Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.40810

Beyond the Kubo formula: unification of adiabatic and isothermal response in quantum systems

Giuliano Chiriacò, Vasco Cavina

quant-phcond-mat.quant-gascond-mat.str-elSubmitted Oct 29, 2026• Announced Nov 2, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The static limit of the Kubo susceptibility describes the adiabatic response of an isolated quantum system, in which energy-level occupations remain unchanged, and generally differs from the isothermal susceptibility, where these occupations readjust to thermal equilibrium. In this work, we introduce a single dynamical framework in which the adiabatic and isothermal responses arise naturally as two distinct limiting regimes. This can be done by considering explicitly an open system version of the Kubo approach in which the dissipation is governed by a typical thermalization rate of the system. By exchanging the order of the static limit and of the vanishing thermalization rate limit, the protocol yields either the adiabatic or isothermal response. This protocol has a solid physical motivation in terms of the thermalization dynamics and is valid for generic systems. We apply it to the case of the magnetic response of the electron gas and reproduce the expected results.

AI Summary

The paper addresses the difference between the zero-frequency Kubo susceptibility of an isolated quantum system, where instantaneous energy-level populations remain fixed, and the isothermal susceptibility, where populations readjust to equilibrium. It introduces an explicit thermalization rate $\kappa$ alongside the probe frequency $\omega$, interpreting the two static responses as different orders of limits of an open-system susceptibility $\chi_{AB}(\omega,\kappa)$. Using thermal-state expressions and a Lehmann representation, it obtains $\chi_{AB}^{T}=\chi_{AB}^{S}-\beta\operatorname{Cov}(A_0,B_0)$, where $A_0,B_0$ are energy-basis diagonal components. For self-response under the convention $H=H_0+\lambda A$, this gives $\chi_{AA}^{T}\leq\chi_{AA}^{S}\leq0$. Taking $\kappa\to0$ before $\omega\to0$ yields the isolated response; reversing the order yields the isothermal response. The explicit application is a free electron gas coupled by particle exchange to a thermal fermionic bath. Keldysh Green-function calculations give $\chi_M(\omega,\kappa)\simeq\chi_P\,2\kappa/(2\kappa-i\omega)$ at low temperature and $\omega,\kappa\ll\varepsilon_F$, recovering zero uniform isolated spin susceptibility and the Pauli isothermal susceptibility. At nonzero momentum, the two static limits coincide in this example; subsequently taking momentum to zero recovers the Pauli result. The bath calculation assumes a flat, effectively momentum-independent bath spectrum and constant broadening. Extensions to other relaxation mechanisms require their corresponding self-energies and consistency with conservation laws. Isolated many-body thermalization at conserved entropy, distinct from fixed-population quantum adiabatic evolution, is explicitly left for future investigation.

Little sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosedOverclaimsUnclear noveltyStrong assumptionsPossible error
This image was AI generated with Claude-Opus5.5.

Central claim may not hold: The paper advertises a generic open-system dynamical framework but supplies neither a general susceptibility formula nor conditions guaranteeing its order-of-limits prescription beyond the explicit particle-exchange reservoir example. A nonzero imaginary single-particle self-energy does not suffice to relax uniform total spin: spin-conserving scattering leaves its exact retarded response zero, despite a finite quasiparticle lifetime. The purportedly generic static susceptibility formulas are undefined or basis-dependent for degenerate Hamiltonians because they use individual eigenstate diagonals and unqualified energy-difference denominators. The displayed zero-temperature crossover formula additionally requires a low-frequency, weak-broadening, approximately constant-density-of-states regime that is stated only in its appendix derivation.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
7+6 pages, 2+1 figures

Related papers

The Kubo-Thermalization Correspondence

Songtao Huang, Xingyu Li, Jianyi Chen +5 more

Quantum thermalization describes how interacting quantum systems relax toward thermal equilibrium, a central problem in modern physics. Yet most experimental information on many-body systems comes from short-time transition spectroscopy, typically interpreted within Kubo's linear-response framework. These perspectives-long-time equilibration versus short-time response-seem fundamentally disconnected. Here we establish an exact link between them: the \emph{Kubo-Thermalization correspondence}, which connects long-time thermalized magnetization under weak driving to short-time linear-response spectra for a spin coupled to a thermal bath. The correspondence holds even when the steady state differs substantially from the initial state and when each regime is individually difficult to describe theoretically. We experimentally confirm the correspondence using effective spin-$1/2$ impurities realized with ultracold fermions in two internal states coupled to a Fermi sea. Our results provide a rare exact statement about quantum thermalization and offer a novel route to infer thermalization dynamics from equilibrium response measurements in strongly interacting quantum systems, independent of microscopic details of the system--bath coupling.

cond-mat.quant-gasCross-listedarXiv:2605.06666•May 8, 2026•0 citations

Quantum response theory for nonequilibrium steady states

Michael Konopik, Eric Lutz

Quantum response theory is a cornerstone of statistical physics.However, the standard Kubo formalism is restricted to isolated equilibrium systems.We here generalize Kubo's results to open quantum systems in nonequilibrium steady states.We derive three different, but equivalent, forms of the quantum response function.We discuss for each of them the role of the noncommutativity of quantum operators and introduce a steady-state extension of the Kubo transformation.We show in particular that the equilibrium response vanishes for perturbations that commute with the unperturbed Hamiltonian, while the steady-state response does not, highlighting the profound difference between the two linear response theories.

arXiv:1811.12277•Physical Review Research•Dec 6, 2019•18 citations

Justifying Kubo’s formula for gapped systems at zero temperature: A brief review and some new results

Joscha Henheik, Stefan Teufel

We first review the problem of a rigorous justification of Kubo’s formula for transport coefficients in gapped extended Hamiltonian quantum systems at zero temperature. In particular, the theoretical understanding of the quantum Hall effect rests on the validity of Kubo’s formula for such systems, a connection that we review briefly as well. We then highlight an approach to linear response theory based on non-equilibrium almost-stationary states (NEASS) and on a corresponding adiabatic theorem for such systems that was recently proposed and worked out by one of us in [51] for interacting fermionic systems on finite lattices. In the second part of our paper, we show how to lift the results of [51] to infinite systems by taking a thermodynamic limit.

arXiv:2002.08669•Reviews in Mathematical Physics•Feb 21, 2020•18 citations

Non-adiabatic linear response in open quantum systems

Xiaotian Nie, Wei Zheng

Adiabatic theorem and non-adiabatic corrections have been widely applied in modern quantum technology. Recently, non-adiabatic linear response theory has been developed to probe the many-body correlations in closed systems. In this work, we generalize the non-adiabatic linear response theory to open quantum many-body systems. We show that, similar to the closed case, the first-order deviation from the instantaneous steady state is memoryless—it depends only on the final parameters and not on the initial state or ramping path. When ramping the Hamiltonian, the linear response of observables is governed by the derivative of the retarded Green’s function, as in closed systems. In contrast, ramping the dissipation gives rise to a different response, characterized by a high-order correlation function defined in the steady state. Our results offer a compact and physically transparent formulation of non-adiabatic response in open systems, and demonstrate that ramping dynamics can serve as a versatile tool for probing many-body correlations beyond equilibrium.

arXiv:2501.08826•SciPost Physics•Dec 19, 2025•0 citations

Full statistics of erasure processes: Isothermal adiabatic theory and a statistical Landauer principle

Tristan Benoist, Martin Fraas, Jaksic, Vojkan +1 more

We study driven finite quantum systems in contact with a thermal reservoir in the regime in which the system changes slowly in comparison to the equilibration time. The associated isothermal adiabatic theorem allows us to control the full statistics of energy transfers in quasi-static processes. Within this approach, we extend Landauer's Principle on the energetic cost of erasure processes to the level of the full statistics and elucidate the nature of the fluctuations breaking Landauer's bound.

arXiv:1602.00051•Jan 30, 2016•7 citations

Kubo formula for open finite-size systems

Jinshan Wu, Mona Berciu

We derive a Kubo-type formula that describes proper non-equilibrium stationary states for finite-size systems. We first argue that the usual Kubo formula considers only equilibrium states of the perturbed system, which are inappropriate to describe transport properties. Moreover, we show that the standard Kubo formula for the dc conductance is only appropriate in the thermodynamic limit. We demonstrate that taking into consideration explicitly the coupling to the leads/baths solves both problems. This approach results in well-behaved response functions, without the singular contributions from degenerate states encountered when Kubo formulae for infinite-size systems are inappropriately used for finite-size systems. We also derive a second, more efficient formulation which is valid only for a set of special physical quantities, which includes the charge current density operator.

arXiv:1003.1992•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Nov 1, 2010•10 citations
The static limit of the Kubo susceptibility describes the adiabatic response of an isolated quantum system, in which energy-level occupations remain unchanged, and generally differs from the isothermal susceptibility, where these occupations readjust to thermal equilibrium. In this work, we introduce a single dynamical framework in which the adiabatic and isothermal responses arise naturally as two distinct limiting regimes. This can be done by considering explicitly an open system version of the Kubo approach in which the dissipation is governed by a typical thermalization rate of the system. By exchanging the order of the static limit and of the vanishing thermalization rate limit, the protocol yields either the adiabatic or isothermal response. This protocol has a solid physical motivation in terms of the thermalization dynamics and is valid for generic systems. We apply it to the case of the magnetic response of the electron gas and reproduce the expected results.
The paper addresses the difference between the zero-frequency Kubo susceptibility of an isolated quantum system, where instantaneous energy-level populations remain fixed, and the isothermal susceptibility, where populations readjust to equilibrium. It introduces an explicit thermalization rate κ\kappaκ alongside the probe frequency ω\omegaω, interpreting the two static responses as different orders of limits of an open-system susceptibility χAB(ω,κ)\chi_{AB}(\omega,\kappa)χAB​(ω,κ).
Using thermal-state expressions and a Lehmann representation, it obtains χABT=χABS−βCov⁡(A0,B0)\chi_{AB}^{T}=\chi_{AB}^{S}-\beta\operatorname{Cov}(A_0,B_0)χABT​=χABS​−βCov(A0​,B0​), where A0,B0A_0,B_0A0​,B0​ are energy-basis diagonal components. For self-response under the convention H=H0+λAH=H_0+\lambda AH=H0​+λA, this gives χAAT≤χAAS≤0\chi_{AA}^{T}\leq\chi_{AA}^{S}\leq0χAAT​≤χAAS​≤0. Taking κ→0\kappa\to0κ→0 before ω→0\omega\to0ω→0 yields the isolated response; reversing the order yields the isothermal response.
The explicit application is a free electron gas coupled by particle exchange to a thermal fermionic bath. Keldysh Green-function calculations give χM(ω,κ)≃χP 2κ/(2κ−iω)\chi_M(\omega,\kappa)\simeq\chi_P\,2\kappa/(2\kappa-i\omega)χM​(ω,κ)≃χP​2κ/(2κ−iω) at low temperature and ω,κ≪εF\omega,\kappa\ll\varepsilon_Fω,κ≪εF​, recovering zero uniform isolated spin susceptibility and the Pauli isothermal susceptibility. At nonzero momentum, the two static limits coincide in this example; subsequently taking momentum to zero recovers the Pauli result.
The bath calculation assumes a flat, effectively momentum-independent bath spectrum and constant broadening. Extensions to other relaxation mechanisms require their corresponding self-energies and consistency with conservation laws. Isolated many-body thermalization at conserved entropy, distinct from fixed-population quantum adiabatic evolution, is explicitly left for future investigation.
Quantum thermalization describes how interacting quantum systems relax toward thermal equilibrium, a central problem in modern physics. Yet most experimental information on many-body systems comes from short-time transition spectroscopy, typically interpreted within Kubo's linear-response framework. These perspectives-long-time equilibration versus short-time response-seem fundamentally disconnected. Here we establish an exact link between them: the \emph{Kubo-Thermalization correspondence}, which connects long-time thermalized magnetization under weak driving to short-time linear-response spectra for a spin coupled to a thermal bath. The correspondence holds even when the steady state differs substantially from the initial state and when each regime is individually difficult to describe theoretically. We experimentally confirm the correspondence using effective spin-1/21/21/2 impurities realized with ultracold fermions in two internal states coupled to a Fermi sea. Our results provide a rare exact statement about quantum thermalization and offer a novel route to infer thermalization dynamics from equilibrium response measurements in strongly interacting quantum systems, independent of microscopic details of the system--bath coupling.
Quantum response theory is a cornerstone of statistical physics.However, the standard Kubo formalism is restricted to isolated equilibrium systems.We here generalize Kubo's results to open quantum systems in nonequilibrium steady states.We derive three different, but equivalent, forms of the quantum response function.We discuss for each of them the role of the noncommutativity of quantum operators and introduce a steady-state extension of the Kubo transformation.We show in particular that the equilibrium response vanishes for perturbations that commute with the unperturbed Hamiltonian, while the steady-state response does not, highlighting the profound difference between the two linear response theories.
We first review the problem of a rigorous justification of Kubo’s formula for transport coefficients in gapped extended Hamiltonian quantum systems at zero temperature. In particular, the theoretical understanding of the quantum Hall effect rests on the validity of Kubo’s formula for such systems, a connection that we review briefly as well. We then highlight an approach to linear response theory based on non-equilibrium almost-stationary states (NEASS) and on a corresponding adiabatic theorem for such systems that was recently proposed and worked out by one of us in [51] for interacting fermionic systems on finite lattices. In the second part of our paper, we show how to lift the results of [51] to infinite systems by taking a thermodynamic limit.
Adiabatic theorem and non-adiabatic corrections have been widely applied in modern quantum technology. Recently, non-adiabatic linear response theory has been developed to probe the many-body correlations in closed systems. In this work, we generalize the non-adiabatic linear response theory to open quantum many-body systems. We show that, similar to the closed case, the first-order deviation from the instantaneous steady state is memoryless—it depends only on the final parameters and not on the initial state or ramping path. When ramping the Hamiltonian, the linear response of observables is governed by the derivative of the retarded Green’s function, as in closed systems. In contrast, ramping the dissipation gives rise to a different response, characterized by a high-order correlation function defined in the steady state. Our results offer a compact and physically transparent formulation of non-adiabatic response in open systems, and demonstrate that ramping dynamics can serve as a versatile tool for probing many-body correlations beyond equilibrium.
We study driven finite quantum systems in contact with a thermal reservoir in the regime in which the system changes slowly in comparison to the equilibration time. The associated isothermal adiabatic theorem allows us to control the full statistics of energy transfers in quasi-static processes. Within this approach, we extend Landauer's Principle on the energetic cost of erasure processes to the level of the full statistics and elucidate the nature of the fluctuations breaking Landauer's bound.
We derive a Kubo-type formula that describes proper non-equilibrium stationary states for finite-size systems. We first argue that the usual Kubo formula considers only equilibrium states of the perturbed system, which are inappropriate to describe transport properties. Moreover, we show that the standard Kubo formula for the dc conductance is only appropriate in the thermodynamic limit. We demonstrate that taking into consideration explicitly the coupling to the leads/baths solves both problems. This approach results in well-behaved response functions, without the singular contributions from degenerate states encountered when Kubo formulae for infinite-size systems are inappropriately used for finite-size systems. We also derive a second, more efficient formulation which is valid only for a set of special physical quantities, which includes the charge current density operator.