Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.13110

Finite Measured Entropy Production Does Not Imply Finite Microscopic Irreversibility

Hieu Nguyen

Published Nov 9, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Coarse-grained measurements provide a lower bound on entropy production, but how much microscopic irreversibility can they conceal? We construct a driven quantum system in which an imperfect counter registers a finite, strictly positive arrow of time while the microscopic entropy production is infinite. The system is a degenerate parametric oscillator below threshold, coupled to a thermal reservoir through repeated interactions with bosonic ancillas. The oscillator sustains a finite, positive heat current into the vacuum bath, where absorption is forbidden and forward and reverse trajectory laws have different supports. A photon counter with finite collection efficiency, gated time bins, and independent dark counts defines a common coarse-graining of the aligned trajectory laws. For fixed observation duration $\mathcal T$ and detector parameters, we prove that the observed relative entropy remains uniformly bounded as the bath temperature $T_b$ vanishes and is strictly positive at vacuum. The hidden contribution obeys $Σ_{\mathrm{hid}}(\mathcal T,T_b)=\mathcal T\dot Q_0/(k_BT_b)+O(1)$, where $\dot Q_0>0$ is the stationary vacuum heat current. False positives conceal the support mismatch while preserving measurable time asymmetry. Thus, finite and informative measurements of entropy production can coexist with infinite microscopic irreversibility.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.13110

Related papers

Reversible Quantum Control Is Not Time Reversal: Unitary Undoing vs. Irreversible Erasure and a Unified Taxonomy of Temporal Arrows

Luiz PUODZIUS

We present a unified operational framework for the arrow of time grounded in irreversible information loss. While microscopic physical laws are time-reversal invariant, macroscopic irreversibility arises when systems overwrite metastable records. We show that recent reversible quantum-control experiments do not reverse time, but instead operate in regimes where no logically irreversible record is created. To formalize this, we introduce the **forgetting rate** \((\Xi_{\mathrm{cr}})\), a coarse-grained rate defined on physically selected metastable record states (e.g., pointer states, memory registers, or macroscopic configurations). Unlike standard entropy production, which is expressed in terms of microscopic transition asymmetry, \((\Xi_{\mathrm{cr}})\) captures the **rate of irreversible record overwriting**. In this formulation, entropy production obeys the lower bound\[\dot{S}_{\mathrm{irr}} \ge k_B \,\Xi_{\mathrm{cr}},\]consistent with Landauer's principle but expressed at the level of record dynamics. Within this framework, thermodynamic, quantum-measurement, psychological, and cosmological arrows emerge as substrate-dependent manifestations of \(\Xi_{\mathrm{cr}} > 0\). Temporal asymmetry is therefore not a single global property, but a distributed feature of physical information-processing systems. The approach naturally explains the decoupling of arrows in composite systems and identifies experimentally accessible regimes where irreversibility can be locally suppressed. This work does not introduce a new microscopic law but provides a unifying, operational reformulation that connects information thermodynamics, decoherence theory, and memory dynamics through a single coarse-grained rate.

•Apr 20, 2016•0 citations

Bounds for Apparent Second-Law Violations in Quantum Trajectories

Domingos S. P. Salazar

Negative stochastic entropy production is commonly called an apparent violation of the second law. In general quantum-trajectory dynamics, however, the physical entropy production $σ$ need not obey a forward detailed fluctuation theorem. A general arbitrary-coupling formulation identifies a dynamical-asymmetry term $σ^\ast$ that completes it into $Ω=σ+σ^\ast$, whose mean is $\langleΩ\rangle=Σ+Σ^\ast$. We prove that the likelihood-ratio sign is optimal among reversal-odd trajectory observables and use this fact to transfer an established sharp fluctuation-theorem floor to the tie-corrected physical sign statistic $Π_σ=\Pr(σ<0)+\Pr(σ=0)/2$. When $\Pr(σ=0)=0$, the result reads $\Pr(σ<0)\ge[1-\langleΩ\rangle/g(\langleΩ\rangle)]/2$, where $g$ is the inverse of $a\mapsto a\tanh(a/2)$. The physical integral fluctuation theorem simultaneously suppresses large negative events, producing a quantitative ``frequent but mild'' law, while the sign imbalance lower-bounds the hidden mean $Σ^\ast$. We formulate the measured-record protocol explicitly and illustrate and numerically audit the tie-corrected theorem in random finite-coupling collision models and a coherently driven qubit interacting with thermal ancillas.

quant-pharXiv:2608.10118•Aug 12, 2026•0 citations

The Arrow of Time from Entropy–Order Balance: Classical and Quantum Manifestations via Finite-Scale Coarse-Graining

Platek, Nir

Why does time seem to have a direction when the microscopic laws do not? This paper gives a rigorous answer. We show that if you look at a system at a fixed resolution where its dynamics are reversible and satisfy a standard regularity condition (a log–Sobolev inequality), then there is no intrinsic arrow of time: entropy production is exactly balanced by an equal “ordering flux,” a state we call entropy–order balance (EOB). The arrow appears only when we observe the system through a lossy filter—such as averaging, ignoring variables, or tracing out an environment. Mathematically, this is a channel that merges many microscopic states into the same observed outcome and therefore forces a one-way loss of distinguishability. The main result is an Arrow Structure Theorem: an arrow of time exists at a given resolution if and only if the observation map is genuinely irreversible in a precise information-theoretic sense. We quantify its strength using a new, scale-dependent number—the arrow intensity As(O;t)∈[0,1]A_s(O;t) \in [0,1]As(O;t)∈[0,1]—which measures how much distinguishability is lost and behaves like a resource that can only increase under further coarse-graining. The same mechanism applies in both the classical and quantum cases and allows one to predict and measure how quickly an observed description forgets details, and to compare the strength of the arrow across platforms using a single information-theoretic yardstick. Conceptually, the work separates what the world does from what we access and provides a structural resolution of Loschmidt’s paradox: the arrow is not a property of the microscopic laws, but of the lossy channels through which we observe them.

•Nov 23, 2025•0 citations

Thermodynamic Irreversibility from Inaccessible Endogenous Quantum Histories

Borhan Ahmadi

Microscopic unitary dynamics preserves all fine information, yet an isolated finite system can show a robust thermodynamic window in which the entropy associated with a restricted record rises. We ask why information hidden from the current record usually fails to rebuild a low-entropy macrostate. For a fixed projective record, every finite step separates exactly into the evolution predicted from the record alone and an exact correction carried by unresolved microscopic structure. The record-only contribution starts only at second order in time, so all instantaneous change of the record comes from hidden currents between macrostates. We derive the exact entropy rate, separate entropy-spreading from return-oriented currents, and resolve those currents into energy-gap amplitudes. Transitions with the same gap add coherently, revealing how the Hamiltonian and the microscopic state organize hidden information for return. In interacting mixing dynamics the current power is spread over many frequencies; free and deliberately commensurate controls progressively concentrate it, and the engineered dynamics reconstructs a low-entropy macrostate. An independent distribution-level test separates hidden dynamical activity from finite-step return, and an exact classical measure-preserving counterpart shows which parts of the construction are not uniquely quantum. Within the specified record and observation window, irreversibility is therefore not loss of microscopic information, but the failure of that information to organize currents that restore macroscopic order.

quant-pharXiv:2609.03748•Sep 4, 2026•3 citations

Fundamental Irreversibility from Discrete Time

M. W. AlMasri

In 1964, Yu. A. Gol'fand proposed an extension of quantum mechanics to discrete time, predicting intrinsic non-unitarity and entropy increase. While historically significant, this formalism predates the modern theory of open quantum systems. In this work, we rigorously recast Gol'fand's discrete evolution equation as a Completely Positive Trace-Preserving (CPTP) quantum channel and derive its continuous-time coarse-grained limit. We demonstrate that the dynamics converge to a specific Lindblad master equation characterized by a fundamental time scale $τ$, which induces decoherence in both the energy basis and a fundamental operator basis $W$. We analyze the thermodynamic implications using Spohn's entropy production formalism, proving that the discrete time step induces a strictly positive entropy production rate driven by the decay of quantum coherences, thereby providing a microscopic foundation for the arrow of time independent of environmental coupling. Furthermore, we quantify the loss of quantum coherence via fidelity decay and purity loss, establishing exact constraints for fault-tolerant quantum computing. We further investigate the impact of this intrinsic decoherence on Discrete Time Crystals (DTCs), showing that Gol'fand dynamics impose a fundamental lifetime limit on time-translation symmetry breaking phases. Finally, we utilize precision data from optical lattice clocks, matter-wave interferometry, and neutrino oscillations to place stringent upper bounds on $τ$. Our results constrain the fundamental time discretization to $τ\lesssim 10^{-26}$ s, significantly tightening previous limits and offering a testable framework for quantum gravity phenomenology.

quant-pharXiv:2606.22187•Jun 23, 2026•0 citations

Non-Markovianity and negative entropy production rates

Philipp Strasberg, Massimiliano Esposito

Entropy production plays a fundamental role in nonequilibrium thermodynamics to quantify the irreversibility of open systems. Its positivity can be ensured for a wide class of setups, but the entropy production rate can become negative sometimes. This is often taken as an indicator of non-Markovianity. We make this link precise by showing under which conditions a negative entropy production rate implies non-Markovianity and when it does not. For a system coupled to a single heat bath, this can be established within a unified language for two setups: (i) the dynamics resulting from a coarse-grained description of a Markovian master equation and (ii) the classical Hamiltonian dynamics of a system coupled to a bath. The quantum version of the latter result is shown not to hold despite the fact that the integrated thermodynamic description is formally equivalent to the classical case. The instantaneous fixed point of a non-Markovian dynamics plays an important role in our study. Our key contribution is to provide a consistent theoretical framework to study the finite-time thermodynamics of a large class of dynamics with a precise link to its non-Markovianity.

arXiv:1806.09101•Physical review. E•Jan 14, 2019•114 citations
Coarse-grained measurements provide a lower bound on entropy production, but how much microscopic irreversibility can they conceal? We construct a driven quantum system in which an imperfect counter registers a finite, strictly positive arrow of time while the microscopic entropy production is infinite. The system is a degenerate parametric oscillator below threshold, coupled to a thermal reservoir through repeated interactions with bosonic ancillas. The oscillator sustains a finite, positive heat current into the vacuum bath, where absorption is forbidden and forward and reverse trajectory laws have different supports. A photon counter with finite collection efficiency, gated time bins, and independent dark counts defines a common coarse-graining of the aligned trajectory laws. For fixed observation duration T\mathcal TT and detector parameters, we prove that the observed relative entropy remains uniformly bounded as the bath temperature TbT_bTb​ vanishes and is strictly positive at vacuum. The hidden contribution obeys Σhid(T,Tb)=TQ˙0/(kBTb)+O(1)Σ_{\mathrm{hid}}(\mathcal T,T_b)=\mathcal T\dot Q_0/(k_BT_b)+O(1)Σhid​(T,Tb​)=TQ˙​0​/(kB​Tb​)+O(1), where Q˙0>0\dot Q_0>0Q˙​0​>0 is the stationary vacuum heat current. False positives conceal the support mismatch while preserving measurable time asymmetry. Thus, finite and informative measurements of entropy production can coexist with infinite microscopic irreversibility.
We present a unified operational framework for the arrow of time grounded in irreversible information loss. While microscopic physical laws are time-reversal invariant, macroscopic irreversibility arises when systems overwrite metastable records. We show that recent reversible quantum-control experiments do not reverse time, but instead operate in regimes where no logically irreversible record is created. To formalize this, we introduce the **forgetting rate** (Ξcr)(\Xi_{\mathrm{cr}})(Ξcr​), a coarse-grained rate defined on physically selected metastable record states (e.g., pointer states, memory registers, or macroscopic configurations). Unlike standard entropy production, which is expressed in terms of microscopic transition asymmetry, (Ξcr)(\Xi_{\mathrm{cr}})(Ξcr​) captures the **rate of irreversible record overwriting**. In this formulation, entropy production obeys the lower boundS˙irr≥kB Ξcr,\dot{S}_{\mathrm{irr}} \ge k_B \,\Xi_{\mathrm{cr}},S˙irr​≥kB​Ξcr​,consistent with Landauer's principle but expressed at the level of record dynamics. Within this framework, thermodynamic, quantum-measurement, psychological, and cosmological arrows emerge as substrate-dependent manifestations of Ξcr>0\Xi_{\mathrm{cr}} > 0Ξcr​>0. Temporal asymmetry is therefore not a single global property, but a distributed feature of physical information-processing systems. The approach naturally explains the decoupling of arrows in composite systems and identifies experimentally accessible regimes where irreversibility can be locally suppressed. This work does not introduce a new microscopic law but provides a unifying, operational reformulation that connects information thermodynamics, decoherence theory, and memory dynamics through a single coarse-grained rate.
Negative stochastic entropy production is commonly called an apparent violation of the second law. In general quantum-trajectory dynamics, however, the physical entropy production σσσ need not obey a forward detailed fluctuation theorem. A general arbitrary-coupling formulation identifies a dynamical-asymmetry term σ∗σ^\astσ∗ that completes it into Ω=σ+σ∗Ω=σ+σ^\astΩ=σ+σ∗, whose mean is ⟨Ω⟩=Σ+Σ∗\langleΩ\rangle=Σ+Σ^\ast⟨Ω⟩=Σ+Σ∗. We prove that the likelihood-ratio sign is optimal among reversal-odd trajectory observables and use this fact to transfer an established sharp fluctuation-theorem floor to the tie-corrected physical sign statistic Πσ=Pr⁡(σ<0)+Pr⁡(σ=0)/2Π_σ=\Pr(σ<0)+\Pr(σ=0)/2Πσ​=Pr(σ<0)+Pr(σ=0)/2. When Pr⁡(σ=0)=0\Pr(σ=0)=0Pr(σ=0)=0, the result reads Pr⁡(σ<0)≥[1−⟨Ω⟩/g(⟨Ω⟩)]/2\Pr(σ<0)\ge[1-\langleΩ\rangle/g(\langleΩ\rangle)]/2Pr(σ<0)≥[1−⟨Ω⟩/g(⟨Ω⟩)]/2, where ggg is the inverse of a↦atanh⁡(a/2)a\mapsto a\tanh(a/2)a↦atanh(a/2). The physical integral fluctuation theorem simultaneously suppresses large negative events, producing a quantitative ``frequent but mild'' law, while the sign imbalance lower-bounds the hidden mean Σ∗Σ^\astΣ∗. We formulate the measured-record protocol explicitly and illustrate and numerically audit the tie-corrected theorem in random finite-coupling collision models and a coherently driven qubit interacting with thermal ancillas.
Why does time seem to have a direction when the microscopic laws do not? This paper gives a rigorous answer. We show that if you look at a system at a fixed resolution where its dynamics are reversible and satisfy a standard regularity condition (a log–Sobolev inequality), then there is no intrinsic arrow of time: entropy production is exactly balanced by an equal “ordering flux,” a state we call entropy–order balance (EOB). The arrow appears only when we observe the system through a lossy filter—such as averaging, ignoring variables, or tracing out an environment. Mathematically, this is a channel that merges many microscopic states into the same observed outcome and therefore forces a one-way loss of distinguishability. The main result is an Arrow Structure Theorem: an arrow of time exists at a given resolution if and only if the observation map is genuinely irreversible in a precise information-theoretic sense. We quantify its strength using a new, scale-dependent number—the arrow intensity As(O;t)∈[0,1]A_s(O;t) \in [0,1]As(O;t)∈[0,1]—which measures how much distinguishability is lost and behaves like a resource that can only increase under further coarse-graining. The same mechanism applies in both the classical and quantum cases and allows one to predict and measure how quickly an observed description forgets details, and to compare the strength of the arrow across platforms using a single information-theoretic yardstick. Conceptually, the work separates what the world does from what we access and provides a structural resolution of Loschmidt’s paradox: the arrow is not a property of the microscopic laws, but of the lossy channels through which we observe them.
Microscopic unitary dynamics preserves all fine information, yet an isolated finite system can show a robust thermodynamic window in which the entropy associated with a restricted record rises. We ask why information hidden from the current record usually fails to rebuild a low-entropy macrostate. For a fixed projective record, every finite step separates exactly into the evolution predicted from the record alone and an exact correction carried by unresolved microscopic structure. The record-only contribution starts only at second order in time, so all instantaneous change of the record comes from hidden currents between macrostates. We derive the exact entropy rate, separate entropy-spreading from return-oriented currents, and resolve those currents into energy-gap amplitudes. Transitions with the same gap add coherently, revealing how the Hamiltonian and the microscopic state organize hidden information for return. In interacting mixing dynamics the current power is spread over many frequencies; free and deliberately commensurate controls progressively concentrate it, and the engineered dynamics reconstructs a low-entropy macrostate. An independent distribution-level test separates hidden dynamical activity from finite-step return, and an exact classical measure-preserving counterpart shows which parts of the construction are not uniquely quantum. Within the specified record and observation window, irreversibility is therefore not loss of microscopic information, but the failure of that information to organize currents that restore macroscopic order.
In 1964, Yu. A. Gol'fand proposed an extension of quantum mechanics to discrete time, predicting intrinsic non-unitarity and entropy increase. While historically significant, this formalism predates the modern theory of open quantum systems. In this work, we rigorously recast Gol'fand's discrete evolution equation as a Completely Positive Trace-Preserving (CPTP) quantum channel and derive its continuous-time coarse-grained limit. We demonstrate that the dynamics converge to a specific Lindblad master equation characterized by a fundamental time scale τττ, which induces decoherence in both the energy basis and a fundamental operator basis WWW. We analyze the thermodynamic implications using Spohn's entropy production formalism, proving that the discrete time step induces a strictly positive entropy production rate driven by the decay of quantum coherences, thereby providing a microscopic foundation for the arrow of time independent of environmental coupling. Furthermore, we quantify the loss of quantum coherence via fidelity decay and purity loss, establishing exact constraints for fault-tolerant quantum computing. We further investigate the impact of this intrinsic decoherence on Discrete Time Crystals (DTCs), showing that Gol'fand dynamics impose a fundamental lifetime limit on time-translation symmetry breaking phases. Finally, we utilize precision data from optical lattice clocks, matter-wave interferometry, and neutrino oscillations to place stringent upper bounds on τττ. Our results constrain the fundamental time discretization to τ≲10−26τ\lesssim 10^{-26}τ≲10−26 s, significantly tightening previous limits and offering a testable framework for quantum gravity phenomenology.
Entropy production plays a fundamental role in nonequilibrium thermodynamics to quantify the irreversibility of open systems. Its positivity can be ensured for a wide class of setups, but the entropy production rate can become negative sometimes. This is often taken as an indicator of non-Markovianity. We make this link precise by showing under which conditions a negative entropy production rate implies non-Markovianity and when it does not. For a system coupled to a single heat bath, this can be established within a unified language for two setups: (i) the dynamics resulting from a coarse-grained description of a Markovian master equation and (ii) the classical Hamiltonian dynamics of a system coupled to a bath. The quantum version of the latter result is shown not to hold despite the fact that the integrated thermodynamic description is formally equivalent to the classical case. The instantaneous fixed point of a non-Markovian dynamics plays an important role in our study. Our key contribution is to provide a consistent theoretical framework to study the finite-time thermodynamics of a large class of dynamics with a precise link to its non-Markovianity.