Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.04496

Broken-Symmetry Reference States for Sample-Based Quantum Diagonalization with Near-DMRG Accuracy

Kunal Kumar, Tomonori Shirakawa, Boseong Kim, Ryo Wakizaka, Ikko Hamamura, Mitsuhisa Sato, Seiji Yunoki, Mario Motta, Hiroshi Horii, Yuri Kobayashi

quant-phphysics.chem-phSubmitted Nov 3, 2026• Announced Nov 4, 2026• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Sample-based quantum diagonalization (SQD) accuracy remains limited for strongly correlated systems like iron-sulfur clusters. This accuracy heavily depends on the mean-field reference state, which determines the sampling ansatz and configuration-recovery target. We extend the qcsc-prefect workflow to support a broken-symmetry unrestricted Hartree-Fock (BS-UHF) starting point, derived from atom-localized antiferromagnetic initial guesses. For the $[Fe_4S_4(SCH_3)_4]^{2-}$ cubane (54 electrons, 36 orbitals, 72 data qubits; 88 total qubits), this lowers the mean-field reference by $\approx 534$ mHa relative to the Restricted Hartree-Fock (RHF) solution (-327.0809 vs. -326.5474 Ha). Combined with deep multi-step configuration recovery on ROQUO GPU nodes at subspace dimension $d = 3 \times 10^{10}$, we reach $E = -327.235076$ Ha. This is 4.3 mHa above the finite-$D = 4000$ DMRG value (-327.2393952 Ha) and $\sim 512-517$ mHa below a previous same-active-space RHF-reference SQD calculation. Extrapolating to the $d \to \infty$ limit via a Gaussian-in-log $d$ fitting ansatz gives an asymptotic estimate $E_\infty = -327.244468$ Ha $\pm 1.05$ mHa, just 0.33 mHa above our discarded-weight-extrapolated DMRG estimate ($E_{D\to\infty} = -327.244797$ Ha $\pm 0.46$ mHa), well within their combined $1σ$ uncertainty. We characterize the determinant-subspace composition driving convergence, show matching validation on $[Fe_2S_2(SCH_3)_4]^{2-}$, and report multi-HPC execution on Fugaku, Miyabi-G, and ROQUO. We conclude that reference-state preparation, rather than subspace size alone, is a key driver of SQD energy accuracy under strong electronic correlation.

AI Summary

The paper asks how the mean-field reference affects sample-based quantum diagonalization (SQD) for strongly correlated iron–sulfur clusters. It extends `qcsc-prefect` to prepare atom-localized antiferromagnetic broken-symmetry UHF references, initialize LUCJ sampling circuits from unrestricted coupled-cluster amplitudes, and perform checkpointed configuration recovery and classical subspace diagonalization. A candidate-generation booster recombines sampled excitation patterns. For $[\mathrm{Fe}_4\mathrm{S}_4(\mathrm{SCH}_3)_4]^{2-}$ in CAS(54e,36o), the selected BS-UHF reference is $534$ mHa below RHF. A 72-data-qubit circuit, using 88 physical qubits, supplies five million hardware shots; the resulting pool is reused throughout recovery. At subspace dimension $d=3\times10^{10}$, the directly computed energy is $-327.235076$ Ha: $4.3$ mHa above finite-$D=4000$ DMRG and $9.7$ mHa above extrapolated DMRG. An empirical Gaussian-in-$\log d$ fit to five SQD points estimates $-327.244468\pm1.05$ mHa, versus DMRG’s $-327.244797\pm0.46$ mHa. A smaller CAS(30e,20o) cluster provides an additional SQD–DMRG comparison. Rank-resolved wavefunction weights document increasing triple-and-higher excitation content with subspace size. The extrapolation uncertainties are fit-conditional; the larger-cluster calculation samples only $3.4\times10^{-4}\%$ of the complete space. The paper also reports iteration-capped Davidson solves with residual convergence errors, unmeasured final-state spin contamination, and unmatched SQD/DMRG reference preparation. Comparisons with earlier RHF-based SQD additionally differ in dimension, recovery depth, samples, and hardware. No quantum advantage or accuracy for chemical energy differences is established.

Likely largely AI-generatedIncrementalMissing comparisonOverclaimsPossible error

Central claim may not hold: The paper's strong attribution of the historical energy improvement almost entirely to the broken-symmetry reference is not isolated from a 300-fold increase in subspace dimension and other workflow changes. The quoted SQD extrapolation uncertainty is conditional on an empirical three-parameter fit to five points and does not quantify functional-form uncertainty or unresolved diagonalization error. The largest projected diagonalizations terminate with several-mHa last-iteration energy changes, so small recovery-step changes do not demonstrate eigensolver convergence at the accuracy claimed for the extrapolation. The dimer's fitted infinite-dimension asymptote differs from its fitted complete-space endpoint, so its agreement with DMRG does not validate that asymptote as the exact-diagonalization limit.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
22 pages, 10 figures, 7 tables. Data: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23064186 (FCIDUMPs and raw quantum-hardware sample pools)

Related papers

Cluster-Adaptive Sample-Based Quantum Diagonalization for Strongly Correlated Systems

Byeongyong Park, Sanha Kang, Jongseok Seo +3 more

Sample-based quantum diagonalization (SQD) is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm for estimating ground-state energies in electronic-structure calculations. It uses a quantum processor as a sampler to construct a variational subspace, with Hamiltonian projection and diagonalization performed classically. A critical step in SQD is self-consistent particle-number recovery guided by a global reference occupancy vector. In strongly correlated systems, however, dominant determinants can be distributed across regions of determinant space, causing this reference to become mixture-averaged and biasing recovery toward mean occupations. Here, we introduce cluster-adaptive SQD (CSQD), which clusters pooled single-spin strings and performs particle-number recovery using cluster-specific reference occupancy vectors. Under a matched variational budget, CSQD lowers ground-state energies relative to SQD by up to 15.95 mHa for stretched N2 in a (10e,26o) active space and 57.82 mHa for [2Fe-2S] in a (30e,20o) active space. These results suggest that CSQD better captures dispersed occupation structure in strongly correlated systems.

quant-pharXiv:2603.09346•Mar 11, 2026•4 citations

DF-SQD: Deterministic Fields for Sampling-Based Quantum Diagonalization

Kushagra Agarwal, Anupama Ray

Sampling-based quantum diagonalization method exploits Quantum-centric supercomputing platforms to sample bitstrings for Hamiltonian projection on a quantum computer, and then classically diagonalize the Hamiltonian to estimate the eigenvalues and eigenvectors. In current quantum devices an algorithm is useful when shallow quantum circuits with error mitigation support can discover better results while having either a proof of convergence or some method to explain trust in experiment. In this paper, we introduce DF-SQD, a hybrid algorithm that derives deterministic auxiliary-field circuits from selected double-factorization leaves of the two-electron tensor. The circuits propose occupation-number configurations, while selected configuration interaction evaluates the original active-space Hamiltonian and can recentre subsequent proposal rounds. On N2 (32 qubits; 6-31G basis) and a 40-qubit [Fe2S2(SCH3)4]2- active-space Hamiltonian, we show that DF-SQD improves the energy obtained from sampled determinant spaces while using shallow number-preserving circuits in both simulator and hardware runs. For N2, DF-SQD is 45x more accurate with a 11.23\% smaller subspace, and due to its ability to sample better bitstrings at lesser shots it is 2.93x faster than SQD in quantum devices. For the iron-sulfur cluster, DF-SQD generated a subspace dimension of 221M with 400K shots, while SQD needed 1.5M shots to generate a 238M subspace, thus we have better subspace recovery evident from the hardware at 3.75x reduced shots. At a matched 50M subspace dimension, DF-SQD is 1.32x more accurate (achieves a 24.5\% relative error reduction over standard SQD). So overall, our method is able to discover better results with shallower circuits, is sample efficient, uses configuration recovery (so has targeted error mitigation) and we have empirical convergence observation.

quant-pharXiv:2609.01264•Sep 2, 2026•0 citations

Which state are you converging? A spin audit of sample-based quantum diagonalization benchmarks on iron–sulfur clusters

Tyler Vitale

Sample-based quantum diagonalization (SQD/QSCI) selects determinant subspaces from quantum-circuit samples for classical diagonalization; its iron–sulfur demonstrations anchor utility-scale quantum-chemistry claims, and a recent critique disputes them at matched subspace dimension. Both sides benchmark on energy-based diagnostics, not spin identity. We introduce a rotation-invariant spin audit: exact determinant-space ⟨S²⟩, invariant S²-Gram spectra over quasi-degenerate manifolds, and higher spin moments (⟨S⁴⟩ through ⟨S⁸⟩) that bound the spin-sector decomposition, and apply it to the public [2Fe-2S] and [4Fe-4S] benchmarks, IBM's shipped qiskit-addon-sqd pipeline, and IBM's published hardware data. No audited execution returned the named singlet at competitive energy; for published states unavailable to direct audit, the energy-only records do not establish singlet identity. Classical selected-CI growth converges to a spin-contaminated attractor (⟨S²⟩ ≈ 4.7 on [2Fe-2S]); samples drawn from it preserve the contamination; spin-inversion completion permits spin symmetry without producing it; and the released [2Fe-2S] hardware samples yield no energy advantage over the uniform-random control. A scalar mean does not identify these states: two audited arms share ⟨S²⟩ ≈ 2.00, one a triplet eigenstate (Var(S²) = 3×10⁻⁶), the other a 2:1 singlet–quintet mixture whose triplet weight its third moment bounds below 10⁻⁴. At the largest published dimension (5.625×10⁷ determinants, reconstructed here from the released support), the numerically stable lowest root lies 170 mHa below the published energy at ⟨S²⟩ = 1.3711 (stable under an 18.6-fold residual tightening to 1.1% of the 0.285 mHa gap), with Var(S²) = 6.9 and first two moments excluding any decomposition confined to S ≤ 2. Near-singlet character survives only as a non-stationary superposition: selection does not commute with S². Energy-only SQD benchmarks therefore do not establish convergence to the named target state; we propose measured spin moments as a mandatory benchmark output, with spin control active rather than passive.

•Jul 21, 2026•0 citations

Which state are you converging? A spin audit of sample-based quantum diagonalization benchmarks on iron–sulfur clusters

Tyler Vitale

Sample-based quantum diagonalization (SQD/QSCI) diagonalizes the Hamiltonian classically in determinant subspaces selected from quantum-circuit samples. Its iron–sulfur demonstrations underpin claims of utility-scale quantum chemistry, and a recent critique disputes them at matched subspace dimension. Both sides compare energies; neither reports which spin state was computed. Our spin audit uses the exact determinant-space ⟨S²⟩, the invariant spectrum of the S² block over quasi-degenerate manifolds, and higher moments (⟨S⁴⟩ to ⟨S⁸⟩) bounding the spin-sector weights. We apply it to the public [2Fe-2S] and [4Fe-4S] benchmarks, IBM's released qiskit-addon-sqd pipeline and published hardware data. No audited execution returned the named singlet at competitive energy; for published states unavailable to direct audit, the energy-only records do not establish singlet identity. Under the audited HCI protocols, selected-CI growth approaches a spin-contaminated state (⟨S²⟩ ≈ 4.7 on [2Fe-2S]) whose samples keep the contamination. Spin-inversion completion leaves the energy and ⟨S²⟩ of these states unchanged. The released [2Fe-2S] hardware samples give no energy advantage over the released uniform-random control. A scalar mean does not identify these states: two audited arms share ⟨S²⟩ ≈ 2.00, but one is a triplet eigenstate (Var(S²) = 3×10⁻⁶) and the other a 2:1 singlet–quintet mixture whose third moment bounds its triplet weight below 10⁻⁴. At the largest published dimension (5.625×10⁷ determinants, reconstructed here from the released support), the lowest root, 170 mHa below the published energy, has ⟨S²⟩ = 1.3711, unchanged under an 18.6-fold residual tightening to 1.1% of the 0.285 mHa gap. Its first two moments, with Var(S²) = 6.9, exclude any decomposition confined to S ≤ 2. Near-singlet character appears only as a non-stationary superposition, because determinant selection does not commute with S². Energy-only benchmarks therefore do not establish convergence to the named state. We recommend reporting spin moments with every energy and controlling spin during selection.

•Sep 15, 2026•0 citations

Can Phaseless Auxiliary-Field Quantum Monte Carlo with Broken Symmetry Trials Describe Iron–Sulfur Clusters?

Eirik F. Kjønstad, Huanchen Zhai, James Shee +2 more

Abstract Phaseless auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo (AFQMC) has in several cases been found to perform well on strongly correlated systems, including compounds containing transition-metal elements. Here, we benchmark the method for three iron–sulfur clusters ([2Fe-2S], [4Fe-4S], and the FeMo cofactor) using a hierarchy of systematically improved trial states derived from coupled cluster (CC) theory, including up to quadruple excitations relative to the Hartree–Fock (HF) reference, as well as multi-Slater trial states derived from unrestricted density matrix renormalization group wave functions. Our results reveal for these systems that, as the symmetry-broken trial is improved beyond the mean-field level, the phaseless AFQMC energy can become less accurate, and in some cases even less accurate than the underlying trial projected energy itself, displaying an inverted energy pattern that is only corrected once the trial fidelity is sufficiently high. For [2Fe-2S], we show that a decreased accuracy in the AFQMC energy can coincide with a simultaneous improvement in the trial state and the walker ensemble, as measured by their fidelity relative to the exact ground state, a behavior which is allowed by the nonvariational nature of the phaseless AFQMC energy estimator. We further find that this is not solely due to the use of spin-unrestricted trial states, as the inversion persists in [2Fe-2S] when we explicitly break the symmetry of the Hamiltonian by applying a fictitious local spin-Zeeman field. Instead, we find that the energy inversion is related to the choice of measurement trial in the estimator, where using a high-order CC trial state for measurements may introduce errors that are suppressed when the measurement wave function is restricted to lower excitation subspaces. In particular, measuring the energy with the mean-field reference while guiding the walkers with a CC trial removes the inverted pattern and improves the overall accuracy across the iron–sulfur clusters, with a possible exception for [4Fe-4S] where energies with a CCSDT guide may be less accurate than those guided by CCSD for some broken-symmetry families. Taken together, our findings suggest that the relatively accurate energies obtained with an HF trial state in these systems arise from favorable error cancellation, warranting significant caution about the reliability of phaseless AFQMC with such trials for strongly correlated transition-metal systems of this kind.

arXiv:2605.03270•Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Nov 9, 2026•5 citations

Noise-Resilient Quantum Chemistry with Half the Qubits

Shane McFarthing, Aidan Pellow-Jarman, Francesco Petruccione

Sample-based quantum diagonalization (SQD) offers a powerful route to accurate quantum chemistry on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices by combining quantum sampling with classical diagonalization. Here we introduce HSQD, a novel half-qubit SQD approach that halves the qubit requirement for simulating a chemical system and drastically reduces overall circuit depth and gate counts, suppressing hardware noise. When modeling the dissociation of the nitrogen molecule with a (10e, 26o) active space, HSQD matches the accuracy of SQD on IBM quantum hardware using only half the number of qubits and 40% fewer measurements. We further enhance HSQD with a heat-bath configuration interaction (HCI) inspired selection of the samples, forming HCI-HSQD. This yields sub-millihartree accuracy across the N2 potential energy surface and produces subspaces up to 39% smaller than those from classical HCI, showing a significant improvement in the compactness of the ground-state representation. Finally, we demonstrate the scalability of HCI-HSQD using iron-sulfur clusters, reaching active spaces of up to (54e, 36o) while using only half as many qubits as the original SQD. For these systems, HCI-HSQD reduces SQD energy errors by up to 76% for [2Fe-2S] and 26% for [4Fe-4S], while also reducing subspace sizes, halving measurement requirements, and eliminating expensive post-processing. Together, these results establish half-qubit SQD as a noise-resilient and resource-efficient pathway toward practical quantum advantage in strongly correlated chemistry.

quant-pharXiv:2602.01165•Feb 3, 2026•6 citations
Sample-based quantum diagonalization (SQD) accuracy remains limited for strongly correlated systems like iron-sulfur clusters. This accuracy heavily depends on the mean-field reference state, which determines the sampling ansatz and configuration-recovery target. We extend the qcsc-prefect workflow to support a broken-symmetry unrestricted Hartree-Fock (BS-UHF) starting point, derived from atom-localized antiferromagnetic initial guesses. For the [Fe4S4(SCH3)4]2−[Fe_4S_4(SCH_3)_4]^{2-}[Fe4​S4​(SCH3​)4​]2− cubane (54 electrons, 36 orbitals, 72 data qubits; 88 total qubits), this lowers the mean-field reference by ≈534\approx 534≈534 mHa relative to the Restricted Hartree-Fock (RHF) solution (-327.0809 vs. -326.5474 Ha). Combined with deep multi-step configuration recovery on ROQUO GPU nodes at subspace dimension d=3×1010d = 3 \times 10^{10}d=3×1010, we reach E=−327.235076E = -327.235076E=−327.235076 Ha. This is 4.3 mHa above the finite-D=4000D = 4000D=4000 DMRG value (-327.2393952 Ha) and ∼512−517\sim 512-517∼512−517 mHa below a previous same-active-space RHF-reference SQD calculation. Extrapolating to the d→∞d \to \inftyd→∞ limit via a Gaussian-in-log ddd fitting ansatz gives an asymptotic estimate E∞=−327.244468E_\infty = -327.244468E∞​=−327.244468 Ha ±1.05\pm 1.05±1.05 mHa, just 0.33 mHa above our discarded-weight-extrapolated DMRG estimate (ED→∞=−327.244797E_{D\to\infty} = -327.244797ED→∞​=−327.244797 Ha ±0.46\pm 0.46±0.46 mHa), well within their combined 1σ1σ1σ uncertainty. We characterize the determinant-subspace composition driving convergence, show matching validation on [Fe2S2(SCH3)4]2−[Fe_2S_2(SCH_3)_4]^{2-}[Fe2​S2​(SCH3​)4​]2−, and report multi-HPC execution on Fugaku, Miyabi-G, and ROQUO. We conclude that reference-state preparation, rather than subspace size alone, is a key driver of SQD energy accuracy under strong electronic correlation.
The paper asks how the mean-field reference affects sample-based quantum diagonalization (SQD) for strongly correlated iron–sulfur clusters. It extends qcsc-prefect to prepare atom-localized antiferromagnetic broken-symmetry UHF references, initialize LUCJ sampling circuits from unrestricted coupled-cluster amplitudes, and perform checkpointed configuration recovery and classical subspace diagonalization. A candidate-generation booster recombines sampled excitation patterns.
For [Fe4S4(SCH3)4]2−[\mathrm{Fe}_4\mathrm{S}_4(\mathrm{SCH}_3)_4]^{2-}[Fe4​S4​(SCH3​)4​]2− in CAS(54e,36o), the selected BS-UHF reference is 534534534 mHa below RHF. A 72-data-qubit circuit, using 88 physical qubits, supplies five million hardware shots; the resulting pool is reused throughout recovery. At subspace dimension d=3×1010d=3\times10^{10}d=3×1010, the directly computed energy is −327.235076-327.235076−327.235076 Ha: 4.34.34.3 mHa above finite-D=4000D=4000D=4000 DMRG and 9.79.79.7 mHa above extrapolated DMRG. An empirical Gaussian-in-log⁡d\log dlogd fit to five SQD points estimates −327.244468±1.05-327.244468\pm1.05−327.244468±1.05 mHa, versus DMRG’s −327.244797±0.46-327.244797\pm0.46−327.244797±0.46 mHa. A smaller CAS(30e,20o) cluster provides an additional SQD–DMRG comparison. Rank-resolved wavefunction weights document increasing triple-and-higher excitation content with subspace size.
The extrapolation uncertainties are fit-conditional; the larger-cluster calculation samples only 3.4×10−4%3.4\times10^{-4}\%3.4×10−4% of the complete space. The paper also reports iteration-capped Davidson solves with residual convergence errors, unmeasured final-state spin contamination, and unmatched SQD/DMRG reference preparation. Comparisons with earlier RHF-based SQD additionally differ in dimension, recovery depth, samples, and hardware. No quantum advantage or accuracy for chemical energy differences is established.
Sample-based quantum diagonalization (SQD) is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm for estimating ground-state energies in electronic-structure calculations. It uses a quantum processor as a sampler to construct a variational subspace, with Hamiltonian projection and diagonalization performed classically. A critical step in SQD is self-consistent particle-number recovery guided by a global reference occupancy vector. In strongly correlated systems, however, dominant determinants can be distributed across regions of determinant space, causing this reference to become mixture-averaged and biasing recovery toward mean occupations. Here, we introduce cluster-adaptive SQD (CSQD), which clusters pooled single-spin strings and performs particle-number recovery using cluster-specific reference occupancy vectors. Under a matched variational budget, CSQD lowers ground-state energies relative to SQD by up to 15.95 mHa for stretched N2 in a (10e,26o) active space and 57.82 mHa for [2Fe-2S] in a (30e,20o) active space. These results suggest that CSQD better captures dispersed occupation structure in strongly correlated systems.
Sampling-based quantum diagonalization method exploits Quantum-centric supercomputing platforms to sample bitstrings for Hamiltonian projection on a quantum computer, and then classically diagonalize the Hamiltonian to estimate the eigenvalues and eigenvectors. In current quantum devices an algorithm is useful when shallow quantum circuits with error mitigation support can discover better results while having either a proof of convergence or some method to explain trust in experiment. In this paper, we introduce DF-SQD, a hybrid algorithm that derives deterministic auxiliary-field circuits from selected double-factorization leaves of the two-electron tensor. The circuits propose occupation-number configurations, while selected configuration interaction evaluates the original active-space Hamiltonian and can recentre subsequent proposal rounds. On N2 (32 qubits; 6-31G basis) and a 40-qubit [Fe2S2(SCH3)4]2- active-space Hamiltonian, we show that DF-SQD improves the energy obtained from sampled determinant spaces while using shallow number-preserving circuits in both simulator and hardware runs. For N2, DF-SQD is 45x more accurate with a 11.23\% smaller subspace, and due to its ability to sample better bitstrings at lesser shots it is 2.93x faster than SQD in quantum devices. For the iron-sulfur cluster, DF-SQD generated a subspace dimension of 221M with 400K shots, while SQD needed 1.5M shots to generate a 238M subspace, thus we have better subspace recovery evident from the hardware at 3.75x reduced shots. At a matched 50M subspace dimension, DF-SQD is 1.32x more accurate (achieves a 24.5\% relative error reduction over standard SQD). So overall, our method is able to discover better results with shallower circuits, is sample efficient, uses configuration recovery (so has targeted error mitigation) and we have empirical convergence observation.
Sample-based quantum diagonalization (SQD/QSCI) selects determinant subspaces from quantum-circuit samples for classical diagonalization; its iron–sulfur demonstrations anchor utility-scale quantum-chemistry claims, and a recent critique disputes them at matched subspace dimension. Both sides benchmark on energy-based diagnostics, not spin identity. We introduce a rotation-invariant spin audit: exact determinant-space ⟨S²⟩, invariant S²-Gram spectra over quasi-degenerate manifolds, and higher spin moments (⟨S⁴⟩ through ⟨S⁸⟩) that bound the spin-sector decomposition, and apply it to the public [2Fe-2S] and [4Fe-4S] benchmarks, IBM's shipped qiskit-addon-sqd pipeline, and IBM's published hardware data. No audited execution returned the named singlet at competitive energy; for published states unavailable to direct audit, the energy-only records do not establish singlet identity. Classical selected-CI growth converges to a spin-contaminated attractor (⟨S²⟩ ≈ 4.7 on [2Fe-2S]); samples drawn from it preserve the contamination; spin-inversion completion permits spin symmetry without producing it; and the released [2Fe-2S] hardware samples yield no energy advantage over the uniform-random control. A scalar mean does not identify these states: two audited arms share ⟨S²⟩ ≈ 2.00, one a triplet eigenstate (Var(S²) = 3×10⁻⁶), the other a 2:1 singlet–quintet mixture whose triplet weight its third moment bounds below 10⁻⁴. At the largest published dimension (5.625×10⁷ determinants, reconstructed here from the released support), the numerically stable lowest root lies 170 mHa below the published energy at ⟨S²⟩ = 1.3711 (stable under an 18.6-fold residual tightening to 1.1% of the 0.285 mHa gap), with Var(S²) = 6.9 and first two moments excluding any decomposition confined to S ≤ 2. Near-singlet character survives only as a non-stationary superposition: selection does not commute with S². Energy-only SQD benchmarks therefore do not establish convergence to the named target state; we propose measured spin moments as a mandatory benchmark output, with spin control active rather than passive.
Sample-based quantum diagonalization (SQD/QSCI) diagonalizes the Hamiltonian classically in determinant subspaces selected from quantum-circuit samples. Its iron–sulfur demonstrations underpin claims of utility-scale quantum chemistry, and a recent critique disputes them at matched subspace dimension. Both sides compare energies; neither reports which spin state was computed. Our spin audit uses the exact determinant-space ⟨S²⟩, the invariant spectrum of the S² block over quasi-degenerate manifolds, and higher moments (⟨S⁴⟩ to ⟨S⁸⟩) bounding the spin-sector weights. We apply it to the public [2Fe-2S] and [4Fe-4S] benchmarks, IBM's released qiskit-addon-sqd pipeline and published hardware data. No audited execution returned the named singlet at competitive energy; for published states unavailable to direct audit, the energy-only records do not establish singlet identity. Under the audited HCI protocols, selected-CI growth approaches a spin-contaminated state (⟨S²⟩ ≈ 4.7 on [2Fe-2S]) whose samples keep the contamination. Spin-inversion completion leaves the energy and ⟨S²⟩ of these states unchanged. The released [2Fe-2S] hardware samples give no energy advantage over the released uniform-random control. A scalar mean does not identify these states: two audited arms share ⟨S²⟩ ≈ 2.00, but one is a triplet eigenstate (Var(S²) = 3×10⁻⁶) and the other a 2:1 singlet–quintet mixture whose third moment bounds its triplet weight below 10⁻⁴. At the largest published dimension (5.625×10⁷ determinants, reconstructed here from the released support), the lowest root, 170 mHa below the published energy, has ⟨S²⟩ = 1.3711, unchanged under an 18.6-fold residual tightening to 1.1% of the 0.285 mHa gap. Its first two moments, with Var(S²) = 6.9, exclude any decomposition confined to S ≤ 2. Near-singlet character appears only as a non-stationary superposition, because determinant selection does not commute with S². Energy-only benchmarks therefore do not establish convergence to the named state. We recommend reporting spin moments with every energy and controlling spin during selection.
Abstract Phaseless auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo (AFQMC) has in several cases been found to perform well on strongly correlated systems, including compounds containing transition-metal elements. Here, we benchmark the method for three iron–sulfur clusters ([2Fe-2S], [4Fe-4S], and the FeMo cofactor) using a hierarchy of systematically improved trial states derived from coupled cluster (CC) theory, including up to quadruple excitations relative to the Hartree–Fock (HF) reference, as well as multi-Slater trial states derived from unrestricted density matrix renormalization group wave functions. Our results reveal for these systems that, as the symmetry-broken trial is improved beyond the mean-field level, the phaseless AFQMC energy can become less accurate, and in some cases even less accurate than the underlying trial projected energy itself, displaying an inverted energy pattern that is only corrected once the trial fidelity is sufficiently high. For [2Fe-2S], we show that a decreased accuracy in the AFQMC energy can coincide with a simultaneous improvement in the trial state and the walker ensemble, as measured by their fidelity relative to the exact ground state, a behavior which is allowed by the nonvariational nature of the phaseless AFQMC energy estimator. We further find that this is not solely due to the use of spin-unrestricted trial states, as the inversion persists in [2Fe-2S] when we explicitly break the symmetry of the Hamiltonian by applying a fictitious local spin-Zeeman field. Instead, we find that the energy inversion is related to the choice of measurement trial in the estimator, where using a high-order CC trial state for measurements may introduce errors that are suppressed when the measurement wave function is restricted to lower excitation subspaces. In particular, measuring the energy with the mean-field reference while guiding the walkers with a CC trial removes the inverted pattern and improves the overall accuracy across the iron–sulfur clusters, with a possible exception for [4Fe-4S] where energies with a CCSDT guide may be less accurate than those guided by CCSD for some broken-symmetry families. Taken together, our findings suggest that the relatively accurate energies obtained with an HF trial state in these systems arise from favorable error cancellation, warranting significant caution about the reliability of phaseless AFQMC with such trials for strongly correlated transition-metal systems of this kind.
Sample-based quantum diagonalization (SQD) offers a powerful route to accurate quantum chemistry on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices by combining quantum sampling with classical diagonalization. Here we introduce HSQD, a novel half-qubit SQD approach that halves the qubit requirement for simulating a chemical system and drastically reduces overall circuit depth and gate counts, suppressing hardware noise. When modeling the dissociation of the nitrogen molecule with a (10e, 26o) active space, HSQD matches the accuracy of SQD on IBM quantum hardware using only half the number of qubits and 40% fewer measurements. We further enhance HSQD with a heat-bath configuration interaction (HCI) inspired selection of the samples, forming HCI-HSQD. This yields sub-millihartree accuracy across the N2 potential energy surface and produces subspaces up to 39% smaller than those from classical HCI, showing a significant improvement in the compactness of the ground-state representation. Finally, we demonstrate the scalability of HCI-HSQD using iron-sulfur clusters, reaching active spaces of up to (54e, 36o) while using only half as many qubits as the original SQD. For these systems, HCI-HSQD reduces SQD energy errors by up to 76% for [2Fe-2S] and 26% for [4Fe-4S], while also reducing subspace sizes, halving measurement requirements, and eliminating expensive post-processing. Together, these results establish half-qubit SQD as a noise-resilient and resource-efficient pathway toward practical quantum advantage in strongly correlated chemistry.