Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.04238

On the universality of entanglement entropy in quantum field theory

Orr Sela

hep-thcond-mat.str-elquant-phSubmitted Nov 3, 2026• Announced Nov 4, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The standard definition of entanglement entropy in quantum field theory requires regularizing the entangling surface and factorizing the Hilbert space, which in turn involves a choice of boundary conditions at the regularized surface. This raises two natural questions which are open at present. The first is under what conditions there is a choice of boundary conditions that leads to a unitary map between the original Hilbert space and the factorized one, which is a necessary condition for a well-defined entanglement entropy. The second concerns the situation where there are multiple such choices, in which case the question is whether they all yield the same entropy, or at least the same terms usually referred to as universal. Focusing on topological theories and using three-dimensional Chern-Simons theory as a concrete illustration, we show under specified assumptions that different such choices affect only the non-universal terms in the entropy, such that the remaining terms are universal in this sense as well, while we explicitly demonstrate that boundary conditions corresponding to non-unitary maps can change these terms. We then explain how a similar argument applies to two-dimensional conformal field theories and discuss a condition for universality in general theories.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether the universal terms of QFT entanglement entropy are independent of the boundary conditions used to regularize the entangling surface and factorize the Hilbert space. It studies “shrinkable” boundary conditions: those whose regulating boundary reduces to the identity defect, up to local counterterms, as its transverse size vanishes. The main calculation concerns three-dimensional $U(1)_k$ Chern–Simons theory with even $k>0$, for a spherical state partitioned along its equator. Holomorphic boundary conditions are shown to be shrinkable using vacuum dominance of edge-mode characters. Bulk topological invariance permits smoothing the replica geometry while preserving the induced boundary metric. Under specified assumptions, different shrinkable boundary conditions affect only local counterterms, giving $S=2\alpha l/\epsilon-\tfrac12\log k+o(1)$, with boundary-dependent $\alpha$ but fixed topological constant. A non-shrinkable topological boundary in $U(1)_k\times U(1)_{-k}$ instead produces a projector, can annihilate nonzero states, and changes the computed topological constant from $-\log k$ to zero. For two-dimensional CFTs, a local Weyl transformation gives an analogous conditional argument preserving the interval coefficient $(c/3)\log(l/\epsilon)$. The topological proof assumes shrinkability persists under geometry-induced coupling shifts and sufficient regularity to interchange shrinking and replica differentiation; the CFT argument separately assumes this interchange preserves the logarithmic term. In higher dimensions, ordinary shrinkability does not establish universality: the remaining condition concerns the regulator’s shrinking behavior with a modular-Hamiltonian insertion. General existence criteria and explicit higher-dimensional tests, including Maxwell theory, remain open.

No sign of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptions

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
8 pages + appendix, 2 figures

Related papers

Remarks on entanglement entropy in string theory

Vijay Balasubramanian, Onkar Parrikar

Entanglement entropy for spatial subregions is difficult to define in string theory because of the extended nature of strings. Here we propose a definition for bosonic open strings using the framework of string field theory. The key difference (compared to ordinary quantum field theory) is that the subregion is chosen inside a Cauchy surface in the ``space of open string configurations.'' We first present a simple calculation of this entanglement entropy in free light-cone string field theory, ignoring subtleties related to the factorization of the Hilbert space. We reproduce the answer expected from an effective field theory point of view, namely a sum over the one-loop entanglement entropies corresponding to all the particle-excitations of the string, and further show that the full string theory regulates ultraviolet divergences in the entanglement entropy. We then revisit the question of factorization of the Hilbert space by analyzing the covariant phase-space associated with a subregion in Witten's covariant string field theory. We show that the pure gauge (i.e., BRST exact) modes in the string field become dynamical at the entanglement cut. Thus, a proper definition of the entropy must involve an extended Hilbert space, with new stringy edge modes localized at the entanglement cut.

arXiv:1801.03517•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Mar 28, 2018•38 citations

Comments on defining entanglement entropy

Jennifer Lin, Đorđe Radičević

We revisit the issue of defining the entropy of a spatial region in a broad class of quantum theories. In theories with explicit regularizations, working within an elementary but general algebraic framework applicable to matter and gauge theories alike, we give precise path integral expressions for three known types of entanglement entropy that we call full, distillable, and gauge-invariant. For a class of gauge theories that do not necessarily have a regularization in our framework, including Chern-Simons theory, we describe a related approach to defining entropies based on locally extending the Hilbert space at the entangling edge, and we discuss its connections to other calculational prescriptions. Based on results from both approaches, we conjecture that it is always the full entanglement entropy that is calculated by standard holographic techniques in strongly coupled conformal theories.

arXiv:1808.05939•Nuclear Physics B•Jul 30, 2020•83 citations

More physics at the entangling surface: boundary conditions and entanglement in 2d TQFT

Jackson R. Fliss, Alan Rios Fukelman, Stathis Vitouladitis

We present a systematic treatment of entanglement in two-dimensional topological quantum field theories (TQFTs). Our approach clarifies the sensitivity of entanglement measures to the cutting maps that implement Hilbert space factorization. Such maps embed the TQFT Hilbert space into a description with potentially more degrees of freedom, and for entanglement to be well defined they must be isometric, i.e., they must preserve the norms of all states. We show that the naïve cutting map based solely upon path integration subject to boundary conditions is not isometric for generic TQFTs. For any 2d TQFT, we give a prescription to construct isometric cutting maps by dressing path integration with suitable edge operators. This allows us to compute entanglement for any state, any bipartition, and any boundary condition. As a consequence, we find a non-integer "ground-state degeneracy" à la Affleck-Ludwig, despite all boundary conditions being gapped. We further show how to reconstruct the partition function of the TQFT at arbitrary genus from the multi-interval Rényi entropies of a single state. For theories with (possibly non-invertible) symmetries, we show that the entanglement entropy of the symmetric ground state can distinguish gapped phases with the same symmetry, without any further knowledge of their vacua, while the entanglement asymmetry of the vacua entropically detects symmetry breaking. We illustrate our formalism with a range of applications, from finite gauge theories to Haagerup gapped phases and infrared phases of adjoint QCD$_2$.

arXiv:2611.13078•Nov 9, 2026•0 citations

Entanglement, topology, & renormalization

Jackson R. Fliss

In this thesis we will explore entanglement of various subsystems in quantum field theory, and its uses for describing underlying structure of states. We begin this journey by focusing on topological quantum field theory in chapters 1 and 2. These chapters are based heavily upon the papers [1] and [2, 3], respectively. In the introduction to chapter 1 we take the opportunity to recall the definition of bipartite entanglement entropy in quantum field theory and describe, briefly, how the entropy associated to connected spatial subregions provides a signature of topological order at the level of the wave-function. In particular, for a gapped phase with topological order, we recapitulate how the sub-leading correction to the “area-law” of the entanglement entropy contains coarse information about the topological phase while also being insensitive to the short-distance details of the underlying theory. We then present results that show that this sub-leading correction can also detect the class of interactions that glue a subregion to its complement. In principle, the subregion could be a different topological phase than its complement, and so we say that the entanglement entropy provides a signature of the interface between topological phases. In showing this, we discuss the classes of interactions between gapped topological phases and how they are represented as boundary conditions in the low-energy effective topological field theory, which in this case is an Abelian Chern-Simons theory. Using these boundary conditions, we perform path-integral calculations of the entanglement entropy using the replica trick and show that the universal contribution does indeed depend on the class of boundary conditions, and the gapped topological phases of the subsystem and its complement. To finish this chapter we reformulate this problem at the level of the Hilbert space and show how these universal contributions are related to resolving a generic ambiguity in defining subsystems of field theories with gauge invariance. We continue in the theme of topological field theories for chapter 2. Here we will shift focus from subregions of a connected spatial slice to disconnected spatial regions in an effort to explore, firstly, how long-range entanglement is encoded in topological field theory, and secondly, how that entanglement is encoded amongst multiple parties. We begin with a brief introduction of multi-party entanglement and recall the classification of three-party entanglement. Moving on to our specific setup, we describe the construction of states on multiple non-intersecting torus boundaries. Generically, these are states on link complements where the torus boundaries can be thought of as the edges of thickened closed strings entwined and knotted inside a compact manifold, which we will take to be the three-sphere. The wave-functions of these states are represented by various link invariants (such as the Gauss linking number for Abelian links, and Jones polynomial for SU(2)). We will exhibit several examples of multi-component links in both the Abelian and the SU(2) theories, and afterwards discuss generic features of the entanglement of link states in Chern-Simons theories with a compact group. In this discussion, we will conjecture a classification (albeit broad) of links via multi-partite entanglement of their corresponding states. We will end the chapter moving away from compact groups and discuss hyperbolic links in SL(2,C) Chern-Simons theory in the semi-classical limit. In particular, utilizing the generalized volume conjecture, we will show that the entanglement structure of hyperbolic links is greatly constrained in this semi-classical limit. Finally, in chapter 3 we switch gears and discuss renormalization of free bosonic field theory. The content of this chapter is drawn from the work of [4]. Motivated by work establishing duality between the singlet sector of O(N) vector models at large N and higher spin gauge theory on Anti de Sitter (AdS) space, we develop an exact renormalization group (ERG) framework for discussing the renormalization of a large class of O(N) singlet states. We will show that for the ground state and the excited states in this class the ERG is implemented by the action of unitary operators (that can be taken to be local). Consequently, the ERG framework can be regarded as a continuum tensor network. We contrast this tensor network with some well known tensor network renormalization schemes such as the muti-scale entanglement renormalization ansatz (MERA) and its proposed continuum version (cMERA). We also comment on the nature of this network with ordinary Wilsonian renormalization. One of the central features of the ERG network is how it acts on the momentum space entanglement of the field theory. In particular, we argue that for excited states, the ERG disentangles modes that lie just above and below the UV cutoff.

•Jun 5, 2019•0 citations

Topological subregions in Chern Simons theory and topological string theory

Gabriel Wong

The standard, gapped entanglement boundary condition in Chern Simons theory breaks the topological invariance of the theory by introducing a complex structure on the entangling surface. This produces an infinite dimensional subregion Hilbert space, a non-trivial modular Hamiltonion, and a UV-divergent entanglement entropy that is a universal feature of local quantum field theories. In this work, we appeal to the combinatorial quantization of Chern Simons theory to define a purely topological notion of a subregion. The subregion operator algebras are spaces of functions on a quantum group. We develop a diagrammatic calculus for the associated $q$-deformed entanglement entropy, which arise from the entanglement of anyonic edge modes. The $q$-deformation regulates the divergences of the QFT, producing a finite entanglement entropy associated to a $q$-tracial state. We explain how these ideas provide an operator algebraic framework for the entanglement entropy computations in topological string theory \cite{Donnelly:2020teo,Jiang:2020cqo, wongtopstring}, where a large- $N$ limit of the $q$-deformed subregion algebra plays a key role in the stringy description of spacetime.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2511.08746•Nov 13, 2025•2 citations

On entanglement entropy in non-Abelian lattice gauge theory and 3D quantum gravity

Clement Delcamp, Bianca Dittrich, Aldo Riello

Entanglement entropy is a valuable tool for characterizing the correlation structure of quantum field theories. When applied to gauge theories, subtleties arise which prevent the factorization of the Hilbert space underlying the notion of entanglement entropy. Borrowing techniques from extended topological field theories, we introduce a new definition of entanglement entropy for both Abelian and non-Abelian gauge theories. Being based on the notion of excitations, it provides a completely relational way of defining regions. Therefore, it naturally applies to background independent theories, e.g. gravity, by circumventing the difficulty of specifying the position of the entangling surface. We relate our construction to earlier proposals and argue that it brings these closer to each other. In particular, it yields the non-Abelian analogue of the ‘magnetic centre choice’, as obtained through an extended-Hilbert-space method, but applied to the recently introduced fusion basis for 3D lattice gauge theories. We point out that the different definitions of entanglement entropy can be related to a choice of (squeezed) vacuum state.

arXiv:1609.04806•Journal of High Energy Physics•Nov 1, 2016•68 citations
The standard definition of entanglement entropy in quantum field theory requires regularizing the entangling surface and factorizing the Hilbert space, which in turn involves a choice of boundary conditions at the regularized surface. This raises two natural questions which are open at present. The first is under what conditions there is a choice of boundary conditions that leads to a unitary map between the original Hilbert space and the factorized one, which is a necessary condition for a well-defined entanglement entropy. The second concerns the situation where there are multiple such choices, in which case the question is whether they all yield the same entropy, or at least the same terms usually referred to as universal. Focusing on topological theories and using three-dimensional Chern-Simons theory as a concrete illustration, we show under specified assumptions that different such choices affect only the non-universal terms in the entropy, such that the remaining terms are universal in this sense as well, while we explicitly demonstrate that boundary conditions corresponding to non-unitary maps can change these terms. We then explain how a similar argument applies to two-dimensional conformal field theories and discuss a condition for universality in general theories.
The paper asks whether the universal terms of QFT entanglement entropy are independent of the boundary conditions used to regularize the entangling surface and factorize the Hilbert space. It studies “shrinkable” boundary conditions: those whose regulating boundary reduces to the identity defect, up to local counterterms, as its transverse size vanishes.
The main calculation concerns three-dimensional U(1)kU(1)_kU(1)k​ Chern–Simons theory with even k>0k>0k>0, for a spherical state partitioned along its equator. Holomorphic boundary conditions are shown to be shrinkable using vacuum dominance of edge-mode characters. Bulk topological invariance permits smoothing the replica geometry while preserving the induced boundary metric. Under specified assumptions, different shrinkable boundary conditions affect only local counterterms, giving S=2αl/ϵ−12log⁡k+o(1)S=2\alpha l/\epsilon-\tfrac12\log k+o(1)S=2αl/ϵ−21​logk+o(1), with boundary-dependent α\alphaα but fixed topological constant. A non-shrinkable topological boundary in U(1)k×U(1)−kU(1)_k\times U(1)_{-k}U(1)k​×U(1)−k​ instead produces a projector, can annihilate nonzero states, and changes the computed topological constant from −log⁡k-\log k−logk to zero.
For two-dimensional CFTs, a local Weyl transformation gives an analogous conditional argument preserving the interval coefficient (c/3)log⁡(l/ϵ)(c/3)\log(l/\epsilon)(c/3)log(l/ϵ). The topological proof assumes shrinkability persists under geometry-induced coupling shifts and sufficient regularity to interchange shrinking and replica differentiation; the CFT argument separately assumes this interchange preserves the logarithmic term. In higher dimensions, ordinary shrinkability does not establish universality: the remaining condition concerns the regulator’s shrinking behavior with a modular-Hamiltonian insertion. General existence criteria and explicit higher-dimensional tests, including Maxwell theory, remain open.
Entanglement entropy for spatial subregions is difficult to define in string theory because of the extended nature of strings. Here we propose a definition for bosonic open strings using the framework of string field theory. The key difference (compared to ordinary quantum field theory) is that the subregion is chosen inside a Cauchy surface in the ``space of open string configurations.'' We first present a simple calculation of this entanglement entropy in free light-cone string field theory, ignoring subtleties related to the factorization of the Hilbert space. We reproduce the answer expected from an effective field theory point of view, namely a sum over the one-loop entanglement entropies corresponding to all the particle-excitations of the string, and further show that the full string theory regulates ultraviolet divergences in the entanglement entropy. We then revisit the question of factorization of the Hilbert space by analyzing the covariant phase-space associated with a subregion in Witten's covariant string field theory. We show that the pure gauge (i.e., BRST exact) modes in the string field become dynamical at the entanglement cut. Thus, a proper definition of the entropy must involve an extended Hilbert space, with new stringy edge modes localized at the entanglement cut.
We revisit the issue of defining the entropy of a spatial region in a broad class of quantum theories. In theories with explicit regularizations, working within an elementary but general algebraic framework applicable to matter and gauge theories alike, we give precise path integral expressions for three known types of entanglement entropy that we call full, distillable, and gauge-invariant. For a class of gauge theories that do not necessarily have a regularization in our framework, including Chern-Simons theory, we describe a related approach to defining entropies based on locally extending the Hilbert space at the entangling edge, and we discuss its connections to other calculational prescriptions. Based on results from both approaches, we conjecture that it is always the full entanglement entropy that is calculated by standard holographic techniques in strongly coupled conformal theories.
We present a systematic treatment of entanglement in two-dimensional topological quantum field theories (TQFTs). Our approach clarifies the sensitivity of entanglement measures to the cutting maps that implement Hilbert space factorization. Such maps embed the TQFT Hilbert space into a description with potentially more degrees of freedom, and for entanglement to be well defined they must be isometric, i.e., they must preserve the norms of all states. We show that the naïve cutting map based solely upon path integration subject to boundary conditions is not isometric for generic TQFTs. For any 2d TQFT, we give a prescription to construct isometric cutting maps by dressing path integration with suitable edge operators. This allows us to compute entanglement for any state, any bipartition, and any boundary condition. As a consequence, we find a non-integer "ground-state degeneracy" à la Affleck-Ludwig, despite all boundary conditions being gapped. We further show how to reconstruct the partition function of the TQFT at arbitrary genus from the multi-interval Rényi entropies of a single state. For theories with (possibly non-invertible) symmetries, we show that the entanglement entropy of the symmetric ground state can distinguish gapped phases with the same symmetry, without any further knowledge of their vacua, while the entanglement asymmetry of the vacua entropically detects symmetry breaking. We illustrate our formalism with a range of applications, from finite gauge theories to Haagerup gapped phases and infrared phases of adjoint QCD2_22​.
In this thesis we will explore entanglement of various subsystems in quantum field theory, and its uses for describing underlying structure of states. We begin this journey by focusing on topological quantum field theory in chapters 1 and 2. These chapters are based heavily upon the papers [1] and [2, 3], respectively. In the introduction to chapter 1 we take the opportunity to recall the definition of bipartite entanglement entropy in quantum field theory and describe, briefly, how the entropy associated to connected spatial subregions provides a signature of topological order at the level of the wave-function. In particular, for a gapped phase with topological order, we recapitulate how the sub-leading correction to the “area-law” of the entanglement entropy contains coarse information about the topological phase while also being insensitive to the short-distance details of the underlying theory. We then present results that show that this sub-leading correction can also detect the class of interactions that glue a subregion to its complement. In principle, the subregion could be a different topological phase than its complement, and so we say that the entanglement entropy provides a signature of the interface between topological phases. In showing this, we discuss the classes of interactions between gapped topological phases and how they are represented as boundary conditions in the low-energy effective topological field theory, which in this case is an Abelian Chern-Simons theory. Using these boundary conditions, we perform path-integral calculations of the entanglement entropy using the replica trick and show that the universal contribution does indeed depend on the class of boundary conditions, and the gapped topological phases of the subsystem and its complement. To finish this chapter we reformulate this problem at the level of the Hilbert space and show how these universal contributions are related to resolving a generic ambiguity in defining subsystems of field theories with gauge invariance. We continue in the theme of topological field theories for chapter 2. Here we will shift focus from subregions of a connected spatial slice to disconnected spatial regions in an effort to explore, firstly, how long-range entanglement is encoded in topological field theory, and secondly, how that entanglement is encoded amongst multiple parties. We begin with a brief introduction of multi-party entanglement and recall the classification of three-party entanglement. Moving on to our specific setup, we describe the construction of states on multiple non-intersecting torus boundaries. Generically, these are states on link complements where the torus boundaries can be thought of as the edges of thickened closed strings entwined and knotted inside a compact manifold, which we will take to be the three-sphere. The wave-functions of these states are represented by various link invariants (such as the Gauss linking number for Abelian links, and Jones polynomial for SU(2)). We will exhibit several examples of multi-component links in both the Abelian and the SU(2) theories, and afterwards discuss generic features of the entanglement of link states in Chern-Simons theories with a compact group. In this discussion, we will conjecture a classification (albeit broad) of links via multi-partite entanglement of their corresponding states. We will end the chapter moving away from compact groups and discuss hyperbolic links in SL(2,C) Chern-Simons theory in the semi-classical limit. In particular, utilizing the generalized volume conjecture, we will show that the entanglement structure of hyperbolic links is greatly constrained in this semi-classical limit. Finally, in chapter 3 we switch gears and discuss renormalization of free bosonic field theory. The content of this chapter is drawn from the work of [4]. Motivated by work establishing duality between the singlet sector of O(N) vector models at large N and higher spin gauge theory on Anti de Sitter (AdS) space, we develop an exact renormalization group (ERG) framework for discussing the renormalization of a large class of O(N) singlet states. We will show that for the ground state and the excited states in this class the ERG is implemented by the action of unitary operators (that can be taken to be local). Consequently, the ERG framework can be regarded as a continuum tensor network. We contrast this tensor network with some well known tensor network renormalization schemes such as the muti-scale entanglement renormalization ansatz (MERA) and its proposed continuum version (cMERA). We also comment on the nature of this network with ordinary Wilsonian renormalization. One of the central features of the ERG network is how it acts on the momentum space entanglement of the field theory. In particular, we argue that for excited states, the ERG disentangles modes that lie just above and below the UV cutoff.
The standard, gapped entanglement boundary condition in Chern Simons theory breaks the topological invariance of the theory by introducing a complex structure on the entangling surface. This produces an infinite dimensional subregion Hilbert space, a non-trivial modular Hamiltonion, and a UV-divergent entanglement entropy that is a universal feature of local quantum field theories. In this work, we appeal to the combinatorial quantization of Chern Simons theory to define a purely topological notion of a subregion. The subregion operator algebras are spaces of functions on a quantum group. We develop a diagrammatic calculus for the associated qqq-deformed entanglement entropy, which arise from the entanglement of anyonic edge modes. The qqq-deformation regulates the divergences of the QFT, producing a finite entanglement entropy associated to a qqq-tracial state. We explain how these ideas provide an operator algebraic framework for the entanglement entropy computations in topological string theory \cite{Donnelly:2020teo,Jiang:2020cqo, wongtopstring}, where a large- NNN limit of the qqq-deformed subregion algebra plays a key role in the stringy description of spacetime.
Entanglement entropy is a valuable tool for characterizing the correlation structure of quantum field theories. When applied to gauge theories, subtleties arise which prevent the factorization of the Hilbert space underlying the notion of entanglement entropy. Borrowing techniques from extended topological field theories, we introduce a new definition of entanglement entropy for both Abelian and non-Abelian gauge theories. Being based on the notion of excitations, it provides a completely relational way of defining regions. Therefore, it naturally applies to background independent theories, e.g. gravity, by circumventing the difficulty of specifying the position of the entangling surface. We relate our construction to earlier proposals and argue that it brings these closer to each other. In particular, it yields the non-Abelian analogue of the ‘magnetic centre choice’, as obtained through an extended-Hilbert-space method, but applied to the recently introduced fusion basis for 3D lattice gauge theories. We point out that the different definitions of entanglement entropy can be related to a choice of (squeezed) vacuum state.