Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

ESI lectures in mathematics and physics

The debate between Hendrik A. Lorentz and Schrödinger on wave mechanics

Anne J. Kox

Published Apr 11, 2013• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

In 1923 the Austrian Erwin Schrödinger, professor of physics in Zurich, and his Dutch colleague Hendrik Lorentz, grand old man of classical physics, engaged in a fascinating correspondence on the foundations of quantum physics. In this lecture I will go back to that year, give a sketch of the personalities of Lorentz and Schrödinger and of their respective careers, and explain the importance for the history of physics of their remarkable exchange of ideas.

DOI
10.4171/121-1/8

Related papers

Schrödinger and wave mechanics

Malcolm S. Longair

On 13 March 1926, the first of six papers on wave mechanics by Erwin Schrödinger was published in the Annalen der Physik with the title Quantisation as an eigenvalue problem (Part 1) (Schrödinger, 1926b). The startling first paragraph reads: ‘In this paper, I wish to consider, first, the simple case of the hydrogen atom (nonrelativistic and unperturbed), and show that the customary quantum conditions can be replaced by another postulate, in which the concept of “whole numbers”, merely as such, is not introduced. Rather, when integralness does appear, it arises in the same natural way as it does in the case of node-numbers of a vibrating string. The new conception is capable of generalisation, and strikes, I believe, very deeply at the true nature of quantum rules.’ These papers were the fruits of an extraordinary burst of creativity on Schrödinger's part which resulted from his interactions with Einstein in the latter part of 1925. Central to these exchanges were de Broglie's remarkable researches which culminated in his famous PhD dissertation and published papers of 1924. These events have already be recounted in Chap. 9. The subsequent developments which led to Schrödinger's discovery of the equation which bears his name will be taken up in Sect. 14.2, but let us first understand more about Schrödinger's background. Schrödinger's background in physics and mathematics Education and career up to 1925 Unlike Heisenberg, Jordan, Pauli and Dirac, Erwin Schrödinger was not one of the young Turks who developed Knabenphysik , young man's physics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 31, 2013•0 citations

Introduction

Clive W. Kilmister

This book describes the many aspects of the life and scientific work of Erwin Schrödinger, who, perhaps more than anyone else, serves to represent the whole of modern physics. The contributions to the book are from many hands, and so it seemed useful to me to precede them with a short note giving an uncontroversial account of his life which will serve as a framework into which they can be fitted. Such a collection as this still leaves out many aspects of Schrödinger's thought, for it considers his philosophy only in passing, his poetry not at all and ignores his wide and deep interest in sculpture and painting and in the classics. Schrödinger was born in Vienna on August 12, 1887, and entered the University there to read physics in 1906. He worked there as an assistant from 1910 till his war service, and again after the war. Some short term appointments at Jena, Stuttgart and Breslau led up to his appointment to the chair of theoretical physics in Zürich in 1921. He was already treating a wide range of topics, but concentrating on atomic theory, for the old quantum theory had now entered on its heroic phase of final collapse. His six papers founding wave mechanics came at the end of his Zürich years, and in 1927 he went to the chair in Berlin, to remain there till the advent of Hitler in 1933.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 2, 1987•2 citations

Schrödinger and the genesis of wave mechanics

Jürgen Renn

In the context of a new analysis of the notebooks of Erwin Schrödinger, the paper deals with the question of the relation between Schrödinger's creation of wave mechanics and the contemporary efforts by Werner Heisenberg and his colleagues to establish a new quantum mechanics. How can one explain, from a broader historical and epistemological perspective, the astonishing simultaneity and complementarity of these discoveries? The paper argues that neither the physical problems with which both approaches deal nor what ultimately turned out to be their common mathematical ground are sufficient to explain their complementarity. Instead, their closeness is explained by analyzing their common roots in classical mechanics and its transformation in the light of the most fundamental new quantum law, the relation between energy and frequency found by Planck. It is shown, in particular, that for both approaches a bridge between quantum and classical aspects involving this relation was crucial. In the case of Heisenberg, this bridge was given by Bohr’s correspondence principle. In the case of Schrödinger it was constituted by Hamilton’s optical-mechanical analogy.

ESI lectures in mathematics and physics•Apr 11, 2013•18 citations

Hendrik Antoon Lorentz’s struggle with quantum theory

Anne J. Kox

A historical overview is given of the contributions of Hendrik Antoon Lorentz in quantum theory. Although especially his early work is valuable, the main importance of Lorentz’s work lies in the conceptual clarifications he provided and in his critique of the foundations of quantum theory.

Archive for History of Exact Sciences•Jul 23, 2012•36 citations

Erwin Schrödinger and the Rise of Wave Mechanics I: Schrödinger's Scientific Work Before the Creation of Wave Mechanics

This article is in three parts. Part I gives an account of Erwin Schrödinger's growing up and studies in Vienna, his scientific work — first in Vienna from 1911 to 1920, then in Zurich from 1920 to 1925 — on the dielectric properties of matter, atmospheric electricity and radioactivity, general relativity, color theory and physiological optics, and on kinetic theory and statistical mechanics. Part II deals with the creation of the theory of wave mechanics by Schrö;dinger in Zurich during the early months of 1926; he laid the foundations of this theory in his first two communications to Annalen der Physik. Part III deals with the early applications of wave mechanics to atomic problems — including the demonstration of equivalence of wave mechanics with the quantum mechanics of Born, Heisenberg, and Jordan, and that of Dirac — by Schrödinger himself and others. The new theory was immediately accepted by the scientific community.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Feb 1, 2001•0 citations

Erwin Schrödinger and the Rise of Wave Mechanics II: The Creation of Wave Mechanics

This article (Part II) deals with the creation of the theory of wave mechanics by Erwin Schrödinger in Zurich during the early months of 1926; he laid the foundations of this theory in his first two communications to Annalen der Physik . The background of Shrödinger's work on, and his actual creation of, wave mechanics are analyzed.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Feb 1, 2001•0 citations
In 1923 the Austrian Erwin Schrödinger, professor of physics in Zurich, and his Dutch colleague Hendrik Lorentz, grand old man of classical physics, engaged in a fascinating correspondence on the foundations of quantum physics. In this lecture I will go back to that year, give a sketch of the personalities of Lorentz and Schrödinger and of their respective careers, and explain the importance for the history of physics of their remarkable exchange of ideas.
On 13 March 1926, the first of six papers on wave mechanics by Erwin Schrödinger was published in the Annalen der Physik with the title Quantisation as an eigenvalue problem (Part 1) (Schrödinger, 1926b). The startling first paragraph reads: ‘In this paper, I wish to consider, first, the simple case of the hydrogen atom (nonrelativistic and unperturbed), and show that the customary quantum conditions can be replaced by another postulate, in which the concept of “whole numbers”, merely as such, is not introduced. Rather, when integralness does appear, it arises in the same natural way as it does in the case of node-numbers of a vibrating string. The new conception is capable of generalisation, and strikes, I believe, very deeply at the true nature of quantum rules.’ These papers were the fruits of an extraordinary burst of creativity on Schrödinger's part which resulted from his interactions with Einstein in the latter part of 1925. Central to these exchanges were de Broglie's remarkable researches which culminated in his famous PhD dissertation and published papers of 1924. These events have already be recounted in Chap. 9. The subsequent developments which led to Schrödinger's discovery of the equation which bears his name will be taken up in Sect. 14.2, but let us first understand more about Schrödinger's background. Schrödinger's background in physics and mathematics Education and career up to 1925 Unlike Heisenberg, Jordan, Pauli and Dirac, Erwin Schrödinger was not one of the young Turks who developed Knabenphysik , young man's physics.
This book describes the many aspects of the life and scientific work of Erwin Schrödinger, who, perhaps more than anyone else, serves to represent the whole of modern physics. The contributions to the book are from many hands, and so it seemed useful to me to precede them with a short note giving an uncontroversial account of his life which will serve as a framework into which they can be fitted. Such a collection as this still leaves out many aspects of Schrödinger's thought, for it considers his philosophy only in passing, his poetry not at all and ignores his wide and deep interest in sculpture and painting and in the classics. Schrödinger was born in Vienna on August 12, 1887, and entered the University there to read physics in 1906. He worked there as an assistant from 1910 till his war service, and again after the war. Some short term appointments at Jena, Stuttgart and Breslau led up to his appointment to the chair of theoretical physics in Zürich in 1921. He was already treating a wide range of topics, but concentrating on atomic theory, for the old quantum theory had now entered on its heroic phase of final collapse. His six papers founding wave mechanics came at the end of his Zürich years, and in 1927 he went to the chair in Berlin, to remain there till the advent of Hitler in 1933.
In the context of a new analysis of the notebooks of Erwin Schrödinger, the paper deals with the question of the relation between Schrödinger's creation of wave mechanics and the contemporary efforts by Werner Heisenberg and his colleagues to establish a new quantum mechanics. How can one explain, from a broader historical and epistemological perspective, the astonishing simultaneity and complementarity of these discoveries? The paper argues that neither the physical problems with which both approaches deal nor what ultimately turned out to be their common mathematical ground are sufficient to explain their complementarity. Instead, their closeness is explained by analyzing their common roots in classical mechanics and its transformation in the light of the most fundamental new quantum law, the relation between energy and frequency found by Planck. It is shown, in particular, that for both approaches a bridge between quantum and classical aspects involving this relation was crucial. In the case of Heisenberg, this bridge was given by Bohr’s correspondence principle. In the case of Schrödinger it was constituted by Hamilton’s optical-mechanical analogy.
This article is in three parts. Part I gives an account of Erwin Schrödinger's growing up and studies in Vienna, his scientific work — first in Vienna from 1911 to 1920, then in Zurich from 1920 to 1925 — on the dielectric properties of matter, atmospheric electricity and radioactivity, general relativity, color theory and physiological optics, and on kinetic theory and statistical mechanics. Part II deals with the creation of the theory of wave mechanics by Schrö;dinger in Zurich during the early months of 1926; he laid the foundations of this theory in his first two communications to Annalen der Physik. Part III deals with the early applications of wave mechanics to atomic problems — including the demonstration of equivalence of wave mechanics with the quantum mechanics of Born, Heisenberg, and Jordan, and that of Dirac — by Schrödinger himself and others. The new theory was immediately accepted by the scientific community.