those physical phenomena from the mathematical point of view too, e.g. without to consider the set of the zero measures i.e. by Lebesgue’s integrations. The entity of the distributions consist in them that by dropping the knowledge of the function which define the Lebesgue’s zero measure it is possibly to define wide class of generalized functions, included different Dirac δ-functions and his derivations.The real massless photon as a fundamental light quantum particles of the fundamental quantum electromagnetic field is the quantum field vector valued entity of non restrained electric charge of the fundamental relativistic quantum leptons charge field’s systems localized in the so called “strings” in the time like light cone of the Minkowski space coming out from the double cone of definition for the quantum electromagnetic vacuum state. The virtual leptons are the carrier of the electromagnetic field’s energy at the quantum level given by the quantum electromagnetic current and intensity operators. The notion of temporal symmetry in the equations of the quantum interaction between the fundamental particles electrons and photons of the fundamental electron and quantum electromagnetic fields at this level was simply assumed, including the famous Feynman’s diagrams, where the photon is virtual carriers of the interaction’s force between the local quantum currents of those see particles. Then the acausal, atemporal, justification, ignoring: 1) the principle of causality; 2) the time dimension; 3) the gravitational field of matter; 4) the principle of entropy has isregarded the causal, temporal, and local properties of leptons and by implication, all massive particles also all that must be proven anew by the help of the mathematic-physical methods of the theoretical physics. Moreover prove of the causal properties of the Casimir world with given additional boundary conditions are necessary. Than the vacuum is called a physical vacuum and the observed physical entity must fulfilled cinematically conditions (G. Petrov, 1978).For the gravitational field of matter to day is knowing that the aggregate energy represented by the virtual scalar particles, like other forms of energy spectra of the zero fluctuation, could exert a gravitational force, which could be either attractive or repulsive depending on physical principles that are not yet understood, e.g. there are physical phenomena not understanding from the phenomenological point of view. In this case the axiomatic-mathematical physics has his advantages so that we can make predictions for physical phenomena from the point of view of the causality properties of the fine structure of the matter with additional boundary conditions in the global Lorenz geometry induced by the geometry of the Minkowski space-time which describe the special relativistic theory too.By the living cells as an object of the fundamental cryobiological researches i.e. the metabolisms is minimal and also it is possibly by the help of the axiomatically physic-mathematical methods of the relativistic quantum field’s theory to take in the account the problem of a “time’s arrow” at the microscopic level by the contemporary considerations of the quantum vacuum in the Casimir world as a ground state of anyone relativistic quantum system become a fixture by the lyophilized elementary living cells and represented by the symmetrical selfaddjoint Hamiltonian operator taken for simplicity by definition of the quantum scalar fields operator Φ given in the Minkowski space-time. The probability interpretation of his spectral family give as the physical interpretation of the observed entity even for the thermodynamically structure of his ground state, i.e. by the vacuum interactions in the Casimir world, e.g. the Casimir force to day is measured with 5 % exactness. Moreover the Casimir vacuum state may be not belonging in the operator definition domain of the field’s operators, but fulfill the additional causal and boundary conditions for the carrier of the interaction force, the virtual fundamental scalars particles. So also the Casimir vacuum in the asymptotic past at the left of the non moved plate for this case contains from the micro causal point of view the virtual particles for an so one initial observer and in the asymptotic future at the right of this plate and the left of the moved plate the see particles for the late-time observer, e.g. the Maxwell demon, and moreover at the right of the moved plate anew the virtual particles system. Since the 1948 the mathematical description of the so called Casimir world as a part of the physical observed space-time in the relativistic sense is to be considered by the help of the Hamiltonian quantum field’s theory and furthermore it is based on the fine play between the continuity and the discrete too. The axiomatic methods of the local quantum fields theory has given the other possibility then the Lagrange quantum field’s theory and rigorously mathematical way to understand the singularities and the black holes, also the dark energy and the dark matter from one uniformly point of view to describe the fundamental interactions between the anyone concrete fundamental relativistic quantum field system with other someone or with the external and innerness material objects as an external classical fields, material boundaries and everyone internal background. Furthermore it can be set in a Casimir world given by additionally causal and boundary conditions on the Hamiltonian scalar quantum fields system with Banach vector valued one virtual field functional vacuum state and it is element of the so called Hilbert space with infinite metric so also may be not belonging to the definitions domains of the field operators but where they are without perturbation in the set of the symmetrical virtual vacuums and a infinite set of state orbits of Banach vector valued field’s functional states with perturbation by his evolution in the time (oneness and infinity set) e.g. virtual vacuum fluctuations described by the help of the spectral family of the selfaddjoint Hamiltonian operator characterized the mass of the fundamental virtual particles and the vacuum ground state defined on the involutes field’s operators valued algebra on the Hilbert functional spaces with infinite metric in the environment and the innerness between the two parallel plates, non moved and moved with the constant velocity v at the face to the plate at the rest and with the additional causal properties and fulfilled boundary conditions on the plates. The Casimir vacuum is not connected with anyone charge moreover his structure is no more so narrow connected to the structure of the quantum system. The set of the vacuum structure will be obtained by the thermodynamic classical definitions of the Casimir world, i.e. the global structure of the Casimir vacuum state of anyone local quantum field system, e.g. the scalar wave quantum field defined in the Minkowski space-time induced Lorenz global geometry. Also by fulfilling of the following naturally statements defined as early as from the ancient nature-philosophy by Syrian, Egyptian and Grecian in the axiomatically sense of the unity of the opposite entities:1. boundary and infinity2. odd and even 3. oneness and infinity set4. right and left5. manly and womanly6. unmoved and moved7. straight and curve8. light and darkness9. blessing and disguise10. square and parallelogramit is possibly to describe the interacting quantum field’s relativistic systems in the so called Casimir world (boundary and infinity) become a fixture to the environment in living cells and systems from the point of view of the usual axiomatic theory by using the idea of the vacuum as a functional ground state of the axiomatically