arXiv:2611.00902
Quantum Mpemba effect of Z2 symmetry restoration in the Dicke model
Dongni Chen, Wei Xiong, Peng-Cheng Li, Yee Sin Ang, Ching Hua Lee, Yi Qin
Abstract
We study a symmetry-restoration quantum Mpemba effect in the dissipative Dicke model as an example of a weakly $\mathbb Z_2$-symmetric open quantum system, where the full Liouvillian is parity covariant although individual quantum jumps connect the two Hilbert-space parity sectors. Using the entanglement-asymmetry (EA) diagnostic to monitor parity restoration, we compare coherent-product and cat-product initial states. Coherent-product states show conventional relaxation, with larger initial asymmetry decaying more slowly and no Mpemba crossing observed. Cat-product states, by contrast, can reverse this hierarchy over a finite region of initial-state space. This reversal is enabled by initial-state mode filtering: the cat-product superposition suppresses the contributions of the leading slow Liouvillian modes, allowing a more asymmetric state to restore parity through faster decay channels. Our results reveal that symmetry-restoration QME can arise even when parity is preserved only as a weak Liouvillian symmetry, with quantum jumps mixing the Hilbert-space parity sectors. The anomalous relaxation is governed by initial-state-dependent filtering of the leading slow Liouvillian modes, providing a mechanism for symmetry-restoration QME beyond strongly conserved symmetry sectors.
AI Summary
Can symmetry-restoration quantum Mpemba behavior occur when parity is only a weak Liouvillian symmetry, so quantum jumps mix Hilbert-space parity sectors? This paper studies that question in the dissipative Dicke model with cavity photon loss, comparing coherent cavity states and phase-controlled superpositions of parity-related coherent states, each initially coupled to fully polarized atoms. Parity restoration is tracked using the full-density-matrix second-Rényi asymmetry, $\mathrm{EA}=\ln[\mathrm{Tr}(\rho^2)/\mathrm{Tr}(\rho_P^2)]$. Numerical Lindblad evolution finds no crossings for the sampled coherent-product states, whereas cat-product states exhibit crossings: larger initial asymmetry can decay below smaller initial asymmetry. These inversions occupy a finite region of cat amplitude and phase space and occur at representative normal- and superradiant-regime couplings. Calculations use $N=10$ atoms and photon cutoff $n_p=20$, with convergence checked by increasing the cutoff. Biorthogonal Liouvillian decompositions associate the crossings with suppression of leading slow-mode overlaps. Normal-phase linear-fluctuation theory gives a coherent-state overlap proportional to $\alpha$, versus a cat-state overlap proportional to $|\sin\theta|\alpha e^{-2\alpha^2}/[1+\cos\theta e^{-2\alpha^2}]$ for real $\alpha$. The superradiant examples show more structured multiscale relaxation. Additional collective atomic decay smooths that structure without removing crossings over the tested rates $\gamma=0.05$–$0.2$. The results concern finite systems with a unique parity-symmetric steady state. The analytical overlap argument assumes small spin excitations around the normal state; superradiant dynamics are analyzed numerically. Experimental access through purity measurements is discussed, but extending such protocols to the full dissipative many-body density matrix remains a stated challenge.
Error found: The parameter-space analysis establishes instantaneous EA-order inversions, but does not establish their persistence for all later times as required by the paper’s formal QME definition. The claimed slow-mode-filtering mechanism in the superradiant regime lacks an initial-amplitude-dependent overlap analysis; the explicit numerical comparison and analytical derivation establish it only in the normal regime.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.