Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.12494

An Alternative to Quantum Theory

Julian Barbour, Maria I. R. Lourenço

Published Nov 9, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Despite the remarkable empirical success of quantum theory, the interpretation of measurement and the nature of entanglement correlations remain open questions. We outline an alternative framework that seeks to recover the empirical results of quantum theory from a holistic, scale-invariant ontology. Assuming only point particles in Euclidean space, characterised by ratios of masses (and charges) and by the ratios of their mutual separations, the theory describes shapes through a single scale-invariant function; no dynamical evolution is required. In principle, this framework provides a unified description of finite subsystems embedded in a configuration of infinitely many particles and offers a possible route to deriving the observed structures of atoms, molecules and macroscopic bodies without invoking standard quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.12494

Related papers

A Balance-Based Systemic Framework for Wave Function Collapse and Quantum Entanglement

Angelito Enriquez Malicse

Quantum mechanics has been remarkably successful in predicting experimental outcomes, yet foundational questions—such as the nature of wave function collapse and the mechanism of quantum entanglement—remain unresolved. Standard interpretations invoke observer-dependence, intrinsic randomness, or non-local interactions, leading to conceptual difficulties. This work proposes a unifying explanation based on a universal balance-based system framework. Within this approach, quantum systems are treated as interconnected, defect-free systems whose behavior emerges through feedback mechanisms. Wave function collapse corresponds to the enforcement of systemic balance under new constraints, while entanglement arises from globally enforced balance across spatially separated nodes. This framework preserves empirical predictions of quantum mechanics, is consistent with relativistic causality, and provides a coherent conceptual foundation that links microscopic quantum phenomena to universal system dynamics.

•Feb 4, 2026•0 citations

A Balance-Based Systemic Framework for Wave Function Collapse and Quantum Entanglement

Angelito Enriquez Malicse

Quantum mechanics has been remarkably successful in predicting experimental outcomes, yet foundational questions—such as the nature of wave function collapse and the mechanism of quantum entanglement—remain unresolved. Standard interpretations invoke observer-dependence, intrinsic randomness, or non-local interactions, leading to conceptual difficulties. This work proposes a unifying explanation based on a universal balance-based system framework. Within this approach, quantum systems are treated as interconnected, defect-free systems whose behavior emerges through feedback mechanisms. Wave function collapse corresponds to the enforcement of systemic balance under new constraints, while entanglement arises from globally enforced balance across spatially separated nodes. This framework preserves empirical predictions of quantum mechanics, is consistent with relativistic causality, and provides a coherent conceptual foundation that links microscopic quantum phenomena to universal system dynamics.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

A Scale-Invariant Theory of the Universe

Julian Barbour, Maria I. R. Lourenço

Modern physics has achieved extraordinary empirical success while retaining much of the absolute, unobservable structure introduced by Newton, largely without questioning its necessity. We investigate how far this structure can be eliminated by adopting a relational ontology guided by Leibniz's principle of sufficient reason. Removing absolute position, orientation, time and, finally, scale leads naturally to a formulation of the gravitational $N$-body problem where only dimensionless ratios are physically meaningful. Within this framework, the scale-invariant variety $V$ becomes a central quantity, providing a measure of structure, a natural ordering of shapes, and an emergent gravitational arrow of time. We argue that the resulting formulation unifies classes of Newtonian solutions previously regarded as distinct, uncovering a possible new symmetry, suggests a notion of explanation based on timeless spatial correlations rather than temporal evolution, and points towards a more economical ontology. Although developed in the context of Newtonian gravity, the principles proposed here may also offer a new perspective on general relativity and quantum mechanics.

gr-qcCross-listedarXiv:2608.05929•Aug 7, 2026

Quantum Mechanical Reality: Entanglement and Decoherence

Avijit Lahiri

We look into the ontology of quantum theory as distinct from that of the classical theory in the sciences, following a broadly Kantian tradition and distinguishing between the noumenal and phenomenal realities where the former is independent of our perception while the latter is assembled from the former by means of fragmentary bits of interpretation. Within this framework, theories are conceptual constructs applying to models generated in the phenomenal world within limited contexts.The ontology of quantum theory principally rests on the view that entities in the world are pervasively correlated with one another not by means of probabilities as in the case of the classical theory, but by means of probability amplitudes involving finely tuned phases of quantum mechanical states (entanglement). The quantum correlations are shared globally in the process of environment-induced decoherence whereby locally generated correlations are removed, the removal being especially manifest in the case of systems that appear as classical ones, in which case the process is almost instantaneous, being, in all likelihood, driven by field fluctuations in the Planck regime. This points to factors of an unknown nature determining its finest details, since Planck scale physics remains an obscure terrain. In other words, the present day quantum theory holds within a limited context set by the Planck scale.

arXiv:2307.12148•Jul 22, 2023•0 citations

Structure of the quantum world

Roger Penrose

Abstract Quantum theory provides a superb description of physical reality on a small scale, yet it contains many mysteries. Without doubt, it is hard to come to terms with the workings of this theory, and it is particularly difficult to make sense of the kind of ‘physical reality’—or lack of it—that it seems to imply for our world. Taken at its face value, the theory seems to lead to a philosophical standpoint that many (including myself) find deeply unsatisfying. At best, and taking its descriptions at their most literal, it provides us with a very strange view of the world indeed. At worst, and taking literally the proclamations of some of its most famous protagonists, it provides us with no view of the world at all.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Aug 22, 1996•1 citation

Distributed Presence : A Structural Ontological Framework for Randomness and Quantum Phenomena

Nasiri Vatan, Sadeq

Abstract Despite its empirical success, quantum mechanics continues to provoke foundational debates concerning the nature of probability, the ontological status of the quantum state, and the mechanism of measurement. [1] This work introduces Distributed Presence (DP) as a structural ontological framework that addresses these issues by reinterpreting quantum phenomena in terms of a system’s distributed mode of existence across its state space. Crucially, this distribution is modal rather than spatial: it concerns how a system is present across possible states, not how it is extended in physical space. Within the DP framework, a quantum system is not assumed to occupy a definite state prior to interaction. Instead, its fundamental mode of existence is an ontologically distributed presence, understood as a structural feature of reality rather than a reflection of epistemic uncertainty. From this standpoint, probability is not introduced as a primitive postulate but emerges operationally from the geometry of presence, yielding a structural derivation of the Born rule. Core quantum phenomena (including superposition, wave–particle duality, state reduction, and entanglement) are recast as different manifestations of a single underlying principle: the modal distribution, reconfiguration, and non‑separability of presence. Entanglement corresponds to the non‑factorizability of presence fractions over a composite state space, while non‑local correlations are interpreted as consequences of shared modal structure rather than dynamical signal transmission, fully consistent with relativistic causality. The framework is developed within a Euclidean geometric setting chosen to prioritize ontological clarity, without altering the predictive formalism of standard quantum mechanics or its Hilbert‑space representation. By grounding randomness, probability, and quantum behavior in the notion of modal distributed presence, DP offers a coherent foundational program that bridges the conceptual gap between unitary evolution and definite outcomes, providing an alternative to both epistemic interpretations and wave‑function realism.

•Dec 15, 2025•0 citations
Despite the remarkable empirical success of quantum theory, the interpretation of measurement and the nature of entanglement correlations remain open questions. We outline an alternative framework that seeks to recover the empirical results of quantum theory from a holistic, scale-invariant ontology. Assuming only point particles in Euclidean space, characterised by ratios of masses (and charges) and by the ratios of their mutual separations, the theory describes shapes through a single scale-invariant function; no dynamical evolution is required. In principle, this framework provides a unified description of finite subsystems embedded in a configuration of infinitely many particles and offers a possible route to deriving the observed structures of atoms, molecules and macroscopic bodies without invoking standard quantum mechanics.
Quantum mechanics has been remarkably successful in predicting experimental outcomes, yet foundational questions—such as the nature of wave function collapse and the mechanism of quantum entanglement—remain unresolved. Standard interpretations invoke observer-dependence, intrinsic randomness, or non-local interactions, leading to conceptual difficulties. This work proposes a unifying explanation based on a universal balance-based system framework. Within this approach, quantum systems are treated as interconnected, defect-free systems whose behavior emerges through feedback mechanisms. Wave function collapse corresponds to the enforcement of systemic balance under new constraints, while entanglement arises from globally enforced balance across spatially separated nodes. This framework preserves empirical predictions of quantum mechanics, is consistent with relativistic causality, and provides a coherent conceptual foundation that links microscopic quantum phenomena to universal system dynamics.
Quantum mechanics has been remarkably successful in predicting experimental outcomes, yet foundational questions—such as the nature of wave function collapse and the mechanism of quantum entanglement—remain unresolved. Standard interpretations invoke observer-dependence, intrinsic randomness, or non-local interactions, leading to conceptual difficulties. This work proposes a unifying explanation based on a universal balance-based system framework. Within this approach, quantum systems are treated as interconnected, defect-free systems whose behavior emerges through feedback mechanisms. Wave function collapse corresponds to the enforcement of systemic balance under new constraints, while entanglement arises from globally enforced balance across spatially separated nodes. This framework preserves empirical predictions of quantum mechanics, is consistent with relativistic causality, and provides a coherent conceptual foundation that links microscopic quantum phenomena to universal system dynamics.
Modern physics has achieved extraordinary empirical success while retaining much of the absolute, unobservable structure introduced by Newton, largely without questioning its necessity. We investigate how far this structure can be eliminated by adopting a relational ontology guided by Leibniz's principle of sufficient reason. Removing absolute position, orientation, time and, finally, scale leads naturally to a formulation of the gravitational NNN-body problem where only dimensionless ratios are physically meaningful. Within this framework, the scale-invariant variety VVV becomes a central quantity, providing a measure of structure, a natural ordering of shapes, and an emergent gravitational arrow of time. We argue that the resulting formulation unifies classes of Newtonian solutions previously regarded as distinct, uncovering a possible new symmetry, suggests a notion of explanation based on timeless spatial correlations rather than temporal evolution, and points towards a more economical ontology. Although developed in the context of Newtonian gravity, the principles proposed here may also offer a new perspective on general relativity and quantum mechanics.
We look into the ontology of quantum theory as distinct from that of the classical theory in the sciences, following a broadly Kantian tradition and distinguishing between the noumenal and phenomenal realities where the former is independent of our perception while the latter is assembled from the former by means of fragmentary bits of interpretation. Within this framework, theories are conceptual constructs applying to models generated in the phenomenal world within limited contexts.The ontology of quantum theory principally rests on the view that entities in the world are pervasively correlated with one another not by means of probabilities as in the case of the classical theory, but by means of probability amplitudes involving finely tuned phases of quantum mechanical states (entanglement). The quantum correlations are shared globally in the process of environment-induced decoherence whereby locally generated correlations are removed, the removal being especially manifest in the case of systems that appear as classical ones, in which case the process is almost instantaneous, being, in all likelihood, driven by field fluctuations in the Planck regime. This points to factors of an unknown nature determining its finest details, since Planck scale physics remains an obscure terrain. In other words, the present day quantum theory holds within a limited context set by the Planck scale.
Abstract Quantum theory provides a superb description of physical reality on a small scale, yet it contains many mysteries. Without doubt, it is hard to come to terms with the workings of this theory, and it is particularly difficult to make sense of the kind of ‘physical reality’—or lack of it—that it seems to imply for our world. Taken at its face value, the theory seems to lead to a philosophical standpoint that many (including myself) find deeply unsatisfying. At best, and taking its descriptions at their most literal, it provides us with a very strange view of the world indeed. At worst, and taking literally the proclamations of some of its most famous protagonists, it provides us with no view of the world at all.
Abstract Despite its empirical success, quantum mechanics continues to provoke foundational debates concerning the nature of probability, the ontological status of the quantum state, and the mechanism of measurement. [1] This work introduces Distributed Presence (DP) as a structural ontological framework that addresses these issues by reinterpreting quantum phenomena in terms of a system’s distributed mode of existence across its state space. Crucially, this distribution is modal rather than spatial: it concerns how a system is present across possible states, not how it is extended in physical space. Within the DP framework, a quantum system is not assumed to occupy a definite state prior to interaction. Instead, its fundamental mode of existence is an ontologically distributed presence, understood as a structural feature of reality rather than a reflection of epistemic uncertainty. From this standpoint, probability is not introduced as a primitive postulate but emerges operationally from the geometry of presence, yielding a structural derivation of the Born rule. Core quantum phenomena (including superposition, wave–particle duality, state reduction, and entanglement) are recast as different manifestations of a single underlying principle: the modal distribution, reconfiguration, and non‑separability of presence. Entanglement corresponds to the non‑factorizability of presence fractions over a composite state space, while non‑local correlations are interpreted as consequences of shared modal structure rather than dynamical signal transmission, fully consistent with relativistic causality. The framework is developed within a Euclidean geometric setting chosen to prioritize ontological clarity, without altering the predictive formalism of standard quantum mechanics or its Hilbert‑space representation. By grounding randomness, probability, and quantum behavior in the notion of modal distributed presence, DP offers a coherent foundational program that bridges the conceptual gap between unitary evolution and definite outcomes, providing an alternative to both epistemic interpretations and wave‑function realism.