Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.10527

QAOA Inside ADMM: Subproblem Wins Do Not Become Decomposition Wins at Matched Budgets

Mohammad Arif Hossain, Sanim Yousuf Fahim

Published Nov 7, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We benchmark the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) as the binary subproblem solver in a two-block alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) for mixed-binary problems against classical solvers under matched budgets. With 23 optimizer evaluations per subproblem, scoring determines the comparison: on its final readout, the optimized QAOA loses to random search at $n=12$ and 16 binary variables (inconclusive at 20; exploratory and post hoc tests). When credited with its best sample, it wins. In a noiseless 12-qubit simulation, transferred-angle depth-2 QAOA finds the exact optimum of 97.3\% of planted-family subproblems, against 50.6\%--67.4\% for the four strongest local heuristics (100\% against 90.4\%--94.4\% crediting the four best bitstrings) and a not significantly different 96.5\% for semidefinite rounding with local search (SDP+LS). Under our evaluation-counting convention, its time to solution there is a factor of three to five below the local heuristics' but grows with a larger exponent; it is ten times that of SDP+LS and, in seconds, 54 times that of tabu search with restarts. For the benchmark class, an unconstrained binary quadratic problem in disguise, ADMM's binary step is a proximal step on the reduced problem: at unit penalty ADMM re-solves it, and for larger penalties exact solutions increasingly stall. On two families that do not reduce to one, less accurate solvers found the problem optimum more often at unit and larger penalties. No family gave QAOA a better ADMM outcome than the best classical solver and penalty. The benchmark includes a correctness gate and a log of its hypothesis tests.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.10527

Related papers

Multiblock ADMM Heuristics for Mixed-Binary Optimization on Classical and Quantum Computers

Claudio Gambella, Andrea Simonetto

Solving combinatorial optimization problems on current noisy quantum devices is currently being advocated for (and restricted to) binary polynomial optimization with equality constraints via quantum heuristic approaches. This is achieved using, for example, the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) and the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA). In this article, we present a decomposition-based approach to extend the applicability of current approaches to “quadratic plus convex” mixed binary optimization (MBO) problems, so as to solve a broad class of real-world optimization problems. In the MBO framework, we show that the alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) can split the MBO into a binary unconstrained problem (that can be solved with quantum algorithms), and continuous constrained convex subproblems (that can be solved cheaply with classical optimization solvers). The validity of the approach is then showcased by numerical results obtained on several optimization problems via simulations with VQE and QAOA on the quantum circuits implemented in Qiskit, an open-source quantum computing software development framework.

arXiv:2001.02069•IEEE Transactions on Quantum Engineering•Jan 1, 2020•71 citations

A Distributed Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm for Unit Commitment

Ali Rajabi, Milad Hasanzadeh, Amin Kargarian

This paper presents a distributed quantum approximate optimization algorithm (DQAOA)-enabled three-block alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) framework for unit commitment (UC). The relaxed commitment and dispatch variables are solved in a continuous quadratic programming block, while the binary commitment block is formulated as a quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) problem. The DQAOA interface allows this QUBO to be solved using brute-force enumeration, monolithic QAOA, or distributed QAOA, while the remaining ADMM updates are kept unchanged. In the distributed mode, the logical commitment qubits are allocated across multiple capacity-constrained quantum processing units (QPU), avoiding the requirement that the complete binary problem fits on a single device. The framework is evaluated on a five-unit UC instance containing 15 binary variables. All three solver modes reduce the ADMM primal residual below a certain tolerance and recover the same commitment schedule, dispatch, and operating cost. The results demonstrate solution consistency across the three solver modes and the multi-QPU capacity accommodation provided by the distributed QAOA method.

arXiv:2608.04159•Southeast Symposium on Contemporary Engineering Topics (SSCET)•Aug 1, 2026•0 citations

An Efficient Hybrid Classical Quantum Algorithm for Mixed-Integer Constrained Optimization

Amit Surana

Widely used quantum optimization algorithms such as quantum annealing and quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) for quadratically unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) problems cannot systematically and efficiently handle constraints and mixed discrete and continuous decision variables. To address this, we present a novel hybrid classicalquantum approach which combines classical alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) with QAOA. Compared to conventional penalty-based method, this approach avoids quantization of continuous variables, eliminates the need for additional qubits to capture constraints on a quantum device and leads to reduced QAOA circuit depth suitable for near term implementation. We illustrate the efficacy of our approach on several constrained mixed integer optimization problems.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Aug 30, 2025•0 citations

Beyond the Mean Gap: What Transferred-Angle QAOA Retains on a Superconducting Processor

Sanim Yousuf Fahim, Mohammad Arif Hossain

Hardware executions of the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) are often validated by comparing the device's mean cost with a simulation, a check that can miss what matters for optimization. Under global depolarization, the mean normalized gap and the floor-corrected probability of every set of bitstrings, the optimum included, retain the same fraction of their noiseless improvement over uniform sampling. We test this prediction with depth-2, transferred-angle QAOA circuits for binary subproblems of an alternating-direction decomposition on the IBM Heron processor \texttt{ibm\_marrakesh}, with and without dynamical decoupling and twirling. At 12 qubits, the main-family circuits retained 29\% to 46\% of their mean-gap improvement but only 5\% to 15\% of their probability of the optimum, lower on at least nine of ten instances per run. Near-optimal bitstrings were lost about as much as the optimum, whereas the avoidance of poor bitstrings was retained best. In the first submission, a device-matched noise model reproduced the pattern but overestimated the retention of the optimum five- to eightfold. On a rugged planted family, the device found the optimum in 62\% of 768-shot blocks (noiseless: 98\%), within the range of local heuristics. Validations of optimization circuits should report retention of the optimum and of near-optimal sets.

arXiv:2611.10529•Nov 7, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Combinatorial Optimization Algorithms for Network Reconfiguration: QRAO vs. QAOA

Anh Phuong Ngo, Hieu Trung Nguyen

This paper reviews a hybrid quantum-classical distributed algorithm for NP-hard combinatorial optimization problems, which is embedded in IBM Qiskit's Alternating Direction Method of Multipliers (ADMM) optimizer. We demonstrate a proof of concept for solving Mixed-Integer Convex Programs (MICP) in power system applications using a use case on power distribution network reconfiguration in IBM quantum computers. Using the Qiskit ADMM optimizer, the MICP is decomposed into two subproblems: a quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) solved by quantum algorithms and a convex one solved by classical solvers. Our essential contribution is integrating the Quantum Random Access Optimization (QRAO) into the quantum-classical distributed framework and the existing Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) implemented in the Qiskit ADMM Optimizer. QRAO utilizes Quantum Random Access Codes (QRACs) to minimize qubit requirements and utilizes quantum state rounding for solution extraction. We examine the impact of noise on solutions derived from QRAO and compare them with results from QAOA using a use case on network reconfiguration in response to faults in the power distribution system.

North American Power Symposium (NAPS)•Oct 13, 2024•9 citations

Where NISQ-Era Quantum Optimization Stands Today: An Honest Benchmark of QAOA Against Classical Heuristics on a Real-World Exam-Scheduling Max-Cut Problem

Prashant ARYA, Cybergeon Technologies India

Full-pipeline benchmark of the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) against classical combinatorial solvers on a weighted Max-Cut formulation of exam-scheduling conflict minimization. Compares random assignment, greedy heuristic, 2-opt local search, exact ILP (OR-Tools), and QAOA — first via noisy local simulation on an 18-qubit validation subset, then via live execution on IBM's ibm_marrakesh (Heron r2) processor at the full 42-qubit scale. Uses shot-weighted expected-value scoring throughout rather than best-observed-sample reporting. At 18 qubits QAOA reaches 95.4% of the proven optimum; at 42 qubits the hardware run's expected value falls below random guessing (49.05% vs 50.00%), with all 4,096 shots returning distinct bitstrings — the signature of decoherence overwhelming the circuit. Includes causal analysis of the failure mode and outlines planned comparison against quantum annealing hardware.

•Jul 25, 2026•0 citations
We benchmark the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) as the binary subproblem solver in a two-block alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) for mixed-binary problems against classical solvers under matched budgets. With 23 optimizer evaluations per subproblem, scoring determines the comparison: on its final readout, the optimized QAOA loses to random search at n=12n=12n=12 and 16 binary variables (inconclusive at 20; exploratory and post hoc tests). When credited with its best sample, it wins. In a noiseless 12-qubit simulation, transferred-angle depth-2 QAOA finds the exact optimum of 97.3% of planted-family subproblems, against 50.6%--67.4% for the four strongest local heuristics (100% against 90.4%--94.4% crediting the four best bitstrings) and a not significantly different 96.5% for semidefinite rounding with local search (SDP+LS). Under our evaluation-counting convention, its time to solution there is a factor of three to five below the local heuristics' but grows with a larger exponent; it is ten times that of SDP+LS and, in seconds, 54 times that of tabu search with restarts. For the benchmark class, an unconstrained binary quadratic problem in disguise, ADMM's binary step is a proximal step on the reduced problem: at unit penalty ADMM re-solves it, and for larger penalties exact solutions increasingly stall. On two families that do not reduce to one, less accurate solvers found the problem optimum more often at unit and larger penalties. No family gave QAOA a better ADMM outcome than the best classical solver and penalty. The benchmark includes a correctness gate and a log of its hypothesis tests.
Solving combinatorial optimization problems on current noisy quantum devices is currently being advocated for (and restricted to) binary polynomial optimization with equality constraints via quantum heuristic approaches. This is achieved using, for example, the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) and the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA). In this article, we present a decomposition-based approach to extend the applicability of current approaches to “quadratic plus convex” mixed binary optimization (MBO) problems, so as to solve a broad class of real-world optimization problems. In the MBO framework, we show that the alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) can split the MBO into a binary unconstrained problem (that can be solved with quantum algorithms), and continuous constrained convex subproblems (that can be solved cheaply with classical optimization solvers). The validity of the approach is then showcased by numerical results obtained on several optimization problems via simulations with VQE and QAOA on the quantum circuits implemented in Qiskit, an open-source quantum computing software development framework.
This paper presents a distributed quantum approximate optimization algorithm (DQAOA)-enabled three-block alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) framework for unit commitment (UC). The relaxed commitment and dispatch variables are solved in a continuous quadratic programming block, while the binary commitment block is formulated as a quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) problem. The DQAOA interface allows this QUBO to be solved using brute-force enumeration, monolithic QAOA, or distributed QAOA, while the remaining ADMM updates are kept unchanged. In the distributed mode, the logical commitment qubits are allocated across multiple capacity-constrained quantum processing units (QPU), avoiding the requirement that the complete binary problem fits on a single device. The framework is evaluated on a five-unit UC instance containing 15 binary variables. All three solver modes reduce the ADMM primal residual below a certain tolerance and recover the same commitment schedule, dispatch, and operating cost. The results demonstrate solution consistency across the three solver modes and the multi-QPU capacity accommodation provided by the distributed QAOA method.
Widely used quantum optimization algorithms such as quantum annealing and quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) for quadratically unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) problems cannot systematically and efficiently handle constraints and mixed discrete and continuous decision variables. To address this, we present a novel hybrid classicalquantum approach which combines classical alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) with QAOA. Compared to conventional penalty-based method, this approach avoids quantization of continuous variables, eliminates the need for additional qubits to capture constraints on a quantum device and leads to reduced QAOA circuit depth suitable for near term implementation. We illustrate the efficacy of our approach on several constrained mixed integer optimization problems.
Hardware executions of the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) are often validated by comparing the device's mean cost with a simulation, a check that can miss what matters for optimization. Under global depolarization, the mean normalized gap and the floor-corrected probability of every set of bitstrings, the optimum included, retain the same fraction of their noiseless improvement over uniform sampling. We test this prediction with depth-2, transferred-angle QAOA circuits for binary subproblems of an alternating-direction decomposition on the IBM Heron processor \texttt{ibm\_marrakesh}, with and without dynamical decoupling and twirling. At 12 qubits, the main-family circuits retained 29\% to 46\% of their mean-gap improvement but only 5\% to 15\% of their probability of the optimum, lower on at least nine of ten instances per run. Near-optimal bitstrings were lost about as much as the optimum, whereas the avoidance of poor bitstrings was retained best. In the first submission, a device-matched noise model reproduced the pattern but overestimated the retention of the optimum five- to eightfold. On a rugged planted family, the device found the optimum in 62\% of 768-shot blocks (noiseless: 98\%), within the range of local heuristics. Validations of optimization circuits should report retention of the optimum and of near-optimal sets.
This paper reviews a hybrid quantum-classical distributed algorithm for NP-hard combinatorial optimization problems, which is embedded in IBM Qiskit's Alternating Direction Method of Multipliers (ADMM) optimizer. We demonstrate a proof of concept for solving Mixed-Integer Convex Programs (MICP) in power system applications using a use case on power distribution network reconfiguration in IBM quantum computers. Using the Qiskit ADMM optimizer, the MICP is decomposed into two subproblems: a quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) solved by quantum algorithms and a convex one solved by classical solvers. Our essential contribution is integrating the Quantum Random Access Optimization (QRAO) into the quantum-classical distributed framework and the existing Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) implemented in the Qiskit ADMM Optimizer. QRAO utilizes Quantum Random Access Codes (QRACs) to minimize qubit requirements and utilizes quantum state rounding for solution extraction. We examine the impact of noise on solutions derived from QRAO and compare them with results from QAOA using a use case on network reconfiguration in response to faults in the power distribution system.
Full-pipeline benchmark of the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) against classical combinatorial solvers on a weighted Max-Cut formulation of exam-scheduling conflict minimization. Compares random assignment, greedy heuristic, 2-opt local search, exact ILP (OR-Tools), and QAOA — first via noisy local simulation on an 18-qubit validation subset, then via live execution on IBM's ibm_marrakesh (Heron r2) processor at the full 42-qubit scale. Uses shot-weighted expected-value scoring throughout rather than best-observed-sample reporting. At 18 qubits QAOA reaches 95.4% of the proven optimum; at 42 qubits the hardware run's expected value falls below random guessing (49.05% vs 50.00%), with all 4,096 shots returning distinct bitstrings — the signature of decoherence overwhelming the circuit. Includes causal analysis of the failure mode and outlines planned comparison against quantum annealing hardware.