Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.03881

Liouvillian Kramers Degeneracy

Kohei Kawabata

cond-mat.mes-hallquant-phSubmitted Nov 2, 2026• Announced Nov 4, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Kramers theorem generally guarantees the spectral degeneracy of time-reversal-invariant Hamiltonian operators with half-integer spin, underlying a variety of physical phenomena. Despite its fundamental significance, the Kramers degeneracy has been argued to be absent in Liouvillian superoperators acting on mixed states because of the double structure of the Hilbert space. Here, we instead demonstrate that the interplay of time-reversal symmetry$^†$ and parity symmetry enforces the Kramers degeneracy in Liouvillians. We explicitly construct dissipative many-body models of interacting fermions and spins exhibiting the Kramers degeneracy and show that their complex spectral statistics follow those of non-Hermitian random matrices in the corresponding symplectic symmetry classes. Of the three fundamental universality classes of non-Hermitian random matrices, the symplectic class has never been realized in symmetry-resolved many-body Liouvillians. Our constructions provide its explicit realizations and spectral signatures of nonintegrability in symplectic open quantum systems.

AI Summary

Can a physical Liouvillian exhibit Kramers degeneracy within a fully symmetry-resolved operator sector, despite its doubled Hilbert-space structure? This paper identifies a symmetry construction that permits it, revising an earlier exclusion argument based on more restrictive representations of symmetry operators. The central condition is an antiunitary superoperator satisfying $\mathcal{T}\mathcal{L}^{\dagger}\mathcal{T}^{-1}=\mathcal{L}$ and $\mathcal{T}^2=(-1)^{\mathcal{N}}$. Parity commutes with $\mathcal{L}$, so its odd sector has $\mathcal{T}^2=-1$, enforcing degeneracy of complex eigenvalues by the non-Hermitian Kramers theorem. Combining this structure with Hermiticity preservation gives class DIII$^{\dagger}$ for odd weak parity, or class AII$^{\dagger}$ in each opposite-parity coherence sector when parity is strong. Sufficient Lindblad conditions are supplied through jump sets closed under time reversal and Hermitian conjugation. Explicit realizations include interacting spinful fermions with dephasing, a spatially local dissipative spin chain, a random Lindbladian, and an exactly solvable single-orbital model whose odd-sector characteristic polynomial is a perfect square. Numerical complex-spacing-ratio distributions support symplectic random-matrix statistics; the interacting examples use three spinful orbitals or six spins, averaging over 5,000 realizations and selected spectral windows. The protected odd sector contains no density matrices, so the result concerns dynamical modes rather than a necessary degeneracy of stationary states; these modes can be probed through two-time correlations of parity-odd operators. Spin-chain statistics show deviations near spacing-ratio modulus one. Connections to open-system topology and symmetry fractionalization remain prospective.

No sign of AI-generated text

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
8 pages, 3 figures

Related papers

Violation and revival of Kramers' degeneracy in open quantum systems

Pengfei Zhang, Yu Chen

Kramers' theorem ensures double degeneracy in the energy spectrum of a time-reversal symmetric fermionic system with half-integer total spin. Here, we are trying to go beyond the closed system and discuss Kramers' degeneracy in open systems out of equilibrium. A natural way to extend the Kramers' degeneracy in open quantum systems is by the degeneracy of different spins' spectra together with the vanishing interspin spectrum. We find the violation of Kramers' degeneracy in time-reversal symmetric open quantum systems is locked with whether the system reaches thermal equilibrium. After a general coupling to an environment in a time-reversal symmetry-preserving way, the Kramers doublet experiences an energy splitting at a short time and then a recovery process. We verified the violation and revival of Kramers' degeneracy in a concrete model of interacting fermions and we find Kramers' degeneracy is restored after the local thermalization time. By contrast, for time-reversal symmetry $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\mathcal{T}}$ with ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\mathcal{T}}}^{2}=1$, we find that although there is a violation and revival of spectral degeneracy for different spins, the inter-spin spectral function is always nonzero. We also prove that the degeneracy in spectral function protected by unitary symmetry can always be maintained.

arXiv:2108.05493•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 8, 2022•9 citations

Time-Reversal Symmetry in Non-Hermitian Systems

M. Sato, K. Hasebe, K. Esaki +1 more

For ordinary Hermitian Hamiltonians, the states support the mathematical structure of quaternion and show the Kramers degeneracy when the system has a half-odd-integer spin and the time-reversal operator obeys Θ 2 = -1, while no such structure exists when Θ 2 = +1.Here, we point out that for non-Hermitian systems, there exists a similar mathematical structure called split-quaternion even when Θ 2 = +1.It is also found that a degeneracy similar to the Kramers degeneracy follows from the split-quaternion structure if the Hamiltonian is pseudo-Hermitian with the metric operator η satisfying {η, Θ} = 0. Furthermore, we show that particle/hole symmetry gives rise to a pair of states with opposite energies on the basis of the split-quaternion in a class of non-Hermitian Hamiltonians.As concrete examples, we examine in detail N × N Hamiltonians with N = 2 and 4, which are non-Hermitian generalizations of spin 1/2 Hamiltonian and quadrupole Hamiltonian of spin 3/2, respectively.

arXiv:1106.1806•Progress of Theoretical Physics•Jun 1, 2012•87 citations

Symmetry of Open Quantum Systems: Classification of Dissipative Quantum Chaos

Kohei Kawabata, Anish Kulkarni, Jiachen Li +2 more

We develop a theory of symmetry in open quantum systems.Using the operator-state mapping, we characterize symmetry of Liouvillian superoperators for the open quantum dynamics by symmetry of operators in the double Hilbert space and apply the 38-fold internal-symmetry classification of non-Hermitian operators.We find rich symmetry classification due to the interplay between symmetry in the corresponding closed quantum systems and symmetry inherent in the construction of the Liouvillian superoperators.As an illustrative example of open quantum bosonic systems, we study symmetry classes of dissipative quantum spin models.For open quantum fermionic systems, we develop the Z 4 classification of fermion parity symmetry and antiunitary symmetry in the double Hilbert space, which contrasts with the Z 8 classification in closed quantum systems.We also develop the symmetry classification of open quantum fermionic many-body systems-a dissipative generalization of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model described by the Lindblad master equation.We establish the periodic tables of the SYK Lindbladians and elucidate the difference from the SYK Hamiltonians.Furthermore, from extensive numerical calculations, we study its complex-spectral statistics and demonstrate dissipative quantum chaos enriched by symmetry.

arXiv:2212.00605•PRX Quantum•Aug 29, 2023•89 citations

Liouvillian Non-Invertible Symmetry

Ying-Cheng Yang, Jhen-Dong Lin, Yueh-Nan Chen

Non-invertible symmetries extend conventional symmetries beyond group-like transformations and play an important role in quantum field theory and many-body physics. However, a general framework of non-invertible symmetries in open quantum systems is still lacking. Here, we formulate a general Liouville-space duality framework that extends Hilbert-space non-invertible dualities to open quantum systems. The resulting defect relates Liouvillians with dual Hamiltonian and dissipative parameters and becomes an exact symmetry at self-duality. We apply this framework to the periodic transverse-field Ising chain with two collective Lindblad channels exchanged by Kramers--Wannier (KW) duality. A strong $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetry divides Liouville space into four parity sectors, while the defect acts nontrivially only in the even-even sector. At self-duality, the KW defect imposes a momentum-resolved selection rule on Liouvillian Jordan blocks. Modes with different Liouville momenta or KW-defect eigenvalues cannot form a common exceptional Jordan block. For a three-site chain, a global Rényi-2 KW asymmetry dynamically identifies the self-dual conditions. At the same time, the spectral structure exhibits both a semisimple degeneracy and a self-dual exceptional point with a perturbation-selective response. These results extend non-invertible dualities to Markovian quantum dynamics and establish a symmetry-based selection rule for Liouvillian Jordan structures.

quant-pharXiv:2610.23111•Oct 19, 2026•0 citations

Threefold Way for Typical Entanglement

Haruki Yagi, Ken Mochizuki, Zongping Gong

A typical quantum state with no symmetry can be realized by letting a random unitary act on a fixed state, and the subsystem entanglement spectrum follows the Laguerre unitary ensemble (LUE). For integer-spin time reversal symmetry, we have an analogous scenario where we prepare a time-reversal symmetric state and let random orthogonal matrices act on it, leading to the Laguerre orthogonal ensemble (LOE). However, for half-integer-spin time reversal symmetry, a straightforward analog leading to the Laguerre symplectic ensemble (LSE) is no longer valid because that time-reversal symmetric state is forbidden by the Kramers' theorem. We devise a system in which the global time reversal operator is fractionalized on the subsystems, and show that LSE arises in the system. Extending this idea, we incorporate general symmetry fractionalization into the system, and show that the statistics of the entanglement spectrum is decomposed into a direct sum of LOE, LUE, and/or LSE. Here, various degeneracies in the entanglement spectrum may appear, depending on the non-Abelian nature of the symmetry group and the cohomology class of the nontrivial projective representation on the subsystem. Our work establishes the entanglement counterpart of Dyson's threefold way for Hamiltonians with symmetries.

arXiv:2410.11309•Physical Review Letters•Apr 14, 2025•1 citation

On the time-reversal symmetry in pseudo-Hermitian systems

B. Choutri, Omar Cherbal, F.-Z. Ighezou +1 more

In a recent paper [M. Sato, K. Hasebe, K. Esaki, and M. Kohmoto, Prog. Theor. Phys. 127, 937 (2012)] Sato and his collaborators established a generalization of the Kramers degeneracy structure to pseudo-Hermitian Hamiltonian systems, admitting even time-reversal symmetry, |$T^{2}=1$|⁠. This extension is achieved using the mathematical structure of split-quaternions instead of quaternions, usually adopted in the case of Hermitian Hamiltonians with odd time-reversal symmetry, |$T^{2}=-1$|⁠. Here we find that the metric operator for the pseudo-Hermitian Hamiltonian |$H$| that allows the realization of the generalized Kramers degeneracy is necessarily indefinite. We show that such |$H$| with real spectrum also possesses odd antilinear symmetry induced from the existing odd time-reversal symmetry of its Hermitian counterpart |$h$|⁠, so that the generalized Kramers degeneracy of |$H$| is in fact crypto-Hermitian Kramers degeneracy. We study in greater detail a new example of the pseudo-Hermitian split-quaternionic four-level Hamiltonian system, which admits an indefinite metric operator and time-reversal symmetry and, as a consequence, a generalized Kramers degeneracy structure. We provide a complete solution of the eigenvalue problem, construct pseudo-Hermitian ladder operators closing the normal and abnormal pseudo-fermionic algebras, and show that this system fulfills a crypto-Hermitian degeneracy.

Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics•Nov 24, 2014•3 citations
The Kramers theorem generally guarantees the spectral degeneracy of time-reversal-invariant Hamiltonian operators with half-integer spin, underlying a variety of physical phenomena. Despite its fundamental significance, the Kramers degeneracy has been argued to be absent in Liouvillian superoperators acting on mixed states because of the double structure of the Hilbert space. Here, we instead demonstrate that the interplay of time-reversal symmetry†^†† and parity symmetry enforces the Kramers degeneracy in Liouvillians. We explicitly construct dissipative many-body models of interacting fermions and spins exhibiting the Kramers degeneracy and show that their complex spectral statistics follow those of non-Hermitian random matrices in the corresponding symplectic symmetry classes. Of the three fundamental universality classes of non-Hermitian random matrices, the symplectic class has never been realized in symmetry-resolved many-body Liouvillians. Our constructions provide its explicit realizations and spectral signatures of nonintegrability in symplectic open quantum systems.
Can a physical Liouvillian exhibit Kramers degeneracy within a fully symmetry-resolved operator sector, despite its doubled Hilbert-space structure? This paper identifies a symmetry construction that permits it, revising an earlier exclusion argument based on more restrictive representations of symmetry operators.
The central condition is an antiunitary superoperator satisfying TL†T−1=L\mathcal{T}\mathcal{L}^{\dagger}\mathcal{T}^{-1}=\mathcal{L}TL†T−1=L and T2=(−1)N\mathcal{T}^2=(-1)^{\mathcal{N}}T2=(−1)N. Parity commutes with L\mathcal{L}L, so its odd sector has T2=−1\mathcal{T}^2=-1T2=−1, enforcing degeneracy of complex eigenvalues by the non-Hermitian Kramers theorem. Combining this structure with Hermiticity preservation gives class DIII†^{\dagger}† for odd weak parity, or class AII†^{\dagger}† in each opposite-parity coherence sector when parity is strong. Sufficient Lindblad conditions are supplied through jump sets closed under time reversal and Hermitian conjugation.
Explicit realizations include interacting spinful fermions with dephasing, a spatially local dissipative spin chain, a random Lindbladian, and an exactly solvable single-orbital model whose odd-sector characteristic polynomial is a perfect square. Numerical complex-spacing-ratio distributions support symplectic random-matrix statistics; the interacting examples use three spinful orbitals or six spins, averaging over 5,000 realizations and selected spectral windows.
The protected odd sector contains no density matrices, so the result concerns dynamical modes rather than a necessary degeneracy of stationary states; these modes can be probed through two-time correlations of parity-odd operators. Spin-chain statistics show deviations near spacing-ratio modulus one. Connections to open-system topology and symmetry fractionalization remain prospective.
Kramers' theorem ensures double degeneracy in the energy spectrum of a time-reversal symmetric fermionic system with half-integer total spin. Here, we are trying to go beyond the closed system and discuss Kramers' degeneracy in open systems out of equilibrium. A natural way to extend the Kramers' degeneracy in open quantum systems is by the degeneracy of different spins' spectra together with the vanishing interspin spectrum. We find the violation of Kramers' degeneracy in time-reversal symmetric open quantum systems is locked with whether the system reaches thermal equilibrium. After a general coupling to an environment in a time-reversal symmetry-preserving way, the Kramers doublet experiences an energy splitting at a short time and then a recovery process. We verified the violation and revival of Kramers' degeneracy in a concrete model of interacting fermions and we find Kramers' degeneracy is restored after the local thermalization time. By contrast, for time-reversal symmetry $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\mathcal{T}}$ with ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{\mathcal{T}}}^{2}=1$, we find that although there is a violation and revival of spectral degeneracy for different spins, the inter-spin spectral function is always nonzero. We also prove that the degeneracy in spectral function protected by unitary symmetry can always be maintained.
For ordinary Hermitian Hamiltonians, the states support the mathematical structure of quaternion and show the Kramers degeneracy when the system has a half-odd-integer spin and the time-reversal operator obeys Θ 2 = -1, while no such structure exists when Θ 2 = +1.Here, we point out that for non-Hermitian systems, there exists a similar mathematical structure called split-quaternion even when Θ 2 = +1.It is also found that a degeneracy similar to the Kramers degeneracy follows from the split-quaternion structure if the Hamiltonian is pseudo-Hermitian with the metric operator η satisfying {η, Θ} = 0. Furthermore, we show that particle/hole symmetry gives rise to a pair of states with opposite energies on the basis of the split-quaternion in a class of non-Hermitian Hamiltonians.As concrete examples, we examine in detail N × N Hamiltonians with N = 2 and 4, which are non-Hermitian generalizations of spin 1/2 Hamiltonian and quadrupole Hamiltonian of spin 3/2, respectively.
We develop a theory of symmetry in open quantum systems.Using the operator-state mapping, we characterize symmetry of Liouvillian superoperators for the open quantum dynamics by symmetry of operators in the double Hilbert space and apply the 38-fold internal-symmetry classification of non-Hermitian operators.We find rich symmetry classification due to the interplay between symmetry in the corresponding closed quantum systems and symmetry inherent in the construction of the Liouvillian superoperators.As an illustrative example of open quantum bosonic systems, we study symmetry classes of dissipative quantum spin models.For open quantum fermionic systems, we develop the Z 4 classification of fermion parity symmetry and antiunitary symmetry in the double Hilbert space, which contrasts with the Z 8 classification in closed quantum systems.We also develop the symmetry classification of open quantum fermionic many-body systems-a dissipative generalization of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model described by the Lindblad master equation.We establish the periodic tables of the SYK Lindbladians and elucidate the difference from the SYK Hamiltonians.Furthermore, from extensive numerical calculations, we study its complex-spectral statistics and demonstrate dissipative quantum chaos enriched by symmetry.
Non-invertible symmetries extend conventional symmetries beyond group-like transformations and play an important role in quantum field theory and many-body physics. However, a general framework of non-invertible symmetries in open quantum systems is still lacking. Here, we formulate a general Liouville-space duality framework that extends Hilbert-space non-invertible dualities to open quantum systems. The resulting defect relates Liouvillians with dual Hamiltonian and dissipative parameters and becomes an exact symmetry at self-duality. We apply this framework to the periodic transverse-field Ising chain with two collective Lindblad channels exchanged by Kramers--Wannier (KW) duality. A strong Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ symmetry divides Liouville space into four parity sectors, while the defect acts nontrivially only in the even-even sector. At self-duality, the KW defect imposes a momentum-resolved selection rule on Liouvillian Jordan blocks. Modes with different Liouville momenta or KW-defect eigenvalues cannot form a common exceptional Jordan block. For a three-site chain, a global Rényi-2 KW asymmetry dynamically identifies the self-dual conditions. At the same time, the spectral structure exhibits both a semisimple degeneracy and a self-dual exceptional point with a perturbation-selective response. These results extend non-invertible dualities to Markovian quantum dynamics and establish a symmetry-based selection rule for Liouvillian Jordan structures.
A typical quantum state with no symmetry can be realized by letting a random unitary act on a fixed state, and the subsystem entanglement spectrum follows the Laguerre unitary ensemble (LUE). For integer-spin time reversal symmetry, we have an analogous scenario where we prepare a time-reversal symmetric state and let random orthogonal matrices act on it, leading to the Laguerre orthogonal ensemble (LOE). However, for half-integer-spin time reversal symmetry, a straightforward analog leading to the Laguerre symplectic ensemble (LSE) is no longer valid because that time-reversal symmetric state is forbidden by the Kramers' theorem. We devise a system in which the global time reversal operator is fractionalized on the subsystems, and show that LSE arises in the system. Extending this idea, we incorporate general symmetry fractionalization into the system, and show that the statistics of the entanglement spectrum is decomposed into a direct sum of LOE, LUE, and/or LSE. Here, various degeneracies in the entanglement spectrum may appear, depending on the non-Abelian nature of the symmetry group and the cohomology class of the nontrivial projective representation on the subsystem. Our work establishes the entanglement counterpart of Dyson's threefold way for Hamiltonians with symmetries.
In a recent paper [M. Sato, K. Hasebe, K. Esaki, and M. Kohmoto, Prog. Theor. Phys. 127, 937 (2012)] Sato and his collaborators established a generalization of the Kramers degeneracy structure to pseudo-Hermitian Hamiltonian systems, admitting even time-reversal symmetry, |T2=1T^{2}=1T2=1|⁠. This extension is achieved using the mathematical structure of split-quaternions instead of quaternions, usually adopted in the case of Hermitian Hamiltonians with odd time-reversal symmetry, |T2=−1T^{2}=-1T2=−1|⁠. Here we find that the metric operator for the pseudo-Hermitian Hamiltonian |HHH| that allows the realization of the generalized Kramers degeneracy is necessarily indefinite. We show that such |HHH| with real spectrum also possesses odd antilinear symmetry induced from the existing odd time-reversal symmetry of its Hermitian counterpart |hhh|⁠, so that the generalized Kramers degeneracy of |HHH| is in fact crypto-Hermitian Kramers degeneracy. We study in greater detail a new example of the pseudo-Hermitian split-quaternionic four-level Hamiltonian system, which admits an indefinite metric operator and time-reversal symmetry and, as a consequence, a generalized Kramers degeneracy structure. We provide a complete solution of the eigenvalue problem, construct pseudo-Hermitian ladder operators closing the normal and abnormal pseudo-fermionic algebras, and show that this system fulfills a crypto-Hermitian degeneracy.