Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.00987

Melting noncoplanar order on the square-kagome lattice: Chiral, flat-band, and staggered spin liquids from projective symmetry

Harsh Raj, Atanu Maity, Yasir Iqbal

Published Oct 31, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Noncoplanar magnetic orders carry a scalar spin chirality, and their melting by quantum fluctuations has been proposed as a route to chiral spin liquids. We ask what this route can produce on the square-kagome lattice, where couplings across the octagons stabilize noncoplanar cuboc and conical orders. We classify the fermionic spin liquids of this lattice by their projective symmetry groups, identify the symmetry class into which each noncoplanar order would melt, and compare candidate states with Gutzwiller-projected wave functions. A magnetic selection rule constrains the route: the chirality of every cuboc and conical order alternates in space, so a liquid that keeps the symmetry of its parent order has zero Chern number and no spontaneous thermal Hall response. A Chern state can descend only from uniformly chiral orders, and the regular ones we find need ferromagnetic bow-tie couplings. The energetics do not favor a chiral liquid either: among the projected wave functions we compare, a cuboc1-ordered state is lowest for strong cross-octagon couplings, and nonchiral states, a valence-bond crystal or a time-reversal-symmetric liquid, for weaker ones. The two inequivalent site orbits shape the spinons: a relative time-reversal sign between them pins flat bands to the Fermi level, and because the translations of $p4mm$ are not commutators, staggered chiral liquids exist, which are absent on sixfold-symmetric lattices.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.00987

Related papers

Emergence of chiral spin liquids via quantum melting of noncoplanar magnetic orders

Ciarán Hickey, Łukasz Cincio, Zlatko Papić +1 more

Quantum spin liquids (QSLs) are highly entangled states of quantum magnets which lie beyond the Landau paradigm of classifying phases of matter via broken symmetries. A physical route to arriving at QSLs is via frustration-induced quantum melting of ordered states such as valence bond crystals or magnetic orders. Here we show, using extensive exact diagonalization (ED) and density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) studies of concrete $SU(2)$ invariant spin models on honeycomb, triangular, and square lattices, that chiral spin liquids (CSLs) emerge as descendants of triple-$Q$ spin crystals with tetrahedral magnetic order and a large scalar spin chirality. Such ordered-to-CSL melting transitions may yield lattice realizations of effective Chern-Simons-Higgs field theories. Our work provides a distinct unifying perspective on the emergence of CSLs and suggests that materials with certain noncoplanar magnetic orders might provide a good starting point to search for CSLs.

arXiv:1705.05381•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 11, 2017•47 citations

Global phase diagram of competing ordered and quantum spin-liquid phases on the kagome lattice

Shou-Shu Gong, Wei Kang Zhu, Leon Balents +1 more

We study the quantum phase diagram of the spin-$1/2$ Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice with first-, second-, and third-neighbor interactions ${J}_{1},{J}_{2}$, and ${J}_{3}$ by means of density matrix renormalization group. For small ${J}_{2}$ and ${J}_{3}$, this model sustains a time-reversal invariant quantum spin-liquid phase. With increasing ${J}_{2}$ and ${J}_{3}$, we find in addition a $q=(0,0)$ N\'eel phase, a chiral spin-liquid phase, an apparent valence-bond crystal phase, and a complex noncoplanar magnetically ordered state with spins forming the vertices of a cuboctahedron known as a cuboc1 phase. Both the chiral spin liquid and cuboc1 phase break time-reversal symmetry in the sense of spontaneous scalar spin chirality. We show that the chiralities in the chiral spin liquid and cuboc1 are distinct, and that these two states are separated by a strong first-order phase transition. The transitions from the chiral spin liquid to both the $q=(0,0)$ phase and to time-reversal symmetric spin liquid, however, are consistent with continuous quantum phase transitions.

arXiv:1412.1571•Physical Review B•Feb 17, 2015•170 citations

Chiral broken symmetry descendants of the kagome lattice chiral spin liquid

Anjishnu Bose, Arijit Haldar, Erik Schwartz Sørensen +1 more

The breaking of chiral and time-reversal symmetries provides a pathway to exotic quantum phenomena and topological phases. Recent work has extensively explored the resulting emergence of chiral charge orders and chiral spin liquids (CSLs) on the kagome lattice. Such CSLs are closely tied to bosonic fractional quantum Hall states with anyonic quasiparticles; however, their connection to nearby ordered states has remained a mystery. Here, we use spin-wave theory, parton Gutzwiller wave functions, and exact diagonalization to show that two distinct magnetic orders with uniform scalar chirality---the XYZ umbrella state and the octahedral spin crystal--emerge as competing orders in close proximity to the CSL. In this letter, we highlight the intimate link between a topologically ordered liquid and broken symmetry states with nontrivial real-space topology.

arXiv:2204.10329•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 25, 2023•10 citations

Kitaev, semi-Dirac, and spinon quantum spin Hall liquids on the square-hexagon-dodecagon lattice: A parent projective symmetry group classification

Harsh Raj, Yasir Iqbal

The square-hexagon-dodecagon (SHD) lattice hosts an exactly solvable Kitaev spin liquid, while further-neighbor couplings frustrate its Heisenberg magnet into classically degenerate lines where quantum fluctuations can melt the Néel order. To place this state among the lattice's spin liquids, we classify fermionic parton mean-field states with singlet and spin-orbit-coupled triplet amplitudes by their projective symmetry groups (PSGs). As SHD sites lack site symmetry, its $Z_2$ PSGs are the projective classes of $p6mm$ with time reversal, from which those of every single-orbit $p6mm$ lattice follow. In the idealized Kitaev model, where lattice operations do not rotate spins, these liquids carry a single $Z_2$ PSG descending from the $SU(2)$ Lieb-flux state, and their projections are exact eigenstates. The PSG's sixfold-rotation sign, fixed by the dodecagon flux, doubles all Majorana bands, and the mirrors exclude a chiral phase in any uniform field, so only a sublattice-staggered three-spin term drives the non-Abelian Ising phase. Beyond the Kitaev state, we find a critical semi-Dirac spin liquid, with mean-field correlations $\propto r^{-3}$ along three directions and $r^{-6}$ otherwise, and extended Dirac phases with up to $48$ fermion flavors, among them an $N_f=12$ state whose PSG forbids every singlet mass. Out-of-plane Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya couplings gap the Dirac states of its $U(1)$ class into a mean-field spinon counterpart of the Kane-Mele quantum spin Hall insulator, with spin Chern number $1$ or $3$ and spin-carrying monopoles. Chiral states imply Kalmeyer-Laughlin, semion$\times$semion, and three-fermion orders, rotation-breaking ones show $q\to -q$ asymmetric neutron spectra, and sign-alternating fluxes break time reversal alone. Masses and monopoles in these many-flavor phases and the energetics of frustrated SHD Heisenberg models are natural next steps.

arXiv:2610.22965•Oct 16, 2026•2 citations

Projective symmetry group classification of chiral spin liquids

Samuel Bieri, C. Lhuillier, Laura Messio

We present a general review of the projective symmetry group classification of fermionic quantum spin liquids for lattice models of spin $S=1/2$. We then introduce a systematic generalization of the approach for symmetric ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ quantum spin liquids to the one of chiral phases (i.e., singlet states that break time reversal and lattice reflection, but conserve their product). We apply this framework to classify and discuss possible chiral spin liquids on triangular and kagome lattices. We give a detailed prescription on how to construct quadratic spinon Hamiltonians and microscopic wave functions for each representation class on these lattices. Among the chiral ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ states, we study the subset of U(1) phases variationally in the antiferromagnetic ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{d}$ Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice. We discuss static spin structure factors and symmetry constraints on the bulk spectra of these phases.

arXiv:1512.00324•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 30, 2016•107 citations

Emergent quasi-one-dimensionality in a kagome magnet: A simple route to complexity

Shou-Shu Gong, Wei Kang Zhu, Kun Yang +3 more

We study the ground-state phase diagram of the quantum $\text{spin-}1/2$ Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice with first- $({J}_{1}<0)$, second- $({J}_{2}<0)$, and third-neighbor interactions $({J}_{d}>0)$ by means of analytical low-energy field theory and numerical density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) studies. The results offer a consistent picture of the ${J}_{d}\text{-dominant}$ regime in terms of three sets of spin chains weakly coupled by the ferromagnetic interchain interactions ${J}_{1,2}$. When either ${J}_{1}$ or ${J}_{2}$ is much stronger than the other one, the model is found to support one of two cuboctohedral phases, cuboc1, and cuboc2. These cuboc states host noncoplanar long-ranged magnetic order and possess finite scalar spin chirality. However, in the compensated regime ${J}_{1}\ensuremath{\simeq}{J}_{2}$, a valence bond crystal phase emerges between the two cuboc phases. We find excellent agreement between an analytical theory based on coupled spin chains and unbiased DMRG calculations, including at a very detailed level of comparison of the structure of the valence bond crystal state. To our knowledge, this is the first such comprehensive understanding of a highly frustrated two-dimensional quantum antiferromagnet. We find no evidence of either the one-dimensional gapless spin liquid or the chiral spin liquids, which were previously suggested by parton mean-field theories.

arXiv:1604.01459•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 27, 2016•27 citations
Noncoplanar magnetic orders carry a scalar spin chirality, and their melting by quantum fluctuations has been proposed as a route to chiral spin liquids. We ask what this route can produce on the square-kagome lattice, where couplings across the octagons stabilize noncoplanar cuboc and conical orders. We classify the fermionic spin liquids of this lattice by their projective symmetry groups, identify the symmetry class into which each noncoplanar order would melt, and compare candidate states with Gutzwiller-projected wave functions. A magnetic selection rule constrains the route: the chirality of every cuboc and conical order alternates in space, so a liquid that keeps the symmetry of its parent order has zero Chern number and no spontaneous thermal Hall response. A Chern state can descend only from uniformly chiral orders, and the regular ones we find need ferromagnetic bow-tie couplings. The energetics do not favor a chiral liquid either: among the projected wave functions we compare, a cuboc1-ordered state is lowest for strong cross-octagon couplings, and nonchiral states, a valence-bond crystal or a time-reversal-symmetric liquid, for weaker ones. The two inequivalent site orbits shape the spinons: a relative time-reversal sign between them pins flat bands to the Fermi level, and because the translations of p4mmp4mmp4mm are not commutators, staggered chiral liquids exist, which are absent on sixfold-symmetric lattices.
Quantum spin liquids (QSLs) are highly entangled states of quantum magnets which lie beyond the Landau paradigm of classifying phases of matter via broken symmetries. A physical route to arriving at QSLs is via frustration-induced quantum melting of ordered states such as valence bond crystals or magnetic orders. Here we show, using extensive exact diagonalization (ED) and density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) studies of concrete SU(2)SU(2)SU(2) invariant spin models on honeycomb, triangular, and square lattices, that chiral spin liquids (CSLs) emerge as descendants of triple-QQQ spin crystals with tetrahedral magnetic order and a large scalar spin chirality. Such ordered-to-CSL melting transitions may yield lattice realizations of effective Chern-Simons-Higgs field theories. Our work provides a distinct unifying perspective on the emergence of CSLs and suggests that materials with certain noncoplanar magnetic orders might provide a good starting point to search for CSLs.
We study the quantum phase diagram of the spin-1/21/21/2 Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice with first-, second-, and third-neighbor interactions J1,J2{J}_{1},{J}_{2}J1​,J2​, and J3{J}_{3}J3​ by means of density matrix renormalization group. For small J2{J}_{2}J2​ and J3{J}_{3}J3​, this model sustains a time-reversal invariant quantum spin-liquid phase. With increasing J2{J}_{2}J2​ and J3{J}_{3}J3​, we find in addition a q=(0,0)q=(0,0)q=(0,0) N\'eel phase, a chiral spin-liquid phase, an apparent valence-bond crystal phase, and a complex noncoplanar magnetically ordered state with spins forming the vertices of a cuboctahedron known as a cuboc1 phase. Both the chiral spin liquid and cuboc1 phase break time-reversal symmetry in the sense of spontaneous scalar spin chirality. We show that the chiralities in the chiral spin liquid and cuboc1 are distinct, and that these two states are separated by a strong first-order phase transition. The transitions from the chiral spin liquid to both the q=(0,0)q=(0,0)q=(0,0) phase and to time-reversal symmetric spin liquid, however, are consistent with continuous quantum phase transitions.
The breaking of chiral and time-reversal symmetries provides a pathway to exotic quantum phenomena and topological phases. Recent work has extensively explored the resulting emergence of chiral charge orders and chiral spin liquids (CSLs) on the kagome lattice. Such CSLs are closely tied to bosonic fractional quantum Hall states with anyonic quasiparticles; however, their connection to nearby ordered states has remained a mystery. Here, we use spin-wave theory, parton Gutzwiller wave functions, and exact diagonalization to show that two distinct magnetic orders with uniform scalar chirality---the XYZ umbrella state and the octahedral spin crystal--emerge as competing orders in close proximity to the CSL. In this letter, we highlight the intimate link between a topologically ordered liquid and broken symmetry states with nontrivial real-space topology.
The square-hexagon-dodecagon (SHD) lattice hosts an exactly solvable Kitaev spin liquid, while further-neighbor couplings frustrate its Heisenberg magnet into classically degenerate lines where quantum fluctuations can melt the Néel order. To place this state among the lattice's spin liquids, we classify fermionic parton mean-field states with singlet and spin-orbit-coupled triplet amplitudes by their projective symmetry groups (PSGs). As SHD sites lack site symmetry, its Z2Z_2Z2​ PSGs are the projective classes of p6mmp6mmp6mm with time reversal, from which those of every single-orbit p6mmp6mmp6mm lattice follow. In the idealized Kitaev model, where lattice operations do not rotate spins, these liquids carry a single Z2Z_2Z2​ PSG descending from the SU(2)SU(2)SU(2) Lieb-flux state, and their projections are exact eigenstates. The PSG's sixfold-rotation sign, fixed by the dodecagon flux, doubles all Majorana bands, and the mirrors exclude a chiral phase in any uniform field, so only a sublattice-staggered three-spin term drives the non-Abelian Ising phase. Beyond the Kitaev state, we find a critical semi-Dirac spin liquid, with mean-field correlations ∝r−3\propto r^{-3}∝r−3 along three directions and r−6r^{-6}r−6 otherwise, and extended Dirac phases with up to 484848 fermion flavors, among them an Nf=12N_f=12Nf​=12 state whose PSG forbids every singlet mass. Out-of-plane Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya couplings gap the Dirac states of its U(1)U(1)U(1) class into a mean-field spinon counterpart of the Kane-Mele quantum spin Hall insulator, with spin Chern number 111 or 333 and spin-carrying monopoles. Chiral states imply Kalmeyer-Laughlin, semion×\times×semion, and three-fermion orders, rotation-breaking ones show q→−qq\to -qq→−q asymmetric neutron spectra, and sign-alternating fluxes break time reversal alone. Masses and monopoles in these many-flavor phases and the energetics of frustrated SHD Heisenberg models are natural next steps.
We present a general review of the projective symmetry group classification of fermionic quantum spin liquids for lattice models of spin S=1/2S=1/2S=1/2. We then introduce a systematic generalization of the approach for symmetric Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ quantum spin liquids to the one of chiral phases (i.e., singlet states that break time reversal and lattice reflection, but conserve their product). We apply this framework to classify and discuss possible chiral spin liquids on triangular and kagome lattices. We give a detailed prescription on how to construct quadratic spinon Hamiltonians and microscopic wave functions for each representation class on these lattices. Among the chiral Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ states, we study the subset of U(1) phases variationally in the antiferromagnetic ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{d}$ Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice. We discuss static spin structure factors and symmetry constraints on the bulk spectra of these phases.
We study the ground-state phase diagram of the quantum spin-1/2\text{spin-}1/2spin-1/2 Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice with first- (J1<0)({J}_{1}<0)(J1​<0), second- (J2<0)({J}_{2}<0)(J2​<0), and third-neighbor interactions (Jd>0)({J}_{d}>0)(Jd​>0) by means of analytical low-energy field theory and numerical density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) studies. The results offer a consistent picture of the Jd-dominant{J}_{d}\text{-dominant}Jd​-dominant regime in terms of three sets of spin chains weakly coupled by the ferromagnetic interchain interactions J1,2{J}_{1,2}J1,2​. When either J1{J}_{1}J1​ or J2{J}_{2}J2​ is much stronger than the other one, the model is found to support one of two cuboctohedral phases, cuboc1, and cuboc2. These cuboc states host noncoplanar long-ranged magnetic order and possess finite scalar spin chirality. However, in the compensated regime ${J}_{1}\ensuremath{\simeq}{J}_{2}$, a valence bond crystal phase emerges between the two cuboc phases. We find excellent agreement between an analytical theory based on coupled spin chains and unbiased DMRG calculations, including at a very detailed level of comparison of the structure of the valence bond crystal state. To our knowledge, this is the first such comprehensive understanding of a highly frustrated two-dimensional quantum antiferromagnet. We find no evidence of either the one-dimensional gapless spin liquid or the chiral spin liquids, which were previously suggested by parton mean-field theories.