Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Nontrivial systems and the necessity of the scalar quantum mechanics axioms

Jan Kotůlek

Published Jun 1, 2009• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

We discuss the necessity of the axioms of scalar quantum mechanics introduced by Paschke and clearly demonstrate their geometric and/or physical meaning. We show that reasonable nonrelativistic quantum mechanics is exactly specified by the axioms. A system describing the electric Aharonov–Bohm effect is presented. It illustrates the topological obstructions for the existence of a Hamiltonian.

DOI
10.1063/1.3133887

Related papers

Three attempts at two axioms for quantum mechanics

Daniel Rohrlich

The axioms of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics lack clear physical meaning. In particular, they say nothing about nonlocality. Yet quantum mechanics is not only nonlocal, it is twice nonlocal: there are nonlocal quantum correlations, and there is the Aharonov-Bohm effect, which implies that an electric or magnetic field h e r e may act on an electron t h e r e. Can we invert the logical hierarchy? That is, can we adopt nonlocality as an axiom for quantum mechanics and derive quantum mechanics from this axiom and an additional axiom of causality? Three versions of these two axioms lead to three different theories, characterized by "maximal nonlocal correlations", "jamming" and "modular energy". Where is quantum mechanics in these theories?

arXiv:1011.5322•Nov 24, 2010•4 citations

Is quantum mechanics exact?

Anton Kapustin

We formulate physically motivated axioms for a physical theory which for systems with a finite number of degrees of freedom uniquely lead to quantum mechanics as the only nontrivial consistent theory. Complex numbers and the existence of the Planck constant common to all systems arise naturally in this approach. The axioms are divided into two groups covering kinematics and basic measurement theory, respectively. We show that even if the second group of axioms is dropped, there are no deformations of quantum mechanics which preserve the kinematic axioms. Thus, any theory going beyond quantum mechanics must represent a radical departure from the usual a priori assumptions about the laws of nature.

arXiv:1303.6917•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jun 1, 2013•29 citations

Can elementary quantum mechanics explain the Aharonov–Bohm effect?

C. Magni, Fausto Valz-Gris

It is shown that a satisfactory treatment of the Aharonov–Bohm problem requires no departure from the basic principles of ordinary quantum mechanics, a fact not entirely clear in the literature. The discussion ends up with the same formalism as originally proposed by Aharonov and Bohm, in agreement with experimental facts, although in a way that forces no alteration in the traditional interpretation of vector potentials.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 1995•26 citations

Topological effects of Aharonov-Bohm type and the role of the quantum entanglement

Hasan Özgür Çıldıroğlu, A. U. Yilmazer

The state of two or more particle systems in quantum mechanics is generally expressed as linear superpositions of tensor products of discrete states; and entanglement is connected to the superpositions that cannot be expressed by a single tensor product. On the other hand a discussion of nonlocality is always present in quantum entanglement and furthermore this nonlocality may be revealed via entanglement in the cases of the topological effects in quantum mechanics. In this work, aiming a more systematic and a complementary framework we focus on a comparison of the topological effects of Aharonov-Bohm type whose roots seem to be common. In this context, we will discuss the roles of three topological effects on an entangled quantum mechanical system.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2018•4 citations

Posljedice neseparabilnosti kvantno-mehaničkih valnih funkcija

Comay, Eliahu

An analysis based upon fundamental properties of quantum mechanics shows that the electric Aharonov-Bohm effect does not exist. This conclusion is not incompatible with experiment. The significance of the nonseparable nature of quantum mechanical wave functions is discussed.

•Jan 1, 1987•0 citations

2. Basic quantum physics

Arnold Neumaier

Quantum physics consists of a formal core that is universally agreed upon (basically being a piece of mathematics with suggestive names for concepts matching related concepts of experimental culture) and an interpretational halo (trying to make this relation more precise) that remains highly disputed even after more than 90 years of modern quantum physics. The latter is the subject of the interpretation of quantum mechanics (see Part II), where many interpretations coexist and compete for the attention of those interested in what quantum physics really means. In this chapter, an axiomatic introduction to the undisputed formal core of quantum physics is given. The axioms described present nonrelativistic quantum statistical mechanics in the Schrödinger picture. The relativistic case is outside the scope of these axioms, as it must be treated by quantum field theory; see Chapter 7. As in any axiomatic setting (necessary for a formal discipline), there are a number of different but equivalent sets of axioms or postulates that can be used to define formal quantum physics. Since they are equivalent, their choice is a matter of convenience. The choice presented here is a formulation featuring three aspects: It emphasises the similarity of quantum mechanics and classical mechanics, gives most direct access to statistical mechanics, and is free from allusions to measurement. The reason for the first is that this similarity serves as a guide to meaning. From the axiomatic setting for quantum mechanics presented below, classical mechanics (in the Koopman setting discussed in Section 7.10) is obtained by simply restricting the operators to be diagonal, so that all operations happen pointwise on the diagonal elements. Thus, multiplication is commutative, and one can identify operators and functions. In particular, the density operator degenerates into a probability density. Therefore, the quantum case appears as a generalization of the classical case allowing for noncommutativity, so that both q-observables and the density operator are (usually infinite-dimensional) operators. The reason for the second is that statistical mechanics is the main tool for applications of quantum physics to the macroscopic systems we are familiar with. The reason for the third is that realistic measurements constitute a complex process involving macroscopic detectors, hence should be explained by quantum statistical mechanics rather than be part of the axiomatic foundations themselves. (This is in marked contrast to other foundations, and distinguishes the present system of axioms.)

De Gruyter eBooks•Oct 24, 2019•0 citations
We discuss the necessity of the axioms of scalar quantum mechanics introduced by Paschke and clearly demonstrate their geometric and/or physical meaning. We show that reasonable nonrelativistic quantum mechanics is exactly specified by the axioms. A system describing the electric Aharonov–Bohm effect is presented. It illustrates the topological obstructions for the existence of a Hamiltonian.
The axioms of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics lack clear physical meaning. In particular, they say nothing about nonlocality. Yet quantum mechanics is not only nonlocal, it is twice nonlocal: there are nonlocal quantum correlations, and there is the Aharonov-Bohm effect, which implies that an electric or magnetic field h e r e may act on an electron t h e r e. Can we invert the logical hierarchy? That is, can we adopt nonlocality as an axiom for quantum mechanics and derive quantum mechanics from this axiom and an additional axiom of causality? Three versions of these two axioms lead to three different theories, characterized by "maximal nonlocal correlations", "jamming" and "modular energy". Where is quantum mechanics in these theories?
We formulate physically motivated axioms for a physical theory which for systems with a finite number of degrees of freedom uniquely lead to quantum mechanics as the only nontrivial consistent theory. Complex numbers and the existence of the Planck constant common to all systems arise naturally in this approach. The axioms are divided into two groups covering kinematics and basic measurement theory, respectively. We show that even if the second group of axioms is dropped, there are no deformations of quantum mechanics which preserve the kinematic axioms. Thus, any theory going beyond quantum mechanics must represent a radical departure from the usual a priori assumptions about the laws of nature.
The state of two or more particle systems in quantum mechanics is generally expressed as linear superpositions of tensor products of discrete states; and entanglement is connected to the superpositions that cannot be expressed by a single tensor product. On the other hand a discussion of nonlocality is always present in quantum entanglement and furthermore this nonlocality may be revealed via entanglement in the cases of the topological effects in quantum mechanics. In this work, aiming a more systematic and a complementary framework we focus on a comparison of the topological effects of Aharonov-Bohm type whose roots seem to be common. In this context, we will discuss the roles of three topological effects on an entangled quantum mechanical system.
Quantum physics consists of a formal core that is universally agreed upon (basically being a piece of mathematics with suggestive names for concepts matching related concepts of experimental culture) and an interpretational halo (trying to make this relation more precise) that remains highly disputed even after more than 90 years of modern quantum physics. The latter is the subject of the interpretation of quantum mechanics (see Part II), where many interpretations coexist and compete for the attention of those interested in what quantum physics really means. In this chapter, an axiomatic introduction to the undisputed formal core of quantum physics is given. The axioms described present nonrelativistic quantum statistical mechanics in the Schrödinger picture. The relativistic case is outside the scope of these axioms, as it must be treated by quantum field theory; see Chapter 7. As in any axiomatic setting (necessary for a formal discipline), there are a number of different but equivalent sets of axioms or postulates that can be used to define formal quantum physics. Since they are equivalent, their choice is a matter of convenience. The choice presented here is a formulation featuring three aspects: It emphasises the similarity of quantum mechanics and classical mechanics, gives most direct access to statistical mechanics, and is free from allusions to measurement. The reason for the first is that this similarity serves as a guide to meaning. From the axiomatic setting for quantum mechanics presented below, classical mechanics (in the Koopman setting discussed in Section 7.10) is obtained by simply restricting the operators to be diagonal, so that all operations happen pointwise on the diagonal elements. Thus, multiplication is commutative, and one can identify operators and functions. In particular, the density operator degenerates into a probability density. Therefore, the quantum case appears as a generalization of the classical case allowing for noncommutativity, so that both q-observables and the density operator are (usually infinite-dimensional) operators. The reason for the second is that statistical mechanics is the main tool for applications of quantum physics to the macroscopic systems we are familiar with. The reason for the third is that realistic measurements constitute a complex process involving macroscopic detectors, hence should be explained by quantum statistical mechanics rather than be part of the axiomatic foundations themselves. (This is in marked contrast to other foundations, and distinguishes the present system of axioms.)