arXiv:2611.00255
Benchmarking Quantum Convolutional Neural Networks and their classical surrogates on long-range strongly correlated models
Tatiana A. Bespalova, Réka Schwengelbeck, Laura Mismetti, Johannes Schachenmayer, Ivano Tavernelli, Francesco Tacchino
Abstract
We benchmark quantum convolutional neural networks (QCNNs) and their classical surrogates for phase differentiation in one-dimensional strongly correlated systems with beyond-nearest-neighbour terms. Using an anisotropic Heisenberg spin chain and an extended $t$-$t'$ Fermi-Hubbard model as representative spin and fermionic testbeds, we train QCNN classifiers on labelled ground-state datasets and map out finite-size phase diagrams. In hybrid setups, we employ Pauli backpropagation to express the QCNN measurement as a weighted sum of Pauli-string expectation values to be evaluated directly on input states, and study how truncation parameters control the trade-off between approximation accuracy and the size of the resulting Pauli expansion. Robust convergence is achieved for the Heisenberg model under aggressive truncation, whereas the Fermi-Hubbard model requires substantially looser thresholds, resulting in a sharp growth in retained Pauli strings and evaluation cost. Our results contribute to charting where hybrid quantum-classical training is viable for learning strongly correlated quantum states, and provide practical guidance for choosing truncation regimes in Pauli backpropagation-based surrogates.
AI Summary
The paper asks when truncated Pauli-backpropagation surrogates can replace quantum convolutional neural network (QCNN) execution and training for phase classification of strongly correlated ground states. It benchmarks an anisotropic Heisenberg chain with next-nearest-neighbour exchange and a half-filled $t$–$t'$ Fermi–Hubbard chain, using exact-diagonalisation inputs and noiseless simulations at $N=8,12$ qubits (four and six Hubbard sites). QCNNs are trained on binary phase labels, typically using 27 ground states, with additional five-state training tests. The resulting maps qualitatively reproduce selected phase regions, although the six-site Hubbard system requires finite-size-adjusted labels rather than thermodynamic-limit labels. Backpropagating the output observable into a truncated Pauli expansion establishes accuracy–cost trade-offs through output deviations, classification disagreements, and retained-string counts. At fixed trained parameters, Pauli-weight cutoffs around six yield near-minimal classification disagreement in the studied settings. End-to-end surrogate optimisation is more model-dependent. For Heisenberg inputs, maximum Pauli weight four, frequency cutoff 40, and coefficient threshold $10^{-4}$ support convergence at both sizes; the more aggressive combination $(3,30,10^{-3})$ works at eight qubits but stalls at twelve. Hubbard training requires looser truncation and larger expansions. Jordan–Wigner nonlocality is proposed as a possible explanation, without an operator-level analysis. The study does not establish large-system scaling or include state-preparation errors or finite-shot training. Endpoint agreement is explicitly distinguished from trainability. Larger-system tests, alternative fermionic encodings, and interpretation of learned observables are left for future work.
Central claim may not hold: The supplied results do not explicitly document a successful relaxed-truncation Hubbard surrogate run with its convergence and Pauli count, and the table’s nearly untruncated rows explicitly are not surrogate-training runs. The paper does not report actual-circuit held-out performance at surrogate-trained parameters, leaving preservation of the QCNN classifier unverified by the reported surrogate training losses. The shot-cost formula equates a coefficient-discard threshold with measurement precision without accounting for coefficient-weighted accumulation of expectation-estimation errors.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 13 pages, 11 figures