arXiv:2611.02219
What is the connection between quantum relationality and symmetry-based relationality?
Emily Adlam
Abstract
Although it has often been noted that both quantum mechanics and relativistic physics involve significant forms of relationality, the nature of the connection remains unclear. In addressing such a question it makes sense to start from the simplest possibility, so in this article I set out to consider the viability of the hypothesis that the two types of relationality are ultimately the same: that is, quantum states always characterize degrees of freedom which can be changed by a symmetry transformation, so they are relativized for exactly the same reason as partial observables in general relativity. I use the idea that we only measure partial observables to argue that this suggestion is compatible with all existing empirical evidence for quantum mechanics, and then I consider the consequences for ongoing debates about the nature of measurement in quantum mechanics.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether quantum-state relationality, motivated by Wigner’s-friend scenarios, can be identified with the relationality of symmetry-variant quantities in classical and relativistic physics. It explores the hypothesis that quantum states describe only partial observables, while symmetry-invariant complete observables do not enter coherent superpositions. The argument begins with spin and other symmetry-variant quantities, whose state assignments require physical reference systems. It reviews existing quantum-reference-frame machinery: group averaging produces invariant joint states, and a covariant-POVM relativization map constructs invariant joint observables from subsystem operators. For increasingly localized reference states, their expectation values approach ordinary subsystem quantum predictions. The paper uses this framework’s notion of mutual coherence to argue that relative subsystem states can exhibit coherence without coherence between the corresponding invariant alternatives. To extend the proposal beyond quantities variant under global symmetries, it argues that laboratory measurements always concern partial observables, including quantities specified relative to a laboratory clock. Diffeomorphism symmetry is invoked to address apparent counterexamples such as electron–nucleus separation. It then proposes that measurement couples variant quantities to invariant outcomes, and that such couplings need not obey universal linear evolution. Apparent collapse is interpreted as a breakdown of describing a subsystem independently of its interacting reference. The conclusions are conceptual rather than a new dynamical model. Extension of the cited formalism to diffeomorphism symmetry remains open, and no explicit variant–invariant coupling or quantitative collapse law is supplied. The paper presents compatibility with existing evidence as conditional on its account of partial observables, not as a demonstrated empirical equivalence.
Central claim may not hold: The empirical-compatibility argument relies essentially on diffeomorphism symmetry, but the paper explicitly leaves extension of its supporting formalism to that symmetry unresolved. The paper overinterprets symmetry invariance as support for nonquantum complete observables, although invariant sectors can contain experimentally distinguishable coherent superpositions. The proposed nonlinear measurement mechanism has no specified dynamics or derived outcome probabilities, so its empirical compatibility remains unestablished. The claim that variant–invariant recording requires nonlinear dynamics is incorrect because a linear, symmetry-respecting interaction can record an invariant relative observable when the reference is included. The hydrogen ground-state wavefunction has an erroneous positive exponential and is nonnormalizable as printed.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.