Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Decoherence and Dynamical Decoupling in Solid-State Spin Qubits

Wayne M. Witzel

Published Apr 26, 2007• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This dissertation is a study of the decoherence of a solid-state spin qubit, either that of a localized electron spin or a donor nucleus, caused by a nuclear spin bath relevant to semiconductor quantum computer architectures. In the presence of an external magnetic field and at low temperatures, the dominant decoherence mechanism is the spectral diffusion of the qubit spin resonance frequency due to the temporally fluctuating random magnetic field associated with the dipolar interaction induced flip-flops of nuclear spin pairs. The qubit spin dephasing due to this random magnetic field depends intricately on the quantum dynamics of the nuclear spin bath, making the coupled decoherence problem difficult to solve. We provide a formally exact solution of this non-Markovian quantum decoherence problem which numerically calculates accurate spin decoherence at short times, of particular relevance in solid-state spin quantum computer architectures. A quantum cluster expansion method is motivated, developed, and tested for the spectral diffusion problem. The method is applicable to any ideal pulse sequence applied to the qubit. Dynamical decoupling sequences, which aim to prolong qubit coherence, are analyzed. In particular, concatenated dynamical decoupling sequences are shown to prolong not only the coherence time over the entire sequence but also the length of time between pulses necessary to maintain coherence. This is shown to result from successive low-order cancellations in applicable perturbative expansions with each level of concatenation. Each cancellation, however, will require the inclusion, in the cluster expansion, of increasingly large clusters to obtain the lowest-order results. These larger clusters in the lowest order often dominate decoherence and therefore invalidate, as being overly optimistic, the pair approximation as a means to study the effect of concatenated dynamical decoupling. We present numerical results from our cluster expansion technique for echoes of single (Hahn), concatenated, and periodic pulse sequences using realistic models of a localized electron in phosphorus doped Si and in a GaAs quantum dot and of a P donor nucleus in Si or GaAs. In the Si:P electron spin decoherence problem, we consider, along with spectral diffusion, the effects of anisotropic hyperfine (AHF) interactions and suggest a technique to suppress electron spin echo envelope modulations (ESEEM), an additional source of decoherence resulting from the AHF interactions. Our calculations for the Si:P Hahn echoes, including the effects of both anisotropic hyperfine interactions and spectral diffusion, are in excellent agreement with experimental results. Our calculations of concatenated pulse sequence echoes offer important predictions for the effectiveness of a promising strategy to preserve qubit coherence in semiconductor quantum computer architectures.

Related papers

Concatenated dynamical decoupling in a solid-state spin bath

Wayne M. Witzel, S. Das Sarma

Concatenated dynamical decoupling (CDD) pulse sequences hold much promise as a strategy to mitigate decoherence in quantum information processing. It is important to investigate the actual performance of these dynamical decoupling strategies in real systems that are promising qubit candidates. In this Rapid Communication, we compute the echo decay of concatenations of the Hahn echo sequence for a solid-state electronic spin qubit in a nuclear spin bath using a cluster expansion technique. We find that each level of concatenation reverses the effect of successive levels of intrabath fluctuations. On the one hand, this advances CDD as a versatile and realistic decoupling strategy. On the other hand, this invalidates, as overly optimistic, results of the simple pair approximation used previously to study restoration, through CDD, of coherence lost to a mesoscopic spin bath.

arXiv:0707.1037•Physical Review B•Dec 13, 2007•71 citations

Suppression of electron spin decoherence in a quantum dot

Wenxian Zhang, V. V. Dobrovitski, Lea f. Santos +2 more

The dominant source of decoherence for an electron spin in a quantum dot is the hyperfine interaction with the surrounding bath of nuclear spins. The decoherence process may be slowed down by subjecting the electron spin to suitable sequences of external control pulses. We investigate the performance of a variety of dynamical decoupling protocols using exact numerical simulation. Emphasis is given to realistic pulse delays and the long-time limit, beyond the domain where available analytical approaches are guaranteed to work. Our results show that both deterministic and randomized protocols are capable to significantly prolong the electron coherence time, even when using control pulse separations substantially larger than what expected from the upper cutoff frequency of the coupling spectrum between the electron and the nuclear spins. In a realistic parameter range, the total width of such a coupling spectrum appears to be the physically relevant frequency scale affecting the overall quality of the decoupling.

arXiv:cond-mat/0703453•Journal of Modern Optics•Nov 10, 2007•12 citations

Quantum-Bath Decoherence of Hybrid Electron-Nuclear Spin Qubits

S. J. Balian

A major problem facing the realisation of scalable solid-state quantum computing is that of overcoming decoherence - the process whereby phase information encoded in a qubit is lost as the qubit interacts with its environment. Due to the vast number of environmental degrees of freedom, it is challenging to accurately calculate decoherence times $T_2$, especially when the qubit and environment are highly correlated. Hybrid or mixed electron-nuclear spin qubits, such as donors in silicon, possess 'optimal working points' (OWPs) which are sweet-spots for reduced decoherence in magnetic fields. Analysis of sharp variations of $T_2$ near OWPs was previously based on insensitivity to classical noise, even though hybrid qubits are situated in highly correlated quantum environments, such as the nuclear spin bath of $^{29}$Si impurities. This presented limited understanding of the decoherence mechanism and gave unreliable predictions for $T_2$. I present quantum many-body calculations of the qubit-bath dynamics, which (i) yield $T_2$ for hybrid qubits in excellent agreement with experiments in multiple regimes, (ii) elucidate the many-body nature of the nuclear spin bath and (iii) expose significant differences between quantum-bath and classical-field decoherence. To achieve these, the cluster correlation expansion was adapted to include electron-nuclear state mixing. In addition, an analysis supported by experiment was carried out to characterise the nuclear spin bath for a bismuth donor as the hybrid qubit, a simple analytical formula for $T_2$ was derived with predictions in agreement with experiment, and the established method of dynamical decoupling was combined with operating near OWPs in order to maximise $T_2$. Finally, the decoherence of a $^{29}$Si spin in proximity to the hybrid qubit was studied, in order to establish the feasibility for its use as a quantum register.

arXiv:1510.08944•Oct 30, 2015•3 citations

Phenomenological study of decoherence in solid-state spin qubits due to nuclear spin diffusion

Michael J. Biercuk, Hendrik Bluhm

We present a study of the prospects for coherence preservation in solid-state spin qubits using dynamical decoupling protocols. Recent experiments have provided the first demonstrations of multipulse dynamical decoupling sequences in this qubit system, but quantitative analyses of potential coherence improvements have been hampered by a lack of concrete knowledge of the relevant noise processes. We present calculations of qubit coherence under the application of arbitrary dynamical decoupling pulse sequences based on an experimentally validated semiclassical model. This phenomenological approach bundles the details of underlying noise processes into a single experimentally relevant noise power spectral density. Our results show that the dominant features of experimental measurements in a two-electron singlet-triplet spin qubit can be replicated using a $1/{\ensuremath{\omega}}^{2}$ noise power spectrum associated with nuclear spin flips in the host material. Beginning with this validation, we address the effects of nuclear programming, high-frequency nuclear spin dynamics, and other high-frequency classical noise sources, with conjectures supported by physical arguments and microscopic calculations where relevant. Our results provide expected performance bounds and identify diagnostic metrics that can be measured experimentally in order to better elucidate the underlying nuclear spin dynamics.

arXiv:1101.5189•Physical Review B•Jun 10, 2011•23 citations

Study of Electron Spin Dynamics of Phosphorus-Doped Silicon

곽민찬

Quantum information stored in a quantum bit (qubit), basic element of quantum computation, is fragile to interaction with environments, and disappears with time. To overcome this, quantum error correction technique has been studied and it is known that, if a given requirement is satisfied, it is possible to perform fault-tolerant quantum computation. The requirement is that the number of physical qubits should be able to increase arbitrarily and the error probability per each gate operation should be smaller than a certain level (10^-4-10^-6). Kanes silicon-based quantum computer, suggested to satisfy the severe requirement of quantum error correction, has attracted particular attention as a promising candidate for practical quantum computer. Regarding this, relatively short coherence time of electron spins in silicon, compared to that of 31P nuclear spins, is a key factor for reliable quantum computation. Previous researches focused on decreasing density of impurities (donor and 29Si) in silicon to increase coherence time of electron spins. However, considering that the speed of two-qubit operation is proportional to exchange constant (J) between electron spins, research for a sample with high donor density is necessary.\nIn this study, electron spin resonance experiments were performed for dielectric Si:P with the donor density of 6.52E16 /cc and 1.1E17 /cc to investigate electron spin dynamics in silicon. Based on the measured relaxation times for electron spins, their relevant mechanisms were elucidated. Furthermore, it was verified if electron spin coherence can be preserved long enough, to satisfy the requirement for fault-tolerant quantum computation, by dynamical decoupling technique. To obtain information for dynamics of single electron spin from measurements on bulk sample, the effect of field inhomogeneity due to 29Si nuclei in silicon was dealt with by spin echo technique, which utilizes refocusing (π) pulse.\nFor the given experimental condition, the dominant mechanisms for decoherence of electron spins are estimated to be instantaneous diffusion and (29Si) nuclear-induced spectral diffusion. The measured time constants for each mechanism are 0.9 ms (TID) and 0.26 ms (TSD), respectively. Instantaneous diffusion arises when dipolar-coupled electron spins are simultaneously flipped by an applied microwave pulse. The theoretical formula for TID agrees with previous experimental results obtained for low donor densities, but shows large discrepancy with our result (TID,theory~0.02 ms). This can be explained qualitatively by the fact that as donor density increases, the number of exchange-coupled spin pairs, which have exchange constant (J) larger than hyperfine interaction (A) between 31P and electron, also increases. Meanwhile, spectral diffusion arises when local magnetic field at a resonant spin fluctuates due to lattice-related flips of nearby spins or dipolar flip-flops of nearby spins. By comparing our results of TSD with previous results, it is shown that inhomogeneous field due to the presence of 29Si nuclei suppresses electron-induced spectral diffusion so that (29Si) nuclear-induced spectral diffusion becomes dominant.\nIn our results of dynamical decoupling experiment to suppress spectral diffusion, the theoretically driven optimal DD sequence (UDD) outperforms the conventional equidistant sequence (PDD) especially at short times, often called high-fidelity regime. This regime is important in quantum error correction and thus these results show that dynamical decoupling can take an important role in quantum computation. From the measured echo decay using UDD with four refocusing pulses, the time taken for error probability to be 10-6 is estimated to be about 0.13 ms and this value is comparable to the limit of gate operation time due to the limit of current pulse generation technology.

•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations

Dynamical control of electron spin coherence in a quantum dot: A theoretical study

Wenxian Zhang, V. V. Dobrovitski, Léa Ferreira dos Santos +2 more

We investigate the performance of dynamical decoupling methods at suppressing electron spin decoherence from a low-temperature nuclear spin reservoir in a quantum dot. The controlled dynamics is studied through exact numerical simulation, with emphasis on realistic pulse delays and the long-time limit. Our results show that optimal performance for this system is attained by a periodic protocol exploiting concatenated design, with control rates substantially slower than expected from the upper spectral cutoff of the bath. For a known initial electron spin state, coherence can saturate at long times, signaling the creation of a stable ``spin-locked'' decoherence-free subspace. Analytical insight into saturation is obtained for a simple echo protocol, in good agreement with numerical results.

arXiv:cond-mat/0701507•Physical Review B•May 17, 2007•55 citations
This dissertation is a study of the decoherence of a solid-state spin qubit, either that of a localized electron spin or a donor nucleus, caused by a nuclear spin bath relevant to semiconductor quantum computer architectures. In the presence of an external magnetic field and at low temperatures, the dominant decoherence mechanism is the spectral diffusion of the qubit spin resonance frequency due to the temporally fluctuating random magnetic field associated with the dipolar interaction induced flip-flops of nuclear spin pairs. The qubit spin dephasing due to this random magnetic field depends intricately on the quantum dynamics of the nuclear spin bath, making the coupled decoherence problem difficult to solve. We provide a formally exact solution of this non-Markovian quantum decoherence problem which numerically calculates accurate spin decoherence at short times, of particular relevance in solid-state spin quantum computer architectures. A quantum cluster expansion method is motivated, developed, and tested for the spectral diffusion problem. The method is applicable to any ideal pulse sequence applied to the qubit. Dynamical decoupling sequences, which aim to prolong qubit coherence, are analyzed. In particular, concatenated dynamical decoupling sequences are shown to prolong not only the coherence time over the entire sequence but also the length of time between pulses necessary to maintain coherence. This is shown to result from successive low-order cancellations in applicable perturbative expansions with each level of concatenation. Each cancellation, however, will require the inclusion, in the cluster expansion, of increasingly large clusters to obtain the lowest-order results. These larger clusters in the lowest order often dominate decoherence and therefore invalidate, as being overly optimistic, the pair approximation as a means to study the effect of concatenated dynamical decoupling. We present numerical results from our cluster expansion technique for echoes of single (Hahn), concatenated, and periodic pulse sequences using realistic models of a localized electron in phosphorus doped Si and in a GaAs quantum dot and of a P donor nucleus in Si or GaAs. In the Si:P electron spin decoherence problem, we consider, along with spectral diffusion, the effects of anisotropic hyperfine (AHF) interactions and suggest a technique to suppress electron spin echo envelope modulations (ESEEM), an additional source of decoherence resulting from the AHF interactions. Our calculations for the Si:P Hahn echoes, including the effects of both anisotropic hyperfine interactions and spectral diffusion, are in excellent agreement with experimental results. Our calculations of concatenated pulse sequence echoes offer important predictions for the effectiveness of a promising strategy to preserve qubit coherence in semiconductor quantum computer architectures.
Concatenated dynamical decoupling (CDD) pulse sequences hold much promise as a strategy to mitigate decoherence in quantum information processing. It is important to investigate the actual performance of these dynamical decoupling strategies in real systems that are promising qubit candidates. In this Rapid Communication, we compute the echo decay of concatenations of the Hahn echo sequence for a solid-state electronic spin qubit in a nuclear spin bath using a cluster expansion technique. We find that each level of concatenation reverses the effect of successive levels of intrabath fluctuations. On the one hand, this advances CDD as a versatile and realistic decoupling strategy. On the other hand, this invalidates, as overly optimistic, results of the simple pair approximation used previously to study restoration, through CDD, of coherence lost to a mesoscopic spin bath.
The dominant source of decoherence for an electron spin in a quantum dot is the hyperfine interaction with the surrounding bath of nuclear spins. The decoherence process may be slowed down by subjecting the electron spin to suitable sequences of external control pulses. We investigate the performance of a variety of dynamical decoupling protocols using exact numerical simulation. Emphasis is given to realistic pulse delays and the long-time limit, beyond the domain where available analytical approaches are guaranteed to work. Our results show that both deterministic and randomized protocols are capable to significantly prolong the electron coherence time, even when using control pulse separations substantially larger than what expected from the upper cutoff frequency of the coupling spectrum between the electron and the nuclear spins. In a realistic parameter range, the total width of such a coupling spectrum appears to be the physically relevant frequency scale affecting the overall quality of the decoupling.
A major problem facing the realisation of scalable solid-state quantum computing is that of overcoming decoherence - the process whereby phase information encoded in a qubit is lost as the qubit interacts with its environment. Due to the vast number of environmental degrees of freedom, it is challenging to accurately calculate decoherence times T2T_2T2​, especially when the qubit and environment are highly correlated. Hybrid or mixed electron-nuclear spin qubits, such as donors in silicon, possess 'optimal working points' (OWPs) which are sweet-spots for reduced decoherence in magnetic fields. Analysis of sharp variations of T2T_2T2​ near OWPs was previously based on insensitivity to classical noise, even though hybrid qubits are situated in highly correlated quantum environments, such as the nuclear spin bath of 29^{29}29Si impurities. This presented limited understanding of the decoherence mechanism and gave unreliable predictions for T2T_2T2​. I present quantum many-body calculations of the qubit-bath dynamics, which (i) yield T2T_2T2​ for hybrid qubits in excellent agreement with experiments in multiple regimes, (ii) elucidate the many-body nature of the nuclear spin bath and (iii) expose significant differences between quantum-bath and classical-field decoherence. To achieve these, the cluster correlation expansion was adapted to include electron-nuclear state mixing. In addition, an analysis supported by experiment was carried out to characterise the nuclear spin bath for a bismuth donor as the hybrid qubit, a simple analytical formula for T2T_2T2​ was derived with predictions in agreement with experiment, and the established method of dynamical decoupling was combined with operating near OWPs in order to maximise T2T_2T2​. Finally, the decoherence of a 29^{29}29Si spin in proximity to the hybrid qubit was studied, in order to establish the feasibility for its use as a quantum register.
We present a study of the prospects for coherence preservation in solid-state spin qubits using dynamical decoupling protocols. Recent experiments have provided the first demonstrations of multipulse dynamical decoupling sequences in this qubit system, but quantitative analyses of potential coherence improvements have been hampered by a lack of concrete knowledge of the relevant noise processes. We present calculations of qubit coherence under the application of arbitrary dynamical decoupling pulse sequences based on an experimentally validated semiclassical model. This phenomenological approach bundles the details of underlying noise processes into a single experimentally relevant noise power spectral density. Our results show that the dominant features of experimental measurements in a two-electron singlet-triplet spin qubit can be replicated using a $1/{\ensuremath{\omega}}^{2}$ noise power spectrum associated with nuclear spin flips in the host material. Beginning with this validation, we address the effects of nuclear programming, high-frequency nuclear spin dynamics, and other high-frequency classical noise sources, with conjectures supported by physical arguments and microscopic calculations where relevant. Our results provide expected performance bounds and identify diagnostic metrics that can be measured experimentally in order to better elucidate the underlying nuclear spin dynamics.
Quantum information stored in a quantum bit (qubit), basic element of quantum computation, is fragile to interaction with environments, and disappears with time. To overcome this, quantum error correction technique has been studied and it is known that, if a given requirement is satisfied, it is possible to perform fault-tolerant quantum computation. The requirement is that the number of physical qubits should be able to increase arbitrarily and the error probability per each gate operation should be smaller than a certain level (10^-4-10^-6). Kanes silicon-based quantum computer, suggested to satisfy the severe requirement of quantum error correction, has attracted particular attention as a promising candidate for practical quantum computer. Regarding this, relatively short coherence time of electron spins in silicon, compared to that of 31P nuclear spins, is a key factor for reliable quantum computation. Previous researches focused on decreasing density of impurities (donor and 29Si) in silicon to increase coherence time of electron spins. However, considering that the speed of two-qubit operation is proportional to exchange constant (J) between electron spins, research for a sample with high donor density is necessary.\nIn this study, electron spin resonance experiments were performed for dielectric Si:P with the donor density of 6.52E16 /cc and 1.1E17 /cc to investigate electron spin dynamics in silicon. Based on the measured relaxation times for electron spins, their relevant mechanisms were elucidated. Furthermore, it was verified if electron spin coherence can be preserved long enough, to satisfy the requirement for fault-tolerant quantum computation, by dynamical decoupling technique. To obtain information for dynamics of single electron spin from measurements on bulk sample, the effect of field inhomogeneity due to 29Si nuclei in silicon was dealt with by spin echo technique, which utilizes refocusing (π) pulse.\nFor the given experimental condition, the dominant mechanisms for decoherence of electron spins are estimated to be instantaneous diffusion and (29Si) nuclear-induced spectral diffusion. The measured time constants for each mechanism are 0.9 ms (TID) and 0.26 ms (TSD), respectively. Instantaneous diffusion arises when dipolar-coupled electron spins are simultaneously flipped by an applied microwave pulse. The theoretical formula for TID agrees with previous experimental results obtained for low donor densities, but shows large discrepancy with our result (TID,theory~0.02 ms). This can be explained qualitatively by the fact that as donor density increases, the number of exchange-coupled spin pairs, which have exchange constant (J) larger than hyperfine interaction (A) between 31P and electron, also increases. Meanwhile, spectral diffusion arises when local magnetic field at a resonant spin fluctuates due to lattice-related flips of nearby spins or dipolar flip-flops of nearby spins. By comparing our results of TSD with previous results, it is shown that inhomogeneous field due to the presence of 29Si nuclei suppresses electron-induced spectral diffusion so that (29Si) nuclear-induced spectral diffusion becomes dominant.\nIn our results of dynamical decoupling experiment to suppress spectral diffusion, the theoretically driven optimal DD sequence (UDD) outperforms the conventional equidistant sequence (PDD) especially at short times, often called high-fidelity regime. This regime is important in quantum error correction and thus these results show that dynamical decoupling can take an important role in quantum computation. From the measured echo decay using UDD with four refocusing pulses, the time taken for error probability to be 10-6 is estimated to be about 0.13 ms and this value is comparable to the limit of gate operation time due to the limit of current pulse generation technology.
We investigate the performance of dynamical decoupling methods at suppressing electron spin decoherence from a low-temperature nuclear spin reservoir in a quantum dot. The controlled dynamics is studied through exact numerical simulation, with emphasis on realistic pulse delays and the long-time limit. Our results show that optimal performance for this system is attained by a periodic protocol exploiting concatenated design, with control rates substantially slower than expected from the upper spectral cutoff of the bath. For a known initial electron spin state, coherence can saturate at long times, signaling the creation of a stable ``spin-locked'' decoherence-free subspace. Analytical insight into saturation is obtained for a simple echo protocol, in good agreement with numerical results.