Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Asymmetry Due to Quantum Collapse

Armin Nikkhah Shirazi

Published Jun 6, 2013• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

THE PROBLEM IN A NUTSHELL CONCLUSION This poster points out an internal tension between quantum collapse and expressions which set eigenstates equal to superposition states in a different basis and thereby imply that pre-measurement and immediate post-measurement states are of the same kind. Its resolution appears to be either to discard the collapse postulate or to consider such states to be of distinct kinds with respect to their association with a superposition of properties. OVERVIEW Quantum collapse is a postulate in orthodox quantum mechanics, but it is poorly understood, though much has been written about it [1]. Here we point out that it also leads to a subtle internal tension in the theory when it is considered in conjunction with expressions that equate eigenstates with superposition states in a different basis because such expressions are consistent with a symmetry between states and observables under quantum superposition that is broken by quantum collapse. The tension can be relieved either by discarding the collapse postulate or by keeping it and considering pre-measurement and immediate post-measurement states to be of distinct kinds, in which case quantum collapse must be considered a transformation between two kinds of states. The basic strategy employed here is to convert a standard quantum mechanical relation into a logical equivalence, and then show that the imposition of the collapse postulate makes it possible to formulate an argument such that the truth value of the conclusion depends on which of the implications that are part of the equivalence is used, from which it is then possible to derive a contradiction.

Related papers

Asymmetry Due to Quantum Collapse (Poster)

Armin Nikkhah Shirazi

This poster points out an internal tension between quantum collapse and expressions which set eigenstates equal to superposition states in a different basis and thereby imply that pre-measurement and immediate post-measurement states are of the same kind. Its resolution appears to be either to discard the collapse postulate or to consider such states to be of distinct kinds with respect to their association with a superposition of properties.

•Jun 1, 2013•0 citations

Collapse Theories

Peter J. Lewis

The collapse postulate in quantum mechanics is problematic due to the measurement problem. The problem lies not with collapse per se, but with the appeal to measurement; a theory that could underwrite the collapse process without ineliminable reference to measurement would constitute a solution to the measurement problem. This is the strategy pursued by dynamical (or spontaneous) collapse theories. But dynamical collapse theories face a number of challenges. First, they make different empirical predictions from standard quantum mechanics, and hence are potentially empirically refutable. Second, there are difficulties reconciling the dynamical collapse mechanism with special relativity. Third, the post-collapse state is not the same as the post-measurement state of standard quantum mechanics, raising the possibility that dynamical collapse theories do not solve the measurement problem after all. Assuming that these challenges can be met, dynamical collapse theories can lay claim to being serious contenders for the correct description of the quantum world. And the description they provide has a number of interesting consequences. First, it makes indeterminism an irreducible fact about the physical world. It has been argued that this has important consequences for the foundations of statistical mechanics, for free will, and for consciousness. Second, many dynamical collapse theories can be taken to imply that the quantum wave function is fundamental, giving rise to a new kind of vagueness, since a wave can be fuzzy around the edges in a way that a particle cannot. Furthermore, the quantum wave function is defined over a high-dimensional space, not the three-dimensional space of experience, suggesting to some that three-dimensionality is an illusion.

•Nov 6, 2017•0 citations

Overturning negative construal of quantum superposition

Arkady Bolotin

Construal of observable facts or events, that is, the manner in which we understand reality, is based not only on mathematical formulas of a theory suggested as a reasonable explanation for physical phenomena (like general relativity or quantum mechanics), but also on a mathematical model of reasoning used to analyze and appraise statements regarding the objective world (for example, logic of one type or the other). Hence, every time that a certain construal of reality encounters a problem, there is a choice between a modification to the mathematical formalism of the physical theory and a change in the model of reasoning. A case in point is negative construal of quantum superposition causing the problem of definite outcomes. To be sure, according to the said construal, it is not the case that a system being in a superposition of states is exclusively in one of the states constituting the superposition, which in turn implies that macroscopically differing outcomes of observation may appear all at once. The usual approach to the problem of definite outcomes is to modify the quantum mathematical formalism by adding to it some extra postulates (for instance, the postulate of wave function collapse). However, since none of the extra postulates proposed so far has gained broad acceptance, one may try another avenue to resolve the problem, namely, to replace logic with an alternative mathematical model of reasoning. This possibility is studied in the present paper.

arXiv:2107.07989•Jul 16, 2021•0 citations

Why Quantum Collapse May Not Be Fundamental

Atsushi Okamoto

Wave function collapse has long been regarded as a fundamental element of the quantum measurement process, providing a mechanism by which a superposed quantum state yields a single observed outcome. Despite its widespread use, the physical meaning of collapse remains conceptually controversial. In particular, it is often assumed that the quantities associated with a quantum state before measurement and the values obtained after measurement belong to the same conceptual category. This assumption leads naturally to the image of a discontinuous transition in which one value is selected from a superposition of possibilities. In the present work, we reexamine the concept of quantum collapse from the perspective of observability. We argue that pre-measurement quantities do not constitute observable values in the ordinary operational sense. Rather, they represent a structure of potential observability associated with possible measurement outcomes. By contrast, post-measurement outcomes correspond to operationally realized observability, in which a specific result becomes accessible through measurement. From this viewpoint, the apparent collapse does not represent a physical jump of an already existing value, but a transition from potential observability to operationally realized observability. Based on this distinction, we propose that many conceptual difficulties traditionally associated with wave function collapse arise from treating these two fundamentally different forms of observability as if they were physically equivalent. The apparent discontinuity of collapse may therefore originate not from a discontinuous change in reality itself, but from a conceptual conflation of potential observability and operationally realized observability. Within the Intrinsic Observability Framework (IOF), this interpretation naturally leads to the concept of accessibility transition, in which the emergence of a definite outcome is understood as a change in accessible structure rather than as a fundamental non-unitary state reduction. The present analysis suggests that wave function collapse may not be a fundamental physical phenomenon, but instead a consequence of the transition from potential observability to operationally realized observability. This perspective provides a conceptual reorganization of the measurement problem and clarifies the role of observability in the emergence of definite quantum outcomes.

•Jul 11, 2026•0 citations

Measurement Postulate and Paradoxes of Quantum Mechanics

Ravinder Rupchand Puri

The measurement postulate (postulate 4) relates the quantum theoretic predictions with experimental observations. Those predictions are found to be in conformity with experimental observations. That postulate, however, has been the subject of debate right since its conception. The issues debated are: (i) whether the measurement postulate is consistent with the postulate specifying the time evolution (postulate 5) and (ii) whether it denies the objective reality per the criterion of the Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR). The said issues are highlighted in the form of paradoxes by the thought experiment ( Gedanken experiment in German) of Schrödinger, and that of EPR. See [40] for collection of articles and papers on the problem of measurement. See in particular [42] and [43]. The Measurement Problem We recall first the measurement postulate. Let a system S (hereafter called the object ) be subject to the measurement of an observable . Let the eigenvalues of be non-degenerate with as the corresponding orthonormal eigenvectors. Let the object be in the state j s i before the measurement, where According to the measurement postulate, the measurement of would make the state of the object collapse to one of the eigenstates of and the outcome of the measurement would be the eigenvalue corresponding to the eigenstate to which the state of the object has collapsed. Hence, if the outcome of the measurement is the eigenvalue k k then we know that the state of the object after the measurement is, written symbolically as.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 17, 2017•0 citations

Entanglement, decoherence, and the measurement problem

Art Hobson

The entangled Schrodinger cat state obtained immediately upon measurement of a superposed two-state quantum system is often considered paradoxical because it appears to predict two macroscopically different outcomes, such as an alive and dead cat. However, nonlocal interferometry experiments testing momentum-entangled photon pairs over all phases demonstrate that the cat state does not fit this description and is not paradoxical. Both experiment and theory imply that it instead represents a superposition of two nonlocally coherent (i.e. phase-dependent) statistical correlations between its sub-systems. This is not paradoxical. Standard quantum theory rigorously predicts the experimentally-observed outcomes of this state. Neither sub-system is superposed; rather, the correlations between the states of the subsystems are superposed. This resolves the problem of definite outcomes. The nonlocal properties of entanglement then ensure that only one outcome occurs while the other outcome simultaneously does not occur, resolving a problem posed by Einstein in 1927. The single outcome that occurs then triggers an irreversible process leading to macroscopic registration of the outcome. This resolves the quantum measurement problem. Collapse occurs because of entanglement and does not require a special collapse postulate. Collapse is a consequence of standard quantum physics and the irreversible nature of the macroscopic registration.

arXiv:1904.04234•Jan 1, 2019•3 citations
THE PROBLEM IN A NUTSHELL CONCLUSION This poster points out an internal tension between quantum collapse and expressions which set eigenstates equal to superposition states in a different basis and thereby imply that pre-measurement and immediate post-measurement states are of the same kind. Its resolution appears to be either to discard the collapse postulate or to consider such states to be of distinct kinds with respect to their association with a superposition of properties. OVERVIEW Quantum collapse is a postulate in orthodox quantum mechanics, but it is poorly understood, though much has been written about it [1]. Here we point out that it also leads to a subtle internal tension in the theory when it is considered in conjunction with expressions that equate eigenstates with superposition states in a different basis because such expressions are consistent with a symmetry between states and observables under quantum superposition that is broken by quantum collapse. The tension can be relieved either by discarding the collapse postulate or by keeping it and considering pre-measurement and immediate post-measurement states to be of distinct kinds, in which case quantum collapse must be considered a transformation between two kinds of states. The basic strategy employed here is to convert a standard quantum mechanical relation into a logical equivalence, and then show that the imposition of the collapse postulate makes it possible to formulate an argument such that the truth value of the conclusion depends on which of the implications that are part of the equivalence is used, from which it is then possible to derive a contradiction.
The collapse postulate in quantum mechanics is problematic due to the measurement problem. The problem lies not with collapse per se, but with the appeal to measurement; a theory that could underwrite the collapse process without ineliminable reference to measurement would constitute a solution to the measurement problem. This is the strategy pursued by dynamical (or spontaneous) collapse theories. But dynamical collapse theories face a number of challenges. First, they make different empirical predictions from standard quantum mechanics, and hence are potentially empirically refutable. Second, there are difficulties reconciling the dynamical collapse mechanism with special relativity. Third, the post-collapse state is not the same as the post-measurement state of standard quantum mechanics, raising the possibility that dynamical collapse theories do not solve the measurement problem after all. Assuming that these challenges can be met, dynamical collapse theories can lay claim to being serious contenders for the correct description of the quantum world. And the description they provide has a number of interesting consequences. First, it makes indeterminism an irreducible fact about the physical world. It has been argued that this has important consequences for the foundations of statistical mechanics, for free will, and for consciousness. Second, many dynamical collapse theories can be taken to imply that the quantum wave function is fundamental, giving rise to a new kind of vagueness, since a wave can be fuzzy around the edges in a way that a particle cannot. Furthermore, the quantum wave function is defined over a high-dimensional space, not the three-dimensional space of experience, suggesting to some that three-dimensionality is an illusion.
Construal of observable facts or events, that is, the manner in which we understand reality, is based not only on mathematical formulas of a theory suggested as a reasonable explanation for physical phenomena (like general relativity or quantum mechanics), but also on a mathematical model of reasoning used to analyze and appraise statements regarding the objective world (for example, logic of one type or the other). Hence, every time that a certain construal of reality encounters a problem, there is a choice between a modification to the mathematical formalism of the physical theory and a change in the model of reasoning. A case in point is negative construal of quantum superposition causing the problem of definite outcomes. To be sure, according to the said construal, it is not the case that a system being in a superposition of states is exclusively in one of the states constituting the superposition, which in turn implies that macroscopically differing outcomes of observation may appear all at once. The usual approach to the problem of definite outcomes is to modify the quantum mathematical formalism by adding to it some extra postulates (for instance, the postulate of wave function collapse). However, since none of the extra postulates proposed so far has gained broad acceptance, one may try another avenue to resolve the problem, namely, to replace logic with an alternative mathematical model of reasoning. This possibility is studied in the present paper.
Wave function collapse has long been regarded as a fundamental element of the quantum measurement process, providing a mechanism by which a superposed quantum state yields a single observed outcome. Despite its widespread use, the physical meaning of collapse remains conceptually controversial. In particular, it is often assumed that the quantities associated with a quantum state before measurement and the values obtained after measurement belong to the same conceptual category. This assumption leads naturally to the image of a discontinuous transition in which one value is selected from a superposition of possibilities. In the present work, we reexamine the concept of quantum collapse from the perspective of observability. We argue that pre-measurement quantities do not constitute observable values in the ordinary operational sense. Rather, they represent a structure of potential observability associated with possible measurement outcomes. By contrast, post-measurement outcomes correspond to operationally realized observability, in which a specific result becomes accessible through measurement. From this viewpoint, the apparent collapse does not represent a physical jump of an already existing value, but a transition from potential observability to operationally realized observability. Based on this distinction, we propose that many conceptual difficulties traditionally associated with wave function collapse arise from treating these two fundamentally different forms of observability as if they were physically equivalent. The apparent discontinuity of collapse may therefore originate not from a discontinuous change in reality itself, but from a conceptual conflation of potential observability and operationally realized observability. Within the Intrinsic Observability Framework (IOF), this interpretation naturally leads to the concept of accessibility transition, in which the emergence of a definite outcome is understood as a change in accessible structure rather than as a fundamental non-unitary state reduction. The present analysis suggests that wave function collapse may not be a fundamental physical phenomenon, but instead a consequence of the transition from potential observability to operationally realized observability. This perspective provides a conceptual reorganization of the measurement problem and clarifies the role of observability in the emergence of definite quantum outcomes.
The measurement postulate (postulate 4) relates the quantum theoretic predictions with experimental observations. Those predictions are found to be in conformity with experimental observations. That postulate, however, has been the subject of debate right since its conception. The issues debated are: (i) whether the measurement postulate is consistent with the postulate specifying the time evolution (postulate 5) and (ii) whether it denies the objective reality per the criterion of the Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR). The said issues are highlighted in the form of paradoxes by the thought experiment ( Gedanken experiment in German) of Schrödinger, and that of EPR. See [40] for collection of articles and papers on the problem of measurement. See in particular [42] and [43]. The Measurement Problem We recall first the measurement postulate. Let a system S (hereafter called the object ) be subject to the measurement of an observable . Let the eigenvalues of be non-degenerate with as the corresponding orthonormal eigenvectors. Let the object be in the state j s i before the measurement, where According to the measurement postulate, the measurement of would make the state of the object collapse to one of the eigenstates of and the outcome of the measurement would be the eigenvalue corresponding to the eigenstate to which the state of the object has collapsed. Hence, if the outcome of the measurement is the eigenvalue k k then we know that the state of the object after the measurement is, written symbolically as.
The entangled Schrodinger cat state obtained immediately upon measurement of a superposed two-state quantum system is often considered paradoxical because it appears to predict two macroscopically different outcomes, such as an alive and dead cat. However, nonlocal interferometry experiments testing momentum-entangled photon pairs over all phases demonstrate that the cat state does not fit this description and is not paradoxical. Both experiment and theory imply that it instead represents a superposition of two nonlocally coherent (i.e. phase-dependent) statistical correlations between its sub-systems. This is not paradoxical. Standard quantum theory rigorously predicts the experimentally-observed outcomes of this state. Neither sub-system is superposed; rather, the correlations between the states of the subsystems are superposed. This resolves the problem of definite outcomes. The nonlocal properties of entanglement then ensure that only one outcome occurs while the other outcome simultaneously does not occur, resolving a problem posed by Einstein in 1927. The single outcome that occurs then triggers an irreversible process leading to macroscopic registration of the outcome. This resolves the quantum measurement problem. Collapse occurs because of entanglement and does not require a special collapse postulate. Collapse is a consequence of standard quantum physics and the irreversible nature of the macroscopic registration.