Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.04936

Single-anchor Delta-learning with the cluster Gutzwiller approximation: predicting phase boundaries of strongly correlated bosons in optical lattices

Shengbiao Yang, Sheng Yue, Zhi Lin

Published Nov 3, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The cluster Gutzwiller method is widely used to study strongly correlated bosonic systems in optical lattices because it explicitly treats quantum fluctuations within a cluster. However, its computational cost grows exponentially with the cluster size, making large-cluster phase diagrams computationally expensive. To reduce this cost, we recently introduced Delta-learning into cluster Gutzwiller calculations and proposed multipoint regression Delta-learning (MPR-Delta), which learns the difference between small- and large-cluster results from four high-cost critical points of the target cluster and thereby predicts the complete target phase boundary. For sufficiently large target clusters, however, even computing one critical point on the phase boundary is already expensive, so obtaining four such points remains highly costly. A natural question then arises: can the complete target phase boundary be predicted with fewer high-cost critical points of the target cluster? To address this question, we propose single-anchor Delta-learning (SA-Delta), which requires only a single high-cost critical point of the target cluster to reconstruct the complete target phase boundary, thereby greatly reducing the computational cost. We test this framework on several classes of Bose-Hubbard models and find that, in the cases considered, it achieves lower reconstruction errors with fewer high-cost points than MPR-Delta. The combination of SA-Delta with the cluster Gutzwiller approximation thus provides an efficient framework for studying phase transitions of strongly correlated bosonic systems in complex optical lattices, and may be extended to more complex quantum many-body systems.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.04936

Related papers

Delta-learning approach combined with the cluster Gutzwiller approximation for strongly correlated bosonic systems

Zhi Lin, Sheng Yue, T. Y. Wang

The cluster Gutzwiller method is widely used to study the strongly correlated bosonic systems, owing to its ability to provide a more precise description of quantum fluctuations. However, its utility is limited by the exponential increase in computational complexity as the cluster size grows. To overcome this limitation, we propose an artificial intelligence-based method known as $Δ$-Learning. This approach constructs a predictive model by learning the discrepancies between lower-precision (small cluster sizes) and high-precision (large cluster sizes) implementations of the cluster Gutzwiller method, requiring only a small number of training samples. Using this predictive model, we can effectively forecast the outcomes of high-precision methods with high accuracy. Applied to various Bose-Hubbard models, the $Δ$-Learning method effectively predicts phase diagrams while significantly reducing the computational resources and time. Furthermore, we have compared the predictive accuracy of $Δ$-Learning with other direct learning methods and found that $Δ$-Learning exhibits superior performance in scenarios with limited training data. Therefore, when combined with the cluster Gutzwiller approximation, the $Δ$-Learning approach offers a computationally efficient and accurate method for studying phase transitions in large, complex bosonic systems.

arXiv:2408.14306•Physical Review A•Jan 28, 2026•1 citation

Cluster Gutzwiller method for bosonic lattice systems

Dirk-Sören Lühmann

A versatile and numerically inexpensive method is presented allowing the accurate calculation of phase diagrams for bosonic lattice models. By treating clusters within the Gutzwiller theory, a surprisingly good description of quantum fluctuations beyond the mean-field theory is achieved approaching quantum Monte Carlo predictions for large clusters. Applying this powerful method to the Bose-Hubbard model, we demonstrate that it yields precise results for the superfluid to Mott-insulator transition in square, honeycomb, and cubic lattices. Due to the exact treatment within a cluster, the method can be effortlessly adapted to more complicated Hamiltonians in the fast progressing field of optical lattice experiments. This includes state- and site-dependent superlattices, large confined atomic systems, and disordered potentials, as well as various types of extended Hubbard models. Furthermore, the approach allows an excellent treatment of systems with arbitrary filling factors. We discuss the perspectives that allow for the computation of large, spatially varying lattices, low-lying excitations, and time evolution.

arXiv:1302.6761•Physical Review A•Apr 12, 2013•80 citations

Cluster Gutzwiller study of the Bose-Hubbard ladder: Ground-state phase diagram and many-body Landau-Zener dynamics

Haiming Deng, Hui Dai, Jiahao Huang +5 more

We present a cluster Gutzwiller mean-field study for ground states and time-evolution dynamics in the Bose-Hubbard ladder (BHL), which can be realized by loading Bose atoms in double-well optical lattices. In our cluster mean-field approach, we treat each double-well unit of two lattice sites as a coherent whole for composing the cluster Gutzwiller ansatz, which may remain some residual correlations in each two-site unit. For an unbiased BHL, in addition to conventional superfluid phase and integer Mott insulator phases, we find that there are exotic fractional insulator phases if the interchain tunneling is much stronger than the intrachain one. The fractional insulator phases cannot be found by using a conventional mean-field treatment based upon the single-site Gutzwiller ansatz. For a biased BHL, we find there appear single-atom tunneling and interaction blockade if the system is dominated by the interplay between the on-site interaction and the interchain bias. In the many-body Landau-Zener process, in which the interchain bias is linearly swept from negative to positive or vice versa, our numerical results are qualitatively consistent with the experimental observation [Nat. Phys. 7, 61 (2011)]. Our cluster bosonic Gutzwiller treatment is of promising perspectives in exploring exotic quantum phases and time-evolution dynamics of bosonic particles in superlattices.

arXiv:1504.08192•Physical Review A•Aug 13, 2015•17 citations

Strongly correlated ultra-cold bosonic atoms in optical lattices

Kalani Hettiarachchilage

A major focus in condensed matter physics is to study the origin of exotic quantum phases such as coexistent and inhomogeneous phases, quantum criticality, and secondary ordered phases close to quantum critical points. Exotic phenomena in strongly correlated systems occur due to competing complex interactions of spin, charge, lattice, and orbital degrees of freedom. Complex quantum phases in strongly correlated systems are challenging, but they might be very useful due to their possible functionality to make advance devices. In order to understand, utilize, and optimize such behaviors, we need to improve our understanding of these systems. Studies in cold atom systems are of interest since cold atom experiments provide a control on model parameters. In this thesis, we use novel analytical and computational techniques to treat strongly interacting bosonic systems. Taking advantage of the very versatile quantum Monte Carlo Stochastic Green Function algorithm, we studied several interesting problems. First, we explore a recently developed new confining method for cold atoms on optical lattices. Atoms are confined via a hopping integral that decreases as a function of the distance from the center of the lattice. This method might lead to lower temperatures than existing diagonal confinement methods. Next, we study the ground state phase diagram of interacting bosons on a ring-shape lattice with a region of weak hopping integrals. The model, an extension of the well known Bose-Hubbard model, develops a novel local Mott phase in addition to the usual Mott and superfluid phases in the homogeneous system. This might provide a new insight to the description of atomtronics applications. Finally, we study the two species Bose Hubbard model in a two-dimensional lattice. This model presents novel phases due to the complexity associated with multiple species. Its phase diagram shows ordered and coexistence phases including a ferromagnetic phase separated phase with high entropy. This phase might be accessible experimentally. The novel phases found from our studies are linked to experiments on ultra-cold atoms trapped by laser beams.

Civil War Book Review•Jun 19, 2013•0 citations

Collective Modes and Strong Correlations from a Quantum Gutzwiller Ansatz

Fabio Caleffi

The present Thesis aims to deepen the understanding of the physics of strongly-correlated systems along diverse directions with a common denominator, namely a focus on the physical role played by the collective modes shaping quantum many-body correlations. This investigation has been mostly led through the heuristic application of the Quantum Gutzwiller Approach, a recently developed theory of the quantised excitations above the Gutzwiller approximation for strongly-interacting systems on a lattice. In the first place, the intertwining between quantum correlations and collective effects is explored in the context of Bose-Hubbard models, intended both as simple yet highly non-trivial realisations of complex many-body scenarios, and as controllable environments for the quantum simulation of impurity problems. In particular, we are able to provide a comprehensive and semi-analytical description of quantum fluctuations across the critical regimes induced by the proximity of a Mott transition (Mottness), ranging from accurate predictions for the superfluid density and pair correlations across quantum critical regimes to the Andreev-Bashkin effect in a two-component bosonic mixture. As case studies for the effectiveness and flexibility of our approach, we give a detailed account of the rich behaviours of a quantum impurity, either fixed or itinerant, immersed in a Bose-Hubbard environment, showing that both the decoherence dynamics of spinful particle and the resulting Bose polaron in the second case are extremely sensitive probes of the type of critical fluctuations experienced by the surrounding system. Additionally, we extend our analysis of quantum fluctuations to the Fermi-Hubbard model, where we uncover the interplay between low-energy quasiparticles and bosonic elementary excitations in determining two-particle correlations. A more complex physical scenario addressed in this Thesis is represented by driven-dissipative interacting systems, which find a state-of-the-art technological implementation in circuit QED platforms, among others. Inspired by the experimental interest in these systems as a potential toolbox for the generation of exotic quantum states of light, we consider a strongly-correlated fluid of photons on a lattice stabilised via incoherent drive and dissipation, and examine its collective fluctuations across the out-of-equilibrium insulator-to-superfluid transition of the system. Specifically, establishing a conceptual parallelism with our approach to fluctuations at equilibrium, we develop a linear-response theory of the excitations on top of the Gutzwiller stationary state of the Lindblad dynamics, and characterise their physical role in quantum observables and response functions. Taking advantage of our formalism, we describe also dynamical instabilities and novel physical regimes arising in the ultrastrong coupling limit of the superfluid phase. Among the most remarkable results, we bring to light the paradoxical nature of the Mott-like insulating phase of the system, whose peculiar one-body dynamical fluctuations are shown to echo the behaviour of a lasing state. Encompassing diverse modern domains of many-body physics, our investigation goes in the direction of solidifying the interpretation of collective modes as fundamental actors in correlation-induced phenomena under a unified physical picture.

•Nov 15, 2022•0 citations

Benchmarking the variational cluster approach by means of the one-dimensional Bose-Hubbard model

Michael Knap, Enrico Arrigoni, Wolfgang von der Linden

Convergence properties of the variational cluster approach with respect to the variational parameter space, cluster size, and boundary conditions of the reference system are investigated and discussed for bosonic many-body systems. Specifically, the variational cluster approach is applied to the one-dimensional Bose-Hubbard model, which exhibits a quantum phase transition from Mott to superfluid phase. In order to benchmark the variational cluster approach, results for the phase boundary delimiting the first Mott lobe are compared with essentially exact density matrix renormalization group data. Furthermore, static quantities, such as the ground state energy and the one-particle density matrix are compared with high-order strong coupling perturbation theory results. For reference systems with open boundary conditions the variational parameter space is extended by an additional variational parameter which allows for a more uniform particle density on the reference system and thus drastically improves the results. It turns out that the variational cluster approach yields accurate results with relatively low-computational effort for both the phase boundary as well as the static properties of the one-dimensional Bose-Hubbard model, even at the tip of the first Mott lobe where correlation effects are most pronounced.

arXiv:1002.2449•Physical Review B•Jun 17, 2010•16 citations
The cluster Gutzwiller method is widely used to study strongly correlated bosonic systems in optical lattices because it explicitly treats quantum fluctuations within a cluster. However, its computational cost grows exponentially with the cluster size, making large-cluster phase diagrams computationally expensive. To reduce this cost, we recently introduced Delta-learning into cluster Gutzwiller calculations and proposed multipoint regression Delta-learning (MPR-Delta), which learns the difference between small- and large-cluster results from four high-cost critical points of the target cluster and thereby predicts the complete target phase boundary. For sufficiently large target clusters, however, even computing one critical point on the phase boundary is already expensive, so obtaining four such points remains highly costly. A natural question then arises: can the complete target phase boundary be predicted with fewer high-cost critical points of the target cluster? To address this question, we propose single-anchor Delta-learning (SA-Delta), which requires only a single high-cost critical point of the target cluster to reconstruct the complete target phase boundary, thereby greatly reducing the computational cost. We test this framework on several classes of Bose-Hubbard models and find that, in the cases considered, it achieves lower reconstruction errors with fewer high-cost points than MPR-Delta. The combination of SA-Delta with the cluster Gutzwiller approximation thus provides an efficient framework for studying phase transitions of strongly correlated bosonic systems in complex optical lattices, and may be extended to more complex quantum many-body systems.
The cluster Gutzwiller method is widely used to study the strongly correlated bosonic systems, owing to its ability to provide a more precise description of quantum fluctuations. However, its utility is limited by the exponential increase in computational complexity as the cluster size grows. To overcome this limitation, we propose an artificial intelligence-based method known as ΔΔΔ-Learning. This approach constructs a predictive model by learning the discrepancies between lower-precision (small cluster sizes) and high-precision (large cluster sizes) implementations of the cluster Gutzwiller method, requiring only a small number of training samples. Using this predictive model, we can effectively forecast the outcomes of high-precision methods with high accuracy. Applied to various Bose-Hubbard models, the ΔΔΔ-Learning method effectively predicts phase diagrams while significantly reducing the computational resources and time. Furthermore, we have compared the predictive accuracy of ΔΔΔ-Learning with other direct learning methods and found that ΔΔΔ-Learning exhibits superior performance in scenarios with limited training data. Therefore, when combined with the cluster Gutzwiller approximation, the ΔΔΔ-Learning approach offers a computationally efficient and accurate method for studying phase transitions in large, complex bosonic systems.
A versatile and numerically inexpensive method is presented allowing the accurate calculation of phase diagrams for bosonic lattice models. By treating clusters within the Gutzwiller theory, a surprisingly good description of quantum fluctuations beyond the mean-field theory is achieved approaching quantum Monte Carlo predictions for large clusters. Applying this powerful method to the Bose-Hubbard model, we demonstrate that it yields precise results for the superfluid to Mott-insulator transition in square, honeycomb, and cubic lattices. Due to the exact treatment within a cluster, the method can be effortlessly adapted to more complicated Hamiltonians in the fast progressing field of optical lattice experiments. This includes state- and site-dependent superlattices, large confined atomic systems, and disordered potentials, as well as various types of extended Hubbard models. Furthermore, the approach allows an excellent treatment of systems with arbitrary filling factors. We discuss the perspectives that allow for the computation of large, spatially varying lattices, low-lying excitations, and time evolution.
We present a cluster Gutzwiller mean-field study for ground states and time-evolution dynamics in the Bose-Hubbard ladder (BHL), which can be realized by loading Bose atoms in double-well optical lattices. In our cluster mean-field approach, we treat each double-well unit of two lattice sites as a coherent whole for composing the cluster Gutzwiller ansatz, which may remain some residual correlations in each two-site unit. For an unbiased BHL, in addition to conventional superfluid phase and integer Mott insulator phases, we find that there are exotic fractional insulator phases if the interchain tunneling is much stronger than the intrachain one. The fractional insulator phases cannot be found by using a conventional mean-field treatment based upon the single-site Gutzwiller ansatz. For a biased BHL, we find there appear single-atom tunneling and interaction blockade if the system is dominated by the interplay between the on-site interaction and the interchain bias. In the many-body Landau-Zener process, in which the interchain bias is linearly swept from negative to positive or vice versa, our numerical results are qualitatively consistent with the experimental observation [Nat. Phys. 7, 61 (2011)]. Our cluster bosonic Gutzwiller treatment is of promising perspectives in exploring exotic quantum phases and time-evolution dynamics of bosonic particles in superlattices.
A major focus in condensed matter physics is to study the origin of exotic quantum phases such as coexistent and inhomogeneous phases, quantum criticality, and secondary ordered phases close to quantum critical points. Exotic phenomena in strongly correlated systems occur due to competing complex interactions of spin, charge, lattice, and orbital degrees of freedom. Complex quantum phases in strongly correlated systems are challenging, but they might be very useful due to their possible functionality to make advance devices. In order to understand, utilize, and optimize such behaviors, we need to improve our understanding of these systems. Studies in cold atom systems are of interest since cold atom experiments provide a control on model parameters. In this thesis, we use novel analytical and computational techniques to treat strongly interacting bosonic systems. Taking advantage of the very versatile quantum Monte Carlo Stochastic Green Function algorithm, we studied several interesting problems. First, we explore a recently developed new confining method for cold atoms on optical lattices. Atoms are confined via a hopping integral that decreases as a function of the distance from the center of the lattice. This method might lead to lower temperatures than existing diagonal confinement methods. Next, we study the ground state phase diagram of interacting bosons on a ring-shape lattice with a region of weak hopping integrals. The model, an extension of the well known Bose-Hubbard model, develops a novel local Mott phase in addition to the usual Mott and superfluid phases in the homogeneous system. This might provide a new insight to the description of atomtronics applications. Finally, we study the two species Bose Hubbard model in a two-dimensional lattice. This model presents novel phases due to the complexity associated with multiple species. Its phase diagram shows ordered and coexistence phases including a ferromagnetic phase separated phase with high entropy. This phase might be accessible experimentally. The novel phases found from our studies are linked to experiments on ultra-cold atoms trapped by laser beams.
The present Thesis aims to deepen the understanding of the physics of strongly-correlated systems along diverse directions with a common denominator, namely a focus on the physical role played by the collective modes shaping quantum many-body correlations. This investigation has been mostly led through the heuristic application of the Quantum Gutzwiller Approach, a recently developed theory of the quantised excitations above the Gutzwiller approximation for strongly-interacting systems on a lattice. In the first place, the intertwining between quantum correlations and collective effects is explored in the context of Bose-Hubbard models, intended both as simple yet highly non-trivial realisations of complex many-body scenarios, and as controllable environments for the quantum simulation of impurity problems. In particular, we are able to provide a comprehensive and semi-analytical description of quantum fluctuations across the critical regimes induced by the proximity of a Mott transition (Mottness), ranging from accurate predictions for the superfluid density and pair correlations across quantum critical regimes to the Andreev-Bashkin effect in a two-component bosonic mixture. As case studies for the effectiveness and flexibility of our approach, we give a detailed account of the rich behaviours of a quantum impurity, either fixed or itinerant, immersed in a Bose-Hubbard environment, showing that both the decoherence dynamics of spinful particle and the resulting Bose polaron in the second case are extremely sensitive probes of the type of critical fluctuations experienced by the surrounding system. Additionally, we extend our analysis of quantum fluctuations to the Fermi-Hubbard model, where we uncover the interplay between low-energy quasiparticles and bosonic elementary excitations in determining two-particle correlations. A more complex physical scenario addressed in this Thesis is represented by driven-dissipative interacting systems, which find a state-of-the-art technological implementation in circuit QED platforms, among others. Inspired by the experimental interest in these systems as a potential toolbox for the generation of exotic quantum states of light, we consider a strongly-correlated fluid of photons on a lattice stabilised via incoherent drive and dissipation, and examine its collective fluctuations across the out-of-equilibrium insulator-to-superfluid transition of the system. Specifically, establishing a conceptual parallelism with our approach to fluctuations at equilibrium, we develop a linear-response theory of the excitations on top of the Gutzwiller stationary state of the Lindblad dynamics, and characterise their physical role in quantum observables and response functions. Taking advantage of our formalism, we describe also dynamical instabilities and novel physical regimes arising in the ultrastrong coupling limit of the superfluid phase. Among the most remarkable results, we bring to light the paradoxical nature of the Mott-like insulating phase of the system, whose peculiar one-body dynamical fluctuations are shown to echo the behaviour of a lasing state. Encompassing diverse modern domains of many-body physics, our investigation goes in the direction of solidifying the interpretation of collective modes as fundamental actors in correlation-induced phenomena under a unified physical picture.
Convergence properties of the variational cluster approach with respect to the variational parameter space, cluster size, and boundary conditions of the reference system are investigated and discussed for bosonic many-body systems. Specifically, the variational cluster approach is applied to the one-dimensional Bose-Hubbard model, which exhibits a quantum phase transition from Mott to superfluid phase. In order to benchmark the variational cluster approach, results for the phase boundary delimiting the first Mott lobe are compared with essentially exact density matrix renormalization group data. Furthermore, static quantities, such as the ground state energy and the one-particle density matrix are compared with high-order strong coupling perturbation theory results. For reference systems with open boundary conditions the variational parameter space is extended by an additional variational parameter which allows for a more uniform particle density on the reference system and thus drastically improves the results. It turns out that the variational cluster approach yields accurate results with relatively low-computational effort for both the phase boundary as well as the static properties of the one-dimensional Bose-Hubbard model, even at the tip of the first Mott lobe where correlation effects are most pronounced.