Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.12049

Parameterized equivalence checking of quantum circuit generators via weighted automata

Pavel Chuklanov

Published Nov 9, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A generator builds a quantum circuit from the number of qubits and a bit string. We check a generator against a reference for all parameter values under six equivalence relations. For ladder programs, we prove that above a computable threshold the circuit matrices form a uniform matrix product operator, a weighted automaton of dimension independent of the number of qubits. Equivalence reduces to the zeroness of a difference automaton, checked modulo primes. The answer is a counterexample or "equal", exact or with a computed error bound. Experimentally, the method found errors missed by fixed-size checks and produced no incorrect verdicts.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.12049

Related papers

Parameterized Verification of Quantum Circuits

Parosh Aziz Abdulla, Yu-Fang Chen, Michal Hečko +4 more

We present the first fully automatic framework for verifying relational properties of parameterized quantum programs , i.e., a program that, given an input size, generates a corresponding quantum circuit. We focus on verifying input-output correctness as well as equivalence. At the core of our approach is a new automata model, synchronized weighted tree automata (SWTAs), which compactly and precisely captures the infinite families of quantum states produced by parameterized programs. We introduce a class of transducers to model quantum gate semantics and develop composition algorithms for constructing transducers of parameterized circuits. Verification is reduced to functional inclusion or equivalence checking between SWTAs, for which we provide decision procedures. Our implementation demonstrates both the expressiveness and practical efficiency of the framework by verifying a diverse set of representative parameterized quantum programs with verification times ranging from milliseconds to seconds.

arXiv:2511.19897•Proceedings of the ACM on Programming Languages•Jan 8, 2026•14 citations

Partial Equivalence Checking of Quantum Circuits

Tian-Fu Chen, Jie-Hong Roland Jiang, Min-Hsiu Hsieh

Equivalence checking of quantum circuits is an essential element in quantum program compilation, in which a quantum program can be synthesized into different quantum circuits that may vary in the number of qubits, initialization requirements, and output states. Verifying the equivalences among the implementation variants requires proper generality. Although different notions of quantum circuit equivalence have been defined, prior methods cannot check observational equivalence between two quantum circuits whose qubits are partially initialized, which is referred to as partial equivalence. In this work, we prove a necessary and sufficient condition for two circuits to be partially equivalent. Based on the condition, we devise algorithms for checking quantum circuits whose partial equivalence cannot be verified by prior approaches. Experiment results confirm the generality and demonstrate the efficiency and effectiveness of our method. Our result may unleash the optimization power of quantum program compilation to take more aggressive steps.

arXiv:2208.07564•IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Sep 1, 2022•26 citations

Manjushri: A Tool for Equivalence Checking of Quantum Circuits

Xuan Du Trinh, Meghana Sistla, Nengkun Yu +1 more

Verifying whether two quantum circuits are equivalent is a central challenge in the compilation and optimization of quantum programs. We introduce \textsc{Manjushri}, a new automated framework for scalable quantum-circuit equivalence checking. \textsc{Manjushri} uses local projections as discriminative circuit fingerprints, implemented with weighted binary decision diagrams (WBDDs), yielding a compact and efficient symbolic representation of quantum behavior. We present an extensive experimental evaluation that, for random 1D Clifford+$T$ circuits, explores the trade-off between \textsc{Manjushri} and \textsc{ECMC}, a tool for equivalence checking based on a much different approach. \textsc{Manjushri} is much faster up to depth 30 (with the crossover point varying from 39--49, depending on the number of qubits and whether the input circuits are equivalent or inequivalent): when inputs are equivalent, \textsc{Manjushri} is about 10$\times$ faster (or more); when inputs are inequivalent, \textsc{Manjushri} is about 8$\times$ faster (or more). For both kinds of equivalence-checking outcomes, \textsc{ECMC}'s success rate out to depth 50 is impressive on 32- and 64-qubit circuits: on such circuits, \textsc{ECMC} is almost uniformly successful. However, \textsc{ECMC} struggled on 128-qubit circuits for some depths. \textsc{Manjushri} is almost uniformly successful out to about depth 38, before tailing off to about 75\% at depth 50 (falling to 0\% at depth 48 for 128-qubit circuits that are equivalent). These results establish that \textsc{Manjushri} is a practical and scalable solution for large-scale quantum-circuit verification, and would be the preferred choice unless clients need to check equivalence of circuits of depth $>$38.

quant-pharXiv:2601.22372•Feb 2, 2026•1 citation

Equivalence checking of quantum circuits via intermediary matrix product operator

Aaron Sander, Lukas Burgholzer, Robert Wille

As quantum computing advances, the complexity of quantum circuits is rapidly increasing, driving the need for robust methods to aid in their design. Equivalence checking plays a vital role in identifying errors that may arise during compilation and optimization of these circuits and is a critical step in quantum circuit verification. In this work, we introduce a method based on matrix product operators (MPOs) for determining the equivalence of quantum circuits. Our approach contracts tensorized quantum gates from two circuits into an intermediary MPO, exploiting their reversibility to determine their equivalence or nonequivalence. Our results show that this method offers significant scalability improvements over existing methods, with polynomial scaling in circuit width and depth for the practical use cases we explore. We expect that this work to set a standard for scalable equivalence checking of quantum circuits and will become a crucial tool for the validation of increasingly complex quantum systems.

arXiv:2410.10946•Physical Review Research•May 29, 2025•11 citations

Efficient equivalence checking of Clifford-U circuits with shared single-qubit unitaries

Daisuke Sakamoto, Soshun Naito, Yusei Mori +1 more

Quantum circuit equivalence checking asks whether two circuits implement the same unitary. It guarantees compiler correctness and safe optimization, yet most existing approaches scale exponentially with the number of qubits or the circuit depth, or are restricted to specific circuit structures. In this work, we present an equivalence-checking method for circuits formed by arbitrary single-qubit layers interleaved with Clifford layers. This pattern is common in variational quantum algorithms and Hamiltonian simulation via Trotter decomposition. It can also represent any unitary with sufficient depth. We prove the existence of an efficient classical algorithm that determines whether a pair of circuits with shared single-qubit layers are equivalent for every possible choice of the shared single-qubit unitaries. The same algorithm can also certify their non-equivalence for fixed assignments of single-qubit unitaries. Our framework supports the validation of emerging quantum compilers and facilitate the discovery of novel circuit optimization passes.

quant-pharXiv:2603.12697•Mar 16, 2026•2 citations

Equivalence Checking of Parameterized Quantum Circuits: Verifying the Compilation of Variational Quantum Algorithms

Tom Peham, Lukas Burgholzer, Robert Wille

Variational quantum algorithms have been introduced as a promising class of quantum-classical hybrid algorithms that can already be used with the noisy quantum computing hardware available today by employing parameterized quantum circuits. Considering the non-trivial nature of quantum circuit compilation and the subtleties of quantum computing, it is essential to verify that these parameterized circuits have been compiled correctly. Established equivalence checking procedures that handle parameter-free circuits already exist. However, no methodology capable of handling circuits with parameters has been proposed yet. This work fills this gap by showing that verifying the equivalence of parameterized circuits can be achieved in a purely symbolic fashion using an equivalence checking approach based on the ZX-calculus. At the same time, proofs of inequality can be efficiently obtained with conventional methods by taking advantage of the degrees of freedom inherent to parameterized circuits. We implemented the corresponding methods and proved that the resulting methodology is complete. Experimental evaluations (using the entire parametric ansatz circuit library provided by Qiskit as benchmarks) demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed approach.

arXiv:2210.12166•Asia and South Pacific Design Automation Conference (ASP-DAC)•Jan 16, 2023•33 citations
A generator builds a quantum circuit from the number of qubits and a bit string. We check a generator against a reference for all parameter values under six equivalence relations. For ladder programs, we prove that above a computable threshold the circuit matrices form a uniform matrix product operator, a weighted automaton of dimension independent of the number of qubits. Equivalence reduces to the zeroness of a difference automaton, checked modulo primes. The answer is a counterexample or "equal", exact or with a computed error bound. Experimentally, the method found errors missed by fixed-size checks and produced no incorrect verdicts.
We present the first fully automatic framework for verifying relational properties of parameterized quantum programs , i.e., a program that, given an input size, generates a corresponding quantum circuit. We focus on verifying input-output correctness as well as equivalence. At the core of our approach is a new automata model, synchronized weighted tree automata (SWTAs), which compactly and precisely captures the infinite families of quantum states produced by parameterized programs. We introduce a class of transducers to model quantum gate semantics and develop composition algorithms for constructing transducers of parameterized circuits. Verification is reduced to functional inclusion or equivalence checking between SWTAs, for which we provide decision procedures. Our implementation demonstrates both the expressiveness and practical efficiency of the framework by verifying a diverse set of representative parameterized quantum programs with verification times ranging from milliseconds to seconds.
Equivalence checking of quantum circuits is an essential element in quantum program compilation, in which a quantum program can be synthesized into different quantum circuits that may vary in the number of qubits, initialization requirements, and output states. Verifying the equivalences among the implementation variants requires proper generality. Although different notions of quantum circuit equivalence have been defined, prior methods cannot check observational equivalence between two quantum circuits whose qubits are partially initialized, which is referred to as partial equivalence. In this work, we prove a necessary and sufficient condition for two circuits to be partially equivalent. Based on the condition, we devise algorithms for checking quantum circuits whose partial equivalence cannot be verified by prior approaches. Experiment results confirm the generality and demonstrate the efficiency and effectiveness of our method. Our result may unleash the optimization power of quantum program compilation to take more aggressive steps.
Verifying whether two quantum circuits are equivalent is a central challenge in the compilation and optimization of quantum programs. We introduce \textsc{Manjushri}, a new automated framework for scalable quantum-circuit equivalence checking. \textsc{Manjushri} uses local projections as discriminative circuit fingerprints, implemented with weighted binary decision diagrams (WBDDs), yielding a compact and efficient symbolic representation of quantum behavior. We present an extensive experimental evaluation that, for random 1D Clifford+TTT circuits, explores the trade-off between \textsc{Manjushri} and \textsc{ECMC}, a tool for equivalence checking based on a much different approach. \textsc{Manjushri} is much faster up to depth 30 (with the crossover point varying from 39--49, depending on the number of qubits and whether the input circuits are equivalent or inequivalent): when inputs are equivalent, \textsc{Manjushri} is about 10×\times× faster (or more); when inputs are inequivalent, \textsc{Manjushri} is about 8×\times× faster (or more). For both kinds of equivalence-checking outcomes, \textsc{ECMC}'s success rate out to depth 50 is impressive on 32- and 64-qubit circuits: on such circuits, \textsc{ECMC} is almost uniformly successful. However, \textsc{ECMC} struggled on 128-qubit circuits for some depths. \textsc{Manjushri} is almost uniformly successful out to about depth 38, before tailing off to about 75\% at depth 50 (falling to 0\% at depth 48 for 128-qubit circuits that are equivalent). These results establish that \textsc{Manjushri} is a practical and scalable solution for large-scale quantum-circuit verification, and would be the preferred choice unless clients need to check equivalence of circuits of depth $>$38.
As quantum computing advances, the complexity of quantum circuits is rapidly increasing, driving the need for robust methods to aid in their design. Equivalence checking plays a vital role in identifying errors that may arise during compilation and optimization of these circuits and is a critical step in quantum circuit verification. In this work, we introduce a method based on matrix product operators (MPOs) for determining the equivalence of quantum circuits. Our approach contracts tensorized quantum gates from two circuits into an intermediary MPO, exploiting their reversibility to determine their equivalence or nonequivalence. Our results show that this method offers significant scalability improvements over existing methods, with polynomial scaling in circuit width and depth for the practical use cases we explore. We expect that this work to set a standard for scalable equivalence checking of quantum circuits and will become a crucial tool for the validation of increasingly complex quantum systems.
Quantum circuit equivalence checking asks whether two circuits implement the same unitary. It guarantees compiler correctness and safe optimization, yet most existing approaches scale exponentially with the number of qubits or the circuit depth, or are restricted to specific circuit structures. In this work, we present an equivalence-checking method for circuits formed by arbitrary single-qubit layers interleaved with Clifford layers. This pattern is common in variational quantum algorithms and Hamiltonian simulation via Trotter decomposition. It can also represent any unitary with sufficient depth. We prove the existence of an efficient classical algorithm that determines whether a pair of circuits with shared single-qubit layers are equivalent for every possible choice of the shared single-qubit unitaries. The same algorithm can also certify their non-equivalence for fixed assignments of single-qubit unitaries. Our framework supports the validation of emerging quantum compilers and facilitate the discovery of novel circuit optimization passes.
Variational quantum algorithms have been introduced as a promising class of quantum-classical hybrid algorithms that can already be used with the noisy quantum computing hardware available today by employing parameterized quantum circuits. Considering the non-trivial nature of quantum circuit compilation and the subtleties of quantum computing, it is essential to verify that these parameterized circuits have been compiled correctly. Established equivalence checking procedures that handle parameter-free circuits already exist. However, no methodology capable of handling circuits with parameters has been proposed yet. This work fills this gap by showing that verifying the equivalence of parameterized circuits can be achieved in a purely symbolic fashion using an equivalence checking approach based on the ZX-calculus. At the same time, proofs of inequality can be efficiently obtained with conventional methods by taking advantage of the degrees of freedom inherent to parameterized circuits. We implemented the corresponding methods and proved that the resulting methodology is complete. Experimental evaluations (using the entire parametric ansatz circuit library provided by Qiskit as benchmarks) demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed approach.