We present the correspondence between symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases and their anomalous boundary states, based on examples in various spacetime dimensions. Through the study of the effect of interactions on these SPT phases, we discovered a new formalism of quantum anomalies, associated with discrete spacetime (such as time-reversal and spatial reflection) symmetries in particular, to classify distinct interacting topological phases. An example is the Z2 classification of the (2+1)d topological insulator protected by charge U(1) and time-reversal (or CP) symmetries, which can be deduced by the form of the global U(1) gauge anomalies on its edge theories defined on closed unorientable manifolds. In this case, the nontrivial phase (in free systems) is robust against electron interactions. Another example is the (3+1)d topological superconductor protected by only time-reversal or reflection symmetry. For this system, we identified the bulk phase by studying the global gravitational anomalies of the surface theories formulated on unorientable spacetime manifolds, and also discussed its connection to the collapse of the non-interacting classification by an integer Z to Z16, in the presence of interactions. We also revisit the problem of gauging a discrete internal symmetry in theories of chiral (Weyl) fermions in 3+1 dimensions – which have not been fully understood so far – from the perspective of fermionic SPT phases in 4+1 dimensions. Comparing with the previous results, we give a complete answer for the anomalies constraints on the discrete symmetry, as our approach is based on purely geometrical considerations, namely, our assumption is more fundamental and general. Furthermore, our result also provides an understanding of gapped states of fermions with anomalous discrete symmetries, and we present a model, based on weak coupling, for constructing these anomalous gapped states.
Symmetry acting on a (2+1) D D topological order can be anomalous in the sense that they possess an obstruction to being realized as a purely (2+1) D D on-site symmetry. In this paper, we develop a (3+1) D D topological quantum field theory to calculate the anomaly indicators of a (2+1) D D topological order with a general symmetry group G G , which may be discrete or continuous, Abelian or non-Abelian, contain anti-unitary elements or not, and permute anyons or not. These anomaly indicators are partition functions of the (3+1) D D topological quantum field theory on a specific manifold equipped with some G G -bundle, and they are expressed using the data characterizing the topological order and the symmetry actions. Our framework is applied to derive the anomaly indicators for various symmetry groups, including \mathbb{Z}_2\times\mathbb{Z}_2 ℤ 2 × ℤ 2 , \mathbb{Z}_2^T\times\mathbb{Z}_2^T ℤ 2 T × ℤ 2 T , SO(N) S O ( N ) , O(N)^T O ( N ) T , SO(N)\times \mathbb{Z}_2^T S O ( N ) × ℤ 2 T , etc, where \mathbb{Z}_2 ℤ 2 and \mathbb{Z}_2^T ℤ 2 T denote a unitary and anti-unitary order-2 group, respectively, and <
Edge theories of symmetry-protected topological phases are well known to possess global symmetry anomalies. In this Letter we focus on two-dimensional bosonic phases protected by an on-site symmetry and analyze the corresponding edge anomalies in more detail. Physical interpretations of the anomaly in terms of an obstruction to orbifolding and constructing symmetry-preserving boundaries are connected to the cohomology classification of symmetry-protected phases in two dimensions. Using the tensor network and matrix product state formalism we numerically illustrate our arguments and discuss computational detection schemes to identify symmetry-protected order in a ground state wave function.
In a previous work we conjectured that the multi-invariants of the ground state of a gapped
(d−1)+1-dimensional system, labeled by bipartite
(d+1)-edge-colored graphs encoding closed oriented
d-manifolds
M, compute the partition functions
Z(M) of the low energy topological quantum field theory (TQFT), up to non-universal factors determined by the local structure of the triangulation. In this paper we determine which combinations of partition functions can be isolated from the non-universal factors. The answer is governed by oriented bordism. If
M is null-bordant,
Z(M) is obtained from an explicit, state-independent finite family of multi-invariants, up to a power of
Z(Sd) which is fixed to be
Z(Sd)χ(M)/2 for even
d and can be removed for odd
d. Conversely, the obstruction is measured by a quotient of the group of "residues" of colored graphs which receives a surjective map from the oriented bordism group, with kernel precisely the torsion subgroup as far as smooth manifolds are concerned. In
d=4 the obstruction is the signature:
Z(M)/Z(S4)χ(M)/2 can be extracted if and only if
σ(M)=0. This is due to the fact that the first Pontryagin class
p1 has a local expression and thus
eiθσ(M)=e3iθ∫Mp1 cannot be separated from the non-universal factors. Torsion invariants, in contrast, are not obstructed: for the ground state of the
4+1-dimensional invertible phase with partition function
(−1)∫w2w3 we compute the multi-invariants exactly, and two graphs with identical local data, encoding the Dold manifold and
CP2×S1, give opposite signs.
By definition, the physics of the
d-dimensional (dim) boundary of a
(d+1)-dim symmetry protected topological (SPT) state cannot be realized as itself on a
d-dim lattice. If the symmetry of the system is unitary, then a formal way to determine whether a
d-dim theory must be a boundary or not, is to couple this theory to a gauge field (or to ``gauge'' its symmetry), and check if there is a gauge anomaly. In this paper we discuss the following question: Can the boundary of a SPT state be driven into a fully gapped topological order which preserves all the symmetries? We argue (conjecture) that if the gauge anomaly of the boundary is ``perturbative,'' then the boundary must remain gapless; while if the boundary only has global gauge anomaly but no perturbative anomaly, then it is possible to gap out the boundary by driving it into a topological state, when $d\ensuremath{\ge}2$. We will demonstrate this conjecture with two examples: (1) the
3d spin-1/2 chiral fermion with the well-known Witten's global anomaly [Phys. Lett. 117, 324 (1982)], which can be realized on the boundary of a
4d topological superconductor with SU(2) or $U(1)\ensuremath{\rtimes}{Z}_{2}$ symmetry; and (2) the
4d boundary of a
5d topological superconductor with the same symmetry. We show that these boundary systems can be driven into a fully gapped
Z2N topological order with topological degeneracy, but this
Z2N topological order cannot be future driven into a trivial confined phase that preserves all the symmetries due to some special properties of its topological defects. Our study also leads to exotic states of matter in pure
3d space.
We present a systematic treatment of entanglement in two-dimensional topological quantum field theories (TQFTs). Our approach clarifies the sensitivity of entanglement measures to the cutting maps that implement Hilbert space factorization. Such maps embed the TQFT Hilbert space into a description with potentially more degrees of freedom, and for entanglement to be well defined they must be isometric, i.e., they must preserve the norms of all states. We show that the naïve cutting map based solely upon path integration subject to boundary conditions is not isometric for generic TQFTs. For any 2d TQFT, we give a prescription to construct isometric cutting maps by dressing path integration with suitable edge operators. This allows us to compute entanglement for any state, any bipartition, and any boundary condition. As a consequence, we find a non-integer "ground-state degeneracy" à la Affleck-Ludwig, despite all boundary conditions being gapped. We further show how to reconstruct the partition function of the TQFT at arbitrary genus from the multi-interval Rényi entropies of a single state. For theories with (possibly non-invertible) symmetries, we show that the entanglement entropy of the symmetric ground state can distinguish gapped phases with the same symmetry, without any further knowledge of their vacua, while the entanglement asymmetry of the vacua entropically detects symmetry breaking. We illustrate our formalism with a range of applications, from finite gauge theories to Haagerup gapped phases and infrared phases of adjoint QCD
2.