Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Numerical simulation of the ZNG equations

Allan Griffin, Tetsuro Nikuni, E. Zaremba

Published Feb 19, 2009• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this chapter we describe the numerical methods that can be used to solve the ZNG equations in the context of a dynamical simulation. These equations consist of a generalized GP equation (3.21) for the condensate and a Boltzmann equation (3.42) for the thermal component. The fact that the two equations are coupled makes their numerical solution more complex than when either is considered on its own. Indeed, the distinct quantum and classical aspects of the problem require specifically tailored numerical methods. Although most of these methods are well established and described elsewhere (Taha and Ablowitz, 1984; Sanz-Serna and Calvo, 1994), we provide in this chapter a detailed pedagogical discussion that will serve as a guide to those interested in carrying out such calculations for trapped Bose gases. This chapter is based on the papers of Jackson and Zaremba (2002a,b). There are two main parts to the numerical problem. The first is developing a method for solving the time-dependent GP equation for an arbitrary three-dimensional geometry. This we take up in Section 11.1. Second, a method is needed for solving the Boltzmann equation that accounts for the dynamics of the thermal component. Here one must deal both with the Hamiltonian dynamics of the thermal atoms, as they move in the self-consistent mean field of the condensate and thermal cloud, and with the collisions that take place between the thermal atoms themselves (the C 22 collisions) and between the thermal atoms and the condensate (the C 12 collisions). The methods used to account for these two distinct collisional processes are taken up in Section 11.3. As we shall see, collisions play an important role and cannot be neglected even when the dynamical behaviour is dominated by mean-field interactions.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511575150.012

Related papers

A Dynamical Self-Consistent Finite-Temperature Kinetic Theory: The ZNG Scheme

A. Joy Allen, Carlo F. Barenghi, Nick P. Proukakis +1 more

We review a self-consistent scheme for modelling trapped weakly-interacting quantum gases at temperatures where the condensate coexists with a significant thermal cloud. This method has been applied to atomic gases by Zaremba, Nikuni, and Griffin, and is often referred to as ZNG. It describes both mean-field-dominated and hydrodynamic regimes, except at very low temperatures or in the regime of large fluctuations. Condensate dynamics are described by a dissipative Gross-Pitaevskii equation (or the corresponding quantum hydrodynamic equation with a source term), while the non-condensate evolution is represented by a quantum Boltzmann equation, which additionally includes collisional processes which transfer atoms between these two subsystems. In the mean-field-dominated regime collisions are treated perturbatively and the full distribution function is needed to describe the thermal cloud, while in the hydrodynamic regime the system is parametrised in terms of a set of local variables. Applications to finite temperature induced damping of collective modes and vortices in the mean-field-dominated regime are presented.

arXiv:1206.0145•Cold atoms•Mar 18, 2013•5 citations

Coupled equations for the condensate and thermal cloud

Allan Griffin, Tetsuro Nikuni, E. Zaremba

In contrast with Chapter 2, in this chapter we include the dynamics of the thermal cloud. As noted in Chapter 1, we treat the noncondensate atoms using the simplest microscopic model approximation that captures the important physics. In particular, we consider only temperatures high enough ( T ≥ 0.4 T BEC ) that the noncondensate atoms can be described by a particle-like Hartree–Fock (HF) spectrum. To extend the analysis to very low temperatures is in principle straightforward (see Chapter 7). However, the details are more complicated since the excitations of the thermal cloud take on a collective aspect (i.e. a Bogoliubov-type quasiparticle spectrum must be used). In trapped Bose gases, the HF single-particle spectrum gives a good approximation down to much lower temperatures than in the case of uniform Bose gases, as first emphasized by Giorgini et al . (1997). In Section 3.1, we derive a generalized form of the Gross–Pitaevskii equation for the Bose order parameter Φ( r , t ) that is valid at finite temperatures. It involves terms that are coupled to the noncondensate component (the thermal cloud) and thus its solution in general requires one to know the equations of motion for the dynamics of the noncondensate atoms. In Section 3.2 we restrict ourselves to finite temperatures high enough that the noncondensate atoms can be described by a quantum kinetic equation for the single-particle distribution function f ( p, r , t ). A detailed microscopic derivation of this kind of kinetic equation is given in Chapters 6 and 7 using the Kadanoff–Baym Green's function formalism. A characteristic feature of a Bose-condensed gas is that the kinetic equation governing f ( p, r , t ) involves a collision integral C 12 [ f , Φ] describing collisions between condensate and noncondensate atoms.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 19, 2009•0 citations

Dynamical Simulations of Trapped Bose Gases at Finite Temperatures

Jackson, B., E. Zaremba

In this paper, we develop a numerical procedure for investigating the dynamics of trapped Bose gases based on the ZGN theory. The dynamical equations used consist of a generalized Gross-Pitaevskii equation for the condensate order parameter and a semiclassical kinetic equation for the thermal cloud. The former is solved using a fast Fourier transform split-operator technique while the Boltzmann equation is treated by means of N-body simulations. The two components are coupled by mean fields as well as collisional processes that transfer atoms between the two. This scheme has been applied to a model equilibration problem, dipole oscillations in isotropic traps and scissors modes in anisotropic traps. In the case of the latter, the frequencies and damping rates of the condensate mode have been extracted from the simulations for a wide range of temperatures. Good agreement with recent experiments has been found.

arXiv:cond-mat/0106652•Jun 29, 2001•4 citations

Transport coefficients and relaxation times

Allan Griffin, Tetsuro Nikuni, E. Zaremba

In Chapter 17, we derived two-fluid hydrodynamic equations that include damping related to transport coefficients. Our entire analysis was based on the coupled ZNG equations for the condensate and in the thermal cloud. These involved a generalized GP equation for the condensate and a kinetic equation for the thermal atoms. A crucial role is played by the C12 collision term in the kinetic equation, which describes the interactions between atoms in the condensate and in the thermal cloud.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 19, 2009•0 citations

Green's functions and self-energy approximations

Allan Griffin, Tetsuro Nikuni, E. Zaremba

In Chapter 3, we introduced a simple but reasonable approximation for the nonequilibrium dynamics of a Bose-condensed gas based on a generalized GP equation coupled to a kinetic equation. In Chapters 4–7, we turn to the question of how to derive such coupled equations for the condensate and noncondensate components in a way that gives a deeper understanding of the ZNG theory. Chapters 4–7 involve an introduction to Green's functions and field theoretic techniques for nonequilibrium problems. These provide the natural language and formalism to deal with the many subtle aspects of a Bose-condensed gas at finite temperatures. These four chapters are fairly technical. This chapter is mainly based on Kadanoff and Baym (1962) and Imamović-Tomasović (2001). Readers who are not interested in these questions can go straight to Chapter 8, which begins the discussion of applications of the ZNG coupled equations given in Chapter 3.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 19, 2009•0 citations

Simulation of collective modes at finite temperature

Allan Griffin, Tetsuro Nikuni, E. Zaremba

In this chapter we present several dynamical simulations that make use of the numerical methods discussed in the previous chapter. Some of these are model simulations that are not directly linked to experiment but are designed to investigate some aspect of the dynamical behaviour. Others are performed with the express purpose of explaining specific experimental data. Both kinds of simulation serve to illustrate the range of nonequilibrium phenomena that can be studied in ultracold Bose gases using the ZNG equations. A dynamical simulation is typically initiated in one of two ways. Either an appropriate nonequilibrium initial state is imposed on the system, or the system, initially in equilibrium, is dynamically excited by the application of an external perturbation. The latter parallels the procedure used experimentally to study small-amplitude collective excitations and usually amounts to some parametric modulation of the trapping potential. However, this approach may not always be feasible if the excitation phase requires a prohibitively long simulation time. In this case, the best one can do is to specify some initial nonequilibrium state that represents the experimental situation as closely as possible. This is not an issue in model simulations, where we are at liberty to specify the initial state in whatever way serves our purpose. In Sections 12.1–12.3 we present three examples of model simulations. All essentially check some aspect of the numerical procedures. By studying the equilibration of an initial nonequilibrium state in Section 12.1, we confirm that the total number of atoms is conserved to a very good approximation during the course of the evolution. This is a nontrivial result since, as explained at the end of subsection 11.3.2, the numbers of condensate and thermal atoms change in quite different ways.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 19, 2009•9 citations
In this chapter we describe the numerical methods that can be used to solve the ZNG equations in the context of a dynamical simulation. These equations consist of a generalized GP equation (3.21) for the condensate and a Boltzmann equation (3.42) for the thermal component. The fact that the two equations are coupled makes their numerical solution more complex than when either is considered on its own. Indeed, the distinct quantum and classical aspects of the problem require specifically tailored numerical methods. Although most of these methods are well established and described elsewhere (Taha and Ablowitz, 1984; Sanz-Serna and Calvo, 1994), we provide in this chapter a detailed pedagogical discussion that will serve as a guide to those interested in carrying out such calculations for trapped Bose gases. This chapter is based on the papers of Jackson and Zaremba (2002a,b). There are two main parts to the numerical problem. The first is developing a method for solving the time-dependent GP equation for an arbitrary three-dimensional geometry. This we take up in Section 11.1. Second, a method is needed for solving the Boltzmann equation that accounts for the dynamics of the thermal component. Here one must deal both with the Hamiltonian dynamics of the thermal atoms, as they move in the self-consistent mean field of the condensate and thermal cloud, and with the collisions that take place between the thermal atoms themselves (the C 22 collisions) and between the thermal atoms and the condensate (the C 12 collisions). The methods used to account for these two distinct collisional processes are taken up in Section 11.3. As we shall see, collisions play an important role and cannot be neglected even when the dynamical behaviour is dominated by mean-field interactions.
We review a self-consistent scheme for modelling trapped weakly-interacting quantum gases at temperatures where the condensate coexists with a significant thermal cloud. This method has been applied to atomic gases by Zaremba, Nikuni, and Griffin, and is often referred to as ZNG. It describes both mean-field-dominated and hydrodynamic regimes, except at very low temperatures or in the regime of large fluctuations. Condensate dynamics are described by a dissipative Gross-Pitaevskii equation (or the corresponding quantum hydrodynamic equation with a source term), while the non-condensate evolution is represented by a quantum Boltzmann equation, which additionally includes collisional processes which transfer atoms between these two subsystems. In the mean-field-dominated regime collisions are treated perturbatively and the full distribution function is needed to describe the thermal cloud, while in the hydrodynamic regime the system is parametrised in terms of a set of local variables. Applications to finite temperature induced damping of collective modes and vortices in the mean-field-dominated regime are presented.
In contrast with Chapter 2, in this chapter we include the dynamics of the thermal cloud. As noted in Chapter 1, we treat the noncondensate atoms using the simplest microscopic model approximation that captures the important physics. In particular, we consider only temperatures high enough ( T ≥ 0.4 T BEC ) that the noncondensate atoms can be described by a particle-like Hartree–Fock (HF) spectrum. To extend the analysis to very low temperatures is in principle straightforward (see Chapter 7). However, the details are more complicated since the excitations of the thermal cloud take on a collective aspect (i.e. a Bogoliubov-type quasiparticle spectrum must be used). In trapped Bose gases, the HF single-particle spectrum gives a good approximation down to much lower temperatures than in the case of uniform Bose gases, as first emphasized by Giorgini et al . (1997). In Section 3.1, we derive a generalized form of the Gross–Pitaevskii equation for the Bose order parameter Φ( r , t ) that is valid at finite temperatures. It involves terms that are coupled to the noncondensate component (the thermal cloud) and thus its solution in general requires one to know the equations of motion for the dynamics of the noncondensate atoms. In Section 3.2 we restrict ourselves to finite temperatures high enough that the noncondensate atoms can be described by a quantum kinetic equation for the single-particle distribution function f ( p, r , t ). A detailed microscopic derivation of this kind of kinetic equation is given in Chapters 6 and 7 using the Kadanoff–Baym Green's function formalism. A characteristic feature of a Bose-condensed gas is that the kinetic equation governing f ( p, r , t ) involves a collision integral C 12 [ f , Φ] describing collisions between condensate and noncondensate atoms.
In this paper, we develop a numerical procedure for investigating the dynamics of trapped Bose gases based on the ZGN theory. The dynamical equations used consist of a generalized Gross-Pitaevskii equation for the condensate order parameter and a semiclassical kinetic equation for the thermal cloud. The former is solved using a fast Fourier transform split-operator technique while the Boltzmann equation is treated by means of N-body simulations. The two components are coupled by mean fields as well as collisional processes that transfer atoms between the two. This scheme has been applied to a model equilibration problem, dipole oscillations in isotropic traps and scissors modes in anisotropic traps. In the case of the latter, the frequencies and damping rates of the condensate mode have been extracted from the simulations for a wide range of temperatures. Good agreement with recent experiments has been found.
In Chapter 3, we introduced a simple but reasonable approximation for the nonequilibrium dynamics of a Bose-condensed gas based on a generalized GP equation coupled to a kinetic equation. In Chapters 4–7, we turn to the question of how to derive such coupled equations for the condensate and noncondensate components in a way that gives a deeper understanding of the ZNG theory. Chapters 4–7 involve an introduction to Green's functions and field theoretic techniques for nonequilibrium problems. These provide the natural language and formalism to deal with the many subtle aspects of a Bose-condensed gas at finite temperatures. These four chapters are fairly technical. This chapter is mainly based on Kadanoff and Baym (1962) and Imamović-Tomasović (2001). Readers who are not interested in these questions can go straight to Chapter 8, which begins the discussion of applications of the ZNG coupled equations given in Chapter 3.
In this chapter we present several dynamical simulations that make use of the numerical methods discussed in the previous chapter. Some of these are model simulations that are not directly linked to experiment but are designed to investigate some aspect of the dynamical behaviour. Others are performed with the express purpose of explaining specific experimental data. Both kinds of simulation serve to illustrate the range of nonequilibrium phenomena that can be studied in ultracold Bose gases using the ZNG equations. A dynamical simulation is typically initiated in one of two ways. Either an appropriate nonequilibrium initial state is imposed on the system, or the system, initially in equilibrium, is dynamically excited by the application of an external perturbation. The latter parallels the procedure used experimentally to study small-amplitude collective excitations and usually amounts to some parametric modulation of the trapping potential. However, this approach may not always be feasible if the excitation phase requires a prohibitively long simulation time. In this case, the best one can do is to specify some initial nonequilibrium state that represents the experimental situation as closely as possible. This is not an issue in model simulations, where we are at liberty to specify the initial state in whatever way serves our purpose. In Sections 12.1–12.3 we present three examples of model simulations. All essentially check some aspect of the numerical procedures. By studying the equilibration of an initial nonequilibrium state in Section 12.1, we confirm that the total number of atoms is conserved to a very good approximation during the course of the evolution. This is a nontrivial result since, as explained at the end of subsection 11.3.2, the numbers of condensate and thermal atoms change in quite different ways.