Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.00233

Distance to integrability and complexity

Sean Casey, Marius de Leeuw, Tristan McLoughlin, Sergiy Zhuk

quant-phcond-mat.stat-mechcond-mat.str-elhep-thmath-phnlin.SISubmitted Oct 30, 2026• Announced Nov 3, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider nearest-neighbour interactions on spin-1/2 chains. We find the full set of integrable models of this form and apply a numerical algorithm to determine the "closest" integrable model for a given Hamiltonian. This allows us to define a model-independent distance to integrability. We show that standard measures of chaos interpolate between integrable and chaotic values with increasing values of this distance. However, there is a large variation across models and the distance to integrability provides additional information not directly provided by these diagnostics.

AI Summary

The paper asks how to quantify proximity to integrability without choosing a particular integrable Hamiltonian and perturbation direction. For translationally invariant nearest-neighbour spin-$1/2$ chains, it reports 12 integrable families obtained by solving $[Q_2,Q_3]=0$ within the regular Yang–Baxter/boost framework. It defines distance by minimising the full-chain Frobenius norm over these families and local $\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb R)$ similarity transformations. The normalisation $d_{\min}^2=\min_H\|M-H\|_F^2/(L2^L)$ removes chain-length dependence for traceless densities. Linear parameters are eliminated by least squares, leaving a three-parameter non-convex optimisation. A released dataset contains 200,000 random real-symmetric densities, normalised after removing identity and telescoping terms. For $L=16$, spectral-spacing ratios and eigenstate Shannon entropies show average crossovers towards chaotic values as distance increases, but substantial model-to-model variation. At $d_{\min}\gtrsim0.07$, more than half the sampled models have mean adjacent-gap ratio above $0.459$, halfway between Poisson and GOE values. A minimised charge-commutator residual correlates with distance but is not a reliable proxy. Optimising the first three Lanczos coefficients over one- and two-site seed operators shows that proximity to integrability permits both slower and faster early-time operator growth, rather than uniformly suppressing it. The numerical study is restricted to real-symmetric inputs; the closest integrable model need not be symmetric. The spectral crossover depends on system size, distance depends on the chosen norm, and the higher-Lanczos-coefficient optimisations use heuristic global searches. Complex-Hermitian inputs and family-resolved analysis remain open extensions.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsStrong assumptions

Central claim may not hold: The 12 listed families and real local similarities omit the real symmetric integrable XYZ density XX + 3YY + 2ZZ, invalidating completeness even within the sampled real domain. The search is restricted to real densities and real local similarities, so it does not establish the abstract's unrestricted classification. Because non-symmetric candidates are allowed, the reported distance is not established as a distance to the nearest physical Hermitian integrable Hamiltonian. The numerical optimisation lacks a demonstrated global-optimality guarantee, so the reported minima remain uncertified even over the listed search space.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
8 pages, 4 figures

Related papers

Integrability test for spin chains

Marek Grabowski, Pierre Mathieu

We examine a simple heuristic test of integrability for quantum chains. This test is applied to a variety of systems, including isotropic spin-1 models with nearest-neighbour interaction, Potts-type, inhomogeneous spin- 1/2 chains, and a multiparameter family of spin- 1/2 models generalizing the XYZ chain, with next-to-nearest neighbour interactions and bond alternation. Within the latter family we determine all the integrable models with an o(2) symmetry.

arXiv:hep-th/9412039•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Sep 7, 1995•77 citations

Investigation of Quantum Chaos in Local and Non-local Ising Models

Reza Pirmoradian, Maryam Teymouri, Elham Sadoogh +3 more

Time New Roman 10 We investigate signatures of quantum chaos within Ising spin chains subjected to transverse and longitudinal fields, incorporating both local (nearest-neighbor) and non-local (long-range) couplings. While local Ising models may exhibit integrable or chaotic dynamics contingent on interaction strengths and field parameters, systems with non-local interactions generally display a stronger propensity toward chaos, even when the non-local couplings are weak. By examining the distribution of energy level spacings through the level spacing ratio, we delineate the transition from integrable to chaotic regimes and characterize the emergence of quantum chaos in these systems. Our analysis demonstrates that non-local couplings facilitate faster operator spreading and more intricate dynamical behavior, enabling these systems to approach maximal chaos more readily than their local counterparts. Additionally, we analyze Krylov complexity as a dynamical probe of chaos, observing a characteristic peak followed by a plateau at late times in chaotic regimes. This behavior provides a quantitative means to distinguish between integrable and chaotic phases, with the growth rate and saturation level of the complexity serving as effective indicators. Our findings underscore the role of non-local interactions in accelerating the onset of chaos and modifying dynamical complexity in quantum spin chains.

•Jul 24, 2025•0 citations

Interaction distance in the extended XXZ model

Kristian Patrick, Vincent Caudrelier, Zlatko Papić +1 more

We employ the interaction distance to characterize the physics of a one-dimensional extended XXZ spin model, whose phase diagram consists of both integrable and nonintegrable regimes, with various types of ordering, e.g., a gapless Luttinger liquid and gapped crystalline phases. We numerically demonstrate that the interaction distance successfully reveals the known behavior of the model in its integrable regime. As an additional diagnostic tool, we introduce the notion of ``integrability distance'' and particularize it to the XXZ model to quantity how far the ground state of the extended XXZ model is from being integrable. This distance provides insight into the properties of the gapless Luttinger liquid phase in the presence of next-nearest-neighbor spin interactions which break integrability.

arXiv:1905.07239•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 18, 2019•7 citations

Spread and spectral complexity in quantum spin chains: from integrability to chaos

Hugo A. Camargo, Kyoung-Bum Huh, Viktor Jahnke +3 more

A bstract We explore spread and spectral complexity in quantum systems that exhibit a transition from integrability to chaos, namely the mixed-field Ising model and the next-to-nearest-neighbor deformation of the Heisenberg XXZ spin chain. We corroborate the observation that the presence of a peak in spread complexity before its saturation, is a characteristic feature in chaotic systems. We find that, in general, the saturation value of spread complexity post-peak depends not only on the spectral statistics of the Hamiltonian, but also on the specific state. However, there appears to be a maximal universal bound determined by the symmetries and dimension of the Hamiltonian, which is realized by the thermofield double state (TFD) at infinite temperature. We also find that the time scales at which the spread complexity and spectral form factor change their behaviour agree with each other and are independent of the chaotic properties of the systems. In the case of spectral complexity, we identify that the key factor determining its saturation value and timescale in chaotic systems is given by minimum energy difference in the theory’s spectrum. This explains observations made in the literature regarding its earlier saturation in chaotic systems compared to their integrable counterparts. We conclude by discussing the properties of the TFD which, we conjecture, make it suitable for probing signatures of chaos in quantum many-body systems.

arXiv:2405.11254•Journal of High Energy Physics•Aug 30, 2024•58 citations

Probing weak chaos in $\mathcal N=4$ super Yang-Mills and long-range spin chains

Pawel Caputa, Brian Creed, Rathindra Nath Das +2 more

We study signatures of quantum chaos in finite-loop truncations of the planar dilatation operator in the $\mathfrak{su}(2)$ sector of $\mathcal N=4$ super Yang-Mills and its $β$-deformation. These truncations define holographically motivated long-range deformations of the nearest-neighbour XXX spin chain. At one-loop the model is integrable, while the all-loop planar theory is expected to again be integrable. Finite-loop truncations therefore provide a natural setting for investigating how chaotic behaviour emerges between these two integrable limits. We analyse this question using spectral statistics, eigenvector diagnostics and spread complexity. We find that the two- and four-loop truncations develop GOE-like level statistics at sufficiently large coupling but with features characteristic of weak integrability breaking. The integrability breaking at four-loops is weaker than at two-loops and the critical coupling at which chaos occurs is larger, at least for long spin chains. The three-loop truncation does not show the same onset of chaos in the range studied. Eigenvector diagnostics show that the corresponding eigenstates remain less random than GOE vectors, indicating weak ergodicity and multifractality. Finally, we can identify signatures of the eigenvalue and eigenvector chaos in the Krylov-space data. Namely, we demonstrate a correlation of the level spacing statistics with the peak of spread complexity and disorder on the Krylov chain. The delocalisation of the initial state in the Hamiltonian eigenbasis is shown to strongly affect the saturation of complexity. Our results suggest that finite-loop dilatation operators are not generic long-range spin chain Hamiltonians, but already display patterns consistent with the restoration of integrability in the all-loop planar theory.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2606.18351•Jun 18, 2026•2 citations

Krylov complexity for nonlocal spin chains

Aranya Bhattacharya, Pingal Pratyush Nath, Himanshu Sahu

Building upon recent research in spin systems with nonlocal interactions, this study investigates operator growth using the Krylov complexity in different nonlocal versions of the Ising model. We find that the nonlocality results in a faster scrambling of the operator to all sites. While the saturation value of Krylov complexity of local integrable and local chaotic theories differ by a significant margin, this difference is much suppressed when nonlocal terms are introduced in both regimes. This results from the faster scrambling of information in the presence of nonlocality. In addition, we investigate the behavior of level statistics and spectral form factor as probes of quantum chaos to study the integrability breaking due to nonlocal interactions. Our numerics indicate that in the nonlocal case, late time saturation of Krylov complexity distinguishes between different underlying theories, while the early time complexity growth distinguishes different degrees of nonlocality.

arXiv:2312.11677•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Mar 11, 2024•29 citations
We consider nearest-neighbour interactions on spin-1/2 chains. We find the full set of integrable models of this form and apply a numerical algorithm to determine the "closest" integrable model for a given Hamiltonian. This allows us to define a model-independent distance to integrability. We show that standard measures of chaos interpolate between integrable and chaotic values with increasing values of this distance. However, there is a large variation across models and the distance to integrability provides additional information not directly provided by these diagnostics.
The paper asks how to quantify proximity to integrability without choosing a particular integrable Hamiltonian and perturbation direction. For translationally invariant nearest-neighbour spin-1/21/21/2 chains, it reports 12 integrable families obtained by solving [Q2,Q3]=0[Q_2,Q_3]=0[Q2​,Q3​]=0 within the regular Yang–Baxter/boost framework.
It defines distance by minimising the full-chain Frobenius norm over these families and local SL(2,R)\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb R)SL(2,R) similarity transformations. The normalisation dmin⁡2=min⁡H∥M−H∥F2/(L2L)d_{\min}^2=\min_H\|M-H\|_F^2/(L2^L)dmin2​=minH​∥M−H∥F2​/(L2L) removes chain-length dependence for traceless densities. Linear parameters are eliminated by least squares, leaving a three-parameter non-convex optimisation. A released dataset contains 200,000 random real-symmetric densities, normalised after removing identity and telescoping terms.
For L=16L=16L=16, spectral-spacing ratios and eigenstate Shannon entropies show average crossovers towards chaotic values as distance increases, but substantial model-to-model variation. At dmin⁡≳0.07d_{\min}\gtrsim0.07dmin​≳0.07, more than half the sampled models have mean adjacent-gap ratio above 0.4590.4590.459, halfway between Poisson and GOE values. A minimised charge-commutator residual correlates with distance but is not a reliable proxy. Optimising the first three Lanczos coefficients over one- and two-site seed operators shows that proximity to integrability permits both slower and faster early-time operator growth, rather than uniformly suppressing it.
The numerical study is restricted to real-symmetric inputs; the closest integrable model need not be symmetric. The spectral crossover depends on system size, distance depends on the chosen norm, and the higher-Lanczos-coefficient optimisations use heuristic global searches. Complex-Hermitian inputs and family-resolved analysis remain open extensions.
Time New Roman 10 We investigate signatures of quantum chaos within Ising spin chains subjected to transverse and longitudinal fields, incorporating both local (nearest-neighbor) and non-local (long-range) couplings. While local Ising models may exhibit integrable or chaotic dynamics contingent on interaction strengths and field parameters, systems with non-local interactions generally display a stronger propensity toward chaos, even when the non-local couplings are weak. By examining the distribution of energy level spacings through the level spacing ratio, we delineate the transition from integrable to chaotic regimes and characterize the emergence of quantum chaos in these systems. Our analysis demonstrates that non-local couplings facilitate faster operator spreading and more intricate dynamical behavior, enabling these systems to approach maximal chaos more readily than their local counterparts. Additionally, we analyze Krylov complexity as a dynamical probe of chaos, observing a characteristic peak followed by a plateau at late times in chaotic regimes. This behavior provides a quantitative means to distinguish between integrable and chaotic phases, with the growth rate and saturation level of the complexity serving as effective indicators. Our findings underscore the role of non-local interactions in accelerating the onset of chaos and modifying dynamical complexity in quantum spin chains.
We employ the interaction distance to characterize the physics of a one-dimensional extended XXZ spin model, whose phase diagram consists of both integrable and nonintegrable regimes, with various types of ordering, e.g., a gapless Luttinger liquid and gapped crystalline phases. We numerically demonstrate that the interaction distance successfully reveals the known behavior of the model in its integrable regime. As an additional diagnostic tool, we introduce the notion of ``integrability distance'' and particularize it to the XXZ model to quantity how far the ground state of the extended XXZ model is from being integrable. This distance provides insight into the properties of the gapless Luttinger liquid phase in the presence of next-nearest-neighbor spin interactions which break integrability.
A bstract We explore spread and spectral complexity in quantum systems that exhibit a transition from integrability to chaos, namely the mixed-field Ising model and the next-to-nearest-neighbor deformation of the Heisenberg XXZ spin chain. We corroborate the observation that the presence of a peak in spread complexity before its saturation, is a characteristic feature in chaotic systems. We find that, in general, the saturation value of spread complexity post-peak depends not only on the spectral statistics of the Hamiltonian, but also on the specific state. However, there appears to be a maximal universal bound determined by the symmetries and dimension of the Hamiltonian, which is realized by the thermofield double state (TFD) at infinite temperature. We also find that the time scales at which the spread complexity and spectral form factor change their behaviour agree with each other and are independent of the chaotic properties of the systems. In the case of spectral complexity, we identify that the key factor determining its saturation value and timescale in chaotic systems is given by minimum energy difference in the theory’s spectrum. This explains observations made in the literature regarding its earlier saturation in chaotic systems compared to their integrable counterparts. We conclude by discussing the properties of the TFD which, we conjecture, make it suitable for probing signatures of chaos in quantum many-body systems.
Probing weak chaos in N=4\mathcal N=4N=4 super Yang-Mills and long-range spin chains
We study signatures of quantum chaos in finite-loop truncations of the planar dilatation operator in the su(2)\mathfrak{su}(2)su(2) sector of N=4\mathcal N=4N=4 super Yang-Mills and its βββ-deformation. These truncations define holographically motivated long-range deformations of the nearest-neighbour XXX spin chain. At one-loop the model is integrable, while the all-loop planar theory is expected to again be integrable. Finite-loop truncations therefore provide a natural setting for investigating how chaotic behaviour emerges between these two integrable limits. We analyse this question using spectral statistics, eigenvector diagnostics and spread complexity. We find that the two- and four-loop truncations develop GOE-like level statistics at sufficiently large coupling but with features characteristic of weak integrability breaking. The integrability breaking at four-loops is weaker than at two-loops and the critical coupling at which chaos occurs is larger, at least for long spin chains. The three-loop truncation does not show the same onset of chaos in the range studied. Eigenvector diagnostics show that the corresponding eigenstates remain less random than GOE vectors, indicating weak ergodicity and multifractality. Finally, we can identify signatures of the eigenvalue and eigenvector chaos in the Krylov-space data. Namely, we demonstrate a correlation of the level spacing statistics with the peak of spread complexity and disorder on the Krylov chain. The delocalisation of the initial state in the Hamiltonian eigenbasis is shown to strongly affect the saturation of complexity. Our results suggest that finite-loop dilatation operators are not generic long-range spin chain Hamiltonians, but already display patterns consistent with the restoration of integrability in the all-loop planar theory.
Building upon recent research in spin systems with nonlocal interactions, this study investigates operator growth using the Krylov complexity in different nonlocal versions of the Ising model. We find that the nonlocality results in a faster scrambling of the operator to all sites. While the saturation value of Krylov complexity of local integrable and local chaotic theories differ by a significant margin, this difference is much suppressed when nonlocal terms are introduced in both regimes. This results from the faster scrambling of information in the presence of nonlocality. In addition, we investigate the behavior of level statistics and spectral form factor as probes of quantum chaos to study the integrability breaking due to nonlocal interactions. Our numerics indicate that in the nonlocal case, late time saturation of Krylov complexity distinguishes between different underlying theories, while the early time complexity growth distinguishes different degrees of nonlocality.