Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.39129

Reverse Quantum Annealing for Ground-State Energy Calculation in Molecule

Pradyot Pritam Sahoo

quant-phphysics.atom-phphysics.chem-phSubmitted Oct 29, 2026• Announced Oct 30, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present the results of our reverse quantum annealing computations of the ground-state energies of alkaline-earth monofluoride molecules. By partitioning the Dirac--Coulomb electronic Hamiltonian into sub-QUBOs and refining forward-annealing solutions through optimized reverse-annealing schedules, residual configuration errors are systematically minimized. The electronic ground-state wave functions and energies are obtained using the Quantum Annealing Eigensolver algorithm. This work provides a pathway for achieving sub-milliHartree chemical accuracy and advancing molecular electronic structure calculations in the quantum annealing paradigm.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether reverse quantum annealing can refine forward-annealing solutions in a Quantum Annealing Eigensolver (QAE) for relativistic molecular ground-state energies. It studies BeF, MgF, CaF, SrF, and BaF in $(3e,8o)$ and $(7e,14o)$ active spaces using Dirac–Coulomb Hamiltonians. QAE encodes determinant coefficients with 10 binary variables each and partitions the resulting QUBO into hardware-sized blocks. Forward-annealing solutions initialize reverse annealing on a D-Wave Advantage 4.1 processor, testing twelve pause-type and V-shaped schedules with 1,000 reads per schedule. Exact full configuration interaction diagonalization in the same determinant basis provides the reference. Selecting the best reverse schedule for each system reduces residual forward-annealing errors by $82.3\%$–$98.1\%$. Final errors range from $0.305$ to $6.966$ mHa; two of ten systems reach sub-milliHartree accuracy: BeF in $(3e,8o)$ and SrF in $(7e,14o)$. A 20-microsecond V-shaped schedule reversing to $s'=0.40$ gives the largest mean energy lowering in both active spaces, although individual molecules favor different schedules. The paper reports strong schedule and molecule dependence, occasional energy increases in the smaller active space, and reduced mean relative energy lowering as the active space grows: $0.409\%$ versus $0.071\%$, averaged across molecules and schedules. It identifies finite connectivity, embedding and chain effects, stochastic sampling, and separately optimized sub-QUBOs as practical limitations. The results concern refinement against forward annealing within this fixed encoding and decomposition workflow.

Some signs of AI-generated textIncrementalOverclaimsMissing comparisonUnclear writing

Central claim may not hold: The protocol does not explain how reverse annealing optimizes inter-block couplings after concatenation when hardware limitations required partitioning, and decoding or evaluating the full Hamiltonian cannot itself perform that optimization. The stated algorithm omits both normalization of decoded coefficients and a Rayleigh quotient, so its displayed energy expression does not establish the variational energies needed to interpret the FCI benchmarks. The decrease in percentage energy lowering with active-space size is energy-origin dependent and does not establish reduced absolute recovery; the benchmark's mean best-per-system absolute lowering increases from about 21.130 to 26.698 mHa.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
10 pages, 7 figures, comments are welcome

Related papers

Computing the molecular ground state energy in a restricted active space using quantum annealing

Stefano Bruni, Enrico Prati

Calculating the molecular ground-state energy is a central challenge in computational chemistry. Conventional methods such as the Complete Active Space Configuration Interaction scale exponentially with molecular size, limiting their applicability to large molecules. Quantum computing offers a promising alternative by mapping molecular Hamiltonians by qubits, enabling cheaper computational scaling. Previous studies have shown that it is possible to formulate molecular ground state calculations as discrete optimization problems, addressable by quantum annealing. However, these efforts have been limited by previous generations of hardware and suboptimal annealing techniques. Here, the $H_{2}O$ ground-state problem is mapped to an Ising Hamiltonian using the Xian-Bias-Kas (XBK) method. By taking advantage of enhanced qubit connectivity and shorter embedding chains, it is solved with a more than doubled probability of achieving Hartree-Fock-level solutions with respect to the most advanced predecessor. Advanced annealing strategies extend Hartree-Fock-level accuracy to significantly larger problem instances, enabling solutions that use nearly 2.5 times more physically embedded qubits than the largest cases previously reported and allowing to improve annealing results by two orders of magnitude, reaching an energy difference of 0.120~Hartree relative to Hartree-Fock. These results show tangible progress toward practical quantum annealing applications in NISQ era.

quant-pharXiv:2512.11757•Advanced Quantum Technologies•Dec 15, 2025•0 citations

Application of quantum annealing to computation of molecular properties

P. Sahoo, V. S. Prasannaa, B. P. Das

We present the results of our quantum annealing computations of the permanent electric dipole moments of several molecules. By applying an electric field as a perturbation and measuring the corresponding energy responses, the molecular electric dipole moments are obtained numerically through the finite field method. The ground-state electronic wavefunctions and energies are obtained using the quantum annealer eignsolver algorithm. This work provides a pathway for the computation of molecular properties in the quantum annealing paradigm.

arXiv:2508.12779•Physical Review A•May 4, 2026•2 citations

Improving the accuracy of the energy estimation by combining quantum annealing with classical computation

Takashi Imoto, Yuya Seki, Yuichiro Matsuzaki +1 more

Quantum chemistry calculations are important applications of quantum annealing. For practical applications in quantum chemistry, it is essential to estimate a ground state energy of the Hamiltonian with chemical accuracy. However, there are no known methods to guarantee the accuracy of the estimation of the energy calculated by quantum annealing. Here, we propose a way to improve the accuracy of the estimate of the ground state energy by combining quantum annealing with classical computation. In our scheme, before running the QA, we need a pre-estimation of the energies of the ground state and first excited state with some error bars (corresponding to possible estimation error) by performing classical computation with some approximations. We show that, if an expectation value and variance of the energy of the state after the QA are smaller than certain threshold values (that we can calculate from the pre-estimation), the QA provides us with a better estimate of the ground state energy than that of the pre-estimation. Since the expectation value and variance of the energy can be experimentally measurable by the QA, our results pave the way for accurate estimation of the ground state energy with the QA.

arXiv:2102.05323•Feb 10, 2021•5 citations

Extending the computational reach of Quantum Annealing using Reverse Annealing

Lucas Joshua Menger, Thomas Lippert, Manpreet Singh Jattana

Quantum annealing is a promising heuristic for combinatorial optimization, but on current hardware its performance degrades for larger and more complex problems due to noise and small energy gaps. Reverse annealing has been proposed as a refinement strategy, yet it remains unclear when it provides systematic advantages over standard forward annealing or simply increasing annealing time. We find that combining forward and reverse annealing consistently improves solution quality and efficiency across multiple problem classes. The benefits of reverse annealing increase with problem complexity and are strongest in regimes where forward annealing is increasingly limited. Moreover, reverse annealing yields larger efficiency gains than simply extending forward annealing times. We establish these results through a systematic experimental study on a D-Wave Advantage system, benchmarking reverse annealing across Max-Cut, Number Partitioning, and sparse clustering problems while varying reverse distance, pause duration, and annealing time. We identify a narrow optimal regime for reverse annealing parameters linked to the location of freeze-out points and energy-level crossings in the annealing schedule. These findings demonstrate that reverse annealing is most valuable for large, high-complexity optimization problems and is likely to gain importance as quantum annealing hardware scales toward more realistic applications.

quant-pharXiv:2607.02146•EPJ Quantum Technology•Jul 3, 2026•0 citations

Guaranteed-accuracy quantum annealing

Takashi Imoto, Yuya Seki, Yuichiro Matsuzaki +1 more

Quantum chemistry calculations constitute an important application of quantum annealing (QA). For practical applications in quantum chemistry, it is essential to estimate the ground-state energy of the Hamiltonian with chemical accuracy. However, there is no known method for guaranteeing the accuracy of the energy estimated via QA. Here, we propose a method for guaranteeing the accuracy of the energy estimated via QA using the Weinstein and Temple bounds. In our scheme, before QA is performed, the energies of the ground state and first excited state must be preestimated with some error bars (corresponding to the possible estimation error) via classical computation with some approximations. We show that, if the expectation value and standard deviation of the energy of the state after QA are lower than certain threshold values (that we can calculate from the preestimation), the ground-state energy estimated by QA is closer to the ground-state energy than the preestimation. As the expectation value and standard deviation of the energy can be experimentally measured via QA, our results pave the way for accurate estimation of the ground-state energy using QA.

Physical Review A•Oct 28, 2022•1 citation

Applications of quantum annealing to magnetic dipole hyperfine structure constants: First results beyond energies for atoms

Boni Paul, Subimal Deb, Per Jönsson +2 more

We report the first results of the magnetic dipole hyperfine structure (HFS) constants of neutral $\mathrm{Li}$, Li-like $\mathrm{Be}$, neutral $\mathrm{Na}$, and Na-like $\mathrm{Mg}$ using a modified version of the Quantum Annealer Eigensolver (QAE) algorithm on D-Wave's quantum hardware. The results are benchmarked against relativistic configuration interaction with multiconfiguration Dirac Hartree-Fock (MCDHF) calculations using the General-purpose Relativistic Atomic Structure Package (GRASP), and simulated annealing. In our modified QAE, a zooming-and-sigma-annealing approach with a floating-point encoding scheme is adopted to estimate the ground-state eigenvalue and eigenvector of the relativistic Dirac-Coulomb Hamiltonian matrices ($H_{\mathrm{DC}}$) constructed from 11 or fewer configuration state functions (CSFs). For calculations with extended correlation orbital sets, we applied a CSF truncation scheme, retaining only CSFs (up to 12) that make significant contributions to the ground-state wavefunction. Our modified QAE precision is kept limited to three decimal places (up to 10 qubits). Hardware demonstrations on the D-Wave quantum processing unit (QPU) yielded results that were completely consistent with GRASP (at the chosen precision) in determining the magnetic dipole HFS constants, with accuracy varying across systems and $H_{\mathrm{DC}}$ matrix dimensions.

quant-pharXiv:2606.20166•APS Open Science•Jun 19, 2026•1 citation
We present the results of our reverse quantum annealing computations of the ground-state energies of alkaline-earth monofluoride molecules. By partitioning the Dirac--Coulomb electronic Hamiltonian into sub-QUBOs and refining forward-annealing solutions through optimized reverse-annealing schedules, residual configuration errors are systematically minimized. The electronic ground-state wave functions and energies are obtained using the Quantum Annealing Eigensolver algorithm. This work provides a pathway for achieving sub-milliHartree chemical accuracy and advancing molecular electronic structure calculations in the quantum annealing paradigm.
The paper asks whether reverse quantum annealing can refine forward-annealing solutions in a Quantum Annealing Eigensolver (QAE) for relativistic molecular ground-state energies. It studies BeF, MgF, CaF, SrF, and BaF in (3e,8o)(3e,8o)(3e,8o) and (7e,14o)(7e,14o)(7e,14o) active spaces using Dirac–Coulomb Hamiltonians. QAE encodes determinant coefficients with 10 binary variables each and partitions the resulting QUBO into hardware-sized blocks. Forward-annealing solutions initialize reverse annealing on a D-Wave Advantage 4.1 processor, testing twelve pause-type and V-shaped schedules with 1,000 reads per schedule.
Exact full configuration interaction diagonalization in the same determinant basis provides the reference. Selecting the best reverse schedule for each system reduces residual forward-annealing errors by 82.3%82.3\%82.3%–98.1%98.1\%98.1%. Final errors range from 0.3050.3050.305 to 6.9666.9666.966 mHa; two of ten systems reach sub-milliHartree accuracy: BeF in (3e,8o)(3e,8o)(3e,8o) and SrF in (7e,14o)(7e,14o)(7e,14o). A 20-microsecond V-shaped schedule reversing to s′=0.40s'=0.40s′=0.40 gives the largest mean energy lowering in both active spaces, although individual molecules favor different schedules.
The paper reports strong schedule and molecule dependence, occasional energy increases in the smaller active space, and reduced mean relative energy lowering as the active space grows: 0.409%0.409\%0.409% versus 0.071%0.071\%0.071%, averaged across molecules and schedules. It identifies finite connectivity, embedding and chain effects, stochastic sampling, and separately optimized sub-QUBOs as practical limitations. The results concern refinement against forward annealing within this fixed encoding and decomposition workflow.
Calculating the molecular ground-state energy is a central challenge in computational chemistry. Conventional methods such as the Complete Active Space Configuration Interaction scale exponentially with molecular size, limiting their applicability to large molecules. Quantum computing offers a promising alternative by mapping molecular Hamiltonians by qubits, enabling cheaper computational scaling. Previous studies have shown that it is possible to formulate molecular ground state calculations as discrete optimization problems, addressable by quantum annealing. However, these efforts have been limited by previous generations of hardware and suboptimal annealing techniques. Here, the H2OH_{2}OH2​O ground-state problem is mapped to an Ising Hamiltonian using the Xian-Bias-Kas (XBK) method. By taking advantage of enhanced qubit connectivity and shorter embedding chains, it is solved with a more than doubled probability of achieving Hartree-Fock-level solutions with respect to the most advanced predecessor. Advanced annealing strategies extend Hartree-Fock-level accuracy to significantly larger problem instances, enabling solutions that use nearly 2.5 times more physically embedded qubits than the largest cases previously reported and allowing to improve annealing results by two orders of magnitude, reaching an energy difference of 0.120~Hartree relative to Hartree-Fock. These results show tangible progress toward practical quantum annealing applications in NISQ era.
We present the results of our quantum annealing computations of the permanent electric dipole moments of several molecules. By applying an electric field as a perturbation and measuring the corresponding energy responses, the molecular electric dipole moments are obtained numerically through the finite field method. The ground-state electronic wavefunctions and energies are obtained using the quantum annealer eignsolver algorithm. This work provides a pathway for the computation of molecular properties in the quantum annealing paradigm.
Quantum chemistry calculations are important applications of quantum annealing. For practical applications in quantum chemistry, it is essential to estimate a ground state energy of the Hamiltonian with chemical accuracy. However, there are no known methods to guarantee the accuracy of the estimation of the energy calculated by quantum annealing. Here, we propose a way to improve the accuracy of the estimate of the ground state energy by combining quantum annealing with classical computation. In our scheme, before running the QA, we need a pre-estimation of the energies of the ground state and first excited state with some error bars (corresponding to possible estimation error) by performing classical computation with some approximations. We show that, if an expectation value and variance of the energy of the state after the QA are smaller than certain threshold values (that we can calculate from the pre-estimation), the QA provides us with a better estimate of the ground state energy than that of the pre-estimation. Since the expectation value and variance of the energy can be experimentally measurable by the QA, our results pave the way for accurate estimation of the ground state energy with the QA.
Quantum annealing is a promising heuristic for combinatorial optimization, but on current hardware its performance degrades for larger and more complex problems due to noise and small energy gaps. Reverse annealing has been proposed as a refinement strategy, yet it remains unclear when it provides systematic advantages over standard forward annealing or simply increasing annealing time. We find that combining forward and reverse annealing consistently improves solution quality and efficiency across multiple problem classes. The benefits of reverse annealing increase with problem complexity and are strongest in regimes where forward annealing is increasingly limited. Moreover, reverse annealing yields larger efficiency gains than simply extending forward annealing times. We establish these results through a systematic experimental study on a D-Wave Advantage system, benchmarking reverse annealing across Max-Cut, Number Partitioning, and sparse clustering problems while varying reverse distance, pause duration, and annealing time. We identify a narrow optimal regime for reverse annealing parameters linked to the location of freeze-out points and energy-level crossings in the annealing schedule. These findings demonstrate that reverse annealing is most valuable for large, high-complexity optimization problems and is likely to gain importance as quantum annealing hardware scales toward more realistic applications.
Quantum chemistry calculations constitute an important application of quantum annealing (QA). For practical applications in quantum chemistry, it is essential to estimate the ground-state energy of the Hamiltonian with chemical accuracy. However, there is no known method for guaranteeing the accuracy of the energy estimated via QA. Here, we propose a method for guaranteeing the accuracy of the energy estimated via QA using the Weinstein and Temple bounds. In our scheme, before QA is performed, the energies of the ground state and first excited state must be preestimated with some error bars (corresponding to the possible estimation error) via classical computation with some approximations. We show that, if the expectation value and standard deviation of the energy of the state after QA are lower than certain threshold values (that we can calculate from the preestimation), the ground-state energy estimated by QA is closer to the ground-state energy than the preestimation. As the expectation value and standard deviation of the energy can be experimentally measured via QA, our results pave the way for accurate estimation of the ground-state energy using QA.
We report the first results of the magnetic dipole hyperfine structure (HFS) constants of neutral Li\mathrm{Li}Li, Li-like Be\mathrm{Be}Be, neutral Na\mathrm{Na}Na, and Na-like Mg\mathrm{Mg}Mg using a modified version of the Quantum Annealer Eigensolver (QAE) algorithm on D-Wave's quantum hardware. The results are benchmarked against relativistic configuration interaction with multiconfiguration Dirac Hartree-Fock (MCDHF) calculations using the General-purpose Relativistic Atomic Structure Package (GRASP), and simulated annealing. In our modified QAE, a zooming-and-sigma-annealing approach with a floating-point encoding scheme is adopted to estimate the ground-state eigenvalue and eigenvector of the relativistic Dirac-Coulomb Hamiltonian matrices (HDCH_{\mathrm{DC}}HDC​) constructed from 11 or fewer configuration state functions (CSFs). For calculations with extended correlation orbital sets, we applied a CSF truncation scheme, retaining only CSFs (up to 12) that make significant contributions to the ground-state wavefunction. Our modified QAE precision is kept limited to three decimal places (up to 10 qubits). Hardware demonstrations on the D-Wave quantum processing unit (QPU) yielded results that were completely consistent with GRASP (at the chosen precision) in determining the magnetic dipole HFS constants, with accuracy varying across systems and HDCH_{\mathrm{DC}}HDC​ matrix dimensions.