Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The mathematical style of modern physics

Narasimhaiengar Mukunda

Published Feb 1, 1987• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In the author's opinion, two main features are characteristic for modern applications of mathematics to physics: the use of symmetries and the use of unobservable quantities (antioperationalistic approach). He gives a brief history of symmetry in physics: first, symmetry as a tool for describing useful features of given theories, then symmetry as a tool for restricting possible equations (e.g. the Dirac equation was thus obtained) and, finally, symmetry as a creative tool allowing one to obtain equations almost uniquely (Yang-Mills, etc.). Whenever equations are invariant with respect to some group, in the case that our observation data are invariant with respect to some subgroup $G$, one cannot tell the state $x$ from the state $gx$, where $g\\in G$, so the parameters telling $x$ from $gx$ become unobservable---of this kind are potentials in electrodynamics, coordinate effects in general relativity, etc. This unobservability can be ultimate (e.g. phase of wave function in quantum theory) or only approximate---in all other theories where symmetry is only approximate. \n \n \n

Related papers

Symmetries in Quantum Mechanics

Fl. Stancu

Abstract Group theory is a branch of mathematics appropriate for studying symmetries of physical systems. A symmetry is a natural attribute of the physical world and therefore is the starting point of any physical law. The foundation of dynamics is in Lagrangian theory or equivalently in Hamiltonian theory. A symmetry of a physical system is expressed by the invariance of its Lagrangian or Hamiltonian, or ultimately of its equations of motion, under certain transformations. When these transformations form groups it is convenient and useful to study symmetries through group theory. Group theory can explain observed regularities and helps to simplify and unify the physics of apparently different systems. It is a valuable tool that helps in predicting the behaviour of systems for which a symmetry has been found.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Nov 21, 1996•0 citations

Quantum electrodynamics

Alireza R. Baghai-Wadji

This brief and rudimentary chapter on QED has been included to close the circle in the story telling. The aim has been to emphasize the significance of the notion of the planewave in the theory development. With no more than the idea of the planewave and considering the Maxwell equations in free space inside in a cubic box, the Hamiltonian operator for describing the electromagnetic field was obtained. Thereby, the reader was guided to utilize what they already know, while fully respecting the order of operators. A thorough discussion of the QED following the same style of writing which has been pursued in this book would require an independent treatise. Accomplishing such a project would certainly be a noble undertaking. A volume of this kind would also require the inclusion of the theory of special relativity and of a fully-fletched treatment of spin phenomena. The available books on QED, despite being voluminous and comprehensive, are not easily accessible to engineers and technologists. The discussion in this chapter might convince the reader that with reasonable effort the necessary mathematical tools can be developed and satisfactorily understood. The ultimate vision is that the engineers and technologists, once they have acquired a working knowledge of the methods, they will start enriching the quantum field theory by their own unique creative style of thinking. The first five references in the following list provide further detailed information on the structures of the scaffolding matrices in the mathematical physics. The remaining references may assist the reader in digging deeper in QED. The reader can expect to read comprehensive, and at the same time, accessible treatments of the QED, the spin phenomena, and the special theory of relativity in later MQPET Volumes.

Institution of Engineering and Technology eBooks•Dec 18, 2023•46 citations

Symmetry

N M J Woodhouse

Abstract Symmetry principles play an important part in theoretical physics, both as a means of understanding conservation laws and as computational devices providing quick and elegant solutions to problems that would otherwise be tedious to solve. In quantum theory, their role is especially significant since they not only clarify basic concepts and simplify the formal development of the subject, but they also provide detailed information about physical systems for which no explicit dynamical models exist. However, the methods used to investigate symmetry in quantum systems are often based on abstract group-theoretical techniques, which bypass the canonical formalism. They include no general rules for going over to the classical limit and for directly relating the symmetries of the quantum system to those of a corresponding classical system.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 26, 1992•0 citations

Multicomponent WKB and Quantization

C. Emmrich, Hartmann Römer

Hamiltonians whose symbols are not simply real valued, but matrix or, more generally, endomorphism valued functions appear in many places in physics, examples being the Dirac equation, multicomponent wave equations like electrodynamics in media, and Yang-Mills theories, and the Born-Oppenheimer approximation in molecular physics. The aim of this paper is to give a completely geometric approach to the WKB approximation od such systems, and to reduce the problem ``as far as possible'' to the scalar case. A star-product formulation of quantum mechanics proves to be particularly useful in this context. As opposed to other approaches in the literature which restrict themselves to the use of the Moyal product and thus to the study of trivial bundles (or local trivializations) over $\real^{2n}$, we will consider general bundles over arbitrary symplectic manifolds. Here, Fedosov's construction \cite{fedosov} will be the adequate tool, since it gives an explicit construction for star products in this general setting.

arXiv:hep-th/9601138•Jan 25, 1996•2 citations

Describing and Understanding the World

Marta Jordi Taltavull, Tilman Sauer

The relationship between mathematics and physical theory in the twentieth century gained decisive shape through two major conceptual transformations. Quantum mechanics, which concerns the fundamental theory of matter, raised its head at the turn of the century and eventually consolidated in the year

Bloomsbury Publishing Plc eBooks•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

Non‐Adiabatic Effects in Chemical Reactions: Extended Born‐Oppenheimer Equations and its Applications

Satrajit Adhikari, Gert D. Billing

This Chapter gives a review of phase properties in molecular wave functions composed of a number of (and, at least, two) electronic states that become degenerate at some nearby values of the nuclear configuration. Apart from discussing phases and interference in classical (non-quantal) systems, including light waves, this chapter review looks at the constructability of complex wave functions from observable quantities (the phase problem), at the controversy regarding quantum mechanical phase operators, at the modes of observability of phase and at the role of phases in some nondemolition measurements. Advances in experimental and (especially) theoretical aspects of Aharonov–Bohm and topological (Berry) phases are described, including those involving two-electron and relativistic systems. Several works in the phase control and revivals of molecular wavepackets are cited as developments and applications of complex-function theory. Additional topics covered are coherent states, semiclassical approximations and the Maslov index. The interrelation between time and the complex state is noted in the contexts of time delays in scattering, of time-reversal invariance, and of the existence of a molecular time arrow. When the stationary Born–Oppenheimer description for a nearly degenerate state is regarded as “embedded” in a broader dynamic formulation, namely, through solution of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, the wave function becomes necessarily complex. The analytic behavior of this function in the complex time plane can be exploited to gain information about the connection between phases and moduli of the component amplitudes. One form of this connection is a pair of reciprocal (Kramers–Kronig type) relations in the complex time domain. These show that certain phase changes in a component amplitude (e.g., lead to a non–zero Berry phase) require changes in the amplitude moduli, too, and imply degeneracies of the electronic state. The subject of conical degeneracy, or intersection, of adjacent potential surface is extended to nonlinear nuclear-electronic coupling, which can then result in multiple conical degeneracies on a nuclear coordinate plane. We treat cases of double and fourfold intersections, the latter under trigonal symmetry, and employ an analytic-graphical phase tracing method to obtain the resulting Berry phases as the system circles around some or all of the degeneracy points. These phases can take up values that are all integral multiples of π, with integers that vary with the physical situation (or with the model postulated for it). A further type of invariance, with respect to gauge transformation, is also tied to the complex form of the wave function. for a many-component state, this leads to a consideration of tensorial (Yang–Mills type) fields F for molecular systems. It is shown that it is the truncation of the Born–Oppenheimer electron-nuclear superposition that generates the molecular Yang–Mills fields. The equations of motion for the nuclear degrees of freedom are derived from a Lagrangean density ℒ, representing a non-Abelian situation. In ℒ, the non-adiabatic coupling terms (NACTs) that express the electronic background on the nuclear states enter as vector potentials (or gauge fields). We demonstrate a deep lying interrelation between two apparently distinct theoretical developments: that which led to the discovery of the Yang–Mills fields from considerations of local gauge invariance, and the use of an adiabatic–diabatic transformation matrix for the molecular case due to Baer. A generalized form of the NACTs is found, such that it makes the field F vanish for a complete electronic set. Finally, the use of phases and moduli as variables was found to be very convenient to obtain variationally the equation of continuity and the Hamilton–Jacobi equations from the Lagrangian of an electron following either the Schrüdinger or the Dirac equation. In the latter case, to a good approximation (in the nearly nonrelativistic limit) the phases in the different spinor components are not scrambled together and their Berry phases are unaffected.

Advances in chemical physics•Aug 7, 2002•36 citations
In the author's opinion, two main features are characteristic for modern applications of mathematics to physics: the use of symmetries and the use of unobservable quantities (antioperationalistic approach). He gives a brief history of symmetry in physics: first, symmetry as a tool for describing useful features of given theories, then symmetry as a tool for restricting possible equations (e.g. the Dirac equation was thus obtained) and, finally, symmetry as a creative tool allowing one to obtain equations almost uniquely (Yang-Mills, etc.). Whenever equations are invariant with respect to some group, in the case that our observation data are invariant with respect to some subgroup GGG, one cannot tell the state xxx from the state gxgxgx, where ginGg\\in GginG, so the parameters telling xxx from gxgxgx become unobservable---of this kind are potentials in electrodynamics, coordinate effects in general relativity, etc. This unobservability can be ultimate (e.g. phase of wave function in quantum theory) or only approximate---in all other theories where symmetry is only approximate. \n \n \n
Abstract Group theory is a branch of mathematics appropriate for studying symmetries of physical systems. A symmetry is a natural attribute of the physical world and therefore is the starting point of any physical law. The foundation of dynamics is in Lagrangian theory or equivalently in Hamiltonian theory. A symmetry of a physical system is expressed by the invariance of its Lagrangian or Hamiltonian, or ultimately of its equations of motion, under certain transformations. When these transformations form groups it is convenient and useful to study symmetries through group theory. Group theory can explain observed regularities and helps to simplify and unify the physics of apparently different systems. It is a valuable tool that helps in predicting the behaviour of systems for which a symmetry has been found.
This brief and rudimentary chapter on QED has been included to close the circle in the story telling. The aim has been to emphasize the significance of the notion of the planewave in the theory development. With no more than the idea of the planewave and considering the Maxwell equations in free space inside in a cubic box, the Hamiltonian operator for describing the electromagnetic field was obtained. Thereby, the reader was guided to utilize what they already know, while fully respecting the order of operators. A thorough discussion of the QED following the same style of writing which has been pursued in this book would require an independent treatise. Accomplishing such a project would certainly be a noble undertaking. A volume of this kind would also require the inclusion of the theory of special relativity and of a fully-fletched treatment of spin phenomena. The available books on QED, despite being voluminous and comprehensive, are not easily accessible to engineers and technologists. The discussion in this chapter might convince the reader that with reasonable effort the necessary mathematical tools can be developed and satisfactorily understood. The ultimate vision is that the engineers and technologists, once they have acquired a working knowledge of the methods, they will start enriching the quantum field theory by their own unique creative style of thinking. The first five references in the following list provide further detailed information on the structures of the scaffolding matrices in the mathematical physics. The remaining references may assist the reader in digging deeper in QED. The reader can expect to read comprehensive, and at the same time, accessible treatments of the QED, the spin phenomena, and the special theory of relativity in later MQPET Volumes.
Abstract Symmetry principles play an important part in theoretical physics, both as a means of understanding conservation laws and as computational devices providing quick and elegant solutions to problems that would otherwise be tedious to solve. In quantum theory, their role is especially significant since they not only clarify basic concepts and simplify the formal development of the subject, but they also provide detailed information about physical systems for which no explicit dynamical models exist. However, the methods used to investigate symmetry in quantum systems are often based on abstract group-theoretical techniques, which bypass the canonical formalism. They include no general rules for going over to the classical limit and for directly relating the symmetries of the quantum system to those of a corresponding classical system.
Hamiltonians whose symbols are not simply real valued, but matrix or, more generally, endomorphism valued functions appear in many places in physics, examples being the Dirac equation, multicomponent wave equations like electrodynamics in media, and Yang-Mills theories, and the Born-Oppenheimer approximation in molecular physics. The aim of this paper is to give a completely geometric approach to the WKB approximation od such systems, and to reduce the problem ``as far as possible'' to the scalar case. A star-product formulation of quantum mechanics proves to be particularly useful in this context. As opposed to other approaches in the literature which restrict themselves to the use of the Moyal product and thus to the study of trivial bundles (or local trivializations) over ℜ2n\real^{2n}ℜ2n, we will consider general bundles over arbitrary symplectic manifolds. Here, Fedosov's construction \cite{fedosov} will be the adequate tool, since it gives an explicit construction for star products in this general setting.
This Chapter gives a review of phase properties in molecular wave functions composed of a number of (and, at least, two) electronic states that become degenerate at some nearby values of the nuclear configuration. Apart from discussing phases and interference in classical (non-quantal) systems, including light waves, this chapter review looks at the constructability of complex wave functions from observable quantities (the phase problem), at the controversy regarding quantum mechanical phase operators, at the modes of observability of phase and at the role of phases in some nondemolition measurements. Advances in experimental and (especially) theoretical aspects of Aharonov–Bohm and topological (Berry) phases are described, including those involving two-electron and relativistic systems. Several works in the phase control and revivals of molecular wavepackets are cited as developments and applications of complex-function theory. Additional topics covered are coherent states, semiclassical approximations and the Maslov index. The interrelation between time and the complex state is noted in the contexts of time delays in scattering, of time-reversal invariance, and of the existence of a molecular time arrow. When the stationary Born–Oppenheimer description for a nearly degenerate state is regarded as “embedded” in a broader dynamic formulation, namely, through solution of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, the wave function becomes necessarily complex. The analytic behavior of this function in the complex time plane can be exploited to gain information about the connection between phases and moduli of the component amplitudes. One form of this connection is a pair of reciprocal (Kramers–Kronig type) relations in the complex time domain. These show that certain phase changes in a component amplitude (e.g., lead to a non–zero Berry phase) require changes in the amplitude moduli, too, and imply degeneracies of the electronic state. The subject of conical degeneracy, or intersection, of adjacent potential surface is extended to nonlinear nuclear-electronic coupling, which can then result in multiple conical degeneracies on a nuclear coordinate plane. We treat cases of double and fourfold intersections, the latter under trigonal symmetry, and employ an analytic-graphical phase tracing method to obtain the resulting Berry phases as the system circles around some or all of the degeneracy points. These phases can take up values that are all integral multiples of π, with integers that vary with the physical situation (or with the model postulated for it). A further type of invariance, with respect to gauge transformation, is also tied to the complex form of the wave function. for a many-component state, this leads to a consideration of tensorial (Yang–Mills type) fields F for molecular systems. It is shown that it is the truncation of the Born–Oppenheimer electron-nuclear superposition that generates the molecular Yang–Mills fields. The equations of motion for the nuclear degrees of freedom are derived from a Lagrangean density ℒ, representing a non-Abelian situation. In ℒ, the non-adiabatic coupling terms (NACTs) that express the electronic background on the nuclear states enter as vector potentials (or gauge fields). We demonstrate a deep lying interrelation between two apparently distinct theoretical developments: that which led to the discovery of the Yang–Mills fields from considerations of local gauge invariance, and the use of an adiabatic–diabatic transformation matrix for the molecular case due to Baer. A generalized form of the NACTs is found, such that it makes the field F vanish for a complete electronic set. Finally, the use of phases and moduli as variables was found to be very convenient to obtain variationally the equation of continuity and the Hamilton–Jacobi equations from the Lagrangian of an electron following either the Schrüdinger or the Dirac equation. In the latter case, to a good approximation (in the nearly nonrelativistic limit) the phases in the different spinor components are not scrambled together and their Berry phases are unaffected.