Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.02582

Quantum 6j-symbols arising from a subfactor of finite index and finite depth and the zipper condition for 4-tensors in two-dimensional topological order

Yasuyuki Kawahigashi

Published Nov 2, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study 3-tensors satisfying the ``zipper condition,'' which play an important role in tensor network approaches to two-dimensional topological order. In our previous work, we identified the 4-tensors appearing in these approaches with bi-unitary connections in the Jones theory of subfactors in operator algebras. These bi-unitary connections give rise to subfactors of finite index. We prove that, when the associated subfactor has finite depth, the 3-tensors satisfying the zipper condition correspond precisely to the quantum $6j$-symbols, also known as $F$-symbols, of the unitary multi-fusion category arising from the subfactor. This realization of quantum $6j$-symbols differs from their realization through a flat bi-unitary connection arising from the higher relative commutants of a subfactor.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.02582

Related papers

The zipper condition for 4-tensors in two-dimensional topological order and the higher relative commutants of a subfactor arising from a commuting square

Yasuyuki Kawahigashi

Researchers in condensed matter physics recently study two-dimensional topological order in terms of tensor networks involving certain 3- and 4-tensors. Their 3-tensors satisfying the “zipper condition” play an important role there, and such 3-tensors can be made into certain 2-tensors by combining two wires into one. We identify their 4-tensors with bi-unitary connections in Jones’ subfactor theory in operator algebras with precise normalization constants. Then we prove that their 2-tensors satisfying the zipper condition are the same as flat fields of strings in subfactor theory which correspond to elements in the higher relative commutants of the subfactor arising from the bi-unitary connection. This is what we expect, since the zipper condition is a kind of pentagon relations, but we clarify what conditions are exactly needed for this—we do not need the flatness or the finite depth condition for the bi-unitary connection. We actually generalize their 4-tensors so that the four index sets of the 4-tensors can be all different and work on a “half-version” of the zipper condition.

arXiv:2511.10080•Letters in Mathematical Physics•Mar 18, 2026•1 citation

Projector matrix product operators, anyons and higher relative commutants of subfactors

Yasuyuki Kawahigashi

Abstract A bi-unitary connection in subfactor theory of Jones producing a subfactor of finite depth gives a 4-tensor appearing in a recent work of Bultinck–Mariën–Williamson–Şahinoğlu-Haegeman–Verstraete on two-dimensional topological order and anyons. In their work, they have a special projection called a projector matrix product operator. We prove that the range of this projection of lengthkis naturally identified with thekth higher relative commutant of the subfactor arising from the bi-unitary connection. This gives a further connection between two-dimensional topological order and subfactor theory.

arXiv:2102.04562•Mathematische Annalen•Nov 19, 2022•10 citations

Two-dimensional topological order and operator algebras

Yasuyuki Kawahigashi

We review recent interactions between mathematical theory of two-dimensional topological order and operator algebras, particularly the Jones theory of subfactors. The role of representation theory in terms of tensor categories is emphasized. Connections to two-dimensional conformal field theory are also presented. In particular, we discuss anyon condensation, gapped domain walls and matrix product operators in terms of operator algebras.

arXiv:2102.10953•International Journal of Modern Physics B•Mar 30, 2021•17 citations

Subfactors and quantum information theory

Pieter Naaijkens

We consider quantum information tasks in an operator algebraic setting, where we consider normal states on von Neumann algebras. In particular, we consider subfactors N ⊂ M \mathfrak {N} \subset \mathfrak {M} , that is, unital inclusions of von Neumann algebras with trivial center. One can ask the following question: given a normal state ω \omega on M \mathfrak {M} , how much can one learn by only doing measurements from N \mathfrak {N} ? We argue how the Jones index [ M : N ] [\mathfrak {M}:\mathfrak {N}] can be used to give a quantitative answer to this, showing how the rich theory of subfactors can be used in a quantum information context. As an example we discuss how the Jones index can be used in the context of wiretap channels. Subfactors also occur naturally in physics. Here we discuss two examples: rational conformal field theories and Kitaev’s toric code on the plane, a prototypical example of a topologically ordered model. There we can directly relate aspects of the general setting to physical properties such as the quantum dimension of the excitations. In the example of the toric code we also show how we can calculate the index via an approximation with finite dimensional systems. This explicit construction sheds more light on the connection between topological order and the Jones index.

arXiv:1704.05562•Contemporary mathematics - American Mathematical Society•Jan 1, 2018•8 citations

Variational methods for characterizing matrix product operator symmetries

Anna Francuz, Laurens Lootens, Frank Verstraete +1 more

We present a method of extracting information about topological order from the ground state of a strongly correlated two-dimensional system represented by an infinite projected entangled pair state (iPEPS). As in previous works [A. Francuz et al., Phys. Rev. B 101, 041108(R) (2020) and A. Francuz and J. Dziarmaga, Phys. Rev. B 102, 235112 (2020)] we begin by determining symmetries of the iPEPS represented by infinite matrix product operators (iMPO) that map between the different iPEPS transfer matrix fixed points, to which we apply the fundamental theorem of matrix product states to find zipper tensors between products of iMPO's that encode fusion properties of the anyons. The zippers can be combined to extract topological $F$ symbols of the underlying fusion category, which unequivocally identifies the topological order of the ground state. We bring the $F$ symbols to the canonical gauge, and also compute the Drinfeld center of this unitary fusion category to extract the topological $S$ and $T$ matrices encoding mutual statistics and self-statistics of the emergent anyons. The algorithm is applied to Abelian toric code, Kitaev model, double semion, and twisted quantum double of ${Z}_{3}$, as well as to non-Abelian double Fibonacci, double Ising, and quantum double of ${S}_{3}$ and $\mathrm{Rep}({S}_{3})$ string-net models.

arXiv:2107.05265•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 29, 2021•1 citation

Tensor Network Representation of Many-Body Quantum States and Unitary Operators

Sujeet K. Shukla

Understanding many-body quantum systems is one of the most challenging problems in contemporary condensed-matter physics. Tensor network representation of quantum states and operators are taking central stage in this pursuit and beyond. They prove to be a powerful numerical and conceptual tool, and indeed a new language altogether. This thesis investigates various aspects of these representations by focusing on two specific problems: the first half of the thesis is devoted to examining how 'stable' a tensor network representation is for two-dimensional quantum states with topological order, and the second half explores the representability of various unitary loop operators with tensor networks. In the numerical usage of the tensor networks, the tensor is varied as to find the representation of the ground states of the given Hamiltonian. In chapter two and three of this thesis we show that such a numerical program for topological phases can be 'ill-posed'. We show that tensor network can be an unstable representation for a topological phase: even an infinitesimal variation in the representation results in the loss of topological order, completely or partially. We diagnose this problem by identifying the exact causes of this instability, and find that it is only tensor variations in certain directions that result in instability, because they result in the condensation of bosonic quasi-particles of the phase. Such unstable variations are characterized by two properties: (1) they can replace a tensor in the tensor network without making the network collapse, and (2) their presence in the network represents the presence of a non-trivial topological charge. We prove that the general tensor representation of all string-net models suffer with such instabilities. We propose an exact mathematical operator to project out all such unstable variations and show its efficacy for a few models by direct calculations. Such an operator can be useful in numerical programs involving such tensor representations. We also point out that such variations play a crucial role in simulating topological phase transitions and their presence can be vital in an accurate simulation. In chapter four and five of this thesis we focus on the representability of unitary loop operators by tensor networks. Such operators not only provide an important tool in the study of dynamical process in one-dimensional systems, but also in understanding and classification of symmetry protected topological phases in two dimensions. To characterize all such operators, we find a necessary and sufficient condition for any loop tensor network operator of a given length to represent a unitary operator. In particular, it is shown that all unitary operators that map local operators to local operators (locality-preserving) can always be represented by a tensor network. Locality-preserving unitary loop operators are classified by a rational index called the GNVW index defined in Ref. [1] which measures how much information 'flows' along the loop. We define Rank-Ratio index for tensor network operators and show that it is completely equivalent to the GNVW index. Therefore, GNVW index of a unitary operator can be easily extracted from its tensor network representation. We find that, other than representing locality-preserving unitary maps, tensor networks can also represent unitary operators that map local operators to global (non-local) operators. These tensor network operators are found to have a long-ranged order similar to tensors that represent topological tensor network states in two dimensions.

•Sep 25, 2017•0 citations
We study 3-tensors satisfying the ``zipper condition,'' which play an important role in tensor network approaches to two-dimensional topological order. In our previous work, we identified the 4-tensors appearing in these approaches with bi-unitary connections in the Jones theory of subfactors in operator algebras. These bi-unitary connections give rise to subfactors of finite index. We prove that, when the associated subfactor has finite depth, the 3-tensors satisfying the zipper condition correspond precisely to the quantum 6j6j6j-symbols, also known as FFF-symbols, of the unitary multi-fusion category arising from the subfactor. This realization of quantum 6j6j6j-symbols differs from their realization through a flat bi-unitary connection arising from the higher relative commutants of a subfactor.
Researchers in condensed matter physics recently study two-dimensional topological order in terms of tensor networks involving certain 3- and 4-tensors. Their 3-tensors satisfying the “zipper condition” play an important role there, and such 3-tensors can be made into certain 2-tensors by combining two wires into one. We identify their 4-tensors with bi-unitary connections in Jones’ subfactor theory in operator algebras with precise normalization constants. Then we prove that their 2-tensors satisfying the zipper condition are the same as flat fields of strings in subfactor theory which correspond to elements in the higher relative commutants of the subfactor arising from the bi-unitary connection. This is what we expect, since the zipper condition is a kind of pentagon relations, but we clarify what conditions are exactly needed for this—we do not need the flatness or the finite depth condition for the bi-unitary connection. We actually generalize their 4-tensors so that the four index sets of the 4-tensors can be all different and work on a “half-version” of the zipper condition.
Abstract A bi-unitary connection in subfactor theory of Jones producing a subfactor of finite depth gives a 4-tensor appearing in a recent work of Bultinck–Mariën–Williamson–Şahinoğlu-Haegeman–Verstraete on two-dimensional topological order and anyons. In their work, they have a special projection called a projector matrix product operator. We prove that the range of this projection of lengthkis naturally identified with thekth higher relative commutant of the subfactor arising from the bi-unitary connection. This gives a further connection between two-dimensional topological order and subfactor theory.
We consider quantum information tasks in an operator algebraic setting, where we consider normal states on von Neumann algebras. In particular, we consider subfactors N ⊂ M \mathfrak {N} \subset \mathfrak {M} , that is, unital inclusions of von Neumann algebras with trivial center. One can ask the following question: given a normal state ω \omega on M \mathfrak {M} , how much can one learn by only doing measurements from N \mathfrak {N} ? We argue how the Jones index [ M : N ] [\mathfrak {M}:\mathfrak {N}] can be used to give a quantitative answer to this, showing how the rich theory of subfactors can be used in a quantum information context. As an example we discuss how the Jones index can be used in the context of wiretap channels. Subfactors also occur naturally in physics. Here we discuss two examples: rational conformal field theories and Kitaev’s toric code on the plane, a prototypical example of a topologically ordered model. There we can directly relate aspects of the general setting to physical properties such as the quantum dimension of the excitations. In the example of the toric code we also show how we can calculate the index via an approximation with finite dimensional systems. This explicit construction sheds more light on the connection between topological order and the Jones index.
We present a method of extracting information about topological order from the ground state of a strongly correlated two-dimensional system represented by an infinite projected entangled pair state (iPEPS). As in previous works [A. Francuz et al., Phys. Rev. B 101, 041108(R) (2020) and A. Francuz and J. Dziarmaga, Phys. Rev. B 102, 235112 (2020)] we begin by determining symmetries of the iPEPS represented by infinite matrix product operators (iMPO) that map between the different iPEPS transfer matrix fixed points, to which we apply the fundamental theorem of matrix product states to find zipper tensors between products of iMPO's that encode fusion properties of the anyons. The zippers can be combined to extract topological FFF symbols of the underlying fusion category, which unequivocally identifies the topological order of the ground state. We bring the FFF symbols to the canonical gauge, and also compute the Drinfeld center of this unitary fusion category to extract the topological SSS and TTT matrices encoding mutual statistics and self-statistics of the emergent anyons. The algorithm is applied to Abelian toric code, Kitaev model, double semion, and twisted quantum double of Z3{Z}_{3}Z3​, as well as to non-Abelian double Fibonacci, double Ising, and quantum double of S3{S}_{3}S3​ and Rep(S3)\mathrm{Rep}({S}_{3})Rep(S3​) string-net models.
Understanding many-body quantum systems is one of the most challenging problems in contemporary condensed-matter physics. Tensor network representation of quantum states and operators are taking central stage in this pursuit and beyond. They prove to be a powerful numerical and conceptual tool, and indeed a new language altogether. This thesis investigates various aspects of these representations by focusing on two specific problems: the first half of the thesis is devoted to examining how 'stable' a tensor network representation is for two-dimensional quantum states with topological order, and the second half explores the representability of various unitary loop operators with tensor networks. In the numerical usage of the tensor networks, the tensor is varied as to find the representation of the ground states of the given Hamiltonian. In chapter two and three of this thesis we show that such a numerical program for topological phases can be 'ill-posed'. We show that tensor network can be an unstable representation for a topological phase: even an infinitesimal variation in the representation results in the loss of topological order, completely or partially. We diagnose this problem by identifying the exact causes of this instability, and find that it is only tensor variations in certain directions that result in instability, because they result in the condensation of bosonic quasi-particles of the phase. Such unstable variations are characterized by two properties: (1) they can replace a tensor in the tensor network without making the network collapse, and (2) their presence in the network represents the presence of a non-trivial topological charge. We prove that the general tensor representation of all string-net models suffer with such instabilities. We propose an exact mathematical operator to project out all such unstable variations and show its efficacy for a few models by direct calculations. Such an operator can be useful in numerical programs involving such tensor representations. We also point out that such variations play a crucial role in simulating topological phase transitions and their presence can be vital in an accurate simulation. In chapter four and five of this thesis we focus on the representability of unitary loop operators by tensor networks. Such operators not only provide an important tool in the study of dynamical process in one-dimensional systems, but also in understanding and classification of symmetry protected topological phases in two dimensions. To characterize all such operators, we find a necessary and sufficient condition for any loop tensor network operator of a given length to represent a unitary operator. In particular, it is shown that all unitary operators that map local operators to local operators (locality-preserving) can always be represented by a tensor network. Locality-preserving unitary loop operators are classified by a rational index called the GNVW index defined in Ref. [1] which measures how much information 'flows' along the loop. We define Rank-Ratio index for tensor network operators and show that it is completely equivalent to the GNVW index. Therefore, GNVW index of a unitary operator can be easily extracted from its tensor network representation. We find that, other than representing locality-preserving unitary maps, tensor networks can also represent unitary operators that map local operators to global (non-local) operators. These tensor network operators are found to have a long-ranged order similar to tensors that represent topological tensor network states in two dimensions.